Developers back Miller's land transfer tax plan

I hate to admit it but I think this plan will fly. Miller seems to have embraced the compromise as it will get him the extra votes he needs on council and, possibly, at election time.
 
Odd, Miller has nothing to say on cutting spending.

Wonder if the builders who endorsed the tax plan will be allowed to increase the floor space density on their building lots. Must be something in it for the builders, for them to endorse a tax increase.
 
KBear said:
Must be something in it for the builders, for them to endorse a tax increase.
Exactly what I was thinking

They wouldnt endorse a lefty mayor unless something was in it for them
 
I'd be more likely to buy it if they just made it a 1% tax period.

Most houses in Toronto are now selling at more than 400k, so I don't see the compromise frankly.

I'd be more for a 25 cent tax on every bottle of beer sold in the City of Toronto at any bar or restaurant actually.
 
Not surprisingly the developers who support Miller's land transfer tax for residences above $400,000 are condo developers who build crap under 400k.


Among the low end condo developers endorsing higher property taxes: Menkes Developments

Ltd., The Daniels Corporation, Tribute(Sorbara) Communities, Context Development Ltd. and MintoUrban Communities Inc.

Stephen Diamond, the president of developer DiamondCorp and a real estate lawyer who helped fashion the compromise, said he and his fellow developers are confident the new formula will spare the development industry pain while helping to ensure the local government can deliver quality services.

Although the new formula will provide some relief to the condo sector, Mr. Diamond said the developers were acting for the good of the city, not in their own self-interest.

"If you were acting in your own self-interest, you would be working to oppose all taxes because in the short term that would be to your benefit," he said.

http://www.canada.com/nationalpost/...l?id=bfe07253-80ab-4e9c-b2a4-4670b1480d6c&p=1
 
I don't understand...house prices have appreciated in value over the past few years. I assume the gov't is collecting more property tax, so why do they still need to raise tax? I guess they are BIG SPENDERS!
 
LAnterra - those bastards!! I'm buying a Lanterra condo.

Here's a question - GST dropped 1% last year, so does that mean that I should be getting 1% back on the 300k price of a place I sogned for but haven't bought yet?
 
Godiva said:
I don't understand...house prices have appreciated in value over the past few years. I assume the gov't is collecting more property tax, so why do they still need to raise tax? I guess they are BIG SPENDERS!

Not necessarily. The mill rate is set each year. Taxes are home valuation multiplied by mill rate.

So, if Toronto's market valuations were to increase over time, and they were aiming to keep total property taxes flat, the mill rate would decrease. What the market valuation system did was shift the tax load towards those with higher house valuations. Some homeowners taxes jumped, others likely stayed flat or decreased.

http://www.toronto.ca/taxes/tax_rates_previous.htm

2007 mill rate: 0.8528434%
2001 mill rate: 1.073544%

There's likely oddities in there about provincial downloading and stuff.
 
Hangman said:
LAnterra - those bastards!! I'm buying a Lanterra condo.

Here's a question - GST dropped 1% last year, so does that mean that I should be getting 1% back on the 300k price of a place I sogned for but haven't bought yet?

Don't you mean signed for Hangman.

Learn to spell.
 
Hangman said:
Here's a question - GST dropped 1% last year, so does that mean that I should be getting 1% back on the 300k price of a place I sogned for but haven't bought yet?

Yes you do, although the formula is not quite that simple as new housing already qualifies for a reduced rate of GST. In the example given by the CRA, a $330,000.00 house qualifies for a GST transitional rebate of $2112.00. According to my calculation a $300,000 house (or condo) would get a GST transitional rebate of $1920.00.

http://www.cra-arc.gc.ca/E/pub/gi/gi-015/gi-015-e.html

Furthermore, using the same logic, I believe that you should get an extra rebate on top of that if title to the property is transferred after the GST rate is reduced by a further 1% as announced in the throne speach.
 
Developers Menkes Daniels Tribute Sorbara Context Minto Diamond and others corrupt

Toronto Real Estate Board workers prowled the offices at city hall prior to council's July vote on Miller's tax scheme and ultimately convinced intimidated politicians into deferring the decision until after the Oct. 10 provincial election.

"They had a paid lobbyist," said Lindsay Luby. "Who did we have? Nobody."

The city didn't have a lobbyist to woo its own councillors prior to their deferral

Faced with a desperate need to get the new taxes okayed, Miller gave in to right-wing and business interests and this week agreed to set up a panel of high-profile Torontonians who will delve into the city's books.

Deputy Mayor Joe Pantalone said the real estate board didn't obey the rules of the game.

"They should've let the city know" that they were lobbying for the tax, he said. "They're a quasi-public group and it's hard to take them seriously when they play dirty."

"The city is better off that prominent developers have acknowledged that it's good for their industry that the city has the ability to invest in things that support development.

http://www.thestar.com/News/GTA/article/268872