Challenge to BOT

TOVisitor

New member
Jul 14, 2003
3,305
0
0
You have called the current US Congress the "do-nothing" Congress.

Please tell us why -- in detail -- why this is a do-nothing Congress.

For starters, you can read the below, and then try to refute their points. If you cannot, then STFU.

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/26/opinion/26mann.html

August 26, 2007

Op-Chart: A New, Improved Congress?
By THOMAS E. MANN, MOLLY REYNOLDS, and PETER HOEY


JUST before Congress adjourned for its August recess, Democrats engaged in a flurry of legislative activity, while Republicans complained about a “do-nothing” Congress’s meager policy accomplishments. Deep partisan differences, narrow majorities and a Republican in the White House have frustrated Democratic ambitions and fueled a toxic atmosphere in both chambers of Congress. The public’s low approval ratings reflect broad discontent with the direction of the country but also displeasure with Congress for failing to reverse course on Iraq and for continuing the bitter partisan warfare.

But has this really been a do-nothing Congress? The circumstances are similar to those in 1995, when a new Republican majority in both houses took office under a Democratic president. So perhaps the best question to ask is, how is this 110th Congress doing compared with the 104th Congress, in 1995?

Both new majorities began by spending more time in session, holding more committee meetings and roll call votes, and passing more substantive measures than the Congress before them had. At the same time, in both cases, the number of bills signed into law by the president from January to August dropped.

Still, the Democratic Congress’s legislative harvest this year has been bountiful compared with that of its Republican counterpart in 1995. Back then, the Republicans’ Contract With America was stymied by opposition from the Senate and the president. The new Congress has enacted a far-reaching lobbying and ethics reform bill, an increase in the minimum wage, recommendations of the 9/11 Commission, foreign investment rules and a competitiveness package, and has embedded a number of major initiatives and new priorities in continuing and supplemental spending bills. Democrats also made headway on energy, children’s health insurance, college student loans, Head Start, drug safety and a farm bill — though much of this awaits action in the Senate or in conference and faces a possible veto.

During the first seven months of 1995, Congressional oversight of the executive branch increased modestly in the Senate but not at all in the House. But this year Congress, especially the House, has intensified its oversight, following years of inattention and deference by its Republican predecessor.

Democratic promises to restore civility and regular parliamentary procedure by allowing the minority party a larger role in deliberations have foundered. The number of restrictive rules for debate has increased, and the conference process has been short-circuited on various occasions.

In the Senate, Republicans have made the filibuster, or the threat of filibuster, routine, setting a 60-vote hurdle for all contested legislative matters. This has led Harry Reid of Nevada, the majority leader, to file many more petitions for cloture than Bob Dole, his counterpart in 1995, did.

The chart below shows what the 110th Congress accomplished before it closed for its August recess, compared with its immediate predecessor and with the Republican Congress that took office in 1995.

Thomas E. Mann is a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and the co-author of “The Broken Branch.” Molly Reynolds is a research assistant at Brookings. Peter Hoey is an illustrator in Arcata, Calif.

Please also have a look at the accompanying graphic to the story, and tell us why the current Congress is worse than those in the comparison.
 
Is only BOT allowed to answer?

I say the Democrat majority Congress is a do nothing Congress because the Dems recessed for the summer instead of fighting against the war that they were elected to stop.

Don't give me the filibuster excuse. If the Dems held a vote every day in August (and September and October ... if necessary), they would eventually get the votes needed.

The troops don't get the summer off.

Just for good measure, the Congress also apporved S. 1927 the "Protect America Act" before heading out on vacation.

From: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protect_America_Act_of_2007
Protect America Act of 2007
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

A bill to amend the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978 to provide additional procedures for authorizing certain acquisitions of foreign intelligence information and for other purposes also known as the Protect America Act of 2007 (Pub.L. 110-55, S. 1927) was enacted by the 110th United States Congress and signed into law by George W. Bush on 2007-08-05.

It allows for wiretapping and modifies the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act.

Legislative history
Senator Mitch McConnell introduced it on 2007-08-01

8/1/2007: Introduced in Senate
8/3/2007: Passed/agreed to in Senate: Passed Senate with an amendment by Yea-Nay Vote. 60 - 28. Record Vote Number: 309.
8/4/2007: Passed/agreed to in House: On passage Passed by the Yeas and Nays: 227 - 183 (Roll no. 836).
8/5/2007:Signed by President.
8/5/2007 Became Public Law No: 110-055

Amendments
S.AMDT 2649 provides a sunset provision. The sunset provision was passed due to concerns of many members of Congress about the long-term effects of the legislation. Some scholars believe that any future extension of the act will be less expansive than the current time-limited version.

Provisions
On July 28, 2007, President Bush called on Congress to pass legislation to reform the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) in order to ease restrictions on secret surveillance of terrorist suspects. The original FISA bill was passed in 1978, with Bush calling it "badly out of date." He asked that Congress pass the legislation before its August 2007 recess, stating that “Every day that Congress puts off these reforms increases the danger to our nation. Our intelligence community warns that under the current statute, we are missing a significant amount of foreign intelligence that we should be collecting to protect our country.”

On August 3, 2007, the Senate passed a Republican-sponsored version of FISA (S. 1927) in a vote of 60 to 28. The House followed by passing the bill, 227-183. The bill altered the original 1978 law in many ways, including:

Warrant and notification requirements
The bill amended FISA to substitute the requirement of a warrant to conduct surveillance with a system of NSA (National Security Agency) internal controls.

The bill required notification to the FISA Court of warrantless surveillance within 72 hours of any authorization. The bill also required that "a sealed copy of the certification" be sent which would "remain sealed unless the certification is needed to determine the legality of the acquisition."

Domestic wiretapping
The bill allowed the monitoring of electronic communications between people on U.S. soil, including U.S. citizens, and people "reasonably believed to be outside the United States," without a court's order or oversight.

Foreign wiretapping
The bill clarified confusion in current law by allowing the National Security Agency to collect purely foreign communications in the future without a warrant.

Data monitoring
In the bill, the monitoring of data related to Americans communicating with foreigners who are the targets of a U.S. terrorism investigation was addressed. This data could be monitored only if intelligence officials have a reasonable expectation of learning information relevant to that probe.

Authorization power
Under the bill, the director of national intelligence and the attorney general could authorize the surveillance of all communications involving foreign targets. The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, composed of federal judges whose deliberations are secret, could only examine whether the government's guidelines for targeting overseas suspects are appropriate.

The guidelines for authorizing surveillance were:

There was reason to believe that the target of the acquisition was outside the U.S. and that the procedures used would be subject to the review of the court (FISA Court).
That the acquisition involved obtaining the foreign intelligence with the assistance of a telecommunications service provider or other persons who would have access to communications, either as they were transmitted or while they were stored, or access to equipment being used to transmit or store the communications.
That the significant purpose of the procedure would be to acquire foreign intelligence information.
The certification of the determination (sent to the Court) would be written, signed under oath and supported by affidavit of security officials appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate, or the head of any intelligence community agency.

If the determination required immediate action and time would not permit preparing a certification, the certification supporting the determination would be submitted in writing to the Court no more than 72 hours after it was made. The AG would transmit as soon as possible to the Court a sealed copy of the certification that would remain sealed unless the certification was needed to determine the legality of the acquisition.

Reporting requirements
The Attorney General would report to Congress semi-annually with:

A description of any incidents of non-compliance with a directive issued.
Incidents of non-compliance with the guidelines or procedures established for determining that the acquisition concerns persons outside the United States by any entity of the Intelligence Community.
Incidents of noncompliance by a specified person to whom the Attorney General and Director of National Intelligence issued a directive.
The number of certifications and directives issued in the preceding 6 months.
 
markvee said:
Is only BOT allowed to answer?

I say the Democrat majority Congress is a do nothing Congress because the Dems recessed for the summer instead of fighting against the war that they were elected to stop.

Don't give me the filibuster excuse. If the Dems held a vote every day in August (and September and October ... if necessary), they would eventually get the votes needed.

The troops don't get the summer off.

Just for good measure, the Congress also apporved S. 1927 the "Protect America Act" before heading out on vacation.

From: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protect_America_Act_of_2007
Protect America Act of 2007
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

A bill to amend the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978 to provide additional procedures for authorizing certain acquisitions of foreign intelligence information and for other purposes also known as the Protect America Act of 2007 (Pub.L. 110-55, S. 1927) was enacted by the 110th United States Congress and signed into law by George W. Bush on 2007-08-05.

It allows for wiretapping and modifies the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act.

Legislative history
Senator Mitch McConnell introduced it on 2007-08-01

8/1/2007: Introduced in Senate
8/3/2007: Passed/agreed to in Senate: Passed Senate with an amendment by Yea-Nay Vote. 60 - 28. Record Vote Number: 309.
8/4/2007: Passed/agreed to in House: On passage Passed by the Yeas and Nays: 227 - 183 (Roll no. 836).
8/5/2007:Signed by President.
8/5/2007 Became Public Law No: 110-055

Amendments
S.AMDT 2649 provides a sunset provision. The sunset provision was passed due to concerns of many members of Congress about the long-term effects of the legislation. Some scholars believe that any future extension of the act will be less expansive than the current time-limited version.

Provisions
On July 28, 2007, President Bush called on Congress to pass legislation to reform the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) in order to ease restrictions on secret surveillance of terrorist suspects. The original FISA bill was passed in 1978, with Bush calling it "badly out of date." He asked that Congress pass the legislation before its August 2007 recess, stating that “Every day that Congress puts off these reforms increases the danger to our nation. Our intelligence community warns that under the current statute, we are missing a significant amount of foreign intelligence that we should be collecting to protect our country.”

On August 3, 2007, the Senate passed a Republican-sponsored version of FISA (S. 1927) in a vote of 60 to 28. The House followed by passing the bill, 227-183. The bill altered the original 1978 law in many ways, including:

Warrant and notification requirements
The bill amended FISA to substitute the requirement of a warrant to conduct surveillance with a system of NSA (National Security Agency) internal controls.

The bill required notification to the FISA Court of warrantless surveillance within 72 hours of any authorization. The bill also required that "a sealed copy of the certification" be sent which would "remain sealed unless the certification is needed to determine the legality of the acquisition."

Domestic wiretapping
The bill allowed the monitoring of electronic communications between people on U.S. soil, including U.S. citizens, and people "reasonably believed to be outside the United States," without a court's order or oversight.

Foreign wiretapping
The bill clarified confusion in current law by allowing the National Security Agency to collect purely foreign communications in the future without a warrant.

Data monitoring
In the bill, the monitoring of data related to Americans communicating with foreigners who are the targets of a U.S. terrorism investigation was addressed. This data could be monitored only if intelligence officials have a reasonable expectation of learning information relevant to that probe.

Authorization power
Under the bill, the director of national intelligence and the attorney general could authorize the surveillance of all communications involving foreign targets. The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, composed of federal judges whose deliberations are secret, could only examine whether the government's guidelines for targeting overseas suspects are appropriate.

The guidelines for authorizing surveillance were:

There was reason to believe that the target of the acquisition was outside the U.S. and that the procedures used would be subject to the review of the court (FISA Court).
That the acquisition involved obtaining the foreign intelligence with the assistance of a telecommunications service provider or other persons who would have access to communications, either as they were transmitted or while they were stored, or access to equipment being used to transmit or store the communications.
That the significant purpose of the procedure would be to acquire foreign intelligence information.
The certification of the determination (sent to the Court) would be written, signed under oath and supported by affidavit of security officials appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate, or the head of any intelligence community agency.

If the determination required immediate action and time would not permit preparing a certification, the certification supporting the determination would be submitted in writing to the Court no more than 72 hours after it was made. The AG would transmit as soon as possible to the Court a sealed copy of the certification that would remain sealed unless the certification was needed to determine the legality of the acquisition.

Reporting requirements
The Attorney General would report to Congress semi-annually with:

A description of any incidents of non-compliance with a directive issued.
Incidents of non-compliance with the guidelines or procedures established for determining that the acquisition concerns persons outside the United States by any entity of the Intelligence Community.
Incidents of noncompliance by a specified person to whom the Attorney General and Director of National Intelligence issued a directive.
The number of certifications and directives issued in the preceding 6 months.

Amen to that..I think it's time for TOV to STFU...
 
I'll see your copy/Paste:

Congress/Democrats Get Failing Grade
By Ken Taylor Posted in Congress — Comments (2) / Email this page » / Leave a comment »

We are nearing the end of yet another session of the Democrat Majority Congress that made its debut in January of this year. At the end of this week the Congress will shut its doors and take the month of August off returning to Capitol Hill after the Labor Day weekend at the beginning of September.

When Democrats were basking in their victory last November they claimed to have a mandate from the people, which in actuality was no more than the voters throwing out the GOP as majority because of rampant spending, mainly through earmarks. So Democrats in their claim of a mandate about Iraq and spending bragged about how their Congress would be the most ethical Congress in history.

They went on to brag that they would curb earmarks and that investigations would be held to a minimum while they passed what they deemed as necessary legislation which of course followed their liberal agenda. So the first 100 hours came and went while Democrats blocked the GOP from even participating in debate by placing everything in their agenda up for a floor vote immediately.

Two of the more touted votes that passed in that first 100 hours was the minimum wage increase and legislation to stop or actually control earmarks. The minimum wage increase was later attached to a military appropriations bill as a means of trying to force the President into signing a bill with a Democrat withdrawal, (surrender), measure which prompted a Bush VETO. Thus the minimum wage had to be re-visited for passage once again.

The earmarks measure also has fallen by the wayside in a manner that the American public has no clue as to how much. While the minimum wage bill was passed a second time and recently enacted with a 70 cent increase in the wage, the earmarks are more out of control now then they ever were with the GOP. In fact Nancy Pelosi has even tried to force earmarks into legislation by adding them while a bill is on the House floor which prevents any committee revue or debate on the earmark.

So just what has this Democrat led Congress done since taking power in January ? Almost nothing. The only real legislation that has passed the Congress has been the minimum wage increase. While I do not agree with the increase, it at least is something that they have accomplished that was on their agenda.

They have passed legislation that decreases interest due on college loans and loosens requirements for approval making them easier for students to receive, which of course will make a poor student beholden to the government in paying off a college loan until he/she is receiving Social Security.

How do Democrats stand on earmarks ? They have touted that they were going to all but eliminate this practice and as a matter of fact they are once again addressing the issue on the House floor this week, before the cameras, which has no chance of passing before the recess at the end of the week but makes good play before the press.

Earmarks while proposed by both parties cannot make it into a bill without the approval of the majority leadership. Since January Democrats have allowed more than, (I hope you bracing yourself, ) 32, 000 earmarks attached to various legislation ! This in just over six months of the Congressional year.

The GOP while rampant in spending did not allow 32, 000 in an entire year much less six months. While all of this spending has been going on Democrats have been portraying themselves as fiscally responsible and ethically clean, ( do I hear William Jefferson Democrat Louisiana ?).

What else has happened since January ? On the Senate side investigation after investigation has taken place with Iraq withdrawal measure placed in the midst. In fact especially in the last several months the Senate has debated Iraq surrender measures which either failed or were vetoed then once those were no longer before the cameras drift back to the firing of the federal prosecutors and Alberto Gonzales, then back to another Iraq measure, then Gonzales, then Iraq, the Gonzales... you get the picture. Oh and they threw the Amnesty Bill in for good measure.

The House also has voted debated, reworded, re -voted, reworded, then re-voted again more times then one can count Iraq withdrawal measures which just like their Senate counter parts are designed to get media attention and show liberal groups like ,"Move On.org," and others that Democrats bow to and are beholden to that they are pushing the liberal agenda on the war.

The Summer recess is upon us and low and behold both the House and the Senate have already announced that once they return in September the first order of business will be to debate and try to pass yet another Iraq withdrawal, (surrender), measure. This time the debate will most likely last longer since the report from General Petraeus is due in September.

Of course when the report talks of the success of the surge which is already evidenced in so many ways, Democrats as usual will cry foul and claim that the surge has failed and the debate and push their pull out agenda despite the evidence to the contrary. Of course one must always realize that Democrats are not interested in truth, evidence, success or victory, just obstruction, opposition and surrender regardless of the consequences or the reality on the ground.

So they reward themselves with a raise and will go home during August and brag to their constituents on the, "marvelous job, " and the, " tremendous accomplishments, " that they have made since January. While the record shows failure and their delusional status on accomplishments would spark commitment procedures if they worked anywhere else besides Washington DC.
cont....

OTB
 
Cont....

Raise you an op ed from a sitting member on a failed Democratic commitment:

An Unfulfilled Promise
Transparency and accountability in earmarking.

By John Boehner

I read with disappointment Friday’s New York Times column (“Don’t Get Rid of Earmarks”) by Rep. Rahm Emanuel (D., Ill.), the third-ranking Democrat in the House of Representatives, in which he bristles at assertions that the earmarking process in Congress has become less transparent and accountable than it was under the Republican majority. The fact of the matter is that congressional Democrats are well-deserving of the criticism they’re receiving in this area.

In his column, Rep. Emanuel contends congressional Democrats “never promised” to get rid of earmarks. But a year ago, he and other prominent Democrats were more than happy to allow the American people and the media to believe Democrats had, in fact, made such a promise. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D., Calif.) told the Wall Street Journal in a major interview just months before the 2006 election that if she were to become Speaker, earmarks might become a thing of the past. (“Personally, myself, I’d get rid of all of them,” she told the Wall Street Journal in July 2006. “None of them is worth the skepticism, the cynicism the public has . . . and the fiscal irresponsibility of it.”)

These comments were widely reported throughout the country in September 2006 as the House debated earmark reforms, and Democrats pointed to Rep. Pelosi’s comments to support their contention that the reforms being implemented by Republicans were simply a “sham.” Rep. Emanuel and other Democratic leaders conveniently allowed Rep. Pelosi’s comments to stand, leading to widespread assumptions that congressional Democrats were calling for a ban on earmarks. Only now, nine months into their majority, are top Democrats striving to set the record straight.

More troubling, however, is Rep. Emanuel’s assertion that the earmark reforms implemented by the Democratic-controlled Congress have resulted in a system that is more open and transparent than the earmark-reform system implemented under GOP control. This is simply false. The rules and procedures adopted by the current majority leadership in the House prohibit members of Congress from forcing a debate and vote on individual earmarks contained in authorizing or tax bills that are brought to the House floor. This prohibition is a direct reversal of earmark reforms implemented by Republicans last year, which required that all earmarks in all types of bills be publicly disclosed and subject to floor challenge and debate. In fact, the Democratic prohibition originally applied to appropriations bills as well, but House Republicans in June successfully forced Democrats to restore the 2006 GOP reforms for such bills after Democrats were caught trying to use the appropriations process to create slush funds for secret earmarks.

Tax and authorizing bills have been vehicles for some of the most indefensible earmarks produced by Congress, under both Democrats and Republicans. An authorizing bill was recently the vehicle for an illegitimate earmark requested by Rep. John Murtha (D., Pa.) that shifted $23 million in taxpayer funds to the so-called National Drug Intelligence Center — a facility located in Rep. Murtha’s district that was declared “expensive and duplicative” by independent government analysts. When a Republican congressman attempted to challenge this earmark, he was not only denied the opportunity to force a vote on the House floor concerning the controversial expenditure, but threatened with the loss of his own earmark — a violation of the new rules Rep. Emanuel celebrates in his column.

The rules pushed through the House by the majority leadership in January on the opening day of the current Congress do include some commendable provisions that were not part of last year’s Republican reforms, and I commended the Democratic leadership for including these provisions when they were passed. Unfortunately, since that time, the leadership has constructed a system that conveniently ensures earmarks in such bills cannot be debated or stripped out on the House floor. This is a giant step back from the reforms Republicans implemented last year on behalf of taxpayers — and until it is fixed, this loophole will continue to undermine public trust and confidence in our institution.

Rep. Emanuel is wrong to suggest the current system in Congress is as open and transparent as it needs to be or could be. Republicans should have acted far sooner to reform the earmark process when we had the majority, and our failure to do so contributed to the loss last November. But while Republicans have gotten the message the hard way, the Democratic majority now appears resigned to repeating our mistakes. Americans are rightly outraged that Congress has passed an “ethics reform” bill that fails to ensure all earmarks are subject to appropriate debate and scrutiny. Legislative action needs to be taken in Congress as soon as possible to remedy this problem.

Earlier this summer I introduced a resolution that would require all taxpayer-funded earmarks to be publicly disclosed and subject to challenge on the House floor. I have requested that Speaker Pelosi and Majority Leader Steny Hoyer (D., Md.) schedule this resolution for a vote to give all Members, Republican and Democrat alike, the opportunity to assure the American people that appropriate scrutiny is applied to all taxpayer-funded earmarks. I regret to report that to date, my requests have been met only with silence.

If the majority leadership in Congress is serious about bringing transparency and accountability to the earmark process, it will bring my resolution to the floor in September for an up-or-down vote by the full House. Until this has happened and the loopholes are fixed, Democrats should expect to continue to hear from Americans who believe reform of the broken earmarking process in Congress remains a woefully unfulfilled promise.

— Rep. John Boehner (R., Ohio) is House Republican Leader.

cont....
OTB
 
Cont.....

And finish with what the American people think of this congress:

Gallup poll from August 13-16 has Congress at a 18% approval rating....

LOL

OTB
 
Thanks for posting Ken Taylor from "The Liberals Lie" website and John Boehner, one the Rethug leaders in the House. Both of these are very reliable, unbiased sources.

We know that you know how to cut and paste. Congratulations. However, neither they nor you have refuted the lie that this is a do-nothing Congress.

And you point to the low ratings of Congress as your proof?

I have posted several times with data -- yes, data-- that shows that the reason for the low rating is the fact that the Dems are NOT standing up to the shrub.

All you have are the grindings of the mighty right-wing Wurlitizer.

How sad.
 
TOVisitor said:
I have posted several times with data -- yes, data-- that shows that the reason for the low rating is the fact that the Dems are NOT standing up to the shrub.


For example:

Discontent Over Iraq Increasing, Poll Finds
Americans Also Unhappy With Congress
By Dan Balz and Jon Cohen
Washington Post Staff Writers
Tuesday, June 5, 2007; Page A01


Growing frustration with the performance of the Democratic Congress, combined with widespread public pessimism over President Bush's temporary troop buildup in Iraq, has left satisfaction with the overall direction of the country at its lowest point in more than a decade, according to a new Washington Post-ABC News poll.

Almost six in 10 Americans said they do not think the additional troops sent to Iraq since the beginning of the year will help restore civil order there, and 53 percent -- a new high in Post-ABC News polls -- said they do not believe that the war has contributed to the long-term security of the United States.

A record-high percentage of poll respondents say the Iraq war has not achieved its primary objective ¿ increasing the long-term security of the United States ¿ and few say a troop increase will help.

Disapproval of Bush's performance in office remains high, but the poll highlighted growing disapproval of the new Democratic majority in Congress. Just 39 percent said they approve of the job Congress is doing, down from 44 percent in April, when the new Congress was about 100 days into its term. More significant, approval of congressional Democrats dropped 10 percentage points over that same period, from 54 percent to 44 percent.

Much of that drop was fueled by lower approval ratings of the Democrats in Congress among strong opponents of the war, independents and liberal Democrats. While independents were evenly split on the Democrats in Congress in April (49 percent approved, 48 percent disapproved), now 37 percent said they approved and 54 percent disapproved. Among liberal Democrats, approval of congressional Democrats dropped 18 points.

If you go to the Roper site, they poll the approval of Congressional Democrats and Republicans separately.

What do we find? Repubs are polling about 10% less than the Dems. So just who is the low overall approval attributable to? Clearly it's the Republicans.
 
bot is great at massaging them 'fuzzy numbers'!.......:D