Changes in border crossing rules starting in 2008

papasmerf said:
Get real. Did you know that Canada refuses entry to Americans with a DWI conviction????? Did you knowthat America does not do the same to Canadians with DWI's? Did you know that Canadian Citizens living in Canada are allowed to work in the US??? can you say the same?
Ya i know all that.
 
JoyfulC said:
It still seems to me like the US is taking the "Frank Burns & HotLips" approach to national security.

Good luck with it! :p

..c..

Na

We just want to sell passports
 
Big F'n Deal

I'm with homonger here - What is the big deal? It's not like it's so cumbersome to carry. I instinctively always bring my passport everytime I travel to a different country, even to the US. Why? Because it gives the least hassle. When they ask for ID at the border, the passport gets me throught immediately, with the least hassle. So why wouldn't I use the document at my disposal that gives me the most ease?

Fingerprinting and all that nonsense is one thing. Requiring a passport? Big deal. If it forces some people to get a passport then that is a good thing. Maybe they will be more tempted to do some traveling and see/learn a bit more of the world.
 
That's fine for you, but not everyone is like that.

A number of years back, a friend of mine (a client I've known since my high school days) picked me up in Windsor and brought me over the border.

I'd crossed the border hundreds of times and wasn't really concerned about it. My friend, however, very rarely crossed the border and was quite intimidated by the whole process.

We waited in line, and as the car ahead of us pulled up to the wicket, my friend nervously jolted forward -- busting the arm off the gate. It didn't look good at all!

So our turn finally comes and we are talking to the guy in the little house -- my friend is so nervous, he's sweating bullets. No reason for this -- he's been a law-abiding American citizen all his life, a former pro athlete. But for sure, he's got the jitters.

The border guard decides he wants to look in the trunk, and steps out of his little house. At that same time, my nervous friend (who already broke the gate!) opens his car door and nearly knocks the US border guard over.

The guard has him open the trunk -- I have a couple of bags in there (one pink and another floral printed). I am asked if these are my bags -- and I assert that they are. My friend has a black gym bag in his trunk, and the guard makes him take this out, open it up and reveal its contents.

Obviously, he had nothing threatening in there (he is such an all-American good boy!), but he got all the attention, just because he was nervous. But he definitely got put through the paces. I'm not sure that border guards are much more sophisticated these days.

My friend is the kind of person I lament not coming over the border in the future, due to the new rules. Sure, I appreciate that there are seasoned travelers who carry their passports everywhere -- whether they need to or not -- but Canada has known a lot of bread & butter (and also US border towns have known a lot of bread & butter) business from people who maybe aren't such sophisticated international travelers. I don't see how this new standard will prevent terrorism (compared to the option of reigning in obnoxious foreign policies) and I don't see how it will promote casual cross-border business.

I feel that it is a way of punishing Canada for failing to be subservient to Bush's demands.

..c..
 
So we have to pay admission to go to the US? Does it at least include a free pass to Epcott Center?
 
JoyfulC said:
That's fine for you, but not everyone is like that.

A number of years back, a friend of mine (a client I've known since my high school days) picked me up in Windsor and brought me over the border.

I'd crossed the border hundreds of times and wasn't really concerned about it. My friend, however, very rarely crossed the border and was quite intimidated by the whole process.

We waited in line, and as the car ahead of us pulled up to the wicket, my friend nervously jolted forward -- busting the arm off the gate. It didn't look good at all!

So our turn finally comes and we are talking to the guy in the little house -- my friend is so nervous, he's sweating bullets. No reason for this -- he's been a law-abiding American citizen all his life, a former pro athlete. But for sure, he's got the jitters.

The border guard decides he wants to look in the trunk, and steps out of his little house. At that same time, my nervous friend (who already broke the gate!) opens his car door and nearly knocks the US border guard over.

The guard has him open the trunk -- I have a couple of bags in there (one pink and another floral printed). I am asked if these are my bags -- and I assert that they are. My friend has a black gym bag in his trunk, and the guard makes him take this out, open it up and reveal its contents.

Obviously, he had nothing threatening in there (he is such an all-American good boy!), but he got all the attention, just because he was nervous. But he definitely got put through the paces. I'm not sure that border guards are much more sophisticated these days.

My friend is the kind of person I lament not coming over the border in the future, due to the new rules. Sure, I appreciate that there are seasoned travelers who carry their passports everywhere -- whether they need to or not -- but Canada has known a lot of bread & butter (and also US border towns have known a lot of bread & butter) business from people who maybe aren't such sophisticated international travelers. I don't see how this new standard will prevent terrorism (compared to the option of reigning in obnoxious foreign policies) and I don't see how it will promote casual cross-border business.

I feel that it is a way of punishing Canada for failing to be subservient to Bush's demands.

..c..

If your friend freaks out that much then he's best off staying put where he is. Some people I know don't feel comfortable with air travel. So they don't do it. It's their issue. The security checks aren't going to change because some people don't feel comfortable with it. Anyone that freaks out like your friend in moments of question are going to attract attention. I don't see how the passport thing will make it any different. Some people just weren't cut out for certain situations.

If this is Bush's way of 'punishing' Canada then gosh gee Bush sure is a mild mannered guy... making people (including Americans, not just Canadians) show a photo ID. If that is the best the USA can do then I don't know what the world is worried about. Man that's rough. :rolleyes:
 
papasmerf said:
Get real. Did you know that Canada refuses entry to Americans with a DWI conviction????? Did you knowthat America does not do the same to Canadians with DWI's? Did you know that Canadian Citizens living in Canada are allowed to work in the US??? can you say the same?
In Canada under our Ciminal Code DWI is a criminal offence. So, if what you say is true, we're refusing entry to convicted criminals. In the US, each of the fifty states has its own criminal laws, and at least some don't make DWI a criminal offence. That's howcum, the Premier of BC still has his job after what would have been a criminal conviction here. Lucky for him he was in Hawaii.

When I cross to the US, I'm always nervous because the legal advice I paid for is that my criminal conviction for blowing over 80 here, will bar me from the US if Immigration becomes aware of it. Even a pardon, which makes that record inaccessible, does not remove my obligation to answer "Yes", if they ask if I have ever had a criminal conviction. That BC guy can truthfully answer, "No", even though he had a major accident and blew way over 100.

As for working across the border, when I've crossed the rush hour traffic on the Ambassador bridge has been heavy in both directions; it can't all be canucks, some choosing to live in Detroit and work here while equal numbers go the other way. Of course, what was true about open borders very recently is no longer true today. That's what this whole threads about: closing up the border. Th SCs in the Falls must be excreting bulding materials.
 
Even though we have been doing extensive trade with canada, there is no agreement in place that justifies an open border, technically.

Canada's very liberal(when compared with the USA) immigration policies makes people in the USA very nervous. Once you add a possible liberalisation of drug laws here in canada, it should make it easy to understand why the USA wants to know, on who is coming in and out of the country. Well, that's the theory anyway.
The reality is, that the border is soo long, that anybody who wants too, can go in and out of the USA anytime they want.

i was hoping very much that GWB would pursue his vision of a panamerican free trading zone, much like the European model.
Unfortunately 9-11 happened. I believe it will take a president that is less attached to 9-11 to push this type of change.

As for the passports..hhhmm..a minor inconvinience at best.Those people that have to, will get one or have one already.
BTW they still do spot checks in Europe, and yes almost everybody owns a common passort.
 
langeweile said:
Unfortunately 9-11 happened.

Yes, and those terrorists had...you guessed it, passports.

I don't really have a strong opinion about this either way. My biggest beef about it is coughing up the $ to our creaking bureaucracy to pay for it. But I can't help but think it's closing the barn door after the horses have been gone for oh, 3 1/2 yrs.
 
Once again, I repeat, what is the freaking big deal about getting a passport? It is a unchallengable piece of personal identification, and it allows you to travel out of your country whenever you want.

I admit, I am no fan of GWB, but it is clear that 9-11 and its aftermath, for better or worse, has shaped his presidency and its legacy. Tell you what, you Canadian whiners... when terrorists fly planes into your largest buildings in your largest city and kill thousands, then you can dictate U.S./Canadian border policy however the hell you want. Until then, deal with it.
 
Oh, c'mon homonger, relax...no one's attacking the U.S. here. If you think Canadians didn't sympathize over 9/11, you're really mistaken.

I can't speak for anyone else, but I don't think passports for Canadians entering the U.S. are going to prevent any terror attacks. If anything, wouldn't it overload the personnel at border checkpoints, thereby making checks more cursory?

There are so many fake passports out there that someone who wants to get into the U.S. will be able to, not to mention the fact that they could also slip in via the coast, Mexico, or Canada without a passport. I think this is more about making it look like Bush is doing something than about preventing terror.

I also think it's possible that the real aim of 9/11 was not so much to destroy the WTC/Pentagon as to force Americans (and the rest of the West) to see what it's like to live under the shadow of fear, mistrust and isolation.
 
Bobzilla said:
Oh, c'mon homonger, relax...no one's attacking the U.S. here. If you think Canadians didn't sympathize over 9/11, you're really mistaken.

I can't speak for anyone else, but I don't think passports for Canadians entering the U.S. are going to prevent any terror attacks. If anything, wouldn't it overload the personnel at border checkpoints, thereby making checks more cursory?

I don't think this new passport policy will do anything to deter terrorism either, but my point was, 9-11 was a real traumatic experience for the U.S. and GWB. Like I said, I don't care much for GWB or his policies, but I do believe everything he has done since, has been shaped by that day. I'm not saying Canadians or anyone else in the world for that matter, aren't sympathetic. But I just don't think it is completely fair to judge unless you have experienced something like that.

Bobzilla said:
I also think it's possible that the real aim of 9/11 was not so much to destroy the WTC/Pentagon as to force Americans (and the rest of the West) to see what it's like to live under the shadow of fear, mistrust and isolation.

Interesting point. Well, if that's the case, then clearly they've succeeded.
 
homonger said:
I don't think this new passport policy will do anything to deter terrorism either, but my point was, 9-11 was a real traumatic experience for the U.S. and GWB. Like I said, I don't care much for GWB or his policies, but I do believe everything he has done since, has been shaped by that day. I'm not saying Canadians or anyone else in the world for that matter, aren't sympathetic. But I just don't think it is completely fair to judge unless you have experienced something like that.



Interesting point. Well, if that's the case, then clearly they've succeeded.

No question GWB's presidency has been influenced more by 9/11 than anything else.

I would take issue with your point about it fair for anyone to judge unless they've experienced that. I experienced 9/11 like most other people, via TV. I don't think the horror I felt watching the WTC crumble could have been worse had it been say, the CN Tower instead.

And the more I think about it, the more the final point makes sense. Why go through the logistics & expense of planning a terror attack when the threat of one accomplishes the same thing? And why haven't there been further terror attacks on the U.S. homeland since?

In a small way, I feel for GWB. Do nothing & you'll be vilified. Insist on any foreign national to carry a passport on entering the U.S. (& I agree, a passport is not an unreasonable demand to make), & you get ragged on for possibly alienating a long-time ally. It's a no-win situation.
 
Bobzilla said:
I would take issue with your point about it fair for anyone to judge unless they've experienced that. I experienced 9/11 like most other people, via TV. I don't think the horror I felt watching the WTC crumble could have been worse had it been say, the CN Tower instead.

I'm sure you are a decent, good hearted fellow, bobzilla. And I don't mean to overstate my point--I wasn't in NYC at the time, nor do I know anyone personally who perished that day. But I'm from NYC, and I still have family there. So, I respectfully disagree. It's not the same.
 
You're right!

booboobear said:
I believe in security but I don't think requiring a passport will stop terrorist.
What it will do is inconvenience millions of innocent tourists. ...
I recently flown thru two prime terrorist targeted airports for U.S. and U.K. interest (not by choice). Were on 4 different flights, passed 5 seperate X-ray screener, on the U.S. airline that's been pegged as target (U.S. airline's extra precaution was random bag search and extra X-ray screener at gate). I did get pulled aside for random bag search but screener changed his mind as I didn't stumble from his repeated questions asked in different order.

To my surprise, when I got home to find in my carry-on bag, a set of disposable razor from the hotel toilery kit. I was rushed one day and threw it into my toilery bag by mistake and kept it with me for all those flights.

I know I don't fit profile of Terrorist for being slack with screening but doesn't mean I'm not an Extremist. Like Tim McFate, Radicals that exist in most countries, whether France, UK, Japan, Spain, Germany,...

I'm sure reporting the it won't do much, perhap get few screeners working those shifts fired, but won't do dick all if U.S. don't bother to go after Osama.

As fate has it, I was in NYC one week before 9/11 booked Mariott World Trade that no longer exist. I commented that the old security guards at lobby of World Trade would not be able to handle crisis. You would think after the '91 attack, they would wise up. I watch for these things as I hang out with Emerg Prep personnel. There was this tourist lying on the ground of the WTC square to take a perspective photo of the twin tower. I told my friend that they should do the same. And my friend replied with it will be here next time we come back.

Another example, I flew out of O'hara one week before the Shoe bomber after 9/11. I didn't have time to change my steel plated shoes and it set off the metal detector. I offered to to take off the shoes for inspection. But the Screener laughed, "who would hide anything in their shoes." I was so tempted to tell them, easily a small knife or razor.

My point, this is all political window dressing. To give American voters a false sense of security and not addressing the problem. Using fear to stay in white house while keeping the Bin Laden biz $ flowing.
 
I tend to agree that this is another little way of punishing Canada for some of the Liberals little punishments to the US. It is unfortunate that relations between Canada and the US are not better, I would rather see Canada agree to common border policies with the states, and consequently be able to have open borders between us.
 
The reall pisser in this deal is that EACH individual must his/her own docs. So if you have kids under 18, they can no longer just ride along listed within your passport. Sux..... Cash cow is what it is.... It does little for security. Heck, the 1000 Islands brige has xray scanners on the US as you go through... What more do you need??? :)

my plug nickels worth!
 
I'll believe it when I see it. All the American border states will be screaming bloody murder when the tourism tap gets shut off due to Canadians not having their passports...
 
seymorehofmee said:
The reall pisser in this deal is that EACH individual must his/her own docs. So if you have kids under 18, they can no longer just ride along listed within your passport. Sux..... Cash cow is what it is.... It does little for security. Heck, the 1000 Islands brige has xray scanners on the US as you go through... What more do you need??? :)
my plug nickels worth!

Agreed. This is nothing more than a cash cow to keep US business in the US for those that have been exploiting Canadian borders for years.