China and Oil

BlackRanger3d

New member
Feb 4, 2002
94
0
0
Your mom's back!!!
Here is some food for thought.

I was listening to a CBC radio national call in, they were talking about the war, of course.

I called had an interesting view on way the US was so gung-ho to go into Iraq.

They want to try and limit/stop China's ability to get more oil.

Iraq contains a large amount of the worlds oil (40% pops into my head but I think that is too much) and is not friendly with the US. If you look at most of the over large Oil producing (reserve) countries they are friendly with the US
- Venezuela
- Saudi Arabia
- Texas (HA)

But not Iraq (duh).

Looking at the world stage, who is the next must likely Super Power ---China. Not next week or even next year, but within our life times. As China gets closer and closer to super power status their need for oil for industry, military etc will grow exponentially.

So if the US can control / influence China’s ability to get oil then they can possibly slow China’s raise to Super Powerdom and protect the US as the biggest guy on the block.

This is of course long term planning, but just like a multinational company you have to plan for the long –term if you want you country to prosper.

Again just food for thought.

Sorry if this is a bit incoherent. I should be asleep.
 
China export oil.
US goes after Iraq to get to the heart of terrorist attacks & to avoid a more serious 9/11 in the future. Oil does not come into the picture, but is a major side benefit.
 
I was interviewed by the CBC about 2 weeks before the war started . My only comment is don't believe much of what you hear from them in terms of this type of speculative commentary . They just make up most of it and try to force you to agree with them by the questions they ask and the way they phrase them .
 
The whole idea of it being about oil is just so stupid. Hell, it it was JUST about oil, we'd leave Saddam alone, and let him sell all he wants. He doesn't have the leverage to control the price, and realistically, all the oil goes into the same 'pot'.
What difference would it make to the US if they were giving their money to the Saudis, Venezuelans, Mexicans or Iraqis in this case?
If people would just thing things through a bit, they'd at least be able to figure out why the US is NOT doing what they're doing. Figuring out why, is of course, an entirely different and more difficult matter.
 
Export of Oil:

For the ,ost part China is not a country with huge Oil reserves it actually imports a large share. Now if your arguement was that China does not import a large amount of Oil from Iraq yet that would be great since the major oil import countries for China are Iran, Saudi Arabia and Syria. But in the future they could turn to Iraq.

As for going after terrorists. No
There has been NO proof the Sadam has any connects to the Muslim extermists that attack the US. Actually Sadam and Osama hate each other. Osama thinks that Sadam is evil since he is not Religiuos and Iraq is run by a secular government (unlike Afganistan). The only "proven terrorist' dollars out of Iraq were going to the families of Palistianian Suicide Bombers. And unless those sucide bombers were about to get on a plane and come to North America. I don't think the US is worred about them.

About China as a Superpower

(Compililed with some quick and dirty Google searches)
China Nukes (tactical bombs etc)- Under 2000 - 3000
USA Nukes - about 10,000


China has the worlds largest standing army in terms of Raw man power. But their use of machines does not match that of the US yet. Their navy (http://www.navyleague.org/seapower/chinas_navy_today.htm)
is larege but not modern so is their Air Force.

So in the Future China's need for OIL for their military machine will increase, as they modernize and improve their full army to the 21st century.

You can't argue this, as more and more Chinese civilians drive China's need for OIL will go through the roof.

Don't get me wrong I am not saying that this IS the cause for the war, it is just an interesting point raised.
 
Sorry penguin_jf

Most things in the world boil down to money or the control of it.

There have been alot of reasons for the war thrown out on the table but most of them don't seem to wash

1- Stoping Terrorism
2- Liberating the People
3- Removing Sadam to stop his opression of his people
4- Removing WMD from Sadam.

1 - is very weak, as I said before there is no proof that Sadam is funding terrorism against the US.
2 - Benefits of the War Side effects.
3 - Benefits of the War Side effects.

I think that 4 is a partial goal. They could fear long term sales of WMD to terrorist organizations (see 1). But there are other ways to stop this.
I think that a reason that they are in Iraq is similar to why they are in Isreal (with so much money). They would like to have a larger presence in the Midldle east. Through Isreal, it seems, that they have a base from which to stabilize (although very tenuouly) the Middleeast. If they can install a client state in Iraq then they have a stronger base.



More food for thought.
If this is not about oil and is about WMD only, why not go after North Korea who IS moving towards WMD. And whose leader is whack enough to use them.
 
I admit, its a very interesting premise. I disagree that the US would go to war with China over Taiwan though.

Americans do not have the fortitude for a long, involved, bloody, expensive war over an island that most people only know about because "made in Taiwan" is stamped on inexpensive toys and clothing.

For that reason, we want to avoid confrontations with China, and one way to do this is to stall their development (ecomonic, strategic, political, et al) as long as possible.
 
America vs China over Taiwan

Totaly Agree. MuffinMuncher.

Another point.
Think how hard it would be for a country based around the world to send in a force strong enough to take Cuba away from America (if AMerica took Cuba).

What I am saying is that it would be very hard to take back such a small island as Taiwan, when it is sooo close to the main landmass of the aggressor.

And I really don't think Nukes would start to fall because of it.
 
I disagree

What makes the US military so impressive (other than the size, budge and technology) is the ability for the US to PROJECT power. With a broad set of bases around the world, pre positioning of material and CVGs the US is the only world power (could probably stop there) that can actually project it's power outside it's region.

Think of what a great tank barrier the English Channel was in WWII. The straits of Taiwan will provide them with the same security. What China would need is a very large Navy and the ability to protect a line of communications. The US could completely destroy these at will. China knows this, it will never happen by force.

Isn't this a Tom Clancy novel?

OTB
 
Economic Cold War...!

To add to the debate, here are some interesting comments from Jim Sinclair, noted precious metals analyst in the US:

"One thing that's glaringly clear from the second installment of the War in the Gulf is the support that Russia and China are giving to Iraq.

This support has gone much further than simple opposition within the United Nations Security Council. In fact, intelligence sources now believe that Russia has provided Iraq with technology that will jam the signals from Global Positioning Systems (GPS) that help guide smart bombs to their targets.

Since the major weapon being used in today's warfare is the smart bomb, this jamming technology has the ability to render smart bombs STUPID. Mind you, it doesn't affect the bomb's payload in any manner, it simply reduces the targeting capability of the shooter and increases the probability of errant missiles falling in civilian areas.

The only other alternative is close fire observers using laser markers, which puts the observers at risk and is not nearly as efficient or accurate as a smart bomb.

On the war front, Iraq's major population centers in the south have largely been by-passed by US and coalition forces. These cities, along with Baghdad, are supplied for six months, according to Iraqi government reports. Nonetheless, intelligence sources conclude these reports are probably unreliable, creating a scenario for enormous human suffering should the battles for Iraq's major cities be prolonged.

Some are describing the military aid given by China and Russia as the "Awe & Surprise" of the Iraq war. The thesis of this support of Iraq is the "New Cold War" which is the battle for the reconstruction of the world's major power bases.

Right now, we clearly have a "Sino-Russian-Islamic" power basis versus the "US & GB" with Europe (except France). This new cold war will be more economic than a head-to-head clash unless the US administration turns into a family dynasty and another Bush (Jed) arrives on the scene.

It's probably worth noting that the only reason we won the first Cold War was because the Soviet Union went broke before we did, a lesson they're unlikely to repeat. Also, China, with its burgeoning economy, increasingly has the economic resources to counteract US hegemony, especially if the next target of the current administration is North Korea.

Personally, I do not believe that Washington really understands what they have started by giving Russia and China this outrageous opportunity to win the hearts, minds, pocketbooks and weapons of Islam.

The best quote one can use to describe this situation was said more than two thousand years ago: "Father forgive them for they know not what they do." Replace the word "they" with Washington."

Fine Wine
 
I think

it was Russian corporations that sold Iraq the equipment, not the government. China also installed a fiber optic command and control system for the Iraqi military (not on the oil for food list obviously). Post war it will be interesting to see how much stuff France and Germany slipped through.

From an influence perspective I don't know that the US has much to loose. The Arab world hates the US because of our one sided policy towards Israel. We're not getting much business out of Iraq at the moment (pre war) so I don't know that there is much to loose economically.

OTB