condoms effective??

buttercup

Active member
Feb 28, 2005
2,564
11
38
We've all seen the statistics: Condoms are 98 percent effective in preventing pregnancy when used consistently and correctly.

If you all know what that means, and how it shows that condoms really are really effective at preventing pregnancies, I apologize for wasting your time. But to me, "98% effective", at first blush, means: every 100 shags, you get pregnant twice.

It can't mean that. If it meant "98% effective per shag", and you're shagging once a week, you'd be guaranteed to get pregnant once a year. That's a better rate almost than people striving as hard as they can to get pregnant.

So, surely, the "98% effective" figure doesn't mean per shag.

Perhaps it means per year? In other words, of every 100 couples who use condoms, every year two will get pregnant? Over twenty-five years, that's half!

Even if it means per lifetime, it still doesn't look too good. In other words, for every 100 couples that use condoms their whole sex lives, two will have an unwanted pregnancy? And that's when they're used consistently and correctly. Forgetting and mistakes are extra to that basic number.

So: how does "condoms are 98% effective" convince you to use condoms as your contraceptive?
 
We've all seen the statistics: Condoms are 98 percent effective in preventing pregnancy when used consistently and correctly.

If you all know what that means, and how it shows that condoms really are really effective at preventing pregnancies, I apologize for wasting your time. But to me, "98% effective", at first blush, means: every 100 shags, you get pregnant twice.

It can't mean that. If it meant "98% effective per shag", and you're shagging once a week, you'd be guaranteed to get pregnant once a year. That's a better rate almost than people striving as hard as they can to get pregnant.

So, surely, the "98% effective" figure doesn't mean per shag.

Perhaps it means per year? In other words, of every 100 couples who use condoms, every year two will get pregnant? Over twenty-five years, that's half!

Even if it means per lifetime, it still doesn't look too good. In other words, for every 100 couples that use condoms their whole sex lives, two will have an unwanted pregnancy? And that's when they're used consistently and correctly. Forgetting and mistakes are extra to that basic number.

So: how does "condoms are 98% effective" convince you to use condoms as your contraceptive?

Yeah, well most couples don't make to five years let alone 25, so not really an issue I guess.
 
6PD_03.jpg
 
If they said their condoms were 100% effective they would get sued every time one breaks. Condoms remind me of tires, which are both made of rubber. Condoms and tires are reliable but they can fail you at anytime.
 
So, every 100 couples that use condoms properly, two per year get pregnant? Same again, year after year??

Is it just me that's surprised and shocked by that statistic? This is a product that's marketed as the "reliable" contraceptive?

Imagine a statistic like that for clearing landmines - "Yeah, we got ninety-eight percent of 'em out of your field. It's safe to plant your crops now."

And what about using condoms as protection against aids? What's the percentage in that case? If your partner has aids, and you use condoms, you've got a 2% per year chance of getting infected?? Hardly what you'd call protection?
 
So, every 100 couples that use condoms properly, two per year get pregnant? Same again, year after year??

Is it just me that's surprised and shocked by that statistic? This is a product that's marketed as the "reliable" contraceptive?..

That sounds pretty reliable. You can rely on 2% per year.
 
The big problem with condom statistics, and contraceptive statistics generally, is that the failure rate is the number of people who report that they've used the method reliably throughout the year who experience a pregnancy. It still seems overwhelmingly likely that the vast majority of condom failures are actually people who sometimes fail to use condoms, but alas researchers generally can't keep a large group of people under constant watch to verify exactly what they're doing with their birth control every time they have sex.
 
It's like getting a paternity test which my son did when his g/f gave birth. The specialist at the lab explained that DNA paternity tests are 99.999....% accurate. You may wonder what about that .01 % but it just means the chance of someone else being his father is only .01 % out of the entire world population of 7 billion people, which is impossible. Therefore it's reliable and that's how you should be thinking of it.
 
Last edited:
It's like getting a paternity test which my son did when his g/f gave birth. The specialist at the lab explained that DNA paternity tests are 99.999....% accurate. You may wonder what about that .01 % but it means the chance of someone else being his father is only .01 % out of the entire world population of 6 million people, which is impossible. Therefore it's reliable and that's how you should be thinking of it.

Excellent point!

Just because a condom fails (as in breaks) doesn't mean the girl is going to get pregnant. Look at how many couples use no protection in order to get pregnant and it still takes months and months. Just be careful and use lube if things are getting dry which can lead to breakage. I've never contracted an STI or had a girl become pregnant while using condoms and I've probably had sex several thousand times.
 
.., but alas researchers generally can't keep a large group of people under constant watch to verify exactly what they're doing with their birth control every time they have sex.
I wonder if anyone would fund that study? If they don't want to use the olympic village to sample, I'd do my share and volunteer to make appropriate use of 100 condoms in lab conditions.
 
It's like getting a paternity test which my son did when his g/f gave birth. The specialist at the lab explained that DNA paternity tests are 99.999....% accurate. You may wonder what about that .01 % but it just means the chance of someone else being his father is only .01 % out of the entire world population of 7 billion people, which is impossible. Therefore it's reliable and that's how you should be thinking of it.

Pretzel, baby. Where are you going with this arithmetic? If the test is right 99.999% of the time, that means its wrong once every 100,000 tests.

As a matter of fact, the world pop'n is seven billion. So, at that rate, if the whole word were tested, there would be 70,000 incorrectly-identified fathers.

You've heard that thing about aircraft accidents. Suppose there's a "one in a million" chance of a certain concatenation of circumstances that would cause the plane to crash. "Just one in a million" means "it won't happen", right?

Wrong: there are 34 million scheduled air flights per year, worldwide. So, "one chance in a million" means it will happen 34 times a year, on average.

Coming back to condom statistics: the quoted statistic is two unwanted pregnancies per year per hundred couples who use condoms. Now, I would regard one in a hundred thousand as comfortingly unlikely. But two out of a hundred -- not so comforting.
 
Just because a condom fails (as in breaks) doesn't mean the girl is going to get pregnant. Look at how many couples use no protection in order to get pregnant and it still takes months and months. Just be careful and use lube if things are getting dry which can lead to breakage. I've never contracted an STI or had a girl become pregnant while using condoms and I've probably had sex several thousand times.

Same here. Thousands of shags with condoms, and never an unwanted pregnancy, nor an STD.

How can that be?

Now, according to Ray_in_TO's official statistics, out of a hundred couples who use condoms, two per year will have unwanted pregnancies. Putting it another way, each couple can expect to have an unwanted pregnancy once every fifty years.

So, I suppose once per lifetime, on the average, isn't such a bad risk, after all.

That's for the terb-chaps. Assume the chaps average twice a week, or hundred condom-shags per year. Over fifty years, that's 5,000 shags. Sounds about right.

On the other hand, look at it from the terb-ladies' point of view. Only they know how many clients they see, but let's say the average terb-lady might rack up twenty condom-episodes a week. So, if the terb-chaps average a hundred per year, we can figure the terb-ladies at a thousand per year. So, the terb-ladies, if they use condoms, can expect to have unwanted pregnancies at the rate of once every five years.

I suspect not many terb-ladies maintain a rate of twenty condom-episodes a week for anywhere near five years. And those who do, presumably use more than one method of contraception (e.g the pill, or an IUD, in addition to condoms).

So, I guess I've convinced myself that, as a matter of arithmetic, a condom effectiveness rate of 98%, or two unwanted pregnancies per hundred couples per year, which sounded horrendous, is actually not that bad, if you play the percentages.

Apparently, everyone but me knew that already. Toujours la meme chose.
 
Without going into just why the maths are misleading above (and why even a very low rate of "false positives" is never acceptable - hint: if you're testing a large population which is negative, even a very low rate of false positives can overwhelm the number of actual positives), it seems it's time for yet another review of how condoms "fail".

Yes, condoms can break, and that's a major failure.

But that's not the main contributor to the 1-2% "failure rate" for condoms.

When a condom is manufactured, it will have some number of microscopic holes in the rubber. The manufacturing testing provides a level of assurance that very few of those holes are large enough for a sperm to slip through.

As a condom reaches its expiry date, or if it comes into contact with some substance which degrades the latex, the number of holes large enough to let sperm through grow and grow.

But even if the condom meets spec, there is a possibility that a few of the holes will be large enough to let some sperm through, and that enough sperm pass to impregnate the girl.

All of this is without the condom actually breaking.

Everyone should always maintain duplicate means of protection, to help ensure that the low percentage failure rate of one method is likely to be caught in the success rate of the alternate mechanism.

But never think that an old condom, or a degraded condom, will provide protection to the same degree as a fresh one.
 
Pretzel, baby. Where are you going with this arithmetic? If the test is right 99.999% of the time, that means its wrong once every 100,000 tests.

As a matter of fact, the world pop'n is seven billion. So, at that rate, if the whole word were tested, there would be 70,000 incorrectly-identified fathers.

You've heard that thing about aircraft accidents. Suppose there's a "one in a million" chance of a certain concatenation of circumstances that would cause the plane to crash. "Just one in a million" means "it won't happen", right?

Wrong: there are 34 million scheduled air flights per year, worldwide. So, "one chance in a million" means it will happen 34 times a year, on average.

Coming back to condom statistics: the quoted statistic is two unwanted pregnancies per year per hundred couples who use condoms. Now, I would regard one in a hundred thousand as comfortingly unlikely. But two out of a hundred -- not so comforting.

No the lab specialist explained that the chance of anyone else being the baby's father is .01% out of 3 and a half billion men in the world!
If you don't want to agree or dispute the findings, then i suggest you consult a DNA lab for yourself. Maybe they can it explain it to you better than i can.
 
Pretzel, baby. Where are you going with this arithmetic? If the test is right 99.999% of the time, that means its wrong once every 100,000 tests.

As a matter of fact, the world pop'n is seven billion. So, at that rate, if the whole word were tested, there would be 70,000 incorrectly-identified fathers.

You've heard that thing about aircraft accidents. Suppose there's a "one in a million" chance of a certain concatenation of circumstances that would cause the plane to crash. "Just one in a million" means "it won't happen", right?

Wrong: there are 34 million scheduled air flights per year, worldwide. So, "one chance in a million" means it will happen 34 times a year, on average.

Coming back to condom statistics: the quoted statistic is two unwanted pregnancies per year per hundred couples who use condoms. Now, I would regard one in a hundred thousand as comfortingly unlikely. But two out of a hundred -- not so comforting.

I think you're getting your probability equations mixed up... Each use of a condom isn't dependant on the previous use. Foe example, if 98 couples in a group have sex with condoms in a row, it doesn't mean the next two couples are GUARANTEED to have a failure! Each use is 98% effective which just simply means that if used properly from start to finish with sufficient lube, you might encounter a 2% manufacture's defect or somesuch in a condom.

Men make the machines which make the condoms so a .0001cm misalignment or something may yield 1 bad condom every so many million condoms.
 
So: how does "condoms are 98% effective" convince you to use condoms as your contraceptive?
Considering the odds the other way round worked for me.

May I ask what thought-processes/odds-calculations you go through before getting into a car?
 
On my point that the majority of condom failures are human error rather than condom problems, one of my main reasons for thinking that is the research on health issues among SPs. I'm assuming SPs have many, many times more frequent sex than typical users of birth control. Thus, if condoms failed 2% per year because they just weren't that reliable, one would expect SPs to experience a much, much higher failure rate than that. But there is no indication of such frequent failures in the health statistics on SPs; they don't seem to become pregnant very often at all, or contract very many STDs. It seems to me that the only plausible explanation is that condoms are much more than 98% effective when used properly, professional SPs tend to use them properly, and the 2% failure rate in the published statistics is due to the fact that most people are not nearly as reliable in their condom use as SPs.

Of course, one other factor that has already been mentioned is that if condoms degrade over time, I suppose that SPs are much more likely to be using recently purchased condoms, which may boost the reliability for them. Perhaps a tendency to sometimes use old condoms is one of the ways in which non-SPs are unreliable condom users, though I'm still betting that not really using them every single time is a much bigger factor than people admit to when they're surveyed about their use of birth control methods.