Council should appoint Rob Ford to replace Rob Ford

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,936
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
Star ran an editorial saying the same thing so I believe the left would be on side.

It resolves all the issues.

Let the mayor seat sit empty for a week or two to send a strong message that Ford is not above the law and his behavior was unacceptable.

Then appoint him interim mayor until the next election.

Saves the city six million bucks, respects the popular vote, lets the city get back to normal business, and turns this over the top sentence into an appropriate slap on the wrists.
 
Star than an editorial saying the same thing.

It resolves all the issues.

Let the mayor seat sit empty for a week or two to send a strong message that Ford is not above the law and his behavior was unacceptable.

Then appoint him interim mayor until the next election.

Saves the city six million bucks, respects the popular vote, let's the city get back to normal business, and turns this over the top sentence into an appropriate slap on the wrists.


given this is a sensible option - it won't happen
 
It all depend on whether there's enough nose-clips to go around. The Councillors who never stopped believing Ford could do no wrong wouldn't have a problem, but the ones who thought he broke the rules from the get go might have a hard time voting for a convicted and unrepentant wrong-doer, absent an enthusiastic exoneration by the appeal court.

Of course, in the unlikely event the appeal judges declare the first trial a travesty and find the Mayor without blame, then there would be no need to appoint anyone. But if they agree with Hackland, that he was guilty, but excuse him because it was inadvertant or minor, then they're essentially saying that Rob's repeated, lengthy and persistent statements in his own defence, in various august venues were mere slips and oversights, and not the utterance of a fully conscious mind paying close attention and capable of absorbing legal facts and advice. Not precisely the best choice for a responsible Council to put into the Mayor's chair. The underlying assumption that such a guy would [still] be the people's choice is somewhat insulting. Much better to let them vote, and forgive if they choose.

In elections one is expected to vote for the best candidate, after all. Like the Anyone but Smitherman baloney that got him elected in the first place, this would amount to giving the office to a known bad choice because of fear of the some unknown. Do we really imagine it couldn't get worse with Rob? Just give the job to Holyday, who's been doing the work anyway.

But that's in the new year, for now let's all find something pleasant to chat about, and let the Court do its job.
 
Don't they have to appoint someone from Council?
 
Yeah, that's sending a real "tough" message. You're so bad that a judge has to remove you from office yet Council will effectively reinstate you immediately without bothering to wait for an election to see if he even wins again. It's the equivalent of firing someone for theft, pressing charges, and then allowing them to keep working pending the criminal trial (but in Ford's case he's already been found guilty, which makes it even worse).

Dumb idea.
 
I don't think they will take any action either way until the appeal has been fully heard, and there is a chance he could win that appeal.

According to the municipal conflict of interest act

Saving by reason of inadvertence or error

(2) Where the judge determines that a member or a former member while he or she was a member has contravened subsection 5 (1), (2) or (3), if the judge finds that the contravention was committed through inadvertence or by reason of an error in judgment, the member is not subject to having his or her seat declared vacant and the member or former member is not subject to being disqualified as a member, as provided by subsection (1). R.S.O. 1990, c. M.50, s. 10 (2).
 
The reason why Ford couldn't get the error in judgement defense was that he very publicly and repeatedly defended his actions despite multiple people pointing out the problem with his behavior. He went on the radio and publicly said he did nothing wrong.
 
Justice Hackland specifically found that Ford was motivated by a "stubborn sense of entitlement… characterized by ignorance of the law and a lack of diligence… amounting to willful blindness.”

The chances of the Divisional Court reversing that finding of fact are practically zero.


So put that into your pipes and smoke it before fantasizing about possible end games...

Should a reasonable person ignore that finding by an impartial Court and vote for Ford if he were now running in an election?

What price integrity?

Perry
 
Last edited:
I don't think letting him sit for a couple of weeks would send the right message. The man is impossible to embarrass, and a few weeks would send the wrong message. Even now, he could go a long way towards resolving the mess by simply admitting he did wrong. But that is beyond him. He's definitely not a big man in some ways.
 
Ford is am embarrassment. But that is not the worst of it. He is a constant distraction and his actions and demeanor are counter productive. If council wants to respect the voters' wishes and accomplish something in this, Ford's 4 year term as mayor, they will appoint Deputy Mayor Doug Holyday. He will implement the right wing agenda that voters voted for much more effectively than Ford ever could. And by appointing him, he will save the citizens of Toronto $7m, rather then holding a by -election where perhaps 30% of eligible voters will turn out. The best part of that plan is that Ford will no longer be at City Hall and we can get on with the business of managing a city.