Comfort Inn Markham & LE

AJstar

New member
Oct 20, 2002
1,520
0
0
York Regional cops must be having a slow day. I happened to be parked with the car off in the parking lot of that motel. I'm on my cell and a cop pulls up ,knocks on my window and wants to see all my id. I asked if anything was wrong or was there an infraction. He says no, but is aggressive in wanting my id. Checks it out back in his car computer, comes back ,hands me back my id and then starts to lecture on how this area is known and how I don't want to hang around here. WTF, I ask what does that mean? Then he says I'm a smart guy so he doesn't need to spell it out. So this brings out the ?'s. Can they do that without cause? Is there going to be a bust there soon? Survellance? Complaints? Protecting someone else's turf? His intrusion did bother me.
 
Thats strange ...personally I will not give my ID without knowing why ...He can delay me and be an asshole if he wants but I wouldnt just give my ID like that ...
You should have told him that you needed it spelled out ..
I'm sitting in my car in the drivers seat anyway ,so he already has the plates and info. on his computer, so what's the difference?
 
Sorry, not a company car. So, I'm id'd anyway. I can't afford different cars and sets of id's (LOL).
 
This happened to me in south etobicoke about 3 weeks ago at the Stay Inn. Driving, Cell phone rang, blue tooth in pocket, pull in to spot and answer phone. End call and go to back up, cop car behind me, ask what I'm doing, tell him, on my way no ID check.(Probably already checked on plates anyways.)
 
I wonder how many times this random checking has turned into a drug or weapons or warrant arrest. I have no warrants, no arrests, no drugs, no weapons and no problem showing ID to the cop when ask and explained why.
 
What else is there to conclude other than, since they can't bust the girls for running a bawdy house in a hotel, they're harassing potential clients.

What happens if I have a legitimate meeting in a hotel....how are they profiling who to stop? What bullshit....we have a workable system that the politicians tolerate, but the cops have their own standards?
 
I wonder how many times this random checking has turned into a drug or weapons or warrant arrest. I have no warrants, no arrests, no drugs, no weapons and no problem showing ID to the cop when ask and explained why.

I don't have anything to hide but on the other hand I don't have to let a cop check my ID unless he has a reason (i.e. he has a reasonable suspicion).
 
The only ID he can demand, backed up with threat of penalty, is your driver's licence. Along with that, he can demand the car ownership and insurance. And all that comes from traffic law enforcement. Walking on the sidewalk, you only have to account for your activities and presence. Canadians are under no general obligation to carry ID or to produce any on demand from a cop. Only as part of operating a motor vehicle.

Which is not to say he couldn't make you wish you had, but not in a court.
 
They don't call them the Yorky Porkys for nothing. In general, I find the Metro cops to more laid back than the 905ers.
 
The only ID he can demand, backed up with threat of penalty, is your driver's licence. Along with that, he can demand the car ownership and insurance. And all that comes from traffic law enforcement.

I agree that this is generally true, except in OP's case he was in a private parking lot. The obligation to surrender a driver's license is found in the Highway Traffic Act, s.33. That Act, by definition applies to highways, which a private parking lot is not. I don't think the officer in this case had authority to demand to see a driver's license because OP was in a private parking lot. The problem for a die hard civil libertarian is that the officer probably thought he DID have authority to demand it and no amount of reasoning was likely to change his mind - therefore a refusal to produce id was, for all practical purposes, likely to amount to a much bigger headache than anyone needs.
 
Here we go again, all the legal wannabees are out. Where's oagre???? Let's get some true legal opinions here.
 
driver must produce ID, passengers or pedestrians have no such obligation

I don't agree that YRP cops are worse than Toronto police; if anything, it's the other way around. The courts certainly are.
If you are charged with Over 80 in York region for blowing 110, a decent lawyer will be able to get it tossed in exchange for a plea to a careless. If you are charged with an Over 80 in say downtown Toronto for blowing even 100, no Crown in Old City Hall will agree to a careless, and you will be prosecuted to the full extent.
 
Whether you have to give him an id or not, the cops is just trying to keep the city safe so why not help him do his job unless you have something to hide.
 
While some might choose to argue a case based on the private property aspect of a parking lot open to the public, I'd bet that's already been decided long, long ago.
 
Sitting in the driver's seat of a motor vehicle is quite different from walking down the sidewalk.

True, but there is also a big difference between sitting behind the wheel of your automobile, and sitting in the drivers seat of a motor vehicle. If the OP wasn't engaging in commerce then he's not "Driving" he's traveling and doesn't "have to" show ID. It would help in the future to write the license people and demand they unregister your car. There is no law that says you even need a "drivers license" to use a car on any road/highway in Canada You only need a "driver's license" if you are driving a "motor vehicle" which means using your car/truck/motor bike for commerce taxi drivers, bus drivers need a license. You might want to put some sort of plates on your car so your not pulled over every 10 minutes. I think the people at thinkfree.ca were trying to setup there own plate system.

Secondly, when the officer taps on your window ask him right away for his full name and badge numbe, also would be good to have a camra running. then whiether or not s/he gives that infomation let them know your have a schedule of fees and quote him the per hour/per minute fee you added schedule for handing over your ID, be sure to remind him that there are people wwho have went to court and collected their fees.

So yeah, i wouldn't have handed over my ID without asking a lot of questions.
 
There is no law that says you even need a "drivers license" to use a car on any road/highway in Canada You only need a "driver's license" if you are driving a "motor vehicle" which means using your car/truck/motor bike for commerce taxi drivers, bus drivers need a license.

Huh? No law except perhaps the HTA, which says this: "No person shall drive a motor vehicle on a highway unless the motor vehicle is within a class of motor vehicles in respect of which the person holds a driver’s licence issued to him or her under this Act."
 
let them know your have a schedule of fees and quote him the per hour/per minute fee you added schedule for handing over your ID, be sure to remind him that there are people wwho have went to court and collected their fees.

thank you TERB for putting a smile on my face in the beginning of a day:) I bet these people "wwho have went to court" can collect their fees even from Chuck Norris