Clean Sweep Saturday

Aardvark154 said:
From my view far worse would be a system where candidate A could win an election merely by winning the vote in a few major cities while everyone else voted for candidate B, the system was deliberate set up to prevent that.

A few major cities? You're way overexaggerating. Far worse is when candidate A gains significantly more votes than candidate B, and still loses. Explain to me how it makes sense that in a general election for the highest office in the land, the national vote might be tossed aside in a close election.
 
Asterix said:
A few major cities? You're way overexaggerating. Far worse is when candidate A gains significantly more votes than candidate B, and still loses. Explain to me how it makes sense that in a general election for the highest office in the land, the national vote might be tossed aside in a close election.
I'd have to do more research than TERB is worth but yes you could win a certain number of the most populous Metropolitan Statistical Areas in the U.S. and loose the rest of the country and win the General Election under a popular vote system.

Second and more importantly, although I know the concept is often discussed in a selective manner, the U.S. is a Federal Union made up of states, the Citizens of the States vote, not the entire population of the U.S. This deliberately preserves the power of less populous states.
 
Aardvark154 said:
I'd have to do more research than TERB is worth but yes you could win a certain number of the most populous Metropolitan Statistical Areas in the U.S. and loose the rest of the country and win the General Election under a popular vote system.

Second and more importantly, although I know the concept is often discussed in a selective manner, the U.S. is a Federal Union made up of states, the Citizens of the States vote, not the entire population of the U.S. This deliberately preserves the power of less populous states.

The less populus States already have a built-in power due to their equal voice of two elected Senators. In that, Rhode Island equals California or Texas. We disagree. I think the selection of President should be a decision based on the vote of the entire country, not on a compromise decided two centuries ago to satisfy States that feared they would be disaffected.
 
Asterix said:
The less populus States already have a built-in power due to their equal voice of two elected Senators. In that, Rhode Island equals California or Texas. We disagree. I think the selection of President should be a decision based on the vote of the entire country, not on a compromise decided two centuries ago to satisfy States that feared they would be disaffected.
I enjoy how the Founders were so wise - until people disagree with them.
 
Aardvark154 said:
I enjoy how the Founders were so wise - until people disagree with them.

The founding fathers were wise. They also had alot of baggage they had to deal with. Namely how to hold together States that were bent on going their own direction, the chief bent being slavery.
 
Asterix said:
The founding fathers were wise. They also had alot of baggage they had to deal with. Namely how to hold together States that were bent on going their own direction, the chief bent being slavery.
Things like the three-fifths compromise had to due with slavery. Federalism: that the U.S. is a Union of States has nothing to do with Slavery. Neither do protection against the tyranny of the majority, and checks and balances.
 
some prediction, some result from tonight...

Sorry to change the subject, but here's verdict for tonight:

Obama very much clean up capital area, huge round up lucky number 7 straight win.

McCain also win, upset Huckabee's band "Capital Offense" and declair war against Dems

Hillary is in deep trouble once again and another one of her assistant calls quit, my wild guess is, she will be crying at her Texas hotel room alone while Bill goes to bar lobby for beer.:p

Ron Paul continue to cash in and watch the result on CNN from his motel 6 room, while his commercial will play once every 12 hrs in local public broadcasting cable for $140 per slot. He received 5-8% hardcore RON PAUL Revolution voters' votes. He currently have $21 million on hand.
 
Last edited: