Common Law Question.

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,049
1
0
A question for the lawyer or wannabe's.

Buddy has a girlfriend, not a live in, but she might as well be. They are going to be hitting the road in a camper, after she gives up her apartment and travel throughout the US and Canada for maybe 8-10 months a year for however long it take, 2 maybe 3 years, working at odd jobs as needed.


He asked me if this could be considered a common law situation especially since she gave up her apartment. I don't know if she's using his address for mail or a rental mailbox. It's really got me thinking.
 
I'm not a lawyer but as they will be moving between several jusrisdictions then she couldn't claim it that way as she wouldn't be in one place long enough to qualify. Especially if they cross the border. Heck they won't even qualify for OHIP after 6 months so I wouldn't worry about it.
 
I'm not a lawyer, not even a wannabe - this is just my guess.
I'll say no, unless the camper is fixed in place and hooked up to utilities.
If you can drive off immediately, it's a vehicle and not a home and therefore they aren't commonlaw.
 
I'm waiting for Oagre or RLD, however, the question basically boils down to do you have to be physically resident in Ontario for the required period of time (almost certainly you do, save for short vacations), further merely cohabiting is not enough you have to present yourselves to the world as being married.

As a point of interest as matters stand in the U.S. only nine states: Alabama, Colorado, Iowa, Kansas, Montana, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, South Carolina, and Texas plus Washington, D.C. still recognize the creation of a Common Law Marriage.
 
The answer is no.

Now, what was the question?

Oh, yes... they are traveling companions sharing a vehicle.

Perry
 
What does he care, doesn`t sound like she`d get much anyway.
 
Dunno. I will have to think about this one.
 
In legal matters everything is just a question until the last judge has decided. The proper question is more like: What kind of a case does whoever have? The fact that it's a matter of common rather than writtemn law just makes it more arguable. The basic idea of common-law is 'everybody know's', so even if the lawmakers haven't yet gotten around to spelling it out, if you do what everybody knows is wrong, or fail to do what we know is right, there will be legal consequences.

You are a common-law spouse if you and your spouse have commonly and consistently presented you as husband or wife to the world and treated your relationship that way when together. Given how often men and women fail in their spousal arrangements and the attendant property and child-rearing responsibilities that go with them, all sorts of judicial precedents and legislated detail now encrusts the basic principal. And as if things weren't murky enough, non-marital relationships with all sorts of new expectations or non-expectations are becoming commonplace.

But I'd still go by the ages-old principle: You're common-law married if you treat each other, and represent yourselves to the world as if you are. If it matters to the parties, they should say so, spell out how, preferably with witnesses and write something down, whether they're trying to ensure their partnership, or their independence. So your answer: Whether they're common-law is up to them. And most often we like the concept and feel happy for the couple in their new partnership.

Isn't the real question on your mind something else? Like: Whatever this relationship, what are the legal possibilities if it ends unhappily? Worth a chat with your friend, about the virtues of being clear about such stuff.
 
In legal matters everything is just a question until the last judge has decided. The real question is: What kind of a case does whoever have? The fact that it's a matter of common rather than writtemn law just makes it more arguable. The basic idea of common-law is 'everybody know's', so even if the lawmakers haven't yet gotten around to spelling it out, if you do what everybody knows is wrong, or fail to do what we know is right, there will be legal consequences.

You are a common-law spouse if you and your spouse have commonly and consistently presented you as husband or wife to the world and treated your relationship that way when together. Given how often men and women fail in their spousal arrangements and the attendant property and child-rearing responsibilities that go with them, all sorts of judicial precedents and legislated detail now encrusts the basic principal. And as if things weren't murky enough, non-marital relationships with all sorts of new expectations or non-expectations are becoming commonplace.

But I'd still go by the ages-old principle: You're common-law married if you treat each other, and represent yourselves to the world as if you are. If it matters to the parties, they should say so, spell out how, preferably with witnesses and write something down. Whether to ensure their partnership, or their independence. Whether they're common-law is up to them.

Isn't the real question on your mind something else?

I can see it now. Mr Bossman (name being withheld to protect the innocent), I'd like to introduce my fuck buddy Carol.

I wouldn't want to give the wrong impression.
 
I can see it now. Mr Bossman (name being withheld to protect the innocent), I'd like to introduce my fuck buddy Carol.

I wouldn't want to give the wrong impression.
Back in the '70's that was serious problem that often perplexed my sweetie and I in the years before we made it official. These days there are all sorts of usages, 'partner' being the most common, sometimes to emphasize non-spouse, but as often from a linguistic prejudice against terms the speaker simply dislikes. Like everything in law, it's arguable whether 'partner' is equivalent to husband/wife, but it's certainly not unusual with that intended meaning. 'Friend' is a fine old Anglo-Saxon term that fits most situations where your point is that you are not spouse and spouse. "I'd like to introduce Beverly", works even better.

But avoid, 'wife' or 'husband', unless you mean it. And between yourselves, there should be no question.
 
If you mean my buddy, guess again, but it seems to be a clear cut case of meh. He's retiring early and always wanted to this and she' sup for it.

Why would they need to work odd jobs then.
 
If she's the main person in his life, he might want to make sure his will reflects that. Or not.
If he has children, they might get a smaller piece of the pie.
 
Why would they need to work odd jobs then.

Some people do like to work and do different things just for the experience, fruit picking, sheep herding, grape harvest, cattle drive. It get you in good with the locals. You should try it next time.
 
I believe they can have a co-habitation agreement written up that will assist in clarifying the situation. If'n they have kids with them and he disciplines them in the camper he's toast!
 
There may be some risk for your friend if it makes the three years:

“spouse” means a spouse as defined in subsection 1 (1), and in addition includes either of two persons who are not married to each other and have cohabited,
(a) continuously for a period of not less than three years, or
(b) in a relationship of some permanence, if they are the natural or adoptive parents of a child. (“conjoint”) R.S.O. 1990, c. F.3, s. 29; 1999, c. 6, s. 25 (2); 2005, c. 5, s. 27 (4-6); 2009, c. 11, s. 30.

Here is some more simple information:


The court will consider a number of components in order to determine whether parties continuously cohabit for the purposes of section 29. These components include common shelter, the sexual behaviour of the parties, services the parties may have performed for each other, how the parties behaved socially (i.e., did they act like a "couple" by visiting each other’s parents or going on vacation together), societal (did one person extend insurance coverage to the other), and the economic relationship between the two.

I didn't do any case law research, but I suspect the location of the living together is not material because it is not in the statute. There may well be a case to tell me I am wrong, but as I indicated I really have not had time to look.
 
The court will look at whether the couple lived together in a relationship resembling marriage and with the intention that they be souses of one another with some degree of permanence whether or not it ultimately works out that way. There is a difference although not always between traveling companions and spouses.
 
Last edited: