The question truly is......did the ball ACTUALLY TOUCH the ground?
Yes it popped up, but was his forearm underneath it.
i would say if the ball never touched the ground.....and yet yes...still popped up....as long as he brings it back in, it's a catch.
The ball came out of his hands. He did not control the ball throughout the catch.
True, but what about the concept that the ground can't cause a fumble.The ball came out of his hands. He did not control the ball throughout the catch.
True, but what about the concept that the ground can't cause a fumble.
I'm a Packer fan and I thought it should have been a catch. But by the rulebook it clearly isn't. A rule I think needs to be changed.
i want to start by saying i am not a cowboys fan, but i thought it was a good catch. any thoughts?
karma maybe - the flag should not have been picked up the week before!
Has to make a 'football move' after catch ? What is a 'football move' ?
Ball is caught, player turns toward goal line, drives forward with legs, dives forward, stretches out ... are any of those football moves ? I do not know. The NFL should provide a list of acceptable football moves.
There's nothing to "figure out". It's not a puzzle. There is a rulebook, the rules are written in the book. The rulebook is available online for free.I no longer try to figure out this league and it's rules.
They do provide a list - Rule 8, Article 3. Did you even read the rulebook before spouting off on an ignorant rant?
There's nothing to "figure out". It's not a puzzle. There is a rulebook, the rules are written in the book. The rulebook is available online for free.