Children directing air traffic

I'd rather have a sober 13 year old than a drunk 40 year old directing traffic.
I know a controller and he scares us all with stories about what goes on in the tower.
I mean truly frightening stories.
BTW, he works at Pearson.
 
Next we'll have children running city hall.....hey, wait a minute......
 
Not everyone has a job where it's appropriate to bring your kids to work. Jobs where lives hang in the balance are a good example of that.

Among all other problems, the kids merely being there were a distraction to ATC's who sometimes are called on to make split second life and death decisions.

Next you guys will be saying that Canadian soldiers in Kandahar should bring their kids out on patrol with them...

Maybe a heart surgeon could bring his kid in to do a little cutting, under strict parental
guidance of course.
 
I'd rather have a sober 13 year old than a drunk 40 year old directing traffic.
I know a controller and he scares us all with stories about what goes on in the tower.
I mean truly frightening stories.
BTW, he works at Pearson.

If your friend doesn't bring it to the attention of management, he's a fucking idiot. People could die.
 
I agree. This stunt does not look good. Too much risk.

But then again, the "I have kids"/"Awww ... cute kids" excuse/syndrome trumps all.
 
I'd start with PTSD.

You have to be kidding me. I can't believe how people are blowing this out of proportion. Assisting in surgery Danmand? The kid said you're cleared for takeoff with his Dad standing there, that's it. Was it a very bright or professonal move on the Father's part? No. Were any of the passengers at any kind of risk? Again no. I can think of dozens if not a hundred scenarios making commercial flight riskier then this presented.
 
You have to be kidding me. I can't believe how people are blowing this out of proportion. Assisting in surgery Danmand? The kid said you're cleared for takeoff with his Dad standing there, that's it. Was it a very bright or professonal move on the Father's part? No. Were any of the passengers at any kind of risk? Again no. I can think of dozens if not a hundred scenarios making commercial flight riskier then this presented.

Ok, you have convinced me. Let us have children in the control tower every day, if
it is that good and safe.
 
That says a lot about you.

LOL, I didn't mean me in particular; however, you chose to use me as the example. My point is/was that in the USA people still sue others that perform CPR or First Aid on them, so do you really believe that there wouldn't be someone or some lawyer that would start the ball rolling. Remember what I said, it only takes one, then the ball gets rolling.
 
You have to be kidding me. I can't believe how people are blowing this out of proportion. Assisting in surgery Danmand? The kid said you're cleared for takeoff with his Dad standing there, that's it. Was it a very bright or professonal move on the Father's part? No. Were any of the passengers at any kind of risk? Again no. I can think of dozens if not a hundred scenarios making commercial flight riskier then this presented.

http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/storie...LERS?SITE=MABED&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT
Asterisk, it's not being blown out of porportion here's why:
1. It is against standard policy.
2. It is a lack of professionalism
3. Glenn Duffy (the ATC) did it twice and is a 20 year veteran
4. It's negligence on the job.
5. His Supervisor is equally as guilty

NavCan (ATC shool) in Cornwall is a very expensive training ground, which many don't complete because of burn-out. Add into the high stress and burn rate of ATC's worldwide. I think it's more than poor judgement.

Each member in that particular ATC Tower was guilty of lack of professionalism for allowing unauthorized people into the tower. Period. Ok, so the Police Officer say here's my gun but don't shoot it son/daughter, and you think hell wouldn't be raised if a child or youth went onto 911 communications. This can be related to virtually every profession and job in some sort of way.

The flight deck is sealed the cockpit is sealed, no children are permitted to say hi to the pilots anymore. Just what if, the child touched something accidently and shut something down. It's called Risk Management. Bottom line, make an example of these two, and they'll twice before breaching security and policies. Children should not attend the workplace. Career day should be held at school! If there's a closed airport than turn it into a museum attraction.

As for anyone on either of those flights that would claim PTSD that's their business and we can't pass judgement on how someone feels or reacts to a situation. Passenger A could say what if we were in the air and they some kid play with the controls. Think alittle deeper than oh it's cute a couple little kids got to talk to a pilot.
 
As for anyone on either of those flights that would claim PTSD that's their business and we can't pass judgement on how someone feels or reacts to a situation. Passenger A could say what if we were in the air and they some kid play with the controls.
Why don't you go spill some hot coffee on yourself or stick your face in some piping hot KFC poutine?
 
OMG! Seriously...

Some of you guys need to lighten up just a lil bit....

why_so_serious_jazz_jalopnik.jpg


There is no story here... it just a cute "human interest" story about a guy who brought his kid to work and got him involved. All the kid was basically say "hello" to the pilot, what kid wouldn't be thrilled about that. He didn't "CLEAR" the plane... the ATC did that... he just let his kid tell the pilot.

Just my nickels worth.
 
Nobody is condoning it and claiming it should be allowed.

It's just that some of us are keeping it in perspective.

People who equate this to performing surgery, going to war, flying a plane, etc. are idiots.

Next, let all the parents bring their children to work at Norad.
 
The pilots who held all the lives on board in their hands thought it was funny while some posters on an escort review board are outraged and traumatized, calling for firings and lawsuits.

You are right, there should be much more fun and merriment in the control towers and
in the cockpits. Maybe pilots should dress in clown costumes , and the control towers should
be turned into kindergardens, with the traffic controllers doubling as nannies. I am sure that would
result in a less stressful environment for the traffic controllers.

The flying public, who cares about them, as long as the pilots and the traffic controllers have fun
and a nurturing environment.