Here's some observations I've made based on racing, fixing and buying cars for the past 15 years.
1. People to not buy transportation, they buy an image.
If people were practical about what they actually drove, the number of SUV's on the road would go down by 75%. A minivan performs better in all areas than an SUV. Cheaper to purchase, better fuel economy, lower insurance, better space usage, lower centre of gravity, etc. The list goes on, but who wants to be seen in a minivan?
2. As a result, dependability of a vehicle ranks lower when it comes to buying compared to when discussing it.
The best selling vehicles are not always the most dependable. The most desirable vehicles definately are not the most dependable. 4Wd vehicles are harder to work on because there is a drive axle below the engine, making engine maintenance tougher.
3. You cannot paint broad strokes saying import cars are better than domestic cars.
You are crazy if you think Mercedes Benz, BMW, Volkswagon, Mitsubishi, Kia and Subaru are more dependable than domestics. Pick up any Consumer Reports or JD power survey and you'll see.
From my personal experience, Mazda is questionable. My uncle is on his second engine after only 125,000 kms. His aluminum rims were out of balance from being bent because they weren't beefy enough. Mazda was on a kick for a while trying yo make everything as light as possible.
As well, I find when people do have something go wrong with their Toyota or Honda, it seems they go into a state of denial. They say things like. "This shouldn't happen, it's a Toyota, or it must be a freak accident." and they discount these problems as being isolated incidents.
4. GM will not go under. Too many people employed by them. The U.S. Government will step in just like they did with Chrysler. And whoever mentioned Volkswagon doesn't know how bad thier financial situation is. They produce some of the lowest quality cars sold in North America and are on the verge of bankruptcy themselves because they are spending money on cars like the Phaeton and Bentley.
Back to the original question.
In my opinion, people who buy Saturns are wierd socialists who only buy a car because they have to. I also have a good friend who was a Saturn mechanic, and the only Saturn he said he wouldn't buy was the Vue, so if that's the SUV you are considering, I'd look elsewhere.