Career Day in School

Meister

Well-known member
Apr 17, 2003
4,596
1,152
113
Our local school had one of those enlightening career days where they show your children what future careers are possible. They invited a police officer and an HVAC guy and some other dude (I think fitter) to talk about their career. The kids were all impressed by the cop with his cool cop car and the HVAC guy with his cool tools.
Here is where I have a problem. The guidance/career councilors described these careers as exciting, fulfilling, rewarding, blah blah blah. I think it is part of the government's push to make sure we have enough people with trade skills etc...
I am sure those same guidance councilors don't tell their own kids to become an HVAC dude, but instead push them hard to go to university and become a doctor, dentist, lawyer, etc...
I think HVAC dudes have great jobs if that is what they want to do and I'm sure you can make 100k if you are willing to put in the overtime, but I don't think it is fair to push the kids in that direction.

I for one will in the future tell my kids to do their darnedest to become a doctor, dentist, lawyer.....
If they choose to drop out or fail so be it, but to deny my kids the opportunity almost seems foolish.
 
Concidering the thread on the CRAPTACULAR " entry level" jobs University students can look forward to upon graduation IF they do not become lawyers , dentists or doctors .... then YES the trades are great & many start to make big bucks in just a few years. NOT all this crap about working up the corporate ladder for a decade or more before even starting to make decent income. Right now over their lifetime of emplyment the trades make far better than most AND can take more holidays or leaves of absence then the corporate lackey. Wish i became an electrician or plumber when I was in my early 20's.
 
I'm guiding one of my kids to move more into a trade...or semi-professional /college type profession along with doing some business courses ate night.

I think if he is, say an electrician or HVAC guy that has some business background, then I believe he can hire others (ensure they do good work) and run a business. I've a couple of buddies that have done this with some businesses and make really good money - one in particular gets the guys going at a job site in the morning, either plays golf or does some quotes (home renovations business), comes back towards the end of the day and checks on them making sure they clean up - he made well over $300k personally last year! and almost got into the Canadian open with a wild card ticket (he plays that much golf).

He was a tradesman, knows how to run a small business (two things he does well: knows what his costs are - I setup a database for him for quoting jobs etc and knows how to talk to his customers and keep them happy (especially when the guys are leaving at the end of the day, the site is clean and tidy - he found people don't get picky as much when things look in control)
 
In this age of intellectual capital, the highest risk jobs are the so-called professions. Everything from programming, to law to medicine can and has been outsourced to places like India.

If you're a tradesman, your plugged toilet job can't be outsourced to a guy in Bangladesh.
 
I'm guiding one of my kids to move more into a trade...or semi-professional /college type profession along with doing some business courses ate night.

I think if he is, say an electrician or HVAC guy that has some business background, then I believe he can hire others (ensure they do good work) and run a business. I've a couple of buddies that have done this with some businesses and make really good money - one in particular gets the guys going at a job site in the morning, either plays golf or does some quotes (home renovations business), comes back towards the end of the day and checks on them making sure they clean up - he made well over $300k personally last year! and almost got into the Canadian open with a wild card ticket (he plays that much golf).

He was a tradesman, knows how to run a small business (two things he does well: knows what his costs are - I setup a database for him for quoting jobs etc and knows how to talk to his customers and keep them happy (especially when the guys are leaving at the end of the day, the site is clean and tidy - he found people don't get picky as much when things look in control)

I knew I would see posts like these. For every one of these trade success stories there are 10 other self employed trade guys who drive around in Chevy Astro Vans and make an OK living working crazy hours.
How many doctors do you see driving around in Chevy Astro Vans?
There are a few dentists I know who only work 3 days a week, still making a killing.
 
Do you know why they drive Astros? It's because they are cheap to own and run.

Do you know what they drive on weekends?
 
It sucks to go to Medical School, and for some reason fail out. There are very few career opportunities for the "not quite a Doctor" crowd. Similarly, Teacher's College, Law School, and even Engineering are weak programs unless you are the type that succeeds.

If you go to college, get a Technologists diploma, apprentice in a good trade, it is possible to make a fairly steady income with much less risk. Importantly, it only takes 2 to 3 years to complete many college programs. In contrast, it takes a 3 or 4 year university degree + 1 year college for the easiest university degrees to turn into a job. Teachers take 4 year degrees + 2 years Teachers College, and often a 2 year Master's degree. M.D. requires 3 or 4 year undergraduate, and another 10 or so to complete the program. Law school also has similarly lengthy requirements.

I wouldn't point anyone in the direction of meaningless university degrees, unless I knew that for some reason they wanted them and they could succeed.
 
Do you know why they drive Astros? It's because they are cheap to own and run.

Do you know what they drive on weekends?

My HVAC friend who has been doing it for about 20 years still drives his van on the weekend or his wife's Intrepid.
 
^^^ The studies found this to be VERY true because they start making 80- 100k in just a few years. My sister-in-law after 10 years became a forman of electricians making about 150k year at the age of 32. Thus these tradesmen over a lifetime make a gross total accumulated income greater than a guy that does not make 100+ a year, in the corporate world, til his late 40's .... enjoying the higher income for only 15 yrs before retirement. MOST going corporate route enter at around 35-40k a year. 15 years later making 60-75k. 20-25years of employment finally start to see the 100k-120k range. ONLY about 2% in corporate world are at the right place at the right time to get lucky & reach the very top % making 250+ a year & most of those people are 50+ yrs of age.
 
I would hazard to guess that the majority of people who end up with crap jobs after University really had no business being there in the first place. There are too many individuals pursuing higher education purely for the social cachet even if vocational training is a more rational option for them.

http://www.opinionjournal.com/extra/?id=110009535

There is no magic point at which a genuine college-level education becomes an option, but anything below an IQ of 110 is problematic. If you want to do well, you should have an IQ of 115 or higher. Put another way, it makes sense for only about 15% of the population, 25% if one stretches it, to get a college education. And yet more than 45% of recent high school graduates enroll in four-year colleges. Adjust that percentage to account for high-school dropouts, and more than 40% of all persons in their late teens are trying to go to a four-year college--enough people to absorb everyone down through an IQ of 104.

No data that I have been able to find tell us what proportion of those students really want four years of college-level courses, but it is safe to say that few people who are intellectually unqualified yearn for the experience, any more than someone who is athletically unqualified for a college varsity wants to have his shortcomings exposed at practice every day. They are in college to improve their chances of making a good living. What they really need is vocational training. But nobody will say so, because "vocational training" is second class. "College" is first class.

Large numbers of those who are intellectually qualified for college also do not yearn for four years of college-level courses. They go to college because their parents are paying for it and college is what children of their social class are supposed to do after they finish high school. They may have the ability to understand the material in Economics 1 but they do not want to. They, too, need to learn to make a living--and would do better in vocational training.
 
As a teacher this is exactly the type of parental mindset that gets on my nerves. The simple belief that university is this holy grail and if you dont reach it you are absolutely nothing is completely insane. There is nothing wrong with being a doctor or lawyer, but what about the kid who has zero interest in those things or doesnt have the aptitude to get into a program for those professions. This thinking is especially rampant within the recent immigrant community, it has gotten so bad that the school I am at had a vocational school close by that closed down because of declining enrollment.

A lot of these people believe that there is no honour in being a tradesman, newsflash homeys, not everyone can become an electrician or plumber, it takes skill and effort. Now that school closed down the kids that would have gone there are going to a regular school where they are struggling in history and French etc instead of being focused on courses that would benefit their future careers and lives. University isnt for everyone, and is not the be all and end all of humanity.
 
Our local school had one of those enlightening career days where they show your children what future careers are possible. They invited a police officer and an HVAC guy and some other dude (I think fitter) to talk about their career. The kids were all impressed by the cop with his cool cop car and the HVAC guy with his cool tools.
Here is where I have a problem. The guidance/career councilors described these careers as exciting, fulfilling, rewarding, blah blah blah. I think it is part of the government's push to make sure we have enough people with trade skills etc...
I am sure those same guidance councilors don't tell their own kids to become an HVAC dude, but instead push them hard to go to university and become a doctor, dentist, lawyer, etc...
I think HVAC dudes have great jobs if that is what they want to do and I'm sure you can make 100k if you are willing to put in the overtime, but I don't think it is fair to push the kids in that direction.

I for one will in the future tell my kids to do their darnedest to become a doctor, dentist, lawyer.....
If they choose to drop out or fail so be it, but to deny my kids the opportunity almost seems foolish.

Considering the school system when I was there was basically giving the message that if it's not University it's crap, it's about time they give trades some credit.

p.s. my job has me meeting all kinds of trade technicians and a significant number of them are old and foreign educated. There are so few competent young Canadian schooled trades people available that the old farts just hang around making a great salary even though they could be relaxing in retirement. Some of these guys make more than me and a couple guys at my firm have far more invested as retirement savings.
 
Our local school had one of those enlightening career days where they show your children what future careers are possible. They invited a police officer and an HVAC guy and some other dude (I think fitter) to talk about their career. The kids were all impressed by the cop with his cool cop car and the HVAC guy with his cool tools.
Here is where I have a problem. The guidance/career councilors described these careers as exciting, fulfilling, rewarding, blah blah blah. I think it is part of the government's push to make sure we have enough people with trade skills etc...
I am sure those same guidance councilors don't tell their own kids to become an HVAC dude, but instead push them hard to go to university and become a doctor, dentist, lawyer, etc...
I think HVAC dudes have great jobs if that is what they want to do and I'm sure you can make 100k if you are willing to put in the overtime, but I don't think it is fair to push the kids in that direction.

I for one will in the future tell my kids to do their darnedest to become a doctor, dentist, lawyer.....
If they choose to drop out or fail so be it, but to deny my kids the opportunity almost seems foolish.

WHAT? No SPs? Surely, that is a human rights case.
 
I have encouraged my kids to know themselves, and figure out what is right for them. You can be quite successful in various fields, if you are motivated. I was basically forced to go to university by my Dad, he did not care if it was right for me, as far as he was concerned, university was the only option. To me, that is unreasonable. I know I would much rather be an HVAC guy than a dentist, no matter how much I made as a dentist.
 
So true.

If you love what you do, you'll do it well. If you do it well, you'll be financially successful.
 
^^^^^ I agree. Do what you love, regardless of what it is.

HOWEVER, one big warning:

For physical stuff, there will be an age at which you can't do it any more.
 
And doing what you love may never pay, you may love writing poetry, or feeding orphans, or teaching, but it is very unlikely to make you wealthy. That is part of knowing yourself, to understand whether you require lots of money, or whether you have different priorities.
 
And doing what you love may never pay, you may love writing poetry, or feeding orphans, or teaching, but it is very unlikely to make you wealthy. That is part of knowing yourself, to understand whether you require lots of money, or whether you have different priorities.
This sounds very idealistic, but in most cases will disappoint you when you get older. When we are younger we all want to play in a band or rescue whales from the zoo, but the difference is that at some point you get married and then the horror starts. Your wife wants kids, vacation, house, cars. Your kids want education, cars, clothes and toys.
So at this point you are 35-40 years old and you go, what the hell. So it may be very honourable to make your living writing poetry, but don't take on any big responsibilities like a demanding family.
 
Here is where I have a problem. The guidance/career councilors described these careers as exciting, fulfilling, rewarding, blah blah blah. I think it is part of the government's push to make sure we have enough people with trade skills etc...
I am sure those same guidance councilors don't tell their own kids to become an HVAC dude, but instead push them hard to go to university and become a doctor, dentist, lawyer, etc...
I think HVAC dudes have great jobs if that is what they want to do and I'm sure you can make 100k if you are willing to put in the overtime, but I don't think it is fair to push the kids in that direction.

I for one will in the future tell my kids to do their darnedest to become a doctor, dentist, lawyer.....
If they choose to drop out or fail so be it, but to deny my kids the opportunity almost seems foolish.

How many doctors do you see driving around in Chevy Astro Vans?
There are a few dentists I know who only work 3 days a week, still making a killing.
Meister's own biases are apparent in his posts. Life goal = make maximum amount of money. Not everyone wants to spend their life looking into people's mouths just so they can make lots of money. Thankfully the guidance counselor does not share the same bias. If a parent wants to push their own children in a certain direction, that is their decision. A guidance counselor's job is to show a full range of options to the students. Realistically, not every child is going to have the academic aptitude to succeed through 6-10 years of university. Nor should their future happiness depend on it.