derail the gravy train

And the whole story is totally bogus. The source was a quote from an anonymous Indian politician in an Indian news report. It was picked up by Limbaugh, Beck, and Imus and flung across the airwaves. They of course won't admit it, but they got got.

Nobody checked their facts or the source.
 
All the staff and equipment for the Obama trip are already paid for and on the payroll. The only extra is fuel and wear and tear. As for the Toronto councillors. non of this strikes me as particularly excessive. I had a company pay for my post grad degree... let me tell you it was quite a bit more then the 3K in French lessons for monsieur Gimbrone.
 
Giambrone wasn't taking french for his constituents, we all know why, he was using Toronto Taxpayer's money to learn french so he could eventually move on to Federal Politics.

Yeah, probably. Still I wouldn't want to ban councilors from taking language lessons. In most cases they probably do it for legitimate reasons. You can always find iffy cases like this one, but that doesn't mean that you should change the rules and prohibit it. It just means you should vote against the guy making the iffy decisions, if he decides to run anywhere again and give you the opportunity to do something about it.

The solution to politicians making poor judgement calls is better voting, not more rules.
 
And the whole story is totally bogus. The source was a quote from an anonymous Indian politician in an Indian news report. It was picked up by Limbaugh, Beck, and Imus and flung across the airwaves.

Yeah, why let the facts get in the way of a good lie?
Typical!
 
As for the Toronto councillors. non of this strikes me as particularly excessive. I had a company pay for my post grad degree... let me tell you it was quite a bit more then the 3K in French lessons for monsieur Gimbrone.

Difference is that it was the company that paid. If some company paid for Giambrone's French lessons, then good for him. If he expensed it using tax dollars... the f**k him. And he expensed it after he knew he was out.
 
Difference is that it was the company that paid. If some company paid for Giambrone's French lessons, then good for him. If he expensed it using tax dollars... the f**k him. And he expensed it after he knew he was out.

exactly.
 
Yeah, probably. Still I wouldn't want to ban councilors from taking language lessons. In most cases they probably do it for legitimate reasons. You can always find iffy cases like this one, but that doesn't mean that you should change the rules and prohibit it. It just means you should vote against the guy making the iffy decisions, if he decides to run anywhere again and give you the opportunity to do something about it.

The solution to politicians making poor judgement calls is better voting, not more rules.

I would ban language lessons for councillors. Its an unecessary expense- unlike the feds- Toronto only has one official language.
 
I would ban language lessons for councillors. Its an unecessary expense- unlike the feds- Toronto only has one official language.

Last time I looked, Toronto is in Canada, and Canada has 2 official languages.

Don't get me wrong, I am not sticking up for wasteful spending.
I am not even a fan of Giambrone. However, the fact is that private sector businesses offer their executives alot of perks for doing their job, and the public sector should as well. I would more take issue with the amount of the expense for these language lessons and who authorized and paid for them. I don't remember the exact figures, but I do remember thinking... Holy Shit, that is alot of money for a couple of months of French Lessons.
 
Last time I looked, Toronto is in Canada, and Canada has 2 official languages.

Don't get me wrong, I am not sticking up for wasteful spending.
I am not even a fan of Giambrone. However, the fact is that private sector businesses offer their executives alot of perks for doing their job, and the public sector should as well. I would more take issue with the amount of the expense for these language lessons and who authorized and paid for them. I don't remember the exact figures, but I do remember thinking... Holy Shit, that is alot of money for a couple of months of French Lessons.

toronto is in Canada. but when do you ever hear french spoken in toronto? mandarin, italian, punjabi sure- all the time - but french? never. Toronto, as far as I know, is not officially bilingual.
 
toronto is in Canada. but when do you ever hear french spoken in toronto? mandarin, italian, punjabi sure- all the time - but french? never. Toronto, as far as I know, is not officially bilingual.

I think you are mistaken on this. I am not an expert on this stuff, but I was under the impression that all of Canada is Officially Bilingual. Something to do with our Constitution.

Regardless, that was not the point. The point is that in order to get the best and brightest employees and managers, many companies offer certain perks. One of the perks in many organizations is educational improvement. Many companies limit what they will pay for including education. The issue should not be that Giambrone took the lessons. The lessons were approved and reimbursed. So that meant he was allowed to take the lessons.

The question should be why was he allowed to take the lesson? Why was he allowed to spend so much on lessons. If you enroll in a Continuing Education through the Toronto School Board, the cost of French Lessons is something like 100 for a 3 month course.
 
I think you are mistaken on this. I am not an expert on this stuff, but I was under the impression that all of Canada is Officially Bilingual. Something to do with our Constitution.

Regardless, that was not the point. The point is that in order to get the best and brightest employees and managers, many companies offer certain perks. One of the perks in many organizations is educational improvement. Many companies limit what they will pay for including education. The issue should not be that Giambrone took the lessons. The lessons were approved and reimbursed. So that meant he was allowed to take the lessons.

The question should be why was he allowed to take the lesson? Why was he allowed to spend so much on lessons. If you enroll in a Continuing Education through the Toronto School Board, the cost of French Lessons is something like 100 for a 3 month course.

The Federal gov't, Ontario and NB are officially bilingual. I think thats it.

As far as attracting the best and brightest- that may be ok for companies (thats up to the shareholders). I don't think this should apply to city councillors. I am not saying he didn;t follow whatever policy there was- I am saying it was an inappropriate and unnecessary expense and is evidence of the mind set of these councillors. you raised a great point about these lessons being offered by the TDSB- but I guess that wasn't good enough for adam
 
toronto is in Canada. but when do you ever hear french spoken in toronto? mandarin, italian, punjabi sure- all the time - but french? never. Toronto, as far as I know, is not officially bilingual.

Easy does it boyo. There are ~15,000 francophones in TO. They have their own bookstores, theatre and can get their health done at St Mike's with a reasonable expectation of a first language conversation. There is even a French college campus in TO.
 
Easy does it boyo. There are ~15,000 francophones in TO. They have their own bookstores, theatre and can get their health done at St Mike's with a reasonable expectation of a first language conversation. There is even a French college campus in TO.

15K out of 3 million? yes there is a french campus in Toronto- but its principally full of english kids who did french immersion. lets look at ward 18 and the city of toronto languages:
http://www.toronto.ca/wards2000/pdf/2006/ward18_ethnocultural_page.pdf

french is the 9th most common language in ward 18 ( i guess adam already knows the other 8 languages) and doesn't make the top ten in city as a whole. so not much french is spoken in toronto.

In any event- the city of toronto is still not officially bilingual. so why should he take french lessons paid for by the citizens of toronto?
 
15K out of 3 million? yes there is a french campus in Toronto- but its principally full of english kids who did french immersion. lets look at ward 18 and the city of toronto languages:
http://www.toronto.ca/wards2000/pdf/2006/ward18_ethnocultural_page.pdf

french is the 9th most common language in ward 18 ( i guess adam already knows the other 8 languages) and doesn't make the top ten in city as a whole. so not much french is spoken in toronto.

In any event- the city of toronto is still not officially bilingual. so why should he take french lessons paid for by the citizens of toronto?

You know this about the college. I'l guess you've been there, sat in on a class or two, or even contemplated going; maybe not.
 
Difference is that it was the company that paid. If some company paid for Giambrone's French lessons, then good for him. If he expensed it using tax dollars... the f**k him. And he expensed it after he knew he was out.

Don't people keep saying they want government to be run more like a business? Gimbrone as an employee is entitled to come consideration in outplacement training. It's not a big enough deal to worry about IMHO.
 
I would ban language lessons for councillors. Its an unecessary expense- unlike the feds- Toronto only has one official language.

Which is what? Can you provide a citation? I believe the City of Toronto provides services in 150 to 180 different languages.
 
Obama is spending $200 M a DAY to be in India......

Now that's an expense report....

OTB
CNBC, a republican tainted business channel, reported today that the 200 million story simply isnt true.
 
Don't people keep saying they want government to be run more like a business? Gimbrone as an employee is entitled to come consideration in outplacement training. It's not a big enough deal to worry about IMHO.

Yes it should be run more like a business, and one of the major things a business looks at when paying for things like language lessons or post graduate degrees is , is this something we need to assist the company, will it help the botom line?,.

Giambrone was one of the councilors that was active in francophone politicians groups, he was one of the Toronto reps I beleive. That was the original reason for the lessons, once he removed himself from the picture the lessons should have been carried on at his expense not the cities.