Copy VHS Tapes to DVD

kbluejayk

Active member
Oct 26, 2003
1,551
0
36
I'm not sure if this topic has been discussed previously - tried 'Search' but no luck! Does anyone know the best way to copy VHS tapes to DVD format? I have a ton of VHS tapes that I'm getting rid of, but a few 'keepers' I would like to convert. Some of these are store bought tapes - movies, golf instruction videos etc. - is there a good program that gets around the copyright barrier? All these are strictly for personal use.
Would appreciate some technical input from our Terb Techies!
 
One option, I know it works cause I use it,,, item called "GO DVD" from Sima corporation, it will break the macro encoding, it will cost you about $100 plus from The Source, available online as well.Ive not come across anything in my vhs library that it wouldnt break the encoding on.
It conects via RCA cables between your VHS and DVD recorder
There may be other options, I know this works , from personal experience.
I also have video editing devices that allow colour and brightness adjustments ( issues often found on home movies.)
 
All my VHS tapes were turning to mush (very grainy once they were north of 10 years old). I took them to a DVD conversion shop and they wanted like $25per tape. I bought a DVD recorder for $100 and hooked it up to my VCR and did the job myself (but it was time consuming). No quality lost in the conversion. Query: How long will the DVD's last before they turn into mush?
 
Rockslinger said:
Query: How long will the DVD's last before they turn into mush?
If you used the best avaliable media, i.e. Taiyo Yuden, Sony or Verbatim, they may last 3-5 years, cheaper media could fail in 1-2 years.
DVD media will not last as long as Video tape. I have some 30 year old TDK SA VHS tapes that still look remarkably good, while others have faded.
CD media will last longer than DVD media.
 
Gentle Ben said:
One option, I know it works cause I use it,,, item called "GO DVD" from Sima corporation, it will break the macro encoding, it will cost you about $100 plus from The Source, available online as well.Ive not come across anything in my vhs library that it wouldnt break the encoding on.
It conects via RCA cables between your VHS and DVD recorder
There may be other options, I know this works , from personal experience.
I also have video editing devices that allow colour and brightness adjustments ( issues often found on home movies.)

Thanks GB, much appreciated! I checked The Source site and it appears to be going out of stock - just a few stores have it at 50% off ($149 reduced to $79.96). i'll check them out on Monday.

Also did some 'googling' and found this survey:-

http://video-editing-software-review.toptenreviews.com/

Sounds like PowerDirector gets an excellent rating!

Thanks for the other suggestions everyone. However, there are 2 issues here - tape conversion to DVD and 'breaking' the copy code protection.
It sounds like the GO-DVD device is the only solution that can do both!
Is anyone else familiar with 'PowerDirector'?
(GO-DVD is not mentioned in the survey!)
 
WoodPeckr said:
If you used the best avaliable media, i.e. Taiyo Yuden, Sony or Verbatim, they may last 3-5 years, cheaper media could fail in 1-2 years.
DVD media will not last as long as Video tape. I have some 30 year old TDK SA VHS tapes that still look remarkably good, while others have faded.
CD media will last longer than DVD media.


Have copied all my VHS to DVD more than 7 years ago. Still working as long as i don't treat them like coffee coasters!
 
I would totally avoid using a PC to do this. Using a DVD recorder will be 100x easier and probably cheaper too.
 
onehunglow said:
Have copied all my VHS to DVD more than 7 years ago. Still working as long as i don't treat them like coffee coasters!

This is good to hear. What brand DVD did you use and did you use a DVD recorder (did you copy from VCR to DVD recorder)? My VCR is Panasonic and DVD recorder is Pioneer and I used Ridata DVD discs.
 
WoodPeckr said:
If you used the best avaliable media, i.e. Taiyo Yuden, Sony or Verbatim, they may last 3-5 years, cheaper media could fail in 1-2 years.
DVD media will not last as long as Video tape. I have some 30 year old TDK SA VHS tapes that still look remarkably good, while others have faded.
CD media will last longer than DVD media.

Dang! Is that it! 3-5 years? I have some burnt DVD hitting 5 years. Maybe time for a backup.

So what do you think is the best medium for long term storage? USB HD?
 
Don said:
Dang! Is that it! 3-5 years? I have some burnt DVD hitting 5 years. Maybe time for a backup.

So what do you think is the best medium for long term storage? USB HD?
IMHO, VHS Videotape and an Ext HDD. I have some 30 yr old home movie VHS tapes that are still remarkably good quality. The oldest still look like Live TV.
VHS Tape is a problem because it's being phased out, plus the few VCRs left are crap and not the same quality as before.
If you use an ext HDD, put it on two different drives so there is a backup if one dies on you.
 
onehunglow said:
Have copied all my VHS to DVD more than 7 years ago. Still working as long as i don't treat them like coffee coasters!
After 7 yrs it's best to back them up again or put them on an ext HDD for backup. You're lucky they are still opening/playing for you.
I've had some that old that play when you first pop them in a player then fail/freeze mid-way through playing them.
 
WoodPeckr said:
IMHO, VHS Videotape and an Ext HDD. I have some 30 yr old home movie VHS tapes that are still remarkably good quality. The oldest still look like Live TV.
VHS Tape is a problem because it's being phased out, plus the few VCRs left are crap and not the same quality as before.
If you use an ext HDD, put it on two different drives so there is a backup if one dies on you.

I guess it is an external HD for me. I've actually been off converting VHS->DVD for the purpose of saving storage space (in the sense that my VHS tapes occupy too much of my living space). I guess my other question is how long does a hard disk last assuming it is not used very often (just used for backup)?

Thanks!
 
Don said:
....how long does a hard disk last assuming it is not used very often (just used for backup)?
Hard question to answer.
Have read the average HDD life is ~5yrs.
I assume a well cared for, ext HDD with minimal usage will last longer but I'm not sure if this is true.

I still have my heavily used original IBM 5400 rpm 8.5GB HDD from 1997, it still runs fine.
It's in storage now and only used as an XP Pro reinstall CD, when I format my old PC once or twice a year to clean out all the crap built up in Windows to make it run like new again.
I have a couple Seagate drives that I bought for their 5 yr warranty that run great.
One is in the old PC, the other is an ext drive. Important stuff is in partitions on both on them.
I don't store important files on my laptop.
 
Yeah I have several old drives. Some go has far back as 7 years and most work fine. My one disaster was when one of my storage drives failed to spin up. I was able to recover by buying an identical drive and replacing the PCB board on it. whew! otherwise I have been pretty lucky with my drives (knock on wood).
 
Hauppauge Capture Card Recommended

kbluejayk said:
Thanks for the other suggestions everyone. However, there are 2 issues here - tape conversion to DVD and 'breaking' the copy code protection.
It sounds like the GO-DVD device is the only solution that can do both!
Is anyone else familiar with 'PowerDirector'?
(GO-DVD is not mentioned in the survey!)
You are right about the copy protection issue. One reliable solution I found was a Hauppauge video card for capturing video input. Apparently any Hauppauge card will do - I've used a WinTV-HVR1600 very sucessfully. ATI, NVIDA and their various PL brands seem to comply with the Macrovision protection schemes which prevents or distorts any MV encoded captures but Hauppauge cards seem to do decent captures while filtering out the Macrovision crap.
 
Eureka! I found the solution to long term storage of your favourite pics. Black's has a 300 year Gold CD (guranteed, keep your receipt). This means you can still look at pics of your baby son when your son is 299 years old.