cowboys

doggee_01

Active member
Jul 11, 2003
8,343
1
36
i want to start by saying i am not a cowboys fan, but i thought it was a good catch. any thoughts?

karma maybe - the flag should not have been picked up the week before!
 
The question truly is......did the ball ACTUALLY TOUCH the ground?

Yes it popped up, but was his forearm underneath it.

i would say if the ball never touched the ground.....and yet yes...still popped up....as long as he brings it back in, it's a catch.
 
I think the ball did touch the ground but the main point for me is that he caught and controlled the ball completely and then made a football move in continuing to step, extend out, and reach for the goal line.
I thought he went significantly beyond just trying to finish the process of catching the ball.

They seem to be more strict about this rule than in the past.
Like when a guy catches a ball along the sidelines, comes down with control of the ball and both feet in bounds, but he has to maintain control of the ball even as he is driven out and to the ground.
 
The question truly is......did the ball ACTUALLY TOUCH the ground?

Yes it popped up, but was his forearm underneath it.

i would say if the ball never touched the ground.....and yet yes...still popped up....as long as he brings it back in, it's a catch.

Not a catch because of the Calvin Johnson rule. When catching the ball if you are going to the ground as you are catching it you must maintain possession through the ground. It is a PROCESS. I heard Bob Mccown on the Fan590 saying that once the knee hits the ground its a good catch. Wrong. It is a process.

As far as whether the ball actually touches the ground. I have to disagree with you because the ball IS allowed to touch the ground. The ball touching the ground does NOT necessarily mean incomplete. Ball can touch the ground as long as you have control of the ball while it touches the ground - as per the BERT EMANUEL RULE. If you watch SNF with any degree of regularity you hear Al Michaels drop the Bert Emanuel Rule reference several times a season. I won't go and describe the Bert Emanuel Rule - I think anyone that watches football with any degree of regularity is familiar with it.
 
The ball came out of his hands. He did not control the ball throughout the catch.

Basically the Calvin Johnson play at Soldier Field is the precedent. Same case here. So no catch. I must be in the minority because I actually like the rule and do think that when you are catching a ball like that and are going to the ground it is definitely a process. You need to maintain possession through the ground.
 
First I will say for the record for anyone who does not know, I am a Dallas Cowboys fan. Have been since the mid-70s.


The NFL makes these rules confusing so they can bullshit when they know the rules clash.

Has to make a 'football move' after catch ? What is a 'football move' ?
Ball is caught, player turns toward goal line, drives forward with legs, dives forward, stretches out ... are any of those football moves ? I do not know. The NFL should provide a list of acceptable football moves.
Ball control is maintained, comes down and takes a step.

Oh yeah ... as Shack said the ground cannot cause a fumble in the NFL ... well, unless we(the NFL) say otherwise.

Knee or elbow touched ground ... he can no longer advance ball, ending the play but he still must maintain control ?

In short this is what I hear "We are the NFL and we want to have it both ways"


I no longer try to figure out this league and it's rules. Seems to me they have rules that conflict and some loopholes so they can make it up as they go along.
Once the call was reversed I just accepted it.
 
While I do think that the Cowboys got screwed on this call, the bottom line is that you have to do whatever you can to secure the ball for as long as possible.
A significant football move is subject to interpretation.

Don`t get greedy and risk having something like this happen.
He also risked fumbling the ball into the end zone for a touchback, loss of possession.
He could have easily secured the ball.
 
True, but what about the concept that the ground can't cause a fumble.

I can explain that.

You are correct that the ground cannot cause a fumble (unless you go down on your own of course in which case the ground CAN cause a fumble) . For example if a ball carrier is running and just gets tripped up by the turf monster (not contacted by a defender) and goes to the ground and the ball comes loose then that IS a fumble. Neither of those cases apply here though.

However the ground can cause an INCOMPLETE PASS which is what happened here. The ground did not cause a fumble in the Dez Bryant case b/c a fumble would imply he had possession. Possession was never established because he did not maintain control through the process of going to the ground.
 
Dallas Cowboys gave Jason Garrett a new five year extension worth $30 mil.

Defensive coordinator Rod Marinelli also reached an agreement on a contract extension.


Now the players need to be signed.
 
My question is what the hell did they call such a high risk play on fourth and short with the game on the line.
 
i also questioned the play as they more needed a first down at that point. I thought it was a catch....but moreover it was a helluva an athletic play by Bryant...and isn't that what should be rewarded in sports...not that it touched the ground for a nano second. I have family in Texas, so yes I root for the Cowboys....even got to go to a game this year which they lost to washington.
 
I'm a Packer fan and I thought it should have been a catch. But by the rulebook it clearly isn't. A rule I think needs to be changed.
 
I'm a Packer fan and I thought it should have been a catch. But by the rulebook it clearly isn't. A rule I think needs to be changed.

Or at least tweaked.
I want to know what a football move is in the NFL's mind. NFL should provide an acceptable list.
I also want the rule explained entirely, via an official site.

As a youth player we are taught to secure the ball, but as older players(HS, teens and up) there is competition and we learn that to advance, be noticed, you have to do the little extra(scholarships, drafts).
To me Dez demonstrated all the control necessary and was striving for the little bit extra ... you know the 'bit extra' where we as fans say he is earning all those millions he can try a bit harder.
 
i want to start by saying i am not a cowboys fan, but i thought it was a good catch. any thoughts?

karma maybe - the flag should not have been picked up the week before!

I hate the cowboys and am a huge green bay fan. I thought it was a catch.

I think these replays are going to kill the game.
 
Has to make a 'football move' after catch ? What is a 'football move' ?
Ball is caught, player turns toward goal line, drives forward with legs, dives forward, stretches out ... are any of those football moves ? I do not know. The NFL should provide a list of acceptable football moves.

They do provide a list - Rule 8, Article 3. Did you even read the rulebook before spouting off on an ignorant rant?

I no longer try to figure out this league and it's rules.
There's nothing to "figure out". It's not a puzzle. There is a rulebook, the rules are written in the book. The rulebook is available online for free.
 
They do provide a list - Rule 8, Article 3. Did you even read the rulebook before spouting off on an ignorant rant?


There's nothing to "figure out". It's not a puzzle. There is a rulebook, the rules are written in the book. The rulebook is available online for free.

No I did not look it up. I was waiting for someone like you to look it up for me and post exactly where to find it.
Next time please do not wait a whole week to post the information.