Deadbeat Dads web-site (Good or Bad?)

Deadbeat Dads web-site?

  • Good

    Votes: 36 60.0%
  • Bad

    Votes: 24 40.0%

  • Total voters
    60
Good idea if you are a child living in poverty because your father refuses to pay child support because he is an asshole and is pissed off at your mother. Also a good idea if you are a taxpayer because the mother in question may be on welfare because she cannot support her family. I can't think of any reason why it would be a bad idea, unless you are a deadbeat dad.
 
Questor said:
Good idea if you are a child living in poverty because your father refuses to pay child support because he is an asshole and is pissed off at your mother. Also a good idea if you are a taxpayer because the mother in question may be on welfare because she cannot support her family. I can't think of any reason why it would be a bad idea, unless you are a deadbeat dad.

Well then, considering that I'm neither separated nor divorced and have no children out of wedlock (and therefore not a deadbeat dad), here's some things for you to think about:

  • Some people are in arrears because the child support was ordered based on previous, rather than current income (the courts will attribute income to the spouse paying support based on what the court thinks he should be making).
  • There is no corresponding way to enforce visitation rights with mothers who aren't abiding by their obligations to their children.
  • Mothers are not accountable for how they spend child support payments. Many do not spend the money on the children.
  • Even if the mother's income goes up dramatically after separation, the father's support obligations will not diminish. The custodial parent has no matching, quantifiable support obligations to the children.
  • Child support only becomes necessary when there is no joint custody arrangement or order. Most women seek custody for this financial reason, in effect using the children as pawns to achieve a better financial outcome for the mother.

I'm sure there's a lot more to the "deadbeat" dad side of the story than just this list. Did you really think the issue was as simple as women's rights groups try to describe it?

All our family laws actually accomplish is to provide an outlet for the vindictiveness of people.
 
I am almost overwhelmed by the misconceptions and flat out absurdities posted above.

"Some people are in arrears because the child support was ordered based on previous, rather than current income (the courts will attribute income to the spouse paying support based on what the court thinks he should be making)."
Support is based on previous year's income - if there is a LEGITIMATE change in the payors income there is a process by which the support amount can be varied. Payor fathers seem to experience dramatic drop offs in earnings and income with much greater frequency than the general population at large and then are surprised to find out that they are not the first to find out that judges are actually not that stupid.

"There is no corresponding way to enforce visitation rights with mothers who aren't abiding by their obligations to their children."
Its called a contempt order.

"Even if the mother's income goes up dramatically after separation, the father's support obligations will not diminish. The custodial parent has no matching, quantifiable support obligations to the children."
Both parents have support obligations to the children. A parent's support obligation is based on what the parent earns. The support belongs to the children and is the obligation of the parent, regardless of what the custodial spouse is earning. If a guy is separated or gets a divorce he still has financial obligations to his children that are proportional to what he earns - he doesn't get a "get out of jail free" card simply because his spouse is a high earner or marries a high earner - his kids are still entitled to support from him. Child suport is not spousal support.

"Child support only becomes necessary when there is no joint custody arrangement or order."
Joint custody has nothing to do with the amount of child support. Joint custody is about who is making the decisions re education, religion etc.. Child support amounts will be altered if the children are splitting their time between their parents roughly equally (this is not joint custody - this is simply an arrangement of custody and access). To have an equal split of time you generally have to have the kids moving around a fair bit - often during the week. It can work in some circumstances but it shouldn't be imposed just so one parent can avoid having to pay child support - it is the best interests of the child that dictate these issues, not "how can we avoid child support".
 
colt said:
I am almost overwhelmed by the misconceptions and flat out absurdities posted above.

"Some people are in arrears because the child support was ordered based on previous, rather than current income (the courts will attribute income to the spouse paying support based on what the court thinks he should be making)."
Support is based on previous year's income - if there is a LEGITIMATE change in the payors income there is a process by which the support amount can be varied. Payor fathers seem to experience dramatic drop offs in earnings and income with much greater frequency than the general population at large and then are surprised to find out that they are not the first to find out that judges are actually not that stupid.".

Actualy generaly speaking judges are quite smart, unfortunately they have to follow the law, both as written and as interpreted. The politization of the courts has lead to lots of written law becoming ignored over emphasized or rewritten to accomplish what the politicaly appointed judges feel is "good" for society. Men are over represented as payers, as noncustodial and as perpetrators. Even a stupid judge could figure out that those stats don't conform to societial ratios.


colt said:
"There is no corresponding way to enforce visitation rights with mothers who aren't abiding by their obligations to their children."
Its called a contempt order.".

I hear a lot about visitation being denied, not very much (in fact nothing) about contempt orders. The reasoning is that sending a woman to jail or imposing a fine will harm the child.

colt said:
"Even if the mother's income goes up dramatically after separation, the father's support obligations will not diminish. The custodial parent has no matching, quantifiable support obligations to the children."
Both parents have support obligations to the children. A parent's support obligation is based on what the parent earns. The support belongs to the children and is the obligation of the parent, regardless of what the custodial spouse is earning. If a guy is separated or gets a divorce he still has financial obligations to his children that are proportional to what he earns - he doesn't get a "get out of jail free" card simply because his spouse is a high earner or marries a high earner - his kids are still entitled to support from him. Child suport is not spousal support.".

Actually a portion of the calculation in child support is to pay for the expences of the custodial parent, ie. shelter and transportation are clear examples. There is no reduction in support payments based on the time and money spent during visitation untill the threashold of 40% of time is reached. Further a women can, and they have been given full support payments by 1- non biological fathers based on true or false claims of the fathers identity, 2 - full support payments by 2 or more men based on prior relationships 3 - full support based on demial of access to arrive at the threashold limit.

colt said:
"Child support only becomes necessary when there is no joint custody arrangement or order."
Joint custody has nothing to do with the amount of child support. Joint custody is about who is making the decisions re education, religion etc.. Child support amounts will be altered if the children are splitting their time between their parents roughly equally (this is not joint custody - this is simply an arrangement of custody and access). To have an equal split of time you generally have to have the kids moving around a fair bit - often during the week. It can work in some circumstances but it shouldn't be imposed just so one parent can avoid having to pay child support - it is the best interests of the child that dictate these issues, not "how can we avoid child support".

You got this one right.

The bottom line is that of all the cases going before the courts 95% are decided in favour of the woman and child and against the father and child. Women are seen as the underdog needing the courts help. Sometime in the future we may value men to same extent we have become paternistic about women.
 
Why shouldn't a man put in support payments even if a womans income does go up. He partook in the birth of the children that he had. This will allow only for the child to live an even more enjoyable comfortable life and God forbid if the woman loses her job and has a little extra in her bank account to support her children with till she finds something else. Or if she has extra and can afford to send the children to college. I think most parents want what is best for thier children.

If the Mother is a good Mom she will always put the needs of her children first above her own. The sad thing is is that some of those men were in Canada and most likely went back to thier own countries or elsewhere where they just turned thier backs and walked away without ever hearing another word about how thier children are doing. What will the children think of thier fathers in the future then? Let alone he never paid support but he never called and he never came around to see them.
 
stacey4u2luv said:
If the Mother is a good Mom she will always put the needs of her children first above her own. The sad thing is is that some of those men were in Canada and most likely went back to thier own countries or elsewhere where they just turned thier backs and walked away without ever hearing another word about how thier children are doing. What will the children think of thier fathers in the future then? Let alone he never paid support but he never called and he never came around to see them.

It's amazing what happens to people when they split up and a kid is invovled. That caring parent (mom or dad) can get so defensive, defiant, and vindictive that whats best for the kid gets incororated into whats best for the kid and ME.

Pathological parental alienation is a syndrome which occurs most often during devorce/separation. The custodial parent (most often the mom) denegrads and osticies the other parent (most often the dad) in such a way that the target parent is no longer part of the kids life. This is a major reason some kids never see or hear from their dads.

There are cases where dads don't want to see their kids, this is unfortunate and rare. There are of course more cases, very unfortunate as well where moms don't want to see their kids in similar circumstances, they usually adopt out or abort with little or no social stigmna.

KIDS NEED BOTH PARENTS.
 
colt said:
I am almost overwhelmed by the misconceptions and flat out absurdities posted above."

Very Shy covered a fair bit of the ground, but I'll add a couple more points. In short, I think you've exaggerated the points you've made.

colt said:
"Some people are in arrears because the child support was ordered based on previous, rather than current income (the courts will attribute income to the spouse paying support based on what the court thinks he should be making)."
Support is based on previous year's income - if there is a LEGITIMATE change in the payors income there is a process by which the support amount can be varied. Payor fathers seem to experience dramatic drop offs in earnings and income with much greater frequency than the general population at large and then are surprised to find out that they are not the first to find out that judges are actually not that stupid.

The problem is all in defining what is a "legitimate" change in circumstances. As a practical matter, the courts act on the assumption that any voluntary change made which resulted in lower income was irresponsible, and they are prepared to attribute income to men which they did not actually earn. Of course, expenses can also change dramatically, even if income doesn't. Child support is tied to income, not the relationship of income to expenses. In other words, you're quibbling with the truth here.

colt said:
"There is no corresponding way to enforce visitation rights with mothers who aren't abiding by their obligations to their children."
Its called a contempt order.

As pointed out by Very Shy, this is an empty remedy. Courts will not punish mothers in any way for their contempt of access orders as to do so would also punish the children.

colt said:
"Even if the mother's income goes up dramatically after separation, the father's support obligations will not diminish. The custodial parent has no matching, quantifiable support obligations to the children."
Both parents have support obligations to the children. A parent's support obligation is based on what the parent earns. The support belongs to the children and is the obligation of the parent, regardless of what the custodial spouse is earning. If a guy is separated or gets a divorce he still has financial obligations to his children that are proportional to what he earns - he doesn't get a "get out of jail free" card simply because his spouse is a high earner or marries a high earner - his kids are still entitled to support from him. Child suport is not spousal support.

The point here is "quantifiable". The custodial parent gets to decide how much of their income to spend on their kids. Their support obligations are "conceptual" but not quantified. The non-custodial parent does not enjoy this discretion. It seems logical to me (and plenty of others) that kids do not have to live like rock stars even if their parents can afford it. The courts should accept the reasonable judgement of a parent regarding the appropriate standard of living for his/her children. If mommy wants to spoil the kids (and they often do, because they usually want the emotional loyalty of the kids), it should be on her dime. If the parents agree on a standard of living to be maintained by the kids, they should contribute to that standard proprotionate to their means.

colt said:
"Child support only becomes necessary when there is no joint custody arrangement or order."
Joint custody has nothing to do with the amount of child support. Joint custody is about who is making the decisions re education, religion etc.. Child support amounts will be altered if the children are splitting their time between their parents roughly equally (this is not joint custody - this is simply an arrangement of custody and access). To have an equal split of time you generally have to have the kids moving around a fair bit - often during the week. It can work in some circumstances but it shouldn't be imposed just so one parent can avoid having to pay child support - it is the best interests of the child that dictate these issues, not "how can we avoid child support".

Joint custody is the key to equal sharing of living arrangements. When both parents are actually providing their share of the necessities of life, because the kids live with them half the time, there is no need (or at least a subtantially lessened need, given how many mothers have jobs) for anyone to cut child support cheques. Sorry I didn't take the time to paint the entire picture, but I thought the implications were obvious. The equal split between parents is a positive on every level, and is certainly not just a scheme to reduce child support. Maybe judges think about this concept the same way you do? That would explain the lopsided custody decisions.
 
LMAO!!! This should be very interesting once more woman get ahold of it. I am sure there will be thousands of pages. Hey, do not be surprised if some of you know some of these guys. Maybe some of them are TERB members. LMAO.
 
very shy said:
Further a women can, and they have been given full support payments by 1- non biological fathers based on true or false claims of the fathers identity, 2 - full support payments by 2 or more men based on prior relationships. . .
Unfortunately, if you're in the position where there might be any reason at all to believe the child isn't yours, have a paternity test done sooner rather than later. It is well-established law that children born in a marriage are ipso facto children of that marriage (your only - slim - hope is proving the child isn't yours from the outset). Even then this may avail you nothing inasmuch as courts have ruled that raising a child as if it is yours is grounds for imposing child support (both married and common-law partners).

Further, particularly in unmarried situations women really call the shots. In many ways the man might as well be a drone honeybee. The man doesn't want to have a child and is wearing a condom, the woman tells him she's on "the pill," lets say she's actually taking fertility drugs, the condom fails and the woman becomes pregnant - he wants her to have an abortion, she refuses and wants to keep the child. Despite the fraud, too bad, there's still a 99.9 percent chance he'll be on the hook for child support for the next 18 years, and his only hope of gaining child custody would be if she's just a total train wreak.

For example (and I have no way of knowing their situation and do not imply nor believe it is as above), look at the situation of NFL Quarterback T. E. "Tom" Brady, Jr and Actress K. Bridget Moynahan. Basicly he's just along for the ride.
 
All our family laws actually accomplish is to provide an outlet for the vindictiveness of people.

Believe it or not some people are in arrears because the child support was ordered based on imputed (made up) income, rather than current or previous income (the courts will attribute income to the spouse paying support based on what the court believes he could be making with an ideal job).

The mother's income is irrelevant. She could be living on lottery winnings and her impoverished ex husband still has to pay whether he can afford it or not, whether he is injured and cant work, whether he provides for his children directly and voluntarily or not.

There is so much more to the "deadbeat" dad side of the story. A one-two punch. The biased rules create the arrears. The arrears status puts the dad in a subservient position that he can never climb out of. This is a form of persecution that the courts will apologize for posthumously when the men affected are too old or too far down the hole to recover from the damage done.

In my case, my daughter lives with me. Her mother abandoned her to me two years ago after she hit her teens because she was a management problem. In my home she thrives in school, works a part time job and has a decent social life. She is learning the guitar. She could be better at housework but its not an issue for abandonment yet. Prior to my daughters move, while fighting for custody, improper support payments were ordered that exceeded my actual reported and proven income. I owe arrears for 103 percent of what I actually earned for two years of my life. The courts were not only blind in my cause they were deaf and sound asleep. The accumulated weight of the paperwork I generated to support my case is about 70lbs and according to the judge "ironclad". But due to criteria that I cannot begin to comprehend or explain, my previous order has not been varied and my arrears have not been set aside. Furthermore support payments were not ordered against the mother and will not be because she is apparently disabled. Even though she has no medical evidence to support the claim. Even though one of her doctors came forward and testified that she is faking.

I gave up after years of fighting because I needed to move on with my life and take care of my daughter. I feel like that guy in prison in "Harold and Kumar go to Whitecastle" who came to accept his situation in life. So I have worked out a mutually accepted and payment agreement that won't break me yet it will have the final payment made to my ex when my daughter turns 42. She is 16 now. It must be a good agreement because my ex has given up her daughter easier than she gave up the money.

Except for two birthday presents and one christmas present her mother has had zero involvement for more than two years. The courts would not order support against her or impute her income. Simply put the courts are honor bound to punish men to compensate for a legacy of mistreated women. I look forward to seeing my portrait in the deadbeat dad hall of shame.
 
"The problem is all in defining what is a "legitimate" change in circumstances. As a practical matter, the courts act on the assumption that any voluntary change made which resulted in lower income was irresponsible, and they are prepared to attribute income to men which they did not actually earn."

Yes, because shockingly the number of payors in Family Court who have sudden down turns in income after a separation or divorce is drastically out of proportion to what normally occurs in society.

"Child support is tied to income, not the relationship of income to expenses. In other words, you're quibbling with the truth here."
I didn't quibble with anything - child support is tied to a parents income and it is the right of the child to recieve a proportion of the parent's income as support. There is no quibbling, that is the black and white of the law. If you want to argue over whether the law is fair that is one thing, but there is no quibbling about what the law is. As for the issue of expenses increasing - it doesn't get much sympathy. Your children are your priority, you meet their needs first and adjust your expenses accordingly. There are very few , if any, expenses in life that are completely beyond our control.

The courts should accept the reasonable judgment of a parent.
Yes, that will certainly streamline the court process. The child support guidelines were brought in so that we could eliminate three week trials, and arguments for interm orders and interm interm orders over quantums of child support. The courts cannot accept the "reasonable judgment of a parent" because the child has TWO parents - both of whom are entitled to a say. It was simply decided that the most practical and logical way to decide on the level of support owed was to tie it to a parent's income. But by all means lets go back to the old way and have long trials and motions arguing about what the std of living was before the separation and what it should be now - the family lawyers will certainly be happy.

Also you do not get to exercise "judgment" about what your child is entitled to because support is not a gift to the child or a privilege it is something you owe the child and it is not at your discretion how much or how little support that child is owed.

"Joint custody is the key to equal sharing of living arrangements ...The equal split between parents is a positive on every level, and is certainly not just a scheme to reduce child support. "

Joint custody is the key to prolonged litigation. Judges hate it and for good reason. The only thing that is certain in any family dispute is that the two adults have demonstrated, quite clearly, that they cannot function as a unit...and many are quite happy to demonstrate that they cannot function to agree on even the simplest issues let alone something signifcant like education or religion. Further, an equal split is not a positive if a child is being moved around 2 or 3 times a week - children need stability to thrive and, no matter how good the intentions of two parents, shuttling between two principal residences does not provide stability.

Clearly we are bound to disagree. But aprospo of nothing...lets have a show of hands on how many people who so firmly believe the courts are against men (because it is well established that historically the interest's of men are under reprensented in politics and law) are subject to a child support order or have been in the past.

Personally, my interest and knowlege of family law is purely professional. I have studied it and represented clients on both sides of the table but have never been a party personally. No law or regime will be perfect but the cry of men that they are getting short changed in the deal rings hollow in the face of the day to day realities of family court. If you feel you are entitled to joint custody and equal access you make that case BEFORE the separation, not during the litigation. So if you choose not to ever attend a parent-teacher interview, change a diaper or a dirty bed, if you don't take time off work to go to doctor's appt's etc. for the whole time you are living as a family - don't be surprised when the court appointed assessor finds in favour of the child's mother and the judge gives little weight to your pleas for equal access and reduced child support.

My last comment - judges are still largely men and they all used to be lawyers. Divorces and separations are as common (if not moreso) among lawyers as in any segment of the population. Judges themselves or, at the very least, their former friends and colleagues have all been down this road - so have the politicians that drafted the legislation for that matter. Its a little ridiculous for men to stand and portray themselves as victims in the political / legal process.

FYI - I no longer do family law. Many lawyers make a living doing it and some may even enjoy it. For me there is not enough money to deal with that level of bitterness day in and day out.
 
colt. said:
colt: Personally, my interest and knowlege of family law is purely professional. I have studied it and represented clients on both sides of the table but have never been a party personally. No law or regime will be perfect but the cry of men that they are getting short changed in the deal rings hollow in the face of the day to day realities of family court. If you feel you are entitled to joint custody and equal access you make that case BEFORE the separation, not during the litigation. So if you choose not to ever attend a parent-teacher interview, change a diaper or a dirty bed, if you don't take time off work to go to doctor's appt's etc. for the whole time you are living as a family - don't be surprised when the court appointed assessor finds in favour of the child's mother and the judge gives little weight to your pleas for equal access and reduced child support.

My last comment - judges are still largely men and they all used to be lawyers. Divorces and separations are as common (if not moreso) among lawyers as in any segment of the population. Judges themselves or, at the very least, their former friends and colleagues have all been down this road - so have the politicians that drafted the legislation for that matter. Its a little ridiculous for men to stand and portray themselves as victims in the political / legal process.

FYI - I no longer do family law. Many lawyers make a living doing it and some may even enjoy it. For me there is not enough money to deal with that level of bitterness day in and day out.

I respect that your comments as a practitionor. So with that due respect I say, you're full of State Highjacked Intelectual Tonguetwisting.

Men are the bottom of the barrel in court family and criminal. I said this before and will repeat it. Women are always victims, men are always agresors and perpetrators in the eyes of the court, the crown and victim witness services. There are 2 divisions in the crowns office. 1 for domestic violence, the other for murder, sexual assault, assault, robbery, and EVERY other criminal matter. The overwhelmingly largest portion of prosecutions in the Domestic Violence unit is against men. There is zero tolerance and a mandate that all men are fully prosecuted. As one judge said, the crown prosecutes the slightest touch as though they had fortuitously gotten to the murderer seconds before he would have pulled the trigger.

Yes, manny law makers (politicians and judges) are men, many of whom have gone through the family court system or know others that have. But you are intelligent enough to have a law degree, do you for one instant believe that any of them are uninfluenced by the barage of lobbying done on behalf of radicle feminists? on behalf of or directly by interested parties like NOW, LEAF or even the federal women's ministry who by the way dole out millions per year to organizations who litteraly do nothing but lobby for ever increasing power to women.

Ever watch tv? When was the last time you saw a women being slapped around or demeaned by a man in a commercial? How about the same with gender reversals? I can name 5 or 6 in the recent past that fit the last category.

Men have been so deeply cast to the bottom of the social heap we are not worth more than the money in our wallets, and sometimes the money that not in our wallets. Children are deemed to be well taken care of if they see their fathers 2 days a month. or even if they have contact strictly by email (no kidding no exaggeration). I know a case where 3 loving kids were allowed to see their father for 54 hour per YEAR, and then only with a suppervisor in an office building.

Not that they don't exist, but I don't hear of moms in the same situation, ever.

Men and women deliver different and equaly important qualities to their children, women stand at the bottom of the slide ready to catch the kid if he falls, men keep encouraging them to go higher. Both help to give that child a chance at reaching his full potential.


PHEW!

I feel a bit better now.

pS men are often (I use the term on purpose) driven to such dispare that they make arrangements as are neccessary, write a short note, then end their pain. The kids, rarely, if ever are even told of the event.
 
As I have never been married and no children, I hesitate to post here! I will not comment on any of the issues stated above except to say...

a) the reason child support is ordered IS to support and provide for the child or children of the payor
b) any attempt on the part of the payor to forsake their responsibility as a parent is irresponsible and reprehensible (IMHO)!
c) most reasonable people do not "voluntarily" make a career change that results in significantly lower income. Therefore tha change was either involuntary (ie. got fired, laid off etc, and would seem therefore to be grounds for re-visiting the support order) OR is voluntary but they are being paid additional income under the table to avoid supports payment and/or taxes (see point B)

The law attempts to look at what the child's situation would have been had the family unit remained intact. Therefore, if the custodial parent's income increases, it is deemed that the child would have benefited from this had the family unit remained together, therefore this does NOT correlate into a decrease of the required support payments from the non-custodial parent.

Is our system perfect? Of course not! But what is the alternative? Make the child suffer?

Unfortunately this is all too common in our society today! People (men AND women) need to understand that with choices come consequences. If you choose to marry and pro-create, the consequences are that you will be held responsible for the well-being of the child even if the marriage doesn't last. If you are not willing to accept this consequence, then don't make the choice in the first place!

I am all in favour of this website!

P.S. I am a MAN. This means I would accept my responsibility if I became a father.
 
hoser1970 said:
As I have never been married and no children, I hesitate to post here! I will not comment on any of the issues stated above except to say...

a) the reason child support is ordered IS to support and provide for the child or children of the payor
b) any attempt on the part of the payor to forsake their responsibility as a parent is irresponsible and reprehensible (IMHO)!
c) most reasonable people do not "voluntarily" make a career change that results in significantly lower income. Therefore tha change was either involuntary (ie. got fired, laid off etc, and would seem therefore to be grounds for re-visiting the support order) OR is voluntary but they are being paid additional income under the table to avoid supports payment and/or taxes (see point B)

The law attempts to look at what the child's situation would have been had the family unit remained intact. Therefore, if the custodial parent's income increases, it is deemed that the child would have benefited from this had the family unit remained together, therefore this does NOT correlate into a decrease of the required support payments from the non-custodial parent.

Is our system perfect? Of course not! But what is the alternative? Make the child suffer?

Unfortunately this is all too common in our society today! People (men AND women) need to understand that with choices come consequences. If you choose to marry and pro-create, the consequences are that you will be held responsible for the well-being of the child even if the marriage doesn't last. If you are not willing to accept this consequence, then don't make the choice in the first place!

I am all in favour of this website!

P.S. I am a MAN. This means I would accept my responsibility if I became a father.

This all sounds eminently reasonable and a good analysis hoser. I clearly have a different perspective though. Here's some more of it.

Just bytheway, unless you are anti-adoption and a right to lifer, you don't really believe "If you choose to marry and pro-create, the consequences are that you will be held responsible for the well-being of the child". But this isn't my problem now.

Courts run a justice system, in name anyway, they really try and uphold the law, not always just and therefore the blind scales.

However, when applied in a subjective way the courts are doing something other than upholding the law, clearly for what they believe is a just outcome but not the law.

In any event, when the website points to parents (mainly fathers) who are skirting court ordered support payments that may or may not be expedient (it's clearly counter all other remedies the courts take in other types of cases).

My problem is that what is ALWAYS in the best interest of the kid is to have both parents in it's life to love, be loved and most especially to be parented (whatever you deem that to be).

A nonpaying parent is subject to some or all of the following
1. credit rating reporting
2. garnishment to 100% of wages
3. transfer of government monies owed (tax, social assistance, etc.)
4. loss of drivers licenses
5. 6 months in jail (probably not the country club variety)

Most of the above do not help in earning a better wage, and none of the above either absolves the arrears or stops the accumulation of ongoing debt. So once in jail the $$ owed just keep going up with no source of income. I don't know any of the guys on the website now but I would lay odds that none have secret agents sitting at home clipping coupons for when they get out of jail.

There is no equivalent in any other form of debt collection, not civilly (which is what family court orders are) or criminal fines, restitution, or victim surcharges, nothing, nowhere, Nada.

Now add to the above widespread, broadly publicized public humiliation. Go get a good paying job after that.

On the other hand, kids need support and both parents, and because good parents can be earning (or not) the quantum of support has less to do with good parenting than the actual hands on parenting the kid gets. Just look at what happens when one parent is absent from the kids life, no guarantee but the odds of a good healthy kid and future productive member of society drop significantly, I won't argue this but look it up.

The point has been made in a couple of other posts here, the only remedy for a parent (generally moms), who denies the kid the opportunity of being parented by both parents even when they need to be ordered to do so, is contempt of court. For all intent and purpose NEVER gets applied.

So the application of whats in the kids best interest is a bit skewed wouldn't you say?

Now, add the all this that already, of the first few GUYS that are on the site there are mistakes. The government run organization is overwhelmed. Even if they were all law grads they will make mistakes, but they aren't law grads, they make more mistakes. Some of these guys phone numbers are in the phone book and they answer when the media calls and have a very different story than just being dead beats, they are over assessed, under valued as parents, and paying what they can while they themselves live in appalling conditions already.

Women who understand this system, and once in the system with a lawyer they all understand it, they can and often do lie, accuse and make life unbearable for their own kids other parent in ways that make it very difficult to pay anything. Just one example and then I'll leave you alone.

The couple marry, buy a house, have a kid pay off the mortgage before saving. She wants out of the marriage, he leaves the house, has no savings, now has to continue to pay support, start paying for his own roof, and legals, all without the support of his past lifestyle, under what is termed the second most stressful thing anyone can survive, in a system thats overwhelmingly stacked against him and in favour the mom.

Now, do you still think the website is in the best interest of the kid?

Sorry about taking so much band width, I'm a bit concerned with how we are treating men now though.
 
Its a great idea ..... I saw that ln ch live months ago. and i emailed them my opinion no point in copying and pasting it again when its already aired on tv.

with my girlfriend raising her son all by herself, and my friend raising her 2 sons by herself and with my other friend raising her daughter, and being growing up with a dead beat dad.

They need to feel shame for nothing being REAL fathers.
 
I am not sure how I feel about the website. On one hand I believe if it gets a few deadbeat fathers to pay up, that's GREAT, but on the other hand you can't SHAME somebody who doesn't have any shame.

I'm speaking from experience. If your baby father doesn't feel it or have it in his mind that supporting his child is the right thing to do than no website or picture will make him.
 
Questor said:
Good idea if you are a child living in poverty because you
get to finally see who your dad is.

Questor said:
Good idea if you are a child living in poverty because your father refuses to pay child support because he
got screwed by the courts

Questor said:
Good idea if you are a child living in poverty because your father refuses to pay child support because he is an asshole and is pissed off at your mother.
because she won't let you see your kids

Questor said:
I can't think of any reason why it would be a bad idea, unless you are a deadbeat dad.
The courts are tilted because of spineless lawyers. Granted, some people just weren't meant to be parents, or at least be in a stupid relationship. See what happens when the little head does the thinking, and then reality rears it's ugly head. For every action, there is an equal and opposing reaction. From what I've seen, you can't blame it all on the dads. But I do agree that the taxpayer shouldn't be footing the bill.

Solution: Ban alcohol as a beverage before having sex.
Manditory condoms, until you are sure you are compatable, and will stay with your partner.
Manitory investments into a RCSSP. Registered Child Support Savings Plan. If you don't have any kids, you get it back upon proof of a vesectomy, or as part of a retirement fund.
 
It's a twisted system

colt said:
I am almost overwhelmed by the misconceptions and flat out absurdities posted above.

Support is based on previous year's income - if there is a LEGITIMATE change in the payors income there is a process by which the support amount can be varied. Payor fathers seem to experience dramatic drop offs in earnings and income with much greater frequency than the general population at large and then are surprised to find out that they are not the first to find out that judges are actually not that stupid.

Its called a contempt order.

Both parents have support obligations to the children. A parent's support obligation is based on what the parent earns. The support belongs to the children and is the obligation of the parent, regardless of what the custodial spouse is earning. If a guy is separated or gets a divorce he still has financial obligations to his children that are proportional to what he earns - he doesn't get a "get out of jail free" card simply because his spouse is a high earner or marries a high earner - his kids are still entitled to support from him. Child suport is not spousal support.
I am overwhelmed by the misconceptions and flat out absurdities posted above.

I know several guys who've lost their job at no fault of their own, and were on the hook for the going rate for well over a year before a judge would look at their case to reduce payments. In the meantime, vehicles and houses were lost from going bankrupt. BTW, judges are stupid. No parent should be in a position to gain financially upon a breakup.

I know guys living in their car or bunking at a friends, to keep up with payments, and can barely afford to live themselves.

I've got a friend who's wife left Orillia for Niagara Falls area, and he can't go into Niagara Region because of her BS, so he hasn't seen his kids in 9 years. The Niagara Regional police have put him in the clink overnight when he has gone down there.

I know of one case where the mom went out and got a job as a sales rep, and is making over $100G. He is in house renos, and pays less than $500 per kid, while one of my friends who makes less, is paying $650 per kid.

I know women who have had kids solely for the reason of having guaranteed support. If they can pop them out and have someone else support them, then they don't have to be a real parent, just a custodial guardian.
 
Another Child Support Horror Story

I know a friend who divorced several years ago. Child custody was determined to cover raising the child. He faithfully paid the support. He opted to pay it into a court account which was then drawn by the ex. Even with that paper trail showing payment, she registered him on a dead beat dad web site in BC. So even with proper payment he still was harrassed and impuned. The people that run the site didn't do their homework they just added his name to the list. I don't know if it is resolved yet. I hope the ontario site has better management and is designed to prevent abuse by the petty people among us who are trying to screw sombody by any means available.