CMA: Certified Management Accounting

aabbaa1975

New member
Dec 1, 2006
642
0
0
Anyone here a CMA? Researching whether I should go after this degree or do a two year law degree. What are the pros and cons of managerial accountants? Done my research on the net but i would like to hear from people that have the designation
 
CMAs tend to take themselves more seriously than business people do, in my experience. In principle, the ideal candidate for a VP finance position in a private company would be a CMA. But many business owners prefer to hire a CA instead. A CMA is perceived as being more on the level of a CGA, below a CA or MBA. If you are interested in accounting, my suggestion would be an MBA or CA, not a CMA.
 
aabbaa1975 said:
Researching whether I should go after this degree or do a two year law degree.

Go for a law degree and you work only with words and not numbers. Or, go for an MBA and go to Wall Street in 2018 and make millions. Or, go for both if you can afford it and become CEO of Nortel. Me think a law degree or MBA is more highly regarded than a CMA (rightly or wrongly) in the business community but all businesses are going down the toilet now anyway.
 
aabbaa1975 said:
Anyone here a CMA? Researching whether I should go after this degree or do a two year law degree. What are the pros and cons of managerial accountants? Done my research on the net but i would like to hear from people that have the designation

There's very little similarity between an accountant and a lawyer. There's some crossover from a senior accounting position into legal issues, but very little from a lawyer to accounting. You need to assess 1. which one you think you'd like better and 2. which one you think you'd enjoy the most. If they are one and the same, its a no brainer. If its a tie, write down 5 points of what you like and 5 points of you do best. Try to relate them to each profession and then score yourself and then you should have a clearer idea of which way to go. Also, there are many areas of law, so you need to asses which area of expertise you should consider. Obviously a big difference business law and litigation.
From a personality point of view, lawyers tend to be more extroverted and demonstartive and accountants tend to be more introverted. Which one are you? There's a lot to consider. Do you know any lawyers or accountants? If so, do you relate better to any of them vs. the others?
If neither work, maybe you could join a Swedish rock band.;)
 
CMAs tend to get stuck, at least at the outset, with doing alot of budgeting type work. That work can suck, but I guess the same is true with any job when you are starting out. I know lots of CMAs and they all tend to get clogged up in either analysis type work or budget work and never move on to other things. Lawyers seem, in my limited expierience, to be able to jump to different gigs more easily...
 
C Dick said:
CMAs tend to take themselves more seriously than business people do, in my experience. In principle, the ideal candidate for a VP finance position in a private company would be a CMA. But many business owners prefer to hire a CA instead. A CMA is perceived as being more on the level of a CGA, below a CA or MBA. If you are interested in accounting, my suggestion would be an MBA or CA, not a CMA.

This is my experience as well. Rightly or wrongly, many people think of a CMA (or CGA) as a glorified bookkeeper or worse someone not good enough to be a CA or obtain an MBA (from a reputable school like Queens).
 
CMA is a good designation to have. It's Strategic Leadership Program is superb. It teaches skills that most accountant lack, which are doing case study, giving presentations, and answering questions in a detail and precise way.

CA is a good designation to have, but the value comes only when you have worked in a big four.

IMHO, getting either one of them is fine, since it wouldn't be the only designation you will be getting.

Thousand
Certified Massage Attendant (for the ladies)
 
Last edited:
The products of the big 4 are largely drones. Sure there are some smart cookies that come out of, and stay with, the big firms...but that is a small percentage. I'll take a CA from a mid-sized firm every day of the week. Those guys can do it all, from accounting, audit, tax, management....way better rounded.

I am not impressed one bit with the recent CMA hype about being strategic leaders. All the ones I have worked with and have worked for me have been automatons. They complete thier on the job training with 1 firm and in that they pretty much all get stuck doing the same job for those 2 years. Not great breadth of expierience. But then again I feel the same way about most MBA grads in the last 10 years.

I think what the OP should do is call a bunch of headhunters and get thier views on a CMA.
 
gdurham said:
The products of the big 4 are largely drones.

Bear in mind that many powerful positions in industry are populated by graduates from the "Big 4" and they tend to fish in the same pond when they go recruiting.
 
gdurham said:
I am not impressed one bit with the recent CMA hype about being strategic leaders.

During the aborted attempt to merge the CMA's with the CA's a couple of years ago, many CA's were saying that it was like "pissing in the soup". The problem is that because of lower admission standards there are a huge number of CMA's and CGA's and numbers mean political power in this country. So, the CGA's and CMA's wield immense political powers because of sheer number of warm bodies.
 
gdurham said:
I think what the OP should do is call a bunch of headhunters and get thier views on a CMA.

He could simply just do a search on Workopolis.com for CMA. Much easier if he just want to know where a CMA designation will lead and its worth. ;)

Thousand
Married But Available (for hobbying!)
 
In the end, it all comes down to yourself. It doesn't matter if you are a CA, CMA, CGA, MBA, or even no designation, if you are the cream of the crop, you will rise to the top.

:cool:
 
Thousand said:
In the end, it all comes down to yourself. It doesn't matter if you are a CA, CMA, CGA, MBA, or even no designation, if you are the cream of the crop, you will rise to the top.

:cool:

Well put.

Anyone who thinks their preferred designation/qualification is the be all and the end all has drunk their own kool-aid.
 
Thousand said:
In the end, it all comes down to yourself. It doesn't matter if you are a CA, CMA, CGA, MBA, or even no designation, if you are the cream of the crop, you will rise to the top.

:cool:

I agree with you 110%.

Law is a non-honours degree which takes 3 (and not 2) years.
 
Thousand said:
In the end, it all comes down to yourself. It doesn't matter if you are a CA, CMA, CGA, MBA, or even no designation, if you are the cream of the crop, you will rise to the top.

:cool:

I Agree.

Having an MBA is not as valuable as it used to be, unless if it’s from a top school. Nowadays, employers are looking for people with technical skills, so having a professional designation such as a CA, CMA, CGA, CFA, or CIA is definitely an asset.
 
gdurham said:
The products of the big 4 are largely drones. Sure there are some smart cookies that come out of, and stay with, the big firms...but that is a small percentage. I'll take a CA from a mid-sized firm every day of the week. Those guys can do it all, from accounting, audit, tax, management....way better rounded.

Your comments are applicable only for certain instances. If you are an owner-manager type client, then a mid-sized firm would probably suit you much better.

However, if the client is a multi-national who needs, say, cross-border tax advice, it is highly unlikely a mid-size firm tax CA would be able to do the job.

One reason why Big 4 candidates may be well regarded in the recruiting scene is that the Big 4 experience provides some sort of benchmark. A smaller firm trained CA is relatively difficult to benchmark...
 
Thousand said:
In the end, it all comes down to yourself. It doesn't matter if you are a CA, CMA, CGA, MBA, or even no designation, if you are the cream of the crop, you will rise to the top.

:cool:


WELL SAID!!!! couldn't have said it better myself.

I'm a CA and soon to be CFA, CAIA. All i can say is i know tons of CAs, CFAs who know absolutely nothing. I came from a Big4 and while there are some smart ppl the CAs from big4 tend to get very specialized. So if you asked someone in the audit group about tax issues they would have no clue. The same goes for CFAs.

W.r.t advice...the CMA is a waste because of the perception...yes you will get a job but rising to the top is tougher and you will have to prove yourself. CAs have it slightly easier than CMAs. There are tons of 24/25 yr old CAs who just pass and look for jobs that pay atleast $75-80K!!! while the truth is they aren't really worth that much.

Getting back to the law degree if you really want to do it, get both...get your CA and get the LLB after that. There are many ppl who do it.

I've seen the CGA, CMA exam material and its very very similar to the CA exam material so i would just go for the CA instead. It will pay off over the long-run...forget tons of money...not worth the lifestyle. 3 yrs after having a CA designation you can easily pull in 120+ without much effort. If you want more get into private equity, hedge funds, ibanking, equity research if you can even find a job given the current market.
 
Thanks for the responses...

I know that this is a review board and there are other places where I could get the answer that I am looking for, but again, I would just like to know the opinions of those who are in the industry or close to it.

Some info that I guess I should have included in my first post is that I currently I have a marketing degree and about 18 months of relevant work experience but unfortunately I maybe out of a job. When I decided to specialize in marketing, I knew that it was the field that I wanted to be in. But once I entered the working world I started to question that very choice (ie. due to job security, the ability to find a new job, the amount of work to pay ratio). I have spoken to my family members, peers, and even some prof, most of whom say I should stay with marketing as it is what I wanted to do. The only thing that I am concerned about is reaching the point were I will have too many commitments (financial and personal) that it may be difficult/not possible for me to switch careers? As a result, I find myself researching other career option.
 
get the best of both worlds. Wilfrid Laurier offers a combined MBA/CMA or MBA/CFA option now where you can do both in 3 years together. Other universities are offering this now as well i think. Of course the CMA option is a lot easier than the CFA option as u still gotta write the CFA exams.
i think doing just a straight CMA will just pigeon hole u into crunching numbers behind a desk.
 
It may be best to consider the personal satisfaction from
a) The subject matter in the program
b) The type of positions available
for each of the designations

CA CMA positions will be very accounting oriented, many position focus around reporting monthly, quarterly and yearly results, variances from budget, budget preparation, cost analysis and of course keeping the books in order. Possible management opportunities arise for those who can excel at these tasks and impress management.
There is always a big demand for these types of services with the option of being a hired gun contractor type (good $ & flexibility).

CFA is more investment orientated. Possible positions include equity and credit analysis, trading, portfolio management, Institutional sales, Investment Adviser & Investment banker types.
Very good $, however long hours & demand for the skills is a function of the capital markets (not so hot right now) Layoffs do happen.
The CFA exams are challenging - three separate six hour exams, with a significant failure rate. You have to study 10-15 hrs / week for four months in preparation for each exam (obviously varies from person to person)

Worth noting is there are a ton of CFAs in the Toronto Market right now chasing after the same jobs.
It is very competitive & the CFA helps but investment related positions are often filled based more upon experience and who you know.

I believe the Toronto CFA Society is the second largest after New York.
It is very high on a proportional basis relative to the number of available jobs

In addition, firms seeking a CMA or CA are seeking accounting expertise, not necessarily investment expertise. Therefore they may not value the CFA as highly for what they need