creating a will?

pokergod

Member
Apr 15, 2007
614
0
16
So my father passed away and it was easy as everything was given to my mother. Now my mother has to do hers. I have 3 other siblings and she really doesn't want to split everything evenly as we are not a very close family. But she does want to leave some for everybody.

Basically , do you have to tell a set amount of cash you want to give to each person? Can you go by percentages? If you go b y set amounts and when the time comes that there is not enough money to cover the cash amounts that she said to give to each person?

As for the house. If she were to split it 4 ways percentages, can she demand the house to be sold or whoever wants the home then that person can be bought out?
 
She should see a Lawyer. Having a will drafted isn't that expensive and there are a number of advantages: She makes sure that what she actually wants to happen will, and if there is a problem her estate has a malpractice claim, she gets professional counsel as to the best way to carry out her wishes. Finally, the Lawyer can store the will thereby avoiding criminal activity involving a forged will.
 
^^^ Agreed.

Money well spent.
 
She should talk to a lawyer I remember when my grandma passed and to see her 15 beyond adult children argue over money she never had and stuff that wasn't in good condition was a nightmare.
 
As for the house. If she were to split it 4 ways percentages, can she demand the house to be sold or whoever wants the home then that person can be bought out?
Members of the Upper Canada Bar may correct me without offense.

But as a general comment NEVER, ever leave property to heirs in common! e.g. 'I leave my Ranch the Pondersoa to my three sons Adam, Eric, and Joseph.'


Practical advise - a Ranch you can devise into smaller ranches but a house?
 
You can specify that everything be liquidated and then the cash divided as ever she wants.
 
see a lawyer that specializes in wills and Power of Attorneys etc.
A thousand dollars spent on a will now will save many thousands of dollars down the road (when your Mom passes) on legal fees when someone contests . A few years ago I was at the Lawyers with my Mom to have her will re done. the lawyer kept very detailed records of her discussions , he said that has a lot of credibility if/when you get into court because its a transcript sort of of the conversation, not just the final document.
The lawyer will also know the rules on Ontario Law ( presuming Ontario here) regarding splits etc.
If the family is not close, it's best to get all the details sorted out now, because it can very easily become ugly after (especially if not all children are receiving equal amounts.
 
So my father passed away and it was easy as everything was given to my mother. Now my mother has to do hers. I have 3 other siblings and she really doesn't want to split everything evenly as we are not a very close family. But she does want to leave some for everybody.

Basically , do you have to tell a set amount of cash you want to give to each person? Can you go by percentages? If you go b y set amounts and when the time comes that there is not enough money to cover the cash amounts that she said to give to each person?

As for the house. If she were to split it 4 ways percentages, can she demand the house to be sold or whoever wants the home then that person can be bought out?

More or less your Mom can do whatever she wants with her stuff in her will. Drafting it so what she wants actually happens is the hard part. She should have a lawyer draw her will.
 
Good for rld. It's her estate, and whatever she wants to do with it is for her to decide, and talking it over with a lawyer—privately—means less squabbling in the family in the time she has left. All she needs to tell you guys is who has the actual will document and how to get hold of them. She should also be doing Powers of Attorney as part of the same process, to cover any time when she might be unable to manage her affairs or make her own care decisions.

Just in the way of horror stories, it took years and years to settle my father's estate because he made a well-intentioned but ill-informed choice of executor. If she's trying to do anything at all complicated, advise her very strongly to name someone truly professional and who has no possible conflict of interest. And ditto for the named alternate.
 
Last edited:
Use life insurance to cover the various percentages to the siblings and to put money into the estate.


Wow! That's really bad advice unless in your haste you didn't explain what you wanted to say. My advice is for her to see a lawyer - for the $500 or so (maybe $1000 if it's complicated) that its going to cost her, she will know that her final wishes are fulfilled.

Timbit
 
Wow! That's really bad advice unless in your haste you didn't explain what you wanted to say. My advice is for her to see a lawyer - for the $500 or so (maybe $1000 if it's complicated) that its going to cost her, she will know that her final wishes are fulfilled.

Timbit

You are right that the suggestion noted would likely increase the taxation burden on the estate.
 
You are right that the suggestion noted would likely increase the taxation burden on the estate.

The life insurance option depends on a lot of things. That was a quick comment. If there is a house to be divided into 4, and you want specific amounts going to each, then life insurance can be used - maybe pay to 3, and give the house to one. I don't know. A competent advisor will have to take a look. Get a will, yes, certainly. But don't dismiss life insurance. And regarding taxation for the estate, life insurance is not taxable. Everything goes directly to the beneficiaries tax free. It doesn't even go through the estate unless you put it there.

People can always contest a will, and if the 4 survivors don't like each other, it makes no difference whether the will is valid. They can still hold it up, and while that is going on the lawyers get rich and the estate gets poor. Not with insurance.
 
Other than grossly unequal bequests of money among heirs of the same generation, what typically Worf are the sources of will contests are bequests of specific physical items. It is amazing how but I wanted the Tall Case Clock will set people off.
 
Get her to use a lawyer - safer for all concerned.

To answer one specific question, do not use actual dollar amounts where possible as an estate's value can go up and down - use description such as xyz GICs or proceeds from bank account Number ....or a percentage to specific people for the total of liquid assets etc.
 
The life insurance option depends on a lot of things. That was a quick comment. If there is a house to be divided into 4, and you want specific amounts going to each, then life insurance can be used - maybe pay to 3, and give the house to one. I don't know. A competent advisor will have to take a look. Get a will, yes, certainly. But don't dismiss life insurance. And regarding taxation for the estate, life insurance is not taxable. Everything goes directly to the beneficiaries tax free. It doesn't even go through the estate unless you put it there.

People can always contest a will, and if the 4 survivors don't like each other, it makes no difference whether the will is valid. They can still hold it up, and while that is going on the lawyers get rich and the estate gets poor. Not with insurance.

That was my point. You suggested using life insurance to put money into the estate. Which would convert non-taxable funds into taxable funds.
 
Having a lawyer provide her with the best possible advice (including drafting up the Will) is best.

You originally asked about percentages versus dollar amounts. Percentages tend to work better, because they vary with the size of the estate at the time it's being addressed.

I'm aware of a scenario where a woman drafted her will at a time when she had plenty of cash in her estate, specifying so many thousand dollars to this person, and so many thousand dollars to that person (charity, etc). But at the time of her death, her estate had dwindled and the bequests were of a much higher value than the value of the cash in the estate, and it was left to the heirs to understand that the real estate (which was bequeathed to another heir) was never intended to be sold off in order to meet the cash bequests and have each of those who were named in the will "sign off" that they would, in effect, pass on their cash.

Another way the lawyer might approach this is to say that certain "groupings" of heirs take precedence. E.g. A gets X, B gets Y. If so-and-so much cash funds remain, group G divides Z in such-and-such a way. And so on. But that's much tougher to draft and may be tougher to pass probate.
 
How does one find a good and reasonable cost estate lawyer in the GTA or does anyone have a referral? Thanks.