Chevy HHR vs. Saturn SUV

Weekly

No specific review, but I own a piece of crap produced by Saturn. It is the most poorly built vehicle I have ever owned. Squeaks, bad fitting pieces, windows and doors don't seal properly, etc. I know people swear by them, I just swear at them. Personally, I'll never buy one of their products again. Just my 2 cents.

Homer
 
GM produces better cars than the other American manufacturers and offers reasonably good value compared to the Japanese.
 
guyroch said:
Report in the Toronto Star said there is a 40 per cent chance GM will go bankrupt in the next 2 years, I'm hoping it's true !!!
Interesting thought. The way I would like it to happen is that they go bankrupt and then some American investors buy it up and start fresh. A good way to unload your debts.

If they get bought up by Toyota or VW then it's goodbye US car industry.
 
Weekly said:
GM produces better cars than the other American manufacturers and offers reasonably good value compared to the Japanese.

it's too bad the american producers of cars, are lagging behind in sales to the japanese, maybe it's because quality is a big factor?...i mean that's just a guess ;)

there's a reason why US cars only have 25% of the market, whereas the imports have the majority of it.
notice the style/designs of american cars now? a lot like the imports aren't they?
americans know shit and build shit...my grandmother went through 3 corolla's in her lifetime and the ONLY thing she took it in for were oil changes.

buddy of mine a mechanic (and a damn good one) even said, ya you pay a little more for the imports, BUT, the price more than makes up for the garage/parts/labour fees you'd have to pay if you had an american car and had to repair it.

as much as i dont like supporting outside north america, bottom line for me is, my own wallet first
 
On what planet...

guyroch said:
When I see people driving around in their Escalades, I just laugh at them, they could be driving a Porsche Cayenne for the same money. Porsche or Cadillac, which would you drive ?

...would this be?

I cross shopped both, liked the Porsche ALOT, could not afford it.

No, I didn't buy the Escalade either - I didn't like that it was so expensive for such an clearly aged design. But I might would have considered the upcoming brand new model...

I'm not saying I am a fan of GM (I am not), I am saying that Cayennes and Escalades don't leave the dealers lot for the same amount of coin...
 
Ummm...

CuteCob said:
americans know shit and build shit...

...aren't virtually ALL the domestic models built in Canada now?

And...while we are on the topic...aren't most of the major Japanese models built in either the U.S. or Canada as well?

Again, not that I am a defender of GM...I haven't own a GM car in MANY years...and I personally do tend to favor the "not so" imported brands. I guess i just took a bit of offense to the "Americans buld shit" remark...given that it was more than likely Americans or Canadians who built your moms beloved Corollas (which I agree...are tanks)
 
The problem with North American car makers is management is not lean enough. Too many layers of people, nobody can make a decision resulting in confusion.

They are trying to cut costs by squeezing suppliers to death, thereby suppliers cutting corners resulting in poor quality parts.
 
Buyers don't necessarily buy GM for its looks. Japanese cars hold their value better but they cost more reducing the benefit.
 
guyroch said:
They are both GM products so you know they are both a piece of shit !! I still don't understand why people buy GM crap, they are at least 10 years behind every other car maker. You're better off buying a Hyundai, much better vehicles than GM. GM does have a few half decent cars but guess who makes them !!! Daewoo !! Report in the Toronto Star said there is a 40 per cent chance GM will go bankrupt in the next 2 years, I'm hoping it's true !!!

Puuuuulease!

"The Toronto Star said there is a 40% chance GM will go bankrupt in the next two years? LOL! Don't count on it dude!"

GM produced an estimated 6,718,000 units during that period, and sold 7,066,774 vehicles, up 3.7 percent from the same period last year.

For all of 2005, GM has forecast global production of 9,115,000 vehicles.

One word for ya!

CORVETTE!;)
 
Believe it or not the Escalade is a big status symbol in the US. It has been glorified by Rappers, Celebrities etc...

If you are on a lease who cares how the car is built. You are going to give it back after 3 or 4 years anyway. With the Escalade you might be a chick magnet.
 
Meister said:
Believe it or not the Escalade is a big status symbol in the US. It has been glorified by Rappers, Celebrities etc...

If you are on a lease who cares how the car is built. You are going to give it back after 3 or 4 years anyway. With the Escalade you might be a chick magnet.

My buddies Dad just purchased an Escalade and this thing is sweet! ;)

With 400 hp 6.0L LS2 V8!!!!

What power for a luxury car!
 
yeah, right

Weekly said:
GM produces better cars than the other American manufacturers and offers reasonably good value compared to the Japanese.

Who do you work for?

I have owned three Fords and four GM vehicles in the 26 years that I have been driving. Guess what! None of the Fords ever gave me the grief and misery and extreme service expenses that the GM vehicles gave me.

i am sure that there are a mutitude of other TERBites who woll beg to differ with you, each with their own non-GM preferences.
 
What????

guyroch said:
Other car manufactures can get almost 400 hp from an engine half that size !! 400 HP from a 6 litre engine is NOT impressive !!!

Name some....hell, name ONE...
 
Who cares about the horsepower. It's not like you are going to race a Mustang on the 401. Just accept the fact that you can only go 130km/h. The reason people buy Porsche is so they can crawl past Sassafraz on a Saturday night.

You guys ought to check out one of the last pieces of freedom on earth:
Autobahn
 
Here's some observations I've made based on racing, fixing and buying cars for the past 15 years.

1. People to not buy transportation, they buy an image.

If people were practical about what they actually drove, the number of SUV's on the road would go down by 75%. A minivan performs better in all areas than an SUV. Cheaper to purchase, better fuel economy, lower insurance, better space usage, lower centre of gravity, etc. The list goes on, but who wants to be seen in a minivan?

2. As a result, dependability of a vehicle ranks lower when it comes to buying compared to when discussing it.

The best selling vehicles are not always the most dependable. The most desirable vehicles definately are not the most dependable. 4Wd vehicles are harder to work on because there is a drive axle below the engine, making engine maintenance tougher.

3. You cannot paint broad strokes saying import cars are better than domestic cars.

You are crazy if you think Mercedes Benz, BMW, Volkswagon, Mitsubishi, Kia and Subaru are more dependable than domestics. Pick up any Consumer Reports or JD power survey and you'll see.

From my personal experience, Mazda is questionable. My uncle is on his second engine after only 125,000 kms. His aluminum rims were out of balance from being bent because they weren't beefy enough. Mazda was on a kick for a while trying yo make everything as light as possible.

As well, I find when people do have something go wrong with their Toyota or Honda, it seems they go into a state of denial. They say things like. "This shouldn't happen, it's a Toyota, or it must be a freak accident." and they discount these problems as being isolated incidents.

4. GM will not go under. Too many people employed by them. The U.S. Government will step in just like they did with Chrysler. And whoever mentioned Volkswagon doesn't know how bad thier financial situation is. They produce some of the lowest quality cars sold in North America and are on the verge of bankruptcy themselves because they are spending money on cars like the Phaeton and Bentley.

Back to the original question.

In my opinion, people who buy Saturns are wierd socialists who only buy a car because they have to. I also have a good friend who was a Saturn mechanic, and the only Saturn he said he wouldn't buy was the Vue, so if that's the SUV you are considering, I'd look elsewhere.
 
guyroch said:
How much did he pay for it ??? Other car manufactures can get almost 400 hp from an engine half that size !! 400 HP from a 6 litre engine is NOT impressive !!!

I don't know how much he paid for it but it's a beautiful car nonetheless! :)
 
Ummm...

guyroch said:
The Porsche Cayenne 4.5 litre has 450 hp. I know this car is beyond everyones budget bet the SLR has 617 hp from 5.5 Litres.

..The Cayenne you are refering to is also tubrocharged. Turbo the Vette engine in the Escalade and you'd get more than 450 horsepower as well...

Next?
 
Well...

guyroch said:
Mercedes also had a C32. Over 350 HP from a 3.2 litre V6 !!! What people forget about the Escalade is, that it's a GMC Yukon with cheesey Cadillac badges all over the place. You can buy a Yukon and save big bucks and when the badges come off you're driving the same thing as an Escalade. GM just found a way to charge big bucks by sticking Cadillac badges on a regular truck. People are so easily fooled !!!

What does GM have coming out ?? Anything to look forward to ? Maybe the Pontiac Solstice, but most reviews have not been good. The Solstice is a car to compete against the Miata, one reviewer said GM had 15 years to come up with a car to go up against the Miata, and this is what they came up with ??? It's a good looking car but that's about it.

2006 C55 AMG
AMG-built 5.5L 24-valve 90-degree V-8 engine - 362 hp @ 5,750 rpm

Hmmm...seems about equal...


C32 AMG
Powered by a new 349-hp, 3.2-liter supercharged and intercooled V6 Kompressor engine,

Supercharged....hmmm....I am pretty sure if you supercharged the Vette engine in the Escalade you'd get something on the order of 550+ hp.

66 horsepower per litre from a NORMAL ASPARITED ENGINE is very good. You aren't going to find an engine in anything other than an exotic that will provide significantly better horsepower AND tourque numbers (and the tourque number is important...because yes, there are little four bangers that produce lots of horsepower, you'd never stick them in a 5000 lbs truck).
 
I drive.....

2004 Dodge Ram 2500 QuadCab 4X4
5.7 Litre HEMI....
Gibson DualSport exhaust...
AiRaid Cold Air intake.....
HyperTech Power programmer....

420HP.......and 6500lbs.......


hehe.....:D