CNN - Black in America

Mongrel4u

Guest
May 27, 2005
3,426
3
0
I caught a little bit of this show but couldnt get through it as i thought it was dumb.

There was this interracial couple...educated, seemed comfortable. Anyways one of their concerns was "how to raise thier kids...as 'black' or as 'white'"

Now what the hell does that mean? How do you raise a kid as "black or as "white"??? :confused: I couldnt beleive an "educated" couple sees this as an issue...

what ever happened to raising your kid to be respectful and to be a good person?
 
I think it means what culture they would like their child to subscribe to:

rap vs. heavy metal, fubu vs. abecrombie & fitch, etc.

Like any network, CNN is looking for ratings.
 
I think it is a little ridiculous that CNN has such a series in the first place. What about all the ethnic groups in America? In the US, minority seems to be just black (and maybe hispanic) and the others basically forgotten.
 
Mongrel4u said:
I caught a little bit of this show but couldnt get through it as i thought it was dumb.

There was this interracial couple...educated, seemed comfortable. Anyways one of their concerns was "how to raise thier kids...as 'black' or as 'white'"

Now what the hell does that mean? How do you raise a kid as "black or as "white"??? :confused: I couldnt beleive an "educated" couple sees this as an issue...

what ever happened to raising your kid to be respectful and to be a good person?

Not to suggest that Canada is remotely immune from the problems in the US but some of the statistics that have been presented over the course of this series are somewhat disturbing... a black male has essentially the same chances of being called back for a job interview as a white male who just got out of prison while a black male just out of prison has a negligible chance of a call back just for one.

I think that there are lots of rationalizations that occur and as the Coz' said there needs to be some more self introspection but it isn't fair to simply suggest there are not serious systemic problems.

As per the segment you were referring to the crux of their problem was they were trying to raise their kids right but the kids were finding that in school the white kids didn't quite know what to do with them and the black kids told them that they were being 'too white'. That seems to be a fairly difficult situation where they are stuck no matter what they do.

It isn't a bad series, the panel shows that sometimes follow are ridiculous as a rule as they tend to be filled with apologists that jump down the throat of anyone who remotely doesn't endorse the party line. CNN had a good idea but you needed either the CBC or the BBC to do the work and get a bit more in-depth.
 
More CNN imposed induced racism. To think CNN actually has a policy to say "black" and "white", but to never stop saying those words all together. They won't with some of their pundits as severe racists as it is. Lou Dobbs comes to mind, Richard Sanchez (a Cuban American) and there's another guy (who's, *cough, cough* black, not African American, because he's a racist), don't know his name.....we forget.....we forget.

Gyaos Baltar
 
I watched most of the two-parts. It was okay and managed to touch on a couple of interesting bits but then failed to follow up.

The WM/BF couple were a curious pair because of the attitude about raising the child in a particular community. It would have been interesting to explore the reasoning a bit deeper but I get the feeling that would have generated more issues than CNN has an interest in presenting. Anyway, I'd almost bet those two will be getting a divorce in due time.

I also took note of the mention of Something New as a reference point for interracial dating. Having seen the movie, I'd say it was more about inter-class dating than anything else with her a corporate exec and him a landscaper.

The paying children to go to school part was interesting because it is an original experiment. It was mort interesting to notice the issues surrounding the children that were identified as being high risk for being drop outs. Like so much of the stuff, they seemed to skirt the underlying issue of poverty and the destruction of family values that is more prevalent among Blacks (as the US identifies them).

The Spike Lee bit was actually entertaining. Lee makes some decent movies but a great deal of the stuff he's done is not commercial and so it won't get big buck funding. I thought it was hilarious to see him literally say he could get money easily for a movie that would sell to the mainstream yet declare his annoyance that the funds won't be so easy to get for a movie he wants to make that isn't so mainstream. Go figure, eh? I laughed when the interviewer asked him if he thought it was because he was Black and he actually fell for it and agreed. Spike Lee plays victim -- not original but always worth airtime. Thank goodness the comment was followed up someone noting it is a business. If Lee stopped being so full of himself, he'd have already reached the ranks of Spielberg and now he could be making the movies he wants.

One of the most amusing comments about the failure of Black men to take on the roles of husband and father had to be the expert that suggested this was somehow tied to the experience of slavery. I was glad to hear at least one post-special discussion commentator emphasizing that this was nonsense. It is a pity he seemed to be a voice in the wilderness. That says a great deal about the mentality of those who investigate these issues in terms of Black Americans.

Numerous attempts were made to tie in the slave past with the present. I found that disturbing because it essentially is a argument for allowing Black identified individuals to avoid taking responsibility while ignoring that the same trends are evident throughout America.

One element that CNN utterly failed to look at was the experience of African Americans. I think it would have been informative to have a look at Black-identified individuals who came to America directly from Africa, since the end of slavery. African immigrants I have met hold very different attitudes. Perhaps it is because they have a history and maybe it is because they do not have a history of slavery. Anyway, CNN ignored it.
 
An admirable attempt, but CNN on face value needs to bring on board contributors/pundits that are truly "black". Notice when they bring in someone to analyze the "black perspective" especially as it relates to the upcoming election, that person is so light skinned that I barely consider them black.
 
How Stats Lie....on INcome

CNN made big deal about emerging Black middle class. Stated that about 1974 only about 18% of Black Families were earning $50,000

Now in 2008 or so it is 38% earning $50,000.

Well, if one was to compare general salary increases and inflation over that 34 years it would probably mean that Black families are now earning less.

Just a comment on how Stats can mean nothing if not put in proper contect. You could also analyze price of gas too, to income rises, from one time period to another and see that in fact in is almost the cheapest in relationship to what it ever was before the last rise in price.
 
Lady Kyla said:
CNN made big deal about emerging Black middle class. Stated that about 1974 only about 18% of Black Families were earning $50,000

Now in 2008 or so it is 38% earning $50,000.

Well, if one was to compare general salary increases and inflation over that 34 years it would probably mean that Black families are now earning less.

Just a comment on how Stats can mean nothing if not put in proper contect. You could also analyze price of gas too, to income rises, from one time period to another and see that in fact in is almost the cheapest in relationship to what it ever was before the last rise in price.

Great point Kyla.

I recall seeing the same kind of suggestion from the Bush administration suggesting that in 1958 the average income was $8,500 and now it was in the $40k range. Problem is that the guy with the $8,500 salary could buy a house for about a year's salary... not quite exactly the same situation. It was then pointed out later that in terms of buying power the $8,500 was far more money than the $40k in 2005.
 
Keebler Elf said:
It just allows black to continue to wallow in their self-misery and blame games.

I really hope this is a failed attempt at sarcasm... :rolleyes:
 
Black people around the world have been hypnotized into believing that all their failures in life are due to discrimination. This couldn’t be further from the truth. In spite of racial quotas, blacks struggle forward. Black Empowerment businesses hit the wall one after the other. Blacks who get jobs almost never carry out their duties with the same level of competence as the whites who came before them. And it is clear that the problem is not with white people - the problem is with the blacks themselves. But how many black people are willing to admit it?


Any white or Asian person who remains in contact with black people for any length of time stands a very good chance of becoming a racist. Why? When you live among blacks for any length of time you start to realize that they are often their own worst enemies, often the cause of their own disasters, and many refuse to listen and reason until it’s too late. Black people rule more than 50 countries on this planet, and every one is a virtual disaster area.


Exactly what causes this? It is two fold. On one hand, it has to do with their attitude and values. On the other hand, it has to do with intelligence. Black people are extremely gregarious, more so than whites, and they place little value on the individual, and much more on the group. One of the key elements in the rise of European and American dominance in the world has been the value accorded to individual accomplishment. Native black African society suppresses the individual and forces a conformism upon people. This makes them very susceptible to being herded like sheep and unwilling to stand up as leaders who will be prepared to go against the grain. The other fault is a tolerance of the wrong things. Blacks have a very easy-going attitude to life - an attitude of what will be will be. Instead of seeing a problem and dealing with it at its root, they ignore it hoping it will go away. They leave small problems to grow, ferment and become BIG PROBLEMS! This very "black" attitude is reflected in the song "Don’t Worry, be happy". It is precisely that sort of viewpoint towards life which causes many problems for them. There is a tendency for black people to live without a thought for tomorrow


These days one never stops hearing the "political version" of Darwin’s theory of evolution. The political version, as I think of it, is that Africa was the cradle of all human life and therefore, everyone, everywhere, across the world, owe something to Africa and to black people in particular.
If, as the political interpretation of Darwin goes, the first humans were black, how come they aren’t the Master Race of the Earth? If blacks had a head start (by millions of years) on whites, Asians and everyone else, why aren’t they running the world? Some say that the hot climate was not as conducive to development as the cold climate. What causes development? What about the Aztecs - they also lived in a hot climate. Look at what they did. Life was hard enough for blacks. They fought a lot with each other. They did not live in some mythical peace. To this day, there is so much tribal hatred in Africa. In this sense, Africa is no different to Europe. So why is it that blacks did not progress to the extent that Asians or Europeans did?



The Chinese were, in many areas, about 1,000 years ahead of Europe. In fact, in Chinese history, the Chinese once had a huge fleet which was destroyed by a certain Emperor. It has been announced recently that they might have evidence that the Chinese visited southern Africa before the Europeans and the Indians. Recent studies have shown that the Great Zimbabwe ruins might be an Indian temple. There is much evidence of Indian colonization of Zimbabwe and South Africa hundreds of years before whites came here. They even built irrigation canals in Zimbabwe and stone walls miles long.


If one looked at Caesar’s description of Europe, 2,000 years ago, he would see that even the Barbaric Europeans (the non-Romans), were more advanced than the blacks of Africa. Some people say that Caesar’s writings are something of a propaganda exercise aimed at painting the Roman conquest of Gaul in a good light. Caesar does not think much of the Barbarians - as he refers to the other Europeans. The Barbarians had a well-structured capitalist society which was functioning. They had governments, and made laws which were enforced. They negotiated deals, and could engage in impressive feats of engineering. In their exploits - including their cunning and deceit, one sees people who were capable of a high level of organization. And yet, these people were backward by Roman standards. Show me anything in African history which comes even close to this. Africans never invented the wheel. Most Africans were not even settled in cities. Their primitive agriculture could not sustain them for long and so they were migratory. The ownership of land, as defined in modern Western society had little meaning to the blacks of those days.


De-colonization had actually been a good thing everywhere - EXCEPT IN AFRICA! The Pacific and Asian countries, and even South America, had fared much better after decolonization than Africa had. Africa has gone backwards for more than 40 years while Asian and other countries moved forward. All countries run by black people are backward - even those which do not have a history of colonialism, such as Ethiopia and Liberia. Liberia was inhabited by former black Americans. That it descended to the same level as the rest of Africa is telling. It shows that there is a deeper problem. In Zimbabwe, even in something as basic as food production, blacks struggle. Asians in Africa have an even more negative view of black abilities than whites. They have been run out of several black African countries. Even now, in South Africa, when they want to show the "capitalist exploitation of blacks", the best examples they come up with are not white businesses, but Indian businesses.


Now let’s be honest, yes, discrimination can hold back even a talented person. But it is here that the issue becomes interesting. So the theory goes "Give everyone an equal chance and the blacks will rise." But that is not true. Among the blacks there are talented individuals - make no mistake - but to assume that the majority of blacks are similarly talented is clearly false. I go to work, and I notice how white and Asian people are still the driving force of the country. Blacks get work but they get it on the basis that whites once got work - the color of their skin. But the difference is, it is not skin color that is the issue, but IQ.


Blacks will never be represented in proportion to their numbers. Even in the USA, Asians have a hard time, coming to a new country, getting no special treatment and yet, they prove themselves and become extremely successful. In South Africa, there is an insistence on job quotas. 80% of all jobs are supposed to go to blacks. You cannot legislate talent. You cannot legislate intelligence or technical skill. It’s either there or it isn’t. Indians were treated in exactly the same way in Apartheid South Africa and even then, Indians became extremely wealthy.


Biologists have since time immemorial unearthed that given a chance, all people will perform better. But, MOST of intelligence is hereditary, and unless science can figure out how to meddle with the DNA to increase a person’s IQ, there is nothing you can do about it. If a black person marries a white person and they have kids, then those kids will have an IQ (on average), half way between that of blacks and whites. Interestingly in South Africa, the "mixed" people like to identify with the whites and regard themselves superior to the blacks. Intelligence affects countries. Asian countries are very active and moving forward at a great pace. Japan, with no natural resources has the second strongest economy in the world, while Africa, which is up to its eyeballs in natural resources, and is potentially the richest continent in the world, is the poorest.


Many black Americans are mixed - which may explain why they do better than native black Africans. If blacks are as clever as they now say they were, then how come they did not have cities and cultures like that which existed elsewhere? The few cities that existed in ancient Africa were probably only in West Africa. You won’t find any cities in the rest of Africa. How come they could be conquered by very few whites? Also, why didn’t blacks import the knowledge and science of others? They had contact with Arabs, Europeans and Asians. Why didn’t they acquire scientific knowledge from others by buying it or getting people to come and teach them? Why did Indians and even Chinese come to Africa and leave their mark here but you see no marks left by blacks? You can see that Asians were here, even centuries later - yet you see no buildings left by blacks. Why didn’t blacks build fleets of ships and sail the world?


The whites were never coddled. The Asians were never coddled. It was kill or be killed. It was live by your own abilities or die. If you could do something you didn’t talk about how great you were, you went and did it. History was written by people who could do as opposed to those who could talk. On the battle field, or in science, it was a case of winner takes all. Nobody ever asked for or got special treatment.
 
Dev0,


Do you really believe the crap you just wrote? Your sweeping generalizations and acute ignorance make it hard to respond to your post or take you seriously.

If however, that is what you truly believe....well...wow. Just. Wow.


P.S. Where did they teach you this stuff? Tell me so I don't send my kids there.
 
Don't be impressed

dolobsure said:
Dev0,


Do you really believe the crap you just wrote? Your sweeping generalizations and acute ignorance make it hard to respond to your post or take you seriously.

If however, that is what you truly believe....well...wow. Just. Wow.


P.S. Where did they teach you this stuff? Tell me so I don't send my kids there.

It was plagarzized. One racist quoting another.

http://www.africanexecutive.com/modules/magazine/articles.php?article=277
 
Dev0 said:
Black people around the world have been hypnotized into believing that all their failures in life are due to discrimination. This couldn’t be further from the truth. But how many black people are willing to admit it?

Now let’s be honest, yes, discrimination can hold back even a talented person. But it is here that the issue becomes interesting. So the theory goes "Give everyone an equal chance and the blacks will rise." But that is not true. Among the blacks there are talented individuals - make no mistake - but to assume that the majority of blacks are similarly talented is clearly false. I go to work, and I notice how white and Asian people are still the driving force of the country.

Blacks will never be represented in proportion to their numbers. Even in the USA, Asians have a VERY hard time, coming to a new country, getting no special treatment and yet, they prove themselves and become extremely successful.

yet Asians never complain, and face even more racism, in this western world.
especially in the DATING scene :)
 
Gyaos said:
That's one long post....wish I could read it.

Gyaos.




I always figured you for having comprehension problems.


Admitting it is the first step to getting better.



.