CCP or ROC defeated Japan?

Here I will translated it in English for you...

"Under the banner of the Anti-Japanese National United Front advocated by the Communist Party of China..."

The United Front was supposed to be a ROC/CCP alliance...not a mention of the ROC's efforts...implying it was the CCP that took the lead in the battles vs Japan. 🤦‍♂️

Which of CCP and KMT took the lead could be open
to different interpretation.

CCP scarcely had the strength to fight KMT let alone
the Japanese invaders.

KMT ruled China (though nominally) at the time of the war.
Communists were rebels who had joined the ruling regime's
fight against the common enemy of the Chinese people that
was the Japanese invaders.

KMT being the ruling party was the leader on the battlefield.
They fought and indeed won several battles. And yet until the
final year of the war KMT was losing ground when and where
they had made tactical victories.

Chiang Kai-Sek had the entire nation's armies under his
leadership at the battle of Shanghai. Where were his
troops when Japan massacred and raped hundres of
thousands of Chinese in Nanking?

Prior to the battle of Shanghai China already lost a
good part of its territories to the north. The communists
filtrated into those territories to build anti-Japan bases.
Did Chiang and KMT ever attempt to fight back to retake
those territories? Chiang's amies were losing and retreating to
the end of 1944. Any territories retaken to the end of the war
was dismal by comparison to the size of the parts occupied
by Japan. It was the communists who had the audacity to
build military bases under the nose of the invaders for protection
of the Chinese people.

After the loss of Shanghai Chiang and KMT also lost Wuhan
and Canton. China was thereby virutally blockaded from foreign
supply of military and material aid.

No one can deny that Chiang's perseverance through the war
years raised the standing of China in the world. By tying down
1 to 2 million Japanese troops China contrubuted significant
relief to the U.S. fighting Japan in the Pacific war. Such contribution
made Chiang a valued leader of China the nation in the eyes
of the allies but not much of a leader in the Chinese people's war
against Japan.
 
That time that Mao met with Japanese socialists

"I spoke to many Japanese friends about this incident, and some of them said that it was not good for Japan to invade China. I said of course the invasion was bad, but we should not look at this bad side alone, on the other hand, Japan has done us a great favour in China. If Japan had not occupied half of China, the Chinese people would not have awakened. In this respect, we have to "thank" the Japanese Imperial Army. Who is educating you Japanese people now? It is the U.S. imperialists who are your negative teachers, and they are also our negative teachers. ......It is possible and necessary for our two peoples, China and Japan, to cooperate because both are oppressed by U.S. imperialism and have common positions."

 

I crossed path with myriads of well educated people from China during
my years in various schools since the late 1980s through the turn of
the century. Pretty much none of them hold any respect or gratitude
towards Mao. Younger generation of mainland Chinese generally don't
care about Mao just like the younger Taiwanese with Dr Sun Yat-Sen.

Digging out dirts of Mao the bad guy won't have much impact
on the PRC regime. The communists did not succeed because
they were loved by their people.
 
I crossed path with myriads of well educated people from China during
my years in various schools since the late 1980s through the turn of
the century. Pretty much none of them hold any respect or gratitude
towards Mao. Younger generation of mainland Chinese generally don't
care about Mao just like the younger Taiwanese with Dr Sun Yat-Sen.

Digging out dirts of Mao the bad guy won't have much impact
on the PRC regime. The communists did not succeed because
they were loved by their people.
Of course during that period when you were in China, Deng was distancing himself with some of the chaos that Mao and his insane policies caused. As far as communists go, they were opposites and Deng was punished by Mao and his son was tortured and paralyzed because of Mao.

This is not digging up dirt on Mao, this is just how the CCP propaganda machine has worked in the past and continues to work now. I doubt you picked up any history books in your time in China to see how the Japanese War of Aggression is taught to its youth. It portrays the CCP has having a significantly bigger role than it actual had to the point of fantasy.
 
...............................................

This is not digging up dirt on Mao, this is just how the CCP propaganda machine has worked in the past and continues to work now. I doubt you picked up any history books in your time in China to see how the Japanese War of Aggression is taught to its youth. It portrays the CCP has having a significantly bigger role than it actual had to the point of fantasy.

People of China are not as gullible as you might have thought.

If you want to learn more about the history of China in the eras of
the warlords and KMT your better source of knowledge will be the
mainland not Taiwan or Hong Kong.

Just because the ruling regime's narratives of their history has
a lot of BS and has fooled a lot of people doesn't mean you can't learn
from the more well informed. A lot of good and reliable accounts
of the history of China's war years can easily be found,

Never underestimate the wisdom of the Chinese people. They
have just looked past the flaws and failures of their government
and focusd on betterment of their country since Mao's death. They
wisely opt not to openly tear down the propaganda of the communist
party. People of China today enjoy way more freedom than in the
years of Mao. I am sure progress will continue steadily and China
in a decade from now will be a more open society.
 
People of China are not as gullible as you might have thought.

If you want to learn more about the history of China in the eras of
the warlords and KMT your better source of knowledge will be the
mainland not Taiwan or Hong Kong.

Just because the ruling regime's narratives of their history has
a lot of BS and has fooled a lot of people doesn't mean you can't learn
from the more well informed. A lot of good and reliable accounts
of the history of China's war years can easily be found,

Never underestimate the wisdom of the Chinese people. They
have just looked past the flaws and failures of their government
and focusd on betterment of their country since Mao's death. They
wisely opt not to openly tear down the propaganda of the communist
party. People of China today enjoy way more freedom than in the
years of Mao. I am sure progress will continue steadily and China
in a decade from now will be a more open society.
I wouldn't expect you to understand if you haven't lived it or grew up in it. The indoctrination at a very young age during your formative years, and throughout your education is very heavy. World events and even domestic events that threaten the CCP's narrative and stranglehold on power are suppressed, i.e. 64, Berlin Wall, CCP involvement during WWII, floods, etc.

I'm sure in your circle when you visit, there are people who are a bit more affluent and know a bit more of the truth. However, they got rich during the Deng and Jiang era and speaking out against BS CCP narratives and openly tearing down the propaganda will easily make them CCP targets.

One can only hope that China becomes a free open society, but with Xi and his cult of personality, this seems unlikely without a change in leadership with people who are actually willing to engage in meaningful economic reform and nurturing a society that isn't closed off to the rest of the world.
 
...............
One can only hope that China becomes a free open society, but with Xi and his cult of personality, this seems unlikely without a change in leadership with people who are actually willing to engage in meaningful economic reform and nurturing a society that isn't closed off to the rest of the world.

There must be 2, 3 or more flights between Toronto and
Beijing scheduled daily. These flights are often nearly fully
booked.

Among those people who visit China are professionals,
businessmen and scholars. A lot of them are oversea
Chinese who have settled in Canada but still visit their
homeland yearly.

These people are free to exchange ideas with business
partners, collaborators in academic research and family
members on the merits of democracy and shortcomings
of totalitarian government.

China is an open society and will continue to progress.
 
These people are free to exchange ideas with business
partners, collaborators in academic research and family
members on the merits of democracy and shortcomings
of totalitarian government.

China is an open society and will continue to progress.

Lol...I've been back to China multiple times since I came to Canada in the early 2000s up until 2018. Open society is definitely not a way to describe it. The hukou system does not allow for freedom of movement. Having a closed of intranet and restricted access to information is not symbolic of a free and open society. Extreme censorship and one way messaging does not represent a free and open society. Crackdown on freedom of religion - also not emblematic of a free and open society. Jailing human rights lawyers or pro democracy activists - seems pretty closed off to me.

I have co-workers who still go back now and dare not talk to their relatives that they are visiting about some of the pitfalls of the CCP. In fact, when I ask them about their conversations with their relatives about China vs the West, most of their relatives have a very narrow view of the West and have been spoonfed CCP propaganda about the superiority of the communist system and the rise of China. Other relatives just prefer not to talk about it at all out of fear. But sure, open society...
 
Lol...I've been back to China multiple times since I came to Canada in the early 2000s up until 2018. Open society is definitely not a way to describe it. The hukou system
...........................................

Excluding the impact of Covid more and more people have been visting
China since 2018 to this dfay and the trend will continue. And the people
of China will continue to enjoy the freedom to visit foreign countries
or to leave and settle in the democratic parts of the world.

That the ruling regime of China is unloved and unlovable
to their own people is nothing surprising. Nonetheless I
suspect you and those who share your wishes to see the
government of China overthrown are representative of only
a tiny fraction of the Chinese people.