Catholics protest 'Satanic' billboard

Indeed. You're absolutely correct.

Why bring up events that are over a thousand years old when discussing the church?

To think that every week all these people gather to hear about historical figures named David, Moses, Jesus, Muhammad, Salomon and read from ancient scriptures called Testaments, Qur'an Talmud and Torah. All at least, a thousand years old, perhaps?

Because that would be a religious conversation and we would all be arguing from, by or about scripture. I thought we were having a secular conversation. I don't argue from scripture because I don't consider it an authority.

Let's leave out historical facts and only repeat what will keep people in line.

Like you did by claiming incorrectly that the RCC did not try to help jews in WWII? I am happy to debate history with you.
**********************************************************************


Organized religion belongs to the above list. It served it's purpose. It laid down a framework. It did more harm than good. Time to file you away under Slavery and Misanthropia.

I guess though your problem is that organized religion is growing, each and every year. And unlike an "idea", it is an institution. I hope you also credit the role organized religion played in bringing many of those things to an end. Unlike a static idea, like slavery or racial inferiority, religion, like science is a self correcting institution. It evolves and is surviving really, really well.



I know of a very lovely married couple with two children. He is a devout Muslim and she's a good girl from an Anglican family. He's educated and elegant. She's refined and sophisticated. After their first few months of dating, she brought him home to meet her family. Her kin, who preaches tolerance and benevolence, said it was either him or them. He even offered to attend Church with her and her family said they would rather be dead than to see that happen. She was crushed.

I think that is unfortunate, but it reflects a local, parochial prejudice, which can be seen in all sorts of non-religious situations. Have you read the official RCC position on muslims or inter-faith marriage, or read about the large and successful interfaith events that go on all the time. I guess they don't get enough media coverage...they even invite atheists you know.
 
When you wrote "I guess you don't read the news paper" reply to RLD's specific comments, it certainly implies that you believe that the entire Roman Catholic Church is in involved with pedophilia and the cover-up of cases of the same, not merely that a small number of priests have done so.

I think it is fair to say that the church has suffered from institutional lethargy when dealing with this problem. Instead of actively dealing with what is and was more than an uncommon occurrence they pretended the problem didn't exist for far too long. This is not a problem of faith but a failing to acknowledge that faith in the almighty is not and never will be enough we must look to our own here and now and clean up our own messes. Nothing happens for " a reason" but because of reasons.
 
I think the analogy with business fails. Most churches are not designed to, or set up for making a profit.

rld, you are so wrong when you state "I think the analogy with business fails. Most churches are not designed to, or set up for making a profit." Let me enlighten you with 1994 figures.

In 1994, the audit listed:
- 1,483 billion lire in assets [About $848 million]: -
- 732 billion lire [about $419 million] in liabilities (in the
"Consolidated Financial Statements of the Holy See" (410 billion in
cash, 479 billion in stocks and bonds, 29 billion in gold, and 470
billion in fixed assets - investments and real-estate) . 269 billion
lire are in deposits and accounts of Vatican entities, 96 billion for
employees' severance indemnities and 262 billion at the value of
pensions to present employees;
- 750 billion are in net assets [$430 million].

These figures are without the bank and the Vatican City, each of them
was mentioned earlier, and Reese estimates that it would add up to
$500 million to $1 billion. However, deducting the Vatican City's
budget and the $270 million reported as "fixed assets", the sum is
lower than $1 billion, maybe even less than quarter billion dollars.

Although Reese's information is only an estimation, it is probably the
closer you'll get, with the complex structure of the Vatican and the
Church. You can find other estimations online, including from this
site <http://www.vaticanbankclaims.com>, which tries to assert
retributions from the Vatican bank on property looted by the Nazis.
they claim the bank has manages £2bn (British Pounds) of assets, and
that The Vatican had a balance of 2.5bn lira in 1998, then worth about
£1m. <http://www.vaticanbankclaims.com/worldly.htm>

In an interview published in Money Week, Cardinal Edmund C. Szoka, the
Vatican's "finance minister", claims that The Vatican's assets are $5
billion. he adds that " Income to the Holy See from bishops' dioceses
has more than tripled from 1990 levels, to $22 million in 2000." he
also says, "That [$5 billion] doesn't include the Vatican City, which
has a separate financial statement. If property is used for Church
purposes and could never be sold, the value of it is considered 1
lire, or nearly zero." The City's assets are "The revenues in 2000
were $180 million. The net surplus was $22 million, but that
fluctuates greatly since we're responsible for the maintenance of all
buildings, and it's extremely costly. One year we have a profit of $1
million and the next year $10 million. We put the surplus in a
reserve, so we have it when the next work is needed" (Szoka refuses to
refer directly to the Vatican Bank's assets). <source:
http://www.wrns.org/parse.php?idd=4537>

Now, tell me this rld. How much more money does the Vatican church need to help the poor?
 
Now, tell me this rld. How much more money does the Vatican church need to help the poor?

Let's say the Vaticans assets are $5 billion. How far does that take you in changing the world?

Their annual income looks to be, what less than $200 million a year? How far does that take you?

There are over a billion Catholics in the world, so over the course of its thousand year plus existence, they have retained earnings of about $5, a current member. Even if the valuation is 100 billion, it is only about $100 per current member so far.

Some business.

Now others claim church assets are as much as $100 billion, but they are known to spend over 2.3 billion on charity in the US alone every year.

A conservative estimate of payouts in lawsuits might be 5-10 billion.

But you miss the fundamental point, business are designed to generate profits for owners. The church is not designed that way. They do not distribute profits to owners.
 
kenpachi
And that's only the Vatican - there are many different Catholic Church dioceses in many different countries most with substantial holdings of assets well beyond their operating requirements.
 
They do worry about the effect of scandal on their ability to generate revenue to conduct charitable work and grow the influence of the church. In this respect they act more like a traditional business than a faith based institution should.
 
The brain washed can't read

At least have the courage to admit you lied when you suggested the RCC was behind the castradi, when in fact it was specifically against church law.

What I see is that you need to lie to try and make a point. That makes you dishonest.

Actually the statement was ........Catholics have never "gone after little boys."
I'll try to explain this to you, there is a difference between ..........."THE CATHOLIC CHURCH" and "CATHOLICS".
The church is an oranization, catholics are individuals.

Glad to help, FAST
 
Actually the statement was ........Catholics have never "gone after little boys."
I'll try to explain this to you, there is a difference between ..........."THE CATHOLIC CHURCH" and "CATHOLICS".
The church is an oranization, catholics are individuals.
Hence Catholics meaning all Baptized members of the Roman Catholic Church is far broader than the Roman Catholic Church which could be interpreted as meaning only the hierarchy of the RCC.
 
kenpachi
And that's only the Vatican - there are many different Catholic Church dioceses in many different countries most with substantial holdings of assets well beyond their operating requirements.

This is certainly not true in the United States where the cost of legal settlements has caused the closures of a number of ongoing projects.
 
They do worry about the effect of scandal on their ability to generate revenue to conduct charitable work and grow the influence of the church. In this respect they act more like a traditional business than a faith based institution should.

Don't all charitable organizations worry about their ability to carry out the work they believe in?
 
The Roman Catholic church slaughtered millions of muslim and muslims slaughtered millions. I must have slept through that class, When, where, who, and how did this happen? Now the communist did kill many millions, the Russians 60 million and the Chinese 50 million, but can you blame religion on that. don't think so.

Do you know CM? You both must read the same stuff. I believe that the argument that there were more killed in the name of religion than not in his historic religious tome and it was blown out of the water quite easily. It wasn't even close.

Your argument makes no sense. The millions killed by communists or the Khmer Rouge a Genghis Khan were not killed because of atheism they were killed for politics and power. How this diminishes the horrors committed in the name of religion (pick one) is beyond me. Its disturbing that someone would even use it as an argument.
 
Of course but a church must hold itself to greater ethical standards than a normal charity. That is why their failure to act like a church instead of like a business during the child sex abuse scandals is and was so distressing.
 
I'm not a lawyer
Clearly

but your claim of muslim and christian millions, is over shadow by the many millions killed by atheist and the like. It's been recorded that Ghangis Khan killed ~40 million peopple, nearly 12% of the known worlds population and not in the name of any religion.
The POINT is "he didn't kill because of or in the name of atheism". Of course you and your band of pedo protecting brothers will present some inane idea that atheism has tenets. I have asked that one tenet of atheism be named. You cannot. End of discussion.
 
IF you like the term Catholics have gone after little boys, you will have to add...school teachers, hockey coaches, jews, protestants, blacks, whites and everyone else, because the rate at which Catholics have been involved in pedophilia is the same as those other groups. IF you believe in science there is no rational reason to single out the RCC on this troubling issue.

And yes I have a good idea of how much money goes to and from the RCC, and how much they have paid out in settlements to victims (billions...btw) and I know what they do with their money.

Do you suggest there is something wrong with an organization that pulls together a lot of money for good causes?

rld, are you seriously including the Roman Catholic church under the same umbrella as the school teachers, hockey coaches and everyone else? Tell me something, are hockey coaches and public school teachers ordained by God? Nice try rld...

And also, when you state "And yes I have a good idea of how much money goes to and from the RCC, and how much they have paid out in settlements to victims (billions...btw) and I know what they do with their money." are you saying that it is ok for Catholic churches to practice pedophilia just as long as the church pays the victims billions of dollars? WTF... There is something fundamentally wrong with your comment.

I have a better idea for the Catholic church, stop fucking with little children and the money saved to settle with the victims can go to a better cause. According to rld, its billions, so imagine how many people can benefit from that much cash.

And finally, when you quoted "Do you suggest there is something wrong with an organization that pulls together a lot of money for good causes?" what good cause are you talking about? Oh wait, the good cause meaning giving billions to pedophile victims? So are you saying that the money I donate to the Catholic church, a portion of that will help pay the pedophile victims? How messed up is that. It seems fucked up to me.
 
Of course but a church must hold itself to greater ethical standards than a normal charity. That is why their failure to act like a church instead of like a business during the child sex abuse scandals is and was so distressing.
They acted AND CONTINUE TO ACT immorally.
 
rld, are you seriously including the Roman Catholic church under the same umbrella as the school teachers, hockey coaches and everyone else? Tell me something, are hockey coaches and public school teachers ordained by God? Nice try rld...
Welcome to the world of rld. The master of using semblance to downplay the filthy behaviours of the church leaders. Your point has been made several times. Good luck. lol
 
rld, are you seriously including the Roman Catholic church under the same umbrella as the school teachers, hockey coaches and everyone else? Tell me something, are hockey coaches and public school teachers ordained by God? Nice try rld...

And also, when you state "And yes I have a good idea of how much money goes to and from the RCC, and how much they have paid out in settlements to victims (billions...btw) and I know what they do with their money." are you saying that it is ok for Catholic churches to practice pedophilia just as long as the church pays the victims billions of dollars? WTF... There is something fundamentally wrong with your comment.

I have a better idea for the Catholic church, stop fucking with little children and the money saved to settle with the victims can go to a better cause. According to rld, its billions, so imagine how many people can benefit from that much cash.

And finally, when you quoted "Do you suggest there is something wrong with an organization that pulls together a lot of money for good causes?" what good cause are you talking about? Oh wait, the good cause meaning giving billions to pedophile victims? So are you saying that the money I donate to the Catholic church, a portion of that will help pay the pedophile victims? How messed up is that. It seems fucked up to me.

I thought we were having a secular discussion. Do you think the Catholic Church and its agents are ordained by god? If so I am happy to approach the discussion from that direction. If children are being abused, does it matter who is doing it? Isn't what matters stoppingit?

No, I am not saying pedophillia is justified under any circumstances. Kind of a crude effort on your part.

How about this. The employees of the CC have stopped fucking children (more or less) for decades. The majority of the claims being reported now are from well before 1985. All of the data supports a plummeting rate since 1985.

Did you know that 17% of hospital admissions in the US are to Catholic hospitals? That the RC church supports millions of underprivileged children all over the world? IT is funny how you simply ignore this.

As with an organization of over a billion people, you are going to get some bad apples. The rate of bad apples in the RC church does not seem different than other organizations.
 
Welcome to the world of rld. The master of using semblance to downplay the filthy behaviours of the church leaders. Your point has been made several times. Good luck. lol

I have no problem with punishing individuals who abuse children or try to cover that up.

What I am adverse to, is organizational guilt.
 
Well considering this 'business' uses 80% of its money raised from these brained washed followers for charity work worldwide, I'd said that many of those who receive this help from the church and not from their own leaders are saying 'thank god for big business'.

Tell me blackrock13, how can 80% of its money raised goes to charity work worldwide when according to your buddy rld, billions are paid to pedophile victims. Please do your math. Unless that 80% goes to building more Catholic churches and financially supporting all the priests and bishops etc...
 
Your argument makes no sense. The millions killed by communists or the Khmer Rouge a Genghis Khan were not killed because of atheism they were killed for politics and power. How this diminishes the horrors committed in the name of religion (pick one) is beyond me. Its disturbing that someone would even use it as an argument.
It is commonly used in this argument. It will continue to be used in this argument. It is stupidly used in this argument. The argument is that Russian communists believed that religious belief interfered with developing communism and so banned religion. The Three Amigos claim that because the atheist, communist leaders banned religion that it goes to prove that atheism is the reason for the deaths of millions. Being atheist is a tenet of some communist people to support their belief in communism, not the other way around . Atheism does not have any tenets. Communists killed millions in the name of communism and for power as you stated. Not in the name of atheism. They can't seem to grasp this simple but huge difference.