Children directing air traffic

Bringing a kid to work is a little different than letting them do your job. Especially when you are an air traffic controller and literally hundreds of lives are hanging in the balance.
 
Goo goo Jet Blue...you are cleared for takeoff. LOL :)

Humour aside, the tapes reveal that his father was standing there telling him what to say, so no one was in danger and the pilots of the Jet Blue flight knew what was happening and joked with the father about it before starting their takeoff roll, so I think the media is blowing this out of proportion.
 
Bringing a kid to work is a little different than letting them do your job. Especially when you are an air traffic controller and literally hundreds of lives are hanging in the balance.
serious4433551.jpg
 
Humour aside, the tapes reveal that his father was standing there telling him what to say, so no one was in danger and the pilots of the Jet Blue flight knew what was happening and joked with the father about it before starting their takeoff roll, so I think the media is blowing this out of proportion.
Indeed, A huge overreaction!
 
Goo goo Jet Blue...you are cleared for takeoff. LOL :)

Humour aside, the tapes reveal that his father was standing there telling him what to say, so no one was in danger and the pilots of the Jet Blue flight knew what was happening and joked with the father about it before starting their takeoff roll, so I think the media is blowing this out of proportion.
I agree.

People who equate this to a pilot letting his kid fly a plane or a trucker letting his kid drive the truck are idiots.

This reminds me of the underage Canadian woman who had a drink after winning the gold medal.
These are things that shouldn't happen on a regular basis and they should not be shown to the media but it really isn't a big deal.


The head of liveatc.net, an air traffic control communications website that posted the tape, said the incident has been overblown.

When you listen to any of the recordings, the situation in the tower is very controlled," Dave Pascoe told CNN. "There is no hint . . . that anyone was too busy or anyone was interrupting the planes. The kid clears two airplanes. It was very controlled and I don't think safety was compromised, nor should anyone be disciplined for this."
 
Yes, I've brought my teenage children (and pre-teen) to work with me.....

I agree, it was a huge over-reaction - the pilot sounded amused.

OTB
 
The kid actually sounded pretty good. All he was doing was telling the plane they were cleared for take-off which the father obviously had confirmed. The pilots were in on it so what's the big deal? Running out of things to post Fugi?
 
Unfortunately I agree with Fuji on this particular subject.

I'm all for kids learning about what their parents do for a living; however, I'm not for kids actually attending places of work.

Reality being what it is these days, having an unauthorized person in the control, is a major breach of security. What if something dramatic actually occured and here's this little boy having to hear the panic in the room or possibly the last minutes of a flight. I know it probably won't happen, but it could. I don't think it was poor judgement; I think the ATC should be suspended, placed on probation and I wouldn't be shocked if he and the supervisor are fired just to make an example of.

Sorry, I'm a hardass. I always have been and always will be when it comes to safety in the workplace. JMO
 
Unfortunately I agree with Fuji on this particular subject.


Reality being what it is these days, having an unauthorized person in the control, is a major breach of security. What if something dramatic actually occured and here's this little boy having to hear the panic in the room or possibly the last minutes of a flight. I know it probably won't happen, but it could. I don't think it was poor judgement; I think the ATC should be suspended, placed on probation and I wouldn't be shocked if he and the supervisor are fired just to make an example of.

Me too, They both should be fired.
 
A warning would have sufficed.

The guys have already been punished more than enough.

They do not deserve to be fired.

Really, you probably wouldn't say that if you were one of the passengers on that plane. How often do members, cry about unions and unionized workers. There should be no support for this ATC or his supervisor. Fired, for negligence on duty. Wait til someone from that flight gets a lawyer involved.
 
Not everyone has a job where it's appropriate to bring your kids to work. Jobs where lives hang in the balance are a good example of that.

Among all other problems, the kids merely being there were a distraction to ATC's who sometimes are called on to make split second life and death decisions.

Next you guys will be saying that Canadian soldiers in Kandahar should bring their kids out on patrol with them...

That said "fired" is probably too severe for a first offense. If this is the first lapse in judgement these guys have had it would be more appropriate and more humane to send them home without pay for a week or two. You want to be seen as firm but fair by your employees.
 
Didn't he bring his kid the one day, then his kid's friend the next?

It just seems like really poor judgement, actual safety issues aside.
 
I am so relieved that I was not on one of those planes.

Judging by how traumatized the pilots were, I would have freaked out. :eek:

That's fine for you to make light of the incident; however, it only takes one passenger to make this a huge legal issue regarding their safety.
 
I'd start with PTSD.