Cracks on Concrete Driveway

SkyRider

Banned
Mar 31, 2009
17,546
2
0
I have several long narrow cracks on my concrete driveway. Last Fall I filled those cracks with some old "Top and Bond" I had lying around in my basement. Now that Spring has arrived I noticed that my patchwaork from last Fall is breaking up. Why is this happening?
 
How old is it?
Offhand it sounds like you got a crappy mix....
 
Concrete cracks due to the nature of the material.

During curing, heat is generated and the concrete shrinks and you get shrinkage cracks. It is very difficult to avoid shrinkage cracks. Usually what you do is control cracking - i.e. induce cracking where you want it by sawcutting or other similar methods, as well as proper wet curing (for as much as 7 days)

Also, proper reinforcement in the slab will help to prevent differential settlements in the slab once it does crack.

Also, there is the mix that was used. Typically for a driveway, building codes call for a 32 MPA mix. You also want to be very careful with the water to cement ratio. Often times Contractors will add water to the mix when it arrives (the redi mix places always ship it dry) to make it easier to place. This is asking for cracking.

But as I said, cracking is normal - go and look at any bridge deck slab - the Gardiner, the new deck on the Leaside Bridge and you will see thousands of shrinkage cracks.

As to what you can do about them - epoxy injection is the only thing I've ever seen used and its debatable whether it is worth anything or not. The problem will be dirt in the crack. For sure, nothing that you simply smear on the top will work. Davroc is one outfit that I know can fix concrete. You can google them and call them if you are serious about this.
 
Isn't that why concrete roadways are topsealed with ass-fault? It is why there should be designed-in control cracks every 10' or so as jtk says above. There's Roman concrete that's still sound, but as far as I know it was protected by being underwater. And it never freezes there. The cracked diriveway will still hold your car out of the mud for most of a century. Or more.

Here, everything goes back to nature. If you want to slow that down, you have to be constantly working at it.
 
Working with acid is hazardous. In this case, unless there is an old coating on the driveway or thick buildup of grease, you needn't use acid (or properly diluted acid) to prep it prior to re-sealing it. Power washing it is fine, or perhaps even use a mild detergent (tri-phosphate) with hard scrub brushing or brooming, then rinsing off and letting it bone dry.

You may use a mix of boiled linseed oil and thinner but it may temporarily darken the colour, although it will provide protection against salt. Also, you could use silane or siloxane clear liquid sealers that penetrate the concrete (make sure clean, dry and porous first). They will protect against salt (these are used on exposed parking garages).

As for the crack, after routing it clean, fill it with silica sand to leave a proper depth for your repair material and use a non-shrinkable grout mix for crack repair, or use a chemical joint filler (elastomeric) that is not rigid and designed for exterior use where joints are expected to move and for which require flexibility.

If your slab heaves, well, that requires a different solution.
 
Concrete cracks due to the nature of the material.

During curing, heat is generated and the concrete shrinks and you get shrinkage cracks. It is very difficult to avoid shrinkage cracks. Usually what you do is control cracking - i.e. induce cracking where you want it by sawcutting or other similar methods, as well as proper wet curing (for as much as 7 days)

Also, proper reinforcement in the slab will help to prevent differential settlements in the slab once it does crack.

Also, there is the mix that was used. Typically for a driveway, building codes call for a 32 MPA mix. You also want to be very careful with the water to cement ratio. Often times Contractors will add water to the mix when it arrives (the redi mix places always ship it dry) to make it easier to place. This is asking for cracking.

But as I said, cracking is normal - go and look at any bridge deck slab - the Gardiner, the new deck on the Leaside Bridge and you will see thousands of shrinkage cracks.

As to what you can do about them - epoxy injection is the only thing I've ever seen used and its debatable whether it is worth anything or not. The problem will be dirt in the crack. For sure, nothing that you simply smear on the top will work. Davroc is one outfit that I know can fix concrete. You can google them and call them if you are serious about this.

Hey Davroc is great. I've used them but will they tend to such a small residential job Jim?
 
I have several long narrow cracks on my concrete driveway. Last Fall I filled those cracks with some old "Top and Bond" I had lying around in my basement. Now that Spring has arrived I noticed that my patchwaork from last Fall is breaking up. Why is this happening?

I'm going to PM you a contact reference where you can ask a question, but don't you dare say where you got the referral.
 
There's Roman concrete that's still sound, but as far as I know it was protected by being underwater. And it never freezes there.

the Romans built up the roadbed with the ditch material from either side

They then laid stone on the road and covered with gravel then let the traffic wear the roadway smooth

Lots of these roads were built in the colder climes and still stand

Why would this not work for a driveway ?

The driveway should be slightly arched for runoff (would drainage tubes on both sides be needed ? )



The driveway would be bumpy but so what ? Use a softer stone so it wears down smooth

The Romans would drive wagon wheels and chariots over theirs for hundreds of miles !

Each year you could easily attend to the frost heaving ( if necessary) by lifting a few stones and leveling off gravel

Seems like a very cheap 3000 year old style driveway that your great grandchildren will be showing off

Compare the simplicity and cost of the Roman design to the complexity and cost of a rubmeister design

Will a rubmeister design last 2000 years ?
 
The cracked diriveway will still hold your car out of the mud for most of a century. Or more.

Thanks for all the feedback. Fixing these cracks is more complicated than I first imagined.

oldjones: Are you saying I could simply leave the cracks alone and the driveway will still be serviceable for a long time?
 
The grout mix will fail in this application as there is obviously stress. The flexible sealant is the correct solution for a driveway. Epoxy injection is fine if it is a shrinkage crack. But is expensive to seal a non-structural crack against further water infiltration and freeze/thaw damage. And I would say that a flexible sealant would be more durable over time

I would concur Rub! If there wasn't stress, that grout mix might work but it won't be invisible, unfortunately.
 
Thanks for all the feedback. Fixing these cracks is more complicated than I first imagined.

oldjones: Are you saying I could simply leave the cracks alone and the driveway will still be serviceable for a long time?

A few details that I don't see mentioned in this thread, although answers seem to have been assumed:

- How wide are the cracks you're seeing? Are they very fine cracks (can't insert anything between the two cracked faces), or are they about the width of corrogated cardboard, or about the width of your thumb? I think you'll find different solutions are recommended based on the nature of the problem.

- What drainage was in place under the slab? If the problems are arising from water already flowing deep under the concrete and rising to the surface, you'll have to figure out whether it's a serious problem or just a superficial one.

- I would presume your Top & Bond simply didn't get a watertight bond with the concrete, so natural freeze-thaw cycles quickly broke the bond and allowed the Top & Bond to come loose. Getting a good bond isn't easy, as the descriptions above will attest. But as indicated, don't make a problem worse by trying to solve it, either.

- Is there any indication of any heaving on any part of the driveway - particularly more heaving on one side of a crack than on another side? You will want to determine if the problem is primarily lateral stresses or vertical stresses and approach the solution accordingly. (Of course, if the crack is wide enough, even if it was caused by lateral stresses it may allow more water to flow under one side of the slab and cause vertical stresses in the future.)

Good luck!
 
Thanks for all the feedback. Fixing these cracks is more complicated than I first imagined.

oldjones: Are you saying I could simply leave the cracks alone and the driveway will still be serviceable for a long time?
Yes. See Yoga Face's post about Roman roads. You could pound your driveway down to gravel—the aggregate the cement glued together into concrete—and it would still keep your car outta the mud. The slabs that were poured in the '20s to make my driveway have now crumbled into small flagstones, but the car still comes and goes. What more do you want?

Ah! Easy snowshovelling, a place for the kids to ride their trikes and play hopscotch and no sneers from the neighbours or visits from MLS? Then you'll wanna make the cracks go away. rubmeister, jamest and friends have told you how to do it right. But you will be doing it a gain. Year after Year.

Nature always wins.

When I reno mine, I'll stick to unit masonery like the Romans used downtown (gravel's too light, and moves too readil,y as rub said, and my neighbours have proven) With pavers one heave doesn't wreck the whole structure, and they can be re-laid and re-levelled. If I was stuck with a slab with minor cracks, I'd follow up on my idea that asphalt's a more flexy and forgiving surface and topcoat it to keep the water off. But that I do not know. I do know my other neighbour reseals his every year.

Nature always wins.
 
Stick to yoga!

The "rubmeister design" is not a design for a driveway, it is a repair procedure for a damaged driveway you idiot.

Your romantic waxing on the "Roman design" is for a horse and cart road. Not a residential driveway. And the "Roman design" is actually quite complex in its simplicity if you understand roadbuilding. Much of the same techniques are used today but improved upon to accommodate guys like you who want to drive 140 km/h in your Prius'!

As for drainage tubes. If you had any clue about this subject you'd know they are there to intercept water before it seeps under the slab and freezes in the winter. Crowning is for roads to keep standing water off them. Typical Residential Subdivision Driveways are usually simply sloped to the road.

If you don't know what you are talking about STFU.

I was just adding some interesting historic info Rub

You know more then me about the topic ( as I know little) and I respect your knowledge

But I was raised on a farm where all driveways are gravel covered dirt

The driveways are cambered and withstands the weight of farm machinery, seldom potholes, ride your bikes on it (even play hopscotch) , easy to shovel off snow, no extra drainage tubes required yet it never heaves with the frost

Only thing we ever did was throw some crushed gravel on it as it wore away

It is the same basic design as a country road except the roads are constantly graded and are ditched on either side which is meant to capture the run off from tiled farm land


So why go to all the expense and upkeep of a cement or asphalt driveway ?????

The Roman layered cobblestone roads were more complex but they stand today with no maintenance
 
Last edited:
before you use top bond you need to break the surface bond on the drive.

You also need to under cut the cracks.

To under cut you chisel at a 30 to 45 degree angle to back cut or under cut the crack on both sides


To break the bond you dilute MURIATIC ACID (get this at a pool supply place) by 50%

Apply to affected areas and when it stops smoking hose it off.
 
Except that Top and Bond will just crack and spall off again if the slab moves. Which it will. Top and Bond is not flexible and is only for TOPPING (as the name suggests) surface defects. Wrong product.


Actually I put top bond on my drive 15 years ago and as of last year I need to address it.

A great solution if you do it right
 
Except that Top and Bond will just crack and spall off again if the slab moves. Which it will. Top and Bond is not flexible and is only for TOPPING (as the name suggests) surface defects. Wrong product.


BTW you are making the assumption as to the problem'


My bet is it was never sealed
 
can't you guys patch it up. its time to cement the friendship
 
Well in the city and most towns, you are simply not allowed to build with or have a gravel driveway.

Why no gravel driveways allowed in city ?

They work fine in the country and smaller towns


Even public places like graineries , stores ,churchs and pubs have them