Car Insurance Rates

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
507
113
The Keebler Factory
Approximately how much is car insurance for someone over the age of 25 with a Careless Driving conviction (6 points)? Say an average car over 5 years old.

$5,000 ?

$10,000 ?

More ?
 
Keebler Elf said:
Approximately how much is car insurance for someone over the age of 25 with a Careless Driving conviction (6 points)? Say an average car over 5 years old.

$5,000 ?

$10,000 ?

More ?

12 million dollars......+/-

Really though, I heard on City TV about a woman, 34, 92 jetta, had a $400.00 fender bender in a parking lot and her insurance went from $1200.00 per year to $7300.00. Only thing "special" about her case was she was a landed immigrant (from England I think) and had only been in Canada 2 yrs.

All kinding aside I'd estimate that if he's paying $1000.00 now, you'd be looking at anywhere from $4000 - $5000 at least.

Why don't you try a couple of online insurance quotes? I know Royal Bank offers car insurance and I think CIBC does. But do a search for auto insurer websites and I'm sure you will get an idea. Ok, I did a quick one through RBC and they won't do an online quote because careless driving isn't listed under their convictions pull down menu. Why don't you just call up someone?

I just want to say that Careless Driving is a serious offence. I think the only thing worse would be a "racing" conviction or DUI.....
 
cibc and rbc won't touch someone with his driving record. He will probably have to go to one of the companies that specializes in high risk insurance, and I am sur the premiums will be away up there
 
whyte46 said:
... one of the companies that specializes in high risk insurance, and I am sur the premiums will be away up there

Yeah, I was assuming that but forgot to mention it. I'm sure the insurance would be at least $5,000. I was just curious if anyone out has had this experience.
 
try Belair Direct or if u r college or university alumni try TD Meloche.....
 
What I never really understood was that if I had to pay 7000 dollars insurance a year I could rent a car for cheaper. Why don't people do that?
 
car insurance

from Pennsylvania, not from a big city,

I am here, in T.O. as a guest. Yearly rate for a 07 small car, full coverage, 500 deductible about 8-900 US.
Demerit points earned here wont transfer. Parking tickects (unless they changed) wont be sent, so we do not have to pay.

So, if somebody has friends, etc have a us car here and use it here.
 
Rather than pay insurance, maintenance, fuel etc..why not just give the lad..although it s never specified it was a male..a cab allowance for the year?

It has to come out cheaper. If the insurance alone is 4 grand..thats a lot of cab rides.

Aside from that, tell the kid they're out of luck because of their driving record. That might be a better way to handle this.

You screwed up now deal with the consequences like every adult has to.
 
Meister said:
What I never really understood was that if I had to pay 7000 dollars insurance a year I could rent a car for cheaper. Why don't people do that?

Well the reason people don't do that is because at $7000.00 for insurance, that's $19.18 per day. Tell me where you can rent a car for that? I don't even think you can rent a bicycle for that......

BTW: people do do that. I wanted to rent a porsche 911 for a special occasion once and when I called up executive livery they said their 911 was already rented for the next 9 months (by one person).
 
Frequency of use?

Well, the cab solution is great if you're not driving every day, I guess. You'd have to average it out on a number of trips/year basis.

Also, are you just driving around the city - groceries, Home Depot runs, etc occasionally, for a couple of hours at a time? Once you know what your pattern of use really is, the answer becomes clearer.

I think that a combination of cabs, Zip Cars (http://http://www.zipcar.com/toronto/find-cars )and full on rentals would provide someone with a spotty driving record a cost-effective set of solutions. Not as convenient as owning, but some bnenefit like not having to find parking etc are nice.

I realize the poster was originally looking for info on insurance rates; just thought I'd throw out some other options. For rates, just go to http://www.kanetix.ca
 
Cab's not an option. Too many trips over too great a distance. I'm also not talking about a kid, but rather an adult (over the 25-year line).

So adult male, over 25, in an average car, with careless driving on their record.

$7K/year?
 
Keebler Elf said:
Cab's not an option. Too many trips over too great a distance. I'm also not talking about a kid, but rather an adult (over the 25-year line).

So adult male, over 25, in an average car, with careless driving on their record.

$7K/year?

LOL Keeb, just friggin call someone for a quote....sheesh, it doesn't cost anything, you don't have to give them a real name, and it doesn't affect you in any way shape or form.

This is a perfect example of why someone shouldn't fuck around with driving. If it is SO important to you to be able to drive, then you'd think one would realize that and be more careful.

Not to rub salt in a wound but I believe that careless driving points don't come off your licence the same way a speeding ticket does. I think it stays there for a lot longer (like a DUI conviction). Sorry, I check the DOT website and I was incorrect, they come off just like all the other offences....

Another thing, say this "person" decides to bicycle, ttc or cab it until the conviction comes off his record. When he goes for insurance they will treat him like a zero history driver and he will still end up paying through the nose....

A bit of advice on this: If I were him I'd find a POS car that's only worth $1000.00 or less. When you go for insurance don't bother with collision or comp, just liability. I know liability coverage will be the highest of the three, but at least you could save a few bucks on the other two. This way, if he totals the vehicle or ? just get another POS. At least this way he remains an insured driver and eventually his rates should go down. Never to the level he was at before the conviction, but they should go down over time.
 
alienencounters said:
Big mistake.
Believe it or not if a Canadian is caught in Ontario driving a US licenced car then they are liable for the tax (PST AND GST) on the car plus a fine. (Tried this when I was importing a car from the states.
As well if you are not insured continuously in Canada then guess what? When you decide to re-insure yourself you do not have a "continuous history" and then get ready to be charged the same as some inexperienced 18 year old with a new car.
So smile, bend over, and take it in the ass because its gonna happen no matter what.

Actually I emailed RIV and they told me if your just visiting Canada for the weekend and can prove that you are returning to the US you don't have to pay for import fees. It's all up to the immigration officer if he believes your case. But you are right though, if you don't tell this, they will charge you import fees and treat the entry as a returning resident.
 
tboy said:
LOL Keeb, just friggin call someone for a quote....

Hey, it's a discussion board. No one's forcing you to reply.

Re: being considered a new driver after a lapse in insurance, I believe you have to go 2-3 years without insurance before you'd have to start from scratch.

Someone was telling me a scheme where you don't insure, drive a family member's car instead, and if you get pulled over just tell them you were borrowing it for the day (assuming, of course, you've set it up so you're family member covers your story). Do this for two years and on the third year, reactivate your insurance as a casual driver on the car. That keeps you within the 3 year window to avoid being considered a new driver and you only have to pay higher rates for the third year.

Now I would have thought you'd be driving without insurance for the first two years, but maybe so long as the car is insured in someone's name and you're just "borrowing it", you'd be able to weasel by.
 
When I was in University, I totalled my mother's 82 Buick Regal.

Fortunately, no-one was hurt, not even scratched. But both cars were totalled. He ran the red, I was turning left out of a parking lot about 100 metres south of the intersection. My mom was in the car. (She started yelling at the other guy.) :D

Anyway, long story short, we both had to cover our own cars. We got a $4,000 payment for the Buick.

When I tried to get my own insurance, no-one would touch me. (I didn't have a single demerit point, just 1 claim in the last 6 years.)

I phoned EVERYWHERE, even those stupid ads you see in the Sun "Bad Driving Record? - Low Rates"

Sure, you call those numbers and Rangeesh answers the phone from his kitchen and quotes you twice what you've already been quoted.

Bottom line was that I had to go "Facility Insurance", whatever the fuck that is or was. It was $2,300.00 every 6 months.

And yes, I fucking paid it.

It would have been cheaper for me to pay my mother myself the 4 grand. And that's the fucking truth.
 
tboy said:
Well the reason people don't do that is because at $7000.00 for insurance, that's $19.18 per day. Tell me where you can rent a car for that? I don't even think you can rent a bicycle for that......
Weekly rates are cheaper. As well, monthly (if a company goes for that) would be even less.
 
Thrifty's monthly rate for a mid size is $860. if you charge it on a gold card insurance is included. That gives you a brand new car every month, no maintanance, everything covered. Its a good deal.
 
Keebler Elf said:
Hey, it's a discussion board. No one's forcing you to reply.

Re: being considered a new driver after a lapse in insurance, I believe you have to go 2-3 years without insurance before you'd have to start from scratch.

Someone was telling me a scheme where you don't insure, drive a family member's car instead, and if you get pulled over just tell them you were borrowing it for the day (assuming, of course, you've set it up so you're family member covers your story). Do this for two years and on the third year, reactivate your insurance as a casual driver on the car. That keeps you within the 3 year window to avoid being considered a new driver and you only have to pay higher rates for the third year.

Now I would have thought you'd be driving without insurance for the first two years, but maybe so long as the car is insured in someone's name and you're just "borrowing it", you'd be able to weasel by.

Sheesh Keeb, chill, I was just yanking your chain!

As for the family car scheme: Last time I had insurance quoted they asked how many drivers were in the household, and how many cars. I asked why, and they said if there are 3 cars, and 3 drivers, each car had to be insured under 1 driver. No one person(s) could insure all 3, and no one person(s) could not be listed as a driver on the policy. (guess they caught on to the scam??)

Lapse of insurance: Now this is a few years ago (10) so it may have changed but I was living with a gf and for 6 months, I drove part time under her insurance, after being insured solo for 18 yrs. Well when we broke up I went for my own insurance and they listed me as a never been insured 1 star driver (the highest rate). So I said to them "so you're telling me that I should have bought a wreck, put comp on it for $10.00 a month and I would have been fine"? They said yup, I'd still maintain my 6 star rating (1/10th what a 1 star rate is). Like I said, this may have changed since then but the way insurance works, I highly doubt it. It isn't like an insurance company would make it easier on someone.....

Something you might want to try is to list him as a secondary driver on one of your cars. That is, if he lives with you. If he lives at another address that wouldn't work. I will warn you tho the overall rate for the both of you might be more than him and you separate.
 
I think you're right about there not being three people and three cars. I think there'd have to be only 2 cars and 3 people, or 1 car and 2 people. But they can't force you to insure someone on a vehicle (i.e., forcing a second person with a license to be insured on one car in the household). Now, on the other hand, they might be able to force the insured driver to sign a document stating that the uninsured person cannot drive the car.

It's more than 6 months before your insurance lapses. It's now at least 2 years, maybe even 3. They could have just been screwing with you.