hoser1970 said:
As I have never been married and no children, I hesitate to post here! I will not comment on any of the issues stated above except to say...
a) the reason child support is ordered IS to support and provide for the child or children of the payor
b) any attempt on the part of the payor to forsake their responsibility as a parent is irresponsible and reprehensible (IMHO)!
c) most reasonable people do not "voluntarily" make a career change that results in significantly lower income. Therefore tha change was either involuntary (ie. got fired, laid off etc, and would seem therefore to be grounds for re-visiting the support order) OR is voluntary but they are being paid additional income under the table to avoid supports payment and/or taxes (see point B)
The law attempts to look at what the child's situation would have been had the family unit remained intact. Therefore, if the custodial parent's income increases, it is deemed that the child would have benefited from this had the family unit remained together, therefore this does NOT correlate into a decrease of the required support payments from the non-custodial parent.
Is our system perfect? Of course not! But what is the alternative? Make the child suffer?
Unfortunately this is all too common in our society today! People (men AND women) need to understand that with choices come consequences. If you choose to marry and pro-create, the consequences are that you will be held responsible for the well-being of the child even if the marriage doesn't last. If you are not willing to accept this consequence, then don't make the choice in the first place!
I am all in favour of this website!
P.S. I am a MAN. This means I would accept my responsibility if I became a father.
This all sounds eminently reasonable and a good analysis hoser. I clearly have a different perspective though. Here's some more of it.
Just bytheway, unless you are anti-adoption and a right to lifer, you don't really believe "If you choose to marry and pro-create, the consequences are that you will be held responsible for the well-being of the child". But this isn't my problem now.
Courts run a justice system, in name anyway, they really try and uphold the law, not always just and therefore the blind scales.
However, when applied in a subjective way the courts are doing something other than upholding the law, clearly for what they believe is a just outcome but not the law.
In any event, when the website points to parents (mainly fathers) who are skirting court ordered support payments that may or may not be expedient (it's clearly counter all other remedies the courts take in other types of cases).
My problem is that what is ALWAYS in the best interest of the kid is to have both parents in it's life to love, be loved and most especially to be parented (whatever you deem that to be).
A nonpaying parent is subject to some or all of the following
1. credit rating reporting
2. garnishment to 100% of wages
3. transfer of government monies owed (tax, social assistance, etc.)
4. loss of drivers licenses
5. 6 months in jail (probably not the country club variety)
Most of the above do not help in earning a better wage, and none of the above either absolves the arrears or stops the accumulation of ongoing debt. So once in jail the $$ owed just keep going up with no source of income. I don't know any of the guys on the website now but I would lay odds that none have secret agents sitting at home clipping coupons for when they get out of jail.
There is no equivalent in any other form of debt collection, not civilly (which is what family court orders are) or criminal fines, restitution, or victim surcharges, nothing, nowhere, Nada.
Now add to the above widespread, broadly publicized public humiliation. Go get a good paying job after that.
On the other hand, kids need support and both parents, and because good parents can be earning (or not) the quantum of support has less to do with good parenting than the actual hands on parenting the kid gets. Just look at what happens when one parent is absent from the kids life, no guarantee but the odds of a good healthy kid and future productive member of society drop significantly, I won't argue this but look it up.
The point has been made in a couple of other posts here, the only remedy for a parent (generally moms), who denies the kid the opportunity of being parented by both parents even when they need to be ordered to do so, is contempt of court. For all intent and purpose NEVER gets applied.
So the application of whats in the kids best interest is a bit skewed wouldn't you say?
Now, add the all this that already, of the first few GUYS that are on the site there are mistakes. The government run organization is overwhelmed. Even if they were all law grads they will make mistakes, but they aren't law grads, they make more mistakes. Some of these guys phone numbers are in the phone book and they answer when the media calls and have a very different story than just being dead beats, they are over assessed, under valued as parents, and paying what they can while they themselves live in appalling conditions already.
Women who understand this system, and once in the system with a lawyer they all understand it, they can and often do lie, accuse and make life unbearable for their own kids other parent in ways that make it very difficult to pay anything. Just one example and then I'll leave you alone.
The couple marry, buy a house, have a kid pay off the mortgage before saving. She wants out of the marriage, he leaves the house, has no savings, now has to continue to pay support, start paying for his own roof, and legals, all without the support of his past lifestyle, under what is termed the second most stressful thing anyone can survive, in a system thats overwhelmingly stacked against him and in favour the mom.
Now, do you still think the website is in the best interest of the kid?
Sorry about taking so much band width, I'm a bit concerned with how we are treating men now though.