Take the earlier date. Always... Court time is precious and always in short supply. Adjournments, even of trials are frequent, especially in small claims. Your December date could easily become February anyway so get your foot in the door. And just for the record despite the earlier comment - judges do NOT loose their focus after lunch. If a judge is loosing interest in your case it is usually because you are wasting time on evidence that is not relevant or is inadmissible or perhaps because you're flogging a dead horse on an issue on which the evidence is abundantly clear.