Credit Card Debt

I am assuming our U.S. situation is the same or similar as in Canada. There are differences between Canada and the US when it come to insolvency.


When you are delinquent you may be called every day or hour by the bank or collection company. I can not tell you if this is absolutely true, but I heard that a debtor in Canada can tell a debt collector not to call by telephone and then debt collector then must communicate in writing only.

In the U.S. after the 2008 "deep recession" especially with the collapse of home values so many underwater, the 50%+ decline in stock markets and massive job losses this was a much more common issue in the U.S., than in Canada which wasn't hit as badly economically as the U.S. The 2008 recession was barely felt in Canada, it was mostly a problem felt in the US due to the sub-prime housing market bubble burst.

In general people in Canada are more careful with debt than in the US. It is easier to get credit cards and buy on credit in the US.

If you can't pay off $15,000 you got issues. Assuming each credit card has an interest rate of 20%, that's only $3,000 interest a year. Even if you paid $100/week towards it, it would probably be gone in 5 years.

Lesson learned. Don't spend what you don't have.

We do not know who this person is, it could be a 20 year old kid that got in over his head.
 
@ Ceiling Cat,

I think you're right about ending calls from debt collectors. My friend is a credit executive and he says that if you notify a collection agent to "cease and desist", they're supposed to stop.
 
@ Ceiling Cat,

I think you're right about ending calls from debt collectors. My friend is a credit executive and he says that if you notify a collection agent to "cease and desist", they're supposed to stop.

Partly correct. You can't just tell them to stop calling. Notification must be in writing.
 
I cannot relate. Never had debt in my life. Paid for my first car with cash. Could have paid for my first home with cash and I'm not rich. Grew up poor in fact. Make above avg income but nothing extraordinary. Live within your means.

Thats fantastic! Re-read the question, as this was not the answer anyone was looking for
 
Sorry to say, but your "family member" is a fucking idiot to get into that situation. I hope they realise that.
 
First, stop the bleeding. Cut up the credit cards and use cash or a debit card. That way you cannot spend what you do not have. Pay down the debt and make more than the minimum monthly payment. Paying the minimum will prolong the agony and cost a fortune in interest.
 
Honestly I found this thread very helpful. Personally, Ive been struggling with personal credit card debt for quite some time. I think cutting up credit cards are an AMAZING IDEA!
I may just have to do that today!
 
I have a question:


I had a phone bill that I refused to pay. (Long story) Anyway, it went to a collection agency and I paid them with my credit card. They are now saying that I did not pay despite the fact that I have the payment receipt and my credit card statement showing the payment.

They said they realized their mistake (that the account number was incorrect) and mailed a refund cheque to my address in January. Never got it. Telus phoned them and they told a different story - that the payment was returned to my credit card???? My credit card company says it doesn't work that way.

I feel that they stole my money and the credit card company is starting an investigation but that it will take 6 weeks. Meanwhile, the collection agency calls me every day demanding the money and the interest on the debt continues to accumulate. Do the police deal with this sort of thing? Do I need a lawyer?


I've never dealt with an issue like this so I don't know. Any advice would be appreciated. :)
 
I had a phone bill that I refused to pay. (Long story) Anyway, it went to a collection agency
Even if you are in the right, this leaves a black mark in your credit bureau file.

They said they realized their mistake and mailed a refund cheque to my address.
Normally, they would credit back your credit card, not send a cheque.

Do the police deal with this sort of thing? Do I need a lawyer?
This is a civil matter. The police deal only with criminal matters. Lawyers charge at least $250 an hour. How much money is at stake? Have you thought about small claims court?
 
Normally, they would credit back your credit card, not send a cheque.


This is what's fishy. The collection agency told Telus a different story than what they told me. They claimed there was a credit back to my credit card but the credit card company says there is no credit. This is why they are starting an investigation.

This is a civil matter. The police deal only with criminal matters. Lawyers charge at least $250 an hour. How much money is at stake? Have you thought about small claims court?


I've thought about calling the police because the collection agency calls me every day even though I have told them to stop. They yell at me and tell me I have to cooperate. It feels like criminal harassment.
 
Start recording the calls. You can choose whether or not to tell them. In Canada it's legal to record any call you are an active participant in. (What you can't do is record other people's calls you are not party to.)

If you record one call where you are telling them to stop calling and notify you only in writing, and then you can record another call where you play that back and yet another call after that then you've basically nailed them.

Technically you'd have them at the second call but recording you playing back the first and having them still call would have any judge this goes before rolling his eyes in disgust.
 
Echo the advice for the lower interest LOC. Also emphasize the need to get rid of cards. Even worse than credit card debt is to max out the LOC AND the cards. Happens a lot.
 
I've thought about calling the police because the collection agency calls me every day even though I have told them to stop. They yell at me and tell me I have to cooperate. It feels like criminal harassment.

It is harassment. Next time they call record the conversation, especially if they are yelling at you. Then go to a lawyer with the recording. It might cost you a few bucks but the lawyer can send the collection people a letter threatening legal action for harassment.

If you don't want to do that then go to Canadian Tire and buy one of those hand held air horns and when they call again, blast out their eardrum.
 
Or just do this:

"Oh hi, I was hoping you would call. Let me go get my purse, hold on!"

Then gently put down the phone and go mow the lawn.
 
Another collection agency called me and demanded money last week. They had my surname correct but insisted that my first name was Stephen. I said, "Do I sound like a Stephen?" LOL


Or just do this:

"Oh hi, I was hoping you would call. Let me go get my purse, hold on!"

Then gently put down the phone and go mow the lawn.


I prefer to play the first two minutes of this:




It's amazing how long they stay on the phone and keep yelling.
 
Not much sympathy here. Not knowing the circumstances, I think we ought not to judge. The credit card can be a slippery slope and it is carefully designed to entrap folks in all sorts of situations. Banks are even known to push higher credit card limits on cardholders who are clearly in trouble. I think there must be very good profits in the credit card business, even with the fraud and bankruptcies.
Without knowing the facts I would suggest this person:
1. Cut up the card to stop the bleeding.
2. Get some other credit such as line of credit or a lower interest rate if they can
3. Find some friends or family who will do a personal loan, confess everything to them and pay off as much as they can, and then repay the private lenders.