someone said:
…edit…No, we don’t agree on that. My comment was with regard to your claim that it could also be said that employers have monopoly power. Unions would not have bargaining power if they did not have some monopoly power.…edit…
Of course, nor would employers. The closer to monopoly the greater the power—what other work is there in the company town? The unions in more open markets like TO's, like any other alert enterprise, are aware their position is always uncertain. Employees do abandon unions they didn't like—it's happened several times in the news media and at the CBC (CUPE lost the jurisdiction there)—precisely because there is no monopoly. Not much different from the company managers tracking prices and costs, and ocassionaly getting it wrong.
Once a contract is in place—like any contract to be the exclusive supplier of a product or service—then there is a monopoly, but it's voluntary and only for the life and terms of the contract.
In my line of work, the union contracts typically allow any member to bargain for better pay (but just imagine the chaos if we all bargained for individual conditions of work) than the minimums in the contract. That contract was negociated with my union by the Producer's Association, who announced one year they would no longer bargain as individual enterprises. And sure enough, there were no individual producers willing to talk.
Their version of the rate clause forbids us from giving a lower rate to any other producers, though we're free to charge more. They have the jobs, we have the skills, the law lets anyone be a producer or technician, and the contract terms bind only those who have agreed to them. Is there a monopoly here? I just don't see it, here, nor with the TTC and ATWU.
BTW CUPE keeps being mentioned as if it was involved w/ the TTC, not so. It's CUPE who are currently working to rule at the school board. I've always loved the irony of strictly following the employers' rules as a strategy. If management actually made useful, productive rules then work to rule would make a place function better than ever wouldn't it?
And on the "restraint of trade" laws banning union membership: I found
this site which says those laws, which made union membership a criminal conspiracy in restraint of trade, were repealed in 1872. A federal law explicitly permitting collective bargaining was passed under Mackenzie King in 1907. In the US the Sherman Anti-Trust law was used against the Pullman strikers in 1894 and according to
this timeline, it wasn't until 1931 that unions were given legal standing.