Catholics protest 'Satanic' billboard

The organization must bear guilt because it is a clear case of what you knew and if you didn't what should you have known.
It is not good enough to say I didn't know what was going on when you made little or no effort to investigate the cases that came to light or root out the cases where priests were transferred rather than dealing with their crimes. The catholic church reacted belatedly and ineffectually because of external pressure not because they wanted to deal with the monster in their midst
 
It is commonly used in this argument. It will continue to be used in this argument. It is stupidly used in this argument. The argument is that Russian communists believed that religious belief interfered with developing communism and so banned religion. The Three Amigos claim that because the atheist, communist leaders banned religion that it goes to prove that atheism is the reason for the deaths of millions. Being atheist is a tenet of some communist people to support their belief in communism, not the other way around . Atheism does not have any tenets. Communists killed millions in the name of communism and for power as you stated. Not in the name of atheism. They can't seem to grasp this simple but huge difference.

I was under the impression that atheism was a central tenant of classical communism. Opiate of the masses and all that.

And the discussion about mass deaths is usually used as a) a response to the claim that religion is the "biggest" killer, and b) to show that mass murders are not particular to religions, but seem to be common in human society.

There is nothing right, or wonderful about many of the events of say...the crusades...but the suggestion that religion, historically, has been the prime cause of wars or violence, is not made out on the facts.
 
Let's say the Vaticans assets are $5 billion. How far does that take you in changing the world?

Their annual income looks to be, what less than $200 million a year? How far does that take you?

There are over a billion Catholics in the world, so over the course of its thousand year plus existence, they have retained earnings of about $5, a current member. Even if the valuation is 100 billion, it is only about $100 per current member so far.

Some business.

Now others claim church assets are as much as $100 billion, but they are known to spend over 2.3 billion on charity in the US alone every year.

A conservative estimate of payouts in lawsuits might be 5-10 billion.

But you miss the fundamental point, business are designed to generate profits for owners. The church is not designed that way. They do not distribute profits to owners.

rld, that was 1994 figures. Things are much different now. When was the last time your salary tripled? when you work for the Catholic organization it's possible. " Income to the Holy See from bishops' dioceses
has more than tripled from 1990 levels, to $22 million in 2000." All I'm saying is that the Catholic church and the Vatican is a big business.
 
I was under the impression that atheism was a central tenant of classical communism. Opiate of the masses and all that.

And the discussion about mass deaths is usually used as a) a response to the claim that religion is the "biggest" killer, and b) to show that mass murders are not particular to religions, but seem to be common in human society.

There is nothing right, or wonderful about many of the events of say...the crusades...but the suggestion that religion, historically, has been the prime cause of wars or violence, is not made out on the facts.

Atheism is an individuals choice and if a collective ideology misuses it for it's own ends an individual is free to resist. When an institution allows crimes to be committed in its name or under it's auspices it is open to attack. As an institution the church failed in it's duties to protect children and so it diminished itself and the onus is on the church to prove through actions it is the moral authority it has always claimed to be.
 
I have no problem with punishing individuals who abuse children or try to cover that up.

What I am adverse to, is organizational guilt.
Organizations are defined and held accountable by their member's, especially leader's, behaviour. Their actions, reactions, inaction is what truly defines them. I believe you understand this which is why your integrity is called in question in this discussion. Empty arguments make you look very bad when sticking up for a group that claims to represent and know the will of a god but encourages the buggering of children. Make no mistake. Inaction, payoffs, covering up = a safe haven for paedophiles which, in turn, encourages the abuse of kids.
Constantly trying to mitigate their abominable behaviours by highlighting their good work or comparing them to a hockey coach casts a dark shadow on any point you try to make in this discussion. Apologist? Clearly.
 
Organizations are defined and held accountable by their member's, especially leader's, behaviour. Their actions, reactions, inaction is what truly defines them. I believe you understand this which is why your integrity is called in question in this discussion. Empty arguments make you look very bad when sticking up for a group that claims to represent and know the will of a god but encourages the buggering of children. Make no mistake. Inaction, payoffs, covering up = a safe haven for paedophiles which, in turn, encourages the abuse of kids.
Constantly trying to mitigate their abominable behaviours by highlighting their good work or comparing them to a hockey coach casts a dark shadow on any point you try to make in this discussion. Apologist? Clearly.

If you need a label feel free to use it.

Encourages? I disagree. Rooted out as effectively as they should have? No.
 
I was under the impression that atheism was a central tenant of classical communism. Opiate of the masses and all that.

Yes... read my post.

And the discussion about mass deaths is usually used as a) a response to the claim that religion is the "biggest" killer, and b) to show that mass murders are not particular to religions, but seem to be common in human society.

There is nothing right, or wonderful about many of the events of say...the crusades...but the suggestion that religion, historically, has been the prime cause of wars or violence, is not made out on the facts.
Religion is the greatest 'single' cause of wars.
 
Atheism is an individuals choice and if a collective ideology misuses it for it's own ends an individual is free to resist. When an institution allows crimes to be committed in its name or under it's auspices it is open to attack. As an institution the church failed in it's duties to protect children and so it diminished itself and the onus is on the church to prove through actions it is the moral authority it has always claimed to be.

There is no doubt that the church did not do as much as it could to protect the children in its care. I don't know anyone who doubts that.

But for folks who wish to argue that the church is the root of all historical evil etc, they are just plain wrong.
 
rld, that was 1994 figures. Things are much different now. When was the last time your salary tripled? when you work for the Catholic organization it's possible. " Income to the Holy See from bishops' dioceses
has more than tripled from 1990 levels, to $22 million in 2000." All I'm saying is that the Catholic church and the Vatican is a big business.

I didn't say, the RCC is not big. I didn't say the RCC doesn't influence and have a lot of money. What I said is that it is not a business. I think we disagree on what a business is.

And, I don't get a salary, I am self employed. But there are years that I will make 3X or more than other years.
 
Nice try to dice the issue. Your comment about wars is meaningless without a list of what you think the causes of war are.

Wars are always about the failure of parties to resolve the frustrations of one desires without resorting to violence that is the ultimate flaw in human nature.
 
Kenpachi, the fact remains, and if you disbelieve it check with any charitable monitoring institution in Canada or the U.S., that religious charities provide far more "bang" for donors contributions than secular charities.
 
I didn't say, the RCC is not big. I didn't say the RCC doesn't influence and have a lot of money. What I said is that it is not a business. I think we disagree on what a business is.

And, I don't get a salary, I am self employed. But there are years that I will make 3X or more than other years.

Ok, RCC and the Vatican Church is a big monster organization that has tones of priceless paintings and sculptures which generates millions if not billions per year from donations. They also spend millions if not billions to pay off all the victims of pedophilia committed by few priests. So what is the difference between Jacko and the priests committing pedophilia? One is ordained by God, and the other is not.
 
Ok, RCC and the Vatican Church is a big monster organization that has tones of priceless paintings and sculptures which generates millions if not billions per year from donations. They also spend millions if not billions to pay off all the victims of pedophilia committed by few priests. So what is the difference between Jacko and the priests committing pedophilia? One is ordained by God, and the other is not.

There is little significant difference between Jacko (who we assume was a pedo) and any individual priest sexually abusing children.

But that does not appear to be what you are suggesting. Are you suggesting we should wipe out the movie or entertainment industry because Jacko may have committed child abuse? The question is how far do you spread the blame beyond the individuals directly involved.

I trust you have no problem with the victims receiving compensation for their suffering.
 
Kenpachi, the fact remains, and if you disbelieve it check with any charitable monitoring institution in Canada or the U.S., that religious charities provide far more "bang" for donors contributions than secular charities.

Oh Aardvark154, I just hate any religious organizations who condemn the rich or anyone with money by putting God's name in front, while the top ministers like jimmy swaggart practices hypocrisy. Catholic Church is no better.
 
There is little significant difference between Jacko (who we assume was a pedo) and any individual priest sexually abusing children.

But that does not appear to be what you are suggesting. Are you suggesting we should wipe out the movie or entertainment industry because Jacko may have committed child abuse? The question is how far do you spread the blame beyond the individuals directly involved.

I trust you have no problem with the victims receiving compensation for their suffering.

rld, I'm not suggesting anything. Please read my comments carefully.
 
rld, I'm not suggesting anything. Please read my comments carefully.

Actually you are. You keep listing the assets of the group, and then discussing the crimes of the individuals.

The assets of the church are not the personal assets (or income) of individual criminal priests.
 
Actually you are. You keep listing the assets of the group, and then discussing the crimes of the individuals.

The assets of the church are not the personal assets (or income) of individual criminal priests.

Tell me then rld, who does these "individual criminal priests" represent? Of course the Catholic organization. And these "assets" we speak of. What is the point of the church keeping it all when they should be liquidated and help benefit man kind. Oh wait, I guess they need it for a rainy day when another priest gets convicted and the church needs to pay the victim's families millions of dollars. Just my opinion.
 
Last edited: