Did Mark Messier retire?

Toronto Passions

Trusted Since 2001!
Supporting Member
I can't seem to find a good solid answer anywhere. Some sites say yes (without a press meeting). Some other sites say no and he will play.

I'm confused. :confused:

I think next to Pat Lafontain, this guy may have been one of the best talents I have ever seen in my generation. Obviously aside from The Great One and Super Mario. I also think he has worn out his welcome and needs to call it a day.

So what is the deal? Did he retire?
 
I think it's funny when people turn to TERB to verify stories.

Anywho, while Messier is more accomplished than most who have ever played, would he have without Gretzky? I've always likened his situation with Jordan/Pippen.
 
hammertm said:
Lol, i think the exact same thing. Throw in some more names like Kurri, Jagr + Francis. All decent on their own like Pippen, but superstars when playing with Jordan, Gretzky and Lemieux.

People forget that in the 89-90 season Messier had 129 points without Gretzky on the team and then led his team to the Stanley cup. Yes Messier did benefit from having Gretzky, hell who wouldn't. But what seperates the Moose from the rest of the guys like Kurri, Jagr, Francis and Pippen is that he was acknowledged as the league's MVP twice. Those other players that played with the likes of Gretzky and Jordan never did something like that.

The fact is he was a great player, probably not on the same level as Gretzky or Lemieux, but definately a cut above guys like Jagr.
 
rubme said:
TP, not sure how old you are but he would not make my top 20... maybe 21st.

Gretzky
Lemieux
Bobby Hull
Beliveau
Lafleur
Gilbert Perrault
Mike Bossy
Ray Bourque
Bobby Orr
Joe Sakic
Phil Esposito
Paul Coffey
Steve Yzerman
Cam Neely
Bobby Clarke
Larry Robinson
Bob Gainey
Mike Gartner
Scott Stevens
Pat Lafontaine

Most underrated, perhaps of all time....
Adam Oates

Just added the names. They are not in any order of ranking.

I am sure you could drop messier ahead of almost any one of these guys. I based my players upon talent not lenght of playing time. Not looking to argue any of these players it is my choice and I'm sure you all will have your list.


Old enough to have watched most guys on your list. I judge a player on talent, his ability to control the game, and impact he has on a game.
 
t8rs said:
I think it's funny when people turn to TERB to verify stories.

Anywho, while Messier is more accomplished than most who have ever played, would he have without Gretzky? I've always likened his situation with Jordan/Pippen.

That comparison is being thrown around as of late, also that he was just a drifter doing circles for 45 second shifts during the past decade. All I think of is 1990 and 1994. Yeah in 1994 Richter stood on his head, but there was no Gretzky in those situations. And the 1994 cup was a media circus with Mike Keanen acting like a drama queen, which would kill most teams. Mess took em there though, and he got the job done. The guy was a force.

And for the record, Terb answers many questions regarding sports. Ranger 68 needs to go on a sports trivia show. (for example)
 
Toronto Passions said:
Old enough to have watched most guys on your list. I judge a player on talent, his ability to control the game, and impact he has on a game.

Messier was distinctly, if arguably, better than many of the players on that list.
You have it right, TP.
As for saying that he wouldn't be anywhere without Gretzky, that's so foolish it's laughable.
- they both played centre and _very_ rarely ever shared the ice
- Mess won twice without Gretzky, both times leading his team
- he won the Conn Smythe in a year he played _on the same team_ as Gretzky

Please. Don't denigrate Messier beyond all reason. His leadership was overrated, probably, but otherwise he's one of the all-time best.
 
Toronto Passions said:
And for the record, Terb answers many questions regarding sports.

I know; that's precisely why it's funny. :)

As for the Messier debate, it could go on forever and I won't perpetuate it. I don't think there's a right answer, just speculation. Frankly, I'd rather go out and get laid.
 
I've heard that is just what Mark did in Edmonton 1990. After cup party. :)