Dieppe 65 years later

basketcase said:
Sure the Canadians wanted to get in the action but the Brits screwed them out of the naval and air support they needed to be successful. The Canadians were backed into a corner and had to proceed without it.

Doesn't this contradict your point? This implies that the British wanted a failure to prove a point.

The Canaidian soldiers did a hell of a lot and tons was learned from it but that information could still have been learned without the military disaster that happened.

I don't think the British wanted the raid to fail but with first hand experience in fighting the Wehrmacht and after watch the level of training probably felt that in a long, stand up fight, the Canadians would suffer heavy casulaties in part because they would be able to bring support elements with them in this raid. I don't know what if any Air Support would be available and I doubt the Royal Navy would be capable of shelling any German renforcements.

It was a caculated risk, one that had to be taken. The British were't up to the task and it fell on to the Canadians.
 
From my readings, the initial plans included significant pre-raid bombing and support from naval big guns to soften up the hard points. They didn't need the raid to know that troops landing on a beach in front of intact defensive positions was idiotic. Both naval and air support were excluded not long before the raid launched, essentially bacause the Brit commanders were concerned about the material losses that might have occured, especially to capital ships. To put it simply, the Brits thought that their men and machines were more important than those of the Canucks.

WinterHawk said:
It was a caculated risk, one that had to be taken. The British were't up to the task and it fell on to the Canadians.
That I have no problem with.