Crosby a Maple Leaf?

Should Leafs sign Crosby, even though it'll screw over the other teams in the NHL?

  • The Leafs owe it to their fans to sign him and face any potential consequences

    Votes: 10 50.0%
  • The Leafs should honour the NHL rules and not sign him unless the league declares him a free agent

    Votes: 3 15.0%
  • Until there's a new agreement, who gives a shit what any team or player does?

    Votes: 7 35.0%

  • Total voters
    20

BlahBlah

New member
Dec 2, 2001
656
0
0
Not very likely, but if you listened to Jim Kelley of ESPN on The Fan's PrimeTime Sports last night, he made a very interesting suggestion.

With no NHL draft, Crosby could become an unrestricted free agent, espcially if he fights it in court. The NHL is supposed to have the authority to approve any contract, however, with no collective bargaining agreement, that authority may not actually exist.

So... what Kelley suggests, is that the Leafs take a run at signing Crosby NOW! He suggests the team does what Dick Ebersol of NBC did with the Olympics some years ago: take his representatives in a room, make a mind-blowing offer with a 'take it or leave it' proposal, they either walk out with an agreement or the offer is off the table.

Hypothetically, if this was successful, the league and other teams would scream bloody murder. Mr. Kelley's opinion is that the league will go through the motions of protesting it, but would truly love to see Crosby in the league's biggest hockey market, not in Washington or Columbus, etc. The NHL would refuse to allow the contract so then it would be up to the Leafs to take this to court... a case they could very likely win, according to the longtime claim of legal experts who say "drafts" are unconstitutional and will be circumvented the first time a player decides to fight it.

The Leafs would be hated by everyone, except their ticket-buying fans and the television networks. But they could pull it off, or so it seems.

The question is, should they cross that line?
 
BlahBlah said:
The Leafs would be hated by everyone, except their ticket-buying fans and the television networks.

The question is, should they cross that line?
Sure. They are already there.
 
BlahBlah said:
a case they could very likely win, according to the longtime claim of legal experts who say "drafts" are unconstitutional and will be circumvented the first time a player decides to fight it.

Do the names Mike Williams and Maurice Clarette mean anything to you? Probably the Leafs would have to wait until Crosby is declared a free agent by the courts before anything happens. I suspect you will see a CBA in place before Sep 1st(I know everyone thinks I am crazy). I know the NHL doesn't want to go down the Crosby free agent or not path, as well as using replacement players. However I think the NHLPA has a trick up their sleeves when a case would come to the various labour boards.
 
me thinks...

you'll see a new CBA before june. this draft will happen, exactly how they go about the draft order, is another story. hearing this may be just for this one time...drop all the teams name in a hat, with better odds given to the lower teams, based on the last full season played. almost the same as the draft lottery that exists now, except every team will be essentially in the lottery.

Jay