Confused about Candian laws...

Prim0

Meh
Aug 12, 2008
791
0
16
I'm confused as to what is actually legal in Canada in regards to the sex industry. I was under the impression that SPs are ok if they are registered/licensed and only do outcalls. I get the feeling that any extras at all beyond the massage at a MP is illegal but I see activities advertised on the web sites. SCs sound about the same as SCs here in the states. I just want to understand where the lines are drawn as I might like to visit GTA very soon.

Thank you,
Prim0
 
Prim0 said:
I'm confused as to what is actually legal in Canada in regards to the sex industry. I was under the impression that SPs are ok if they are registered/licensed and only do outcalls. I get the feeling that any extras at all beyond the massage at a MP is illegal but I see activities advertised on the web sites. SCs sound about the same as SCs here in the states. I just want to understand where the lines are drawn as I might like to visit GTA very soon.
Prim0 said:
Thank you,
Prim0

I think you are a bit confused on the situation here. There is no licensing of SPs in Ontario although you are correct that outcalls are safer from a legal point of view.

Prostitution is not illegal here. Communicating for the purposes of prostitution (soliciting money for sex) and living off the avails of prostitution (pimping) are illegal as well as being found in a "common bawdy house" (brothel) without lawful purpose.

They never made prostitution illegal because it is difficult to prosecute. You must see the money change hands and the sex happen and then prove that they were connected. It was far easier to just nail someone for the offer of sex for money (or money for sex in the case of a John).

What changed everything up here about 20 years ago or so was a supreme court decision which said that the solicitation must take place in public and be persistent to be illegal. This made it very difficult to prosecute SP's unless they were on the street making a nuisance of themselves. John's were also difficult to prosecute unless the offer of money was made in public (usually to an under cover officer). So the outcall escort services flourished with the fig leaf of saying that the fee was for time and companionship only or with the actual negotiation for money taking place in a private location like a home or hotel room.

Incalls are another matter and you can get busted there. Although in Vancouver there are all kinds of them downtown masquerading as massage parlours and the police leave them alone.

MPs are only supposed to give a massage, although there was a lawyer posting on this board a number of years ago saying that an HJ at the end of a therapeutic massage could be argued to be part of an ancient oriental massage practice and might be defendable. As a rule a nude massage with HJ ending seems to at least be tolerated most of the time here in the GTA. Any other extras are illegal.
 
Preaching to the choir

Why do they have to make things so difficult?! If two consenting adults want to get together and exchange "favors" then what business is it of anyone else. I get that some communities don't want adult entertainment in their neighborhood (or prisons or mental hospitals or....) but c'mon!!! We can't designate areas where people can be free to do as they please without hurting each other?!


FUCK!!!!!!!!!!

..<end rant>

Prim0
 
Prim0 said:
Why do they have to make things so difficult?! If two consenting adults want to get together and exchange "favors" then what business is it of anyone else. I get that some communities don't want adult entertainment in their neighborhood (or prisons or mental hospitals or....) but c'mon!!! We can't designate areas where people can be free to do as they please without hurting each other?!


FUCK!!!!!!!!!!

..<end rant>

Prim0

Decriminalizing prostitution would be ideal, but Canada seems to be a bit behind the times. The irony is that the government could stand to profit by collecting its share of taxes etc. as they do with alcohol and cigarettes. Moreover, it would free up law enforcement to go after real criminals. Prostitution will never be erradicated, but for the time being, you may want to consider moving to Amsterdam! :D
 
Basically, outcall is legal. Anything else, not so much. Lapdance is legal-- but some places have no-touch bylaws. Massage is legal, but release is not. Many place have bylaws with regard to how naked girls can be, and peep hole rules.

Many of these laws aren't regularly enforced, but you can indeed be at the wrong place at the wrong time. Your best bet is to use services that have a decent track record, and that tend to keep a low(er) profile.

If caught in anything beyond picking up a SW (Umm, don't do that :) ) don't plead out or admit guilt until the proprietor's case has been solved. It's hard to be found in a bawdy house if it's not a bawdy house.

drlove said:
Decriminalizing prostitution would be ideal, but Canada seems to be a bit behind the times.

Decriminalization is a mixed bag:
1. You don't really want formal red light districts, because in the developed world they tend to become high priced sex tourist districts. It's the bottom end of the market where most of the problems are, and this does little to help there.
2. You don't want to encourage street prostitution. It's a classic NIMBY problem. Nobody want street walkers, foot and car traffic from Johns, and associated drug dealers, pimps, and riffraff where they live. They like the 'gifts' there folks leave behind even less.
3. You really don't want to encourage pimping / trafficking in women.

On the other hand:
1. You need 'living of the avails' laws that don't penalize 'normal' relationships. An unemployed construction worker liven with a SP isn't necessarily her pimp. A person might sometimes be a driver / muscle, but be an employee rather than a pimp.
2. Incall / outcall laws are dated. The law should do a better job distinguishing from a SP who essentially is running a small business from her apartment, and a full blown brothel. Kind of like the difference between a person who earns some extra cash by hemming pants in their apartment vs a textile factory. It's not that brothels should be outlawed-- it's just that they should be zoned (And not forced into a district.). [There's not much of a NIMBY case there, because a landlord can give you the boot if you're a 'problem tenant'.]
3. Any women who is working in the sex industry should be doing so as a matter of informed choice. Basically, as long as you're an adult, and you're not being forced to do a thing, or you're not doing it fuel a habit, you should be free to do what you want to do.

As an aside, I think that all people who come in regular contact with fluids from relative strangers should be legally forced to get full battery of tests for communicable diseases on say a bi-yearly basis. That's not just sex workers.

The above is just my 2 cents...
 
Lisa of Toronto said:
Windsor requires a license


Yep and that seems to turn many ladies off from working in Windsor :(


What about Barrie, I thought I seen escorts and even their drivers need a license over there?