Chris Carpenter wins CY Young

the_big_E said:
bah

stupid ex-Jay!
Better him than Rocket (The Mercenary) Roger. I have always liked Carpenter and his no nosense approach to piching.

His second most memorable moment was telling the mayor of Philly to kiss his butt as well as his face plant in attempting to take extra bases in that world series.
 
That may be the first time I've ever heard Chris Carpenter confused with Todd Stottlemyre.
;)
 
Great news for CC, who's seems a genuinely nice young guy. But I've said before that it wasn't JP's fault. The entire league gave up on Carpenter and the chances of him ever getting back to the Majors was pretty remote. I mean, who blames the Jays for giving up on Mike Sirotka? Or Billy Koch?
 
Von Wigglestaff said:
JP Ricciardi's mistake:

Not enough patience for Carpenter, too much for Hinske.

Carpenter looked done. Pretty much everyone in baseball thought so.
Sometimes, guys get lucky.
That's no reason to blow your budget on longshots.
 
oagre said:
Great news for CC, who's seems a genuinely nice young guy. But I've said before that it wasn't JP's fault. The entire league gave up on Carpenter and the chances of him ever getting back to the Majors was pretty remote. I mean, who blames the Jays for giving up on Mike Sirotka? Or Billy Koch?

Ah, if those guys had developed, you can put up several names from this board as being in line to criticize the GM.

Hindsight is fabulous, isn't it? It makes everyone a genius. LOL
 
oagre said:
Great news for CC, who's seems a genuinely nice young guy. But I've said before that it wasn't JP's fault. The entire league gave up on Carpenter and the chances of him ever getting back to the Majors was pretty remote. I mean, who blames the Jays for giving up on Mike Sirotka? Or Billy Koch?

Actually the entire league didn't give up on Carpenter, the Jays wanted to resign him on a minor league contract while he gets healthy but he decided to go to St. Louis to get a fresh start
 
benn said:
Actually the entire league didn't give up on Carpenter, the Jays wanted to resign him on a minor league contract while he gets healthy but he decided to go to St. Louis to get a fresh start

The fact that he was signed *to major league minimum* should tell you the level of interest in Carp.
Yep - pretty much everyone gave up on him.