Crosby vs Gretzky

Anderson

Banned
Feb 7, 2007
1,858
1
0
I was reading somewhere about the similarities between these 2 and their early point totals in their first 2 years I think.

The game back then with the much smaller equipment for the goalies, and also with something like over a full goal per game more scored in 99s first 2 years , as oppossed to Crosby's first 2 years.

I for 1 never thought that 99s records could be touched esp since the trap and the per goal game average going down over 1 per game from the early 80's to now.

When I saw this stat it was really impressive for me
Any comments
 
marc anderson said:
I for 1 never thought that 99s records could be touched esp since the trap and the per goal game average going down over 1 per game from the early 80's to now.

link is to NHL Records:

http://statshockey.homestead.com/nhlrecords.html

If Crosby starts getting close to 200 pts a year then we can start comparing him to the Great One.
 
you'll never really know if Crosby is comparable or better than gretzky... they play in different eras...

both Bobby Orr and Gretzky played when points came by alot easier. that game is long, long gone now.

Gretzky's records- for the most part, are UNTOUCHABLE.

though, i'd love to see the game return to a time where these records can be beat. (but, not with 20 ft goal nets)
 
Oh yeah, I agree.

I really do not want to compare but I noticed this stat, it really impressed me a lot.
 
guyroch said:
Well if James does that then that will be incrediable .. His GM hasn't exactly
surrounded him with a cast that is worthy of winning a conference .
That's right. Lebron has no one to support him and has to take it all on his shoulders,so whomever wants to criticize him should take that into account first.
 
sorry guys. nothing to add. talking NBA is akin to me trying to learn Cantonese.
 
i do agree that basketball is exciting. hockey just happens to be my passion. (like i needed to make that clear!?!) lol...
 
A lot of people are comparing the first two years of both players, but forgetting that it was Gretzky's third season when he kicked his offensive game into another solar system.

`80- 137 pts
`81- 164 pts
`82- 212 pts
`83- 196 pts
`84- 205 pts
`85- 208 pts
`86- 215 pts


It'll be interesting to see if Crosby can up his game even more next season like Gretzky did.

Also, while the relative pros and cons of playing in each era can be debated, whatever they are should affect all players from that era evenly. So you can compare them by looking at how much better they were than everyone else at the time. This is where Gretzky's numbers look the most impressive. The gap between him and everyone else was ridiculous. For example:

`83:

1. Gretzky 196
2. Stastny 124
3. Savard 121
4. Bossy 118

`84:

1. Gretzky 205
2. Coffey 126
3. Goulet 121
4. Stastny 119

Gretzky was miles ahead of everyone else. Back then I remember the usual rule with most hockey playoff pools was that Gretzky couldn't be drafted because whoever got him would be guaranteed victory. I don't know if Crosby will ever reach that status.
 
also, alot of people are forgetting that Gretzky's first season in the NHL was his 2nd year of Pro hockey already. the prior season he played for Indianapolis and Edmonton of the WHA...
 
yah his first pro season he was 17
His first season in the NHL He tied for the scoring championship but did not win because of he did not score as many as Dionne
He did not win rookie honors because the NHL was pissed he played in the WHA AT 17 as a pro.

Crosby looks like a very good player but does not have a hope in hell of beating Gretzky's records. But let us wait a few years to see if he even has a chance
 
speaking of Crosby, Hammertm- did you see that sick goal Sid just scored 1 minute ago against Aebischer?? he was 1 on 4 montreal defenders, broke through wide and blew a shot right from the hash marks to behind Aebischer... this is one of the best goals i've ever seen at Mellon Arena. (of course, there's been alot)
 
guyroch said:
200 ... Have you seen the goalies in Gretz's era ... Holly cow were they small
in those nets ... :)

I would have to say that the Oilers had the smallest goalies. Fuhr and Moog were short.

http://www.hockeygoalies.org/

Prior to the Great Ones era, Dryden would dwarf most modern day net minders.

Anyways, remember one thing about Gretzky. Jari Kurri. Four 50 goal seasons plus two 60 goals seasons and one 71 goal season. This sniper gave Wayne a pile of assists. Crosby will need a trigger man as well if he is to gather points. Is Malkin a Kurri? Hmm, maybe.

Don't forget Mike Bossy when talking about the greatest snipers. Nobody was as pure a goal scorer more than Bossy. Not even these other 2. Nine 50+ seasons. Case closed, don't even think about it.
 
Last edited:
fuck man, bossy might've even been better than Gretzky... we'll never really know that, will we?

is Malkin a Kurri? nope. more of a Sergei Federov. (very defensively responsible)

I think there maybe bigger plans for Jordan Staal down the road... he's not ready, yet. the goal touch is there... but, the other intangibles aren't, yet.

consider Staal...

-age 18

-HT: 6-4 WT: 220

-Staal now owns the NHL rookie record by scoring his league-leading seventh shorthanded goal.

-in 70GP he has 28 goals (2nd for Rookies) 10 assists, for 38 points (good for 6th for Rookies) and is a +17

-He has NEVER played an NHL game where he was a MINUS! (and he's a penalty kill specialist) *this is an awesome stat*

-His +/- is the Penguins tops... and 20% of his ice time is playing shorthanded! (highest percentage of SHTOI on the team)

-He averages the least amount of ICE TIME of the top 9 Rookie Point Scorers!

-His shooting percentage is by far the highest among rookies (over 25% scoring accuracy)

-His shooting percentage is actually THE HIGHEST IN THE LEAGUE. 2nd is Tanguay at 21.7%

-he seems to be a pure goal scorer... for every assist he gets, he gets 3 goals. (the highest ratio of goals to assists of any player to have played more than 70 games in NHL Scoring History!)

-he also leads the NHL in short handed Points totals...

next to Crosby, Staal might just be the best draft pick on the Penguins roster for the last 20 years! too early to tell, yes. but, things do look very, very good.