Car Heater and Fuel Consumption?

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
508
113
The Keebler Factory
OK, so I know using the air conditioner in an automobile eats up a significant chunk of fuel. But does the heater do the same? Or is the heat from the engine just channeled into the car?
 
Insignificant electrical draw, and as Sheik says, no parasitic drag on the engine, unlike the A/C.
You want a cooling system trick? Put in a lower temp thermostat - engine runs cooler and increased HP.
(but don't go too low, or engine will not get out of "warm up" phase)
 
A bit OT, but if you ever find the jalopy running hot in traffic in the summer turn the heater on full blast. You'll cook for a while but the engine temp drops noticeably. Just uses heat from the cooling system.
 
Actually, there is an old saying: heat is horsepower, too much heat is death when it comes to engines.....

Depending on your model of car and the heater controls, using your heater can in fact increase your fuel consumption. For instance: on some older model ford taurus and many domestic vehicles that don't have a seperate A/C button, when you turn your selector to one side of "off" you do run the compressor to dehumidify the air. I drive an F150 and all the selections to the right of off run the compressor, all the ones to the left, don't.

Many people run the defroster (to have air blowing out the top of the dash instead of the dash vents) but this too also runs the compressor which is used to dehumidify the air to aid in defrosting the windshield (which inside frost or fog is caused by humid air hitting the cooler windshield).

Way to tell if your compressor is running on any selection is to look at your tach or listen to the engine while moving the selector. If the engine slows down for a split second then speeds up again or slows down and stays slower than idle, that means the compressor is running. (as stated the compressor uses engine power to run the compressor but the onboard computer will speed up the engine to maintain the idle speed).
 
Winston said:
Not a good idea. It would have been 20 years ago, but not now. The engineers design the system to work with in set parameters. The chips are designed to do their job with those parameters in mind. The cat converter needs to be hot to be efficient, etc etc etc.

Yup, good point. Has worked well for me for me, but then I haven't tried it on anything past a '91 model. I think you'd need to trial and error after that, your results may vary.
 
tboy said:
Actually, there is an old saying: heat is horsepower, too much heat is death when it comes to engines.....

Depending on your model of car and the heater controls, using your heater can in fact increase your fuel consumption. For instance: on some older model ford taurus and many domestic vehicles that don't have a seperate A/C button, when you turn your selector to one side of "off" you do run the compressor to dehumidify the air. I drive an F150 and all the selections to the right of off run the compressor, all the ones to the left, don't.

Many people run the defroster (to have air blowing out the top of the dash instead of the dash vents) but this too also runs the compressor which is used to dehumidify the air to aid in defrosting the windshield (which inside frost or fog is caused by humid air hitting the cooler windshield).

Way to tell if your compressor is running on any selection is to look at your tach or listen to the engine while moving the selector. If the engine slows down for a split second then speeds up again or slows down and stays slower than idle, that means the compressor is running. (as stated the compressor uses engine power to run the compressor but the onboard computer will speed up the engine to maintain the idle speed).

True, running the windshield defroster spins the AC compressor, but most AC systems have an ambient temperature switch that does not allow the AC compressor to be turned on below 12 C I believe.
 
I'm not an expert, but I don't think you'd notice too much decrease in fuel economy because you turn your heater on in the winter. The new cars run at a fairly constant temperature.

The thermosat regulates the temperature, so if the coolant gets too cold, the thermostat starts closing up.

180 deg farenheit used to be the standard coolant temp. I run a 160 deg in my GN as it is better for perfomance. 160 is too cold for winter though in a normal car. The inside never really heats up.

The newer car thremostats are opening up at higher temperatures. 200 deg is now very common and some go even higher. It gets a little scary when they are up that high, but the reason they do it is to cut down on emissions. Radiators are bigger and more effective to compensate, and electric puller fans keep the temperature fairly constant.

AC compressors do turn on in the winter. The reason they turn on when the defrost is turned on is to stir up the oil and freon inside the compressor to keep the seals lubricated.
 
poorboy said:
180 deg farenheit used to be the standard coolant temp. I run a 160 deg in my GN as it is better for perfomance. 160 is too cold for winter though in a normal car. The inside never really heats up.


I run stock in the winter, but 165 in the summer. That seems to be the lower practicle limit for Fords.
If I put a 160 in my fuel economy would be so pathetically bad (as opposed to just pathetically bad!)
 
tboy said:
Actually, there is an old saying: heat is horsepower, too much heat is death when it comes to engines.....

In theory this is true. According to the laws of thermodynamics retaining heat within an engine will make it more efficient. However, in a practical world this is highly dangerous to engine longevity. As noted in some of the other posts here engine thermostat temperatures have been going up in recent years in search of this efficiency but, I'm not aware of one over 200°.

Keebler Elf said:
OK, so I know using the air conditioner in an automobile eats up a significant chunk of fuel.
While it is true that running a compressor puts a parasitic loss on the engine, in the real world it is not always true that using the air conditioner "eats up a significant chunk of fuel".

When you don't use your air conditioner on a hot day you will almost certainly open some windows to get a breeze. At 100 km/hr this disrupts the airflow over your car and increaes the aerodynamic drag measurably. In a modern car with good aerodynamics and a modern, clutched air conditioning compressor, while travelling at highway speeds the increased drag on the motor from the open window can exceed the drag from the compressor. This situation will result in poorer mileage with the air conditioning off. It will depend somewhat on the speed and the make of the car though but you are not saving much, if anything at all, doing it.

In city driving what you say is true.
 
Actually Mr Why, during a recent episode of "Myth Busters" (on TLC) they did this exact study.

They filled 2 identical ford explorers (year make model engine size and load)with fuel and drove one with the AC on and 1 with the windows open. The vehicle speed was set at 60 mph, with cruise and were checked with radar (I believe). Now I realize that a lot depends on accuracy, age of engine, mileage, viscosity of oil, tread on the tires etc but the vehicle with the windows open drove approximately 20% or 30 mins. longer than the vehicle with the ac on. This was done on an oval track in socal.......
 
tboy said:
Actually Mr Why, during a recent episode of "Myth Busters" (on TLC) they did this exact study.

They filled 2 identical ford explorers (year make model engine size and load)with fuel and drove one with the AC on and 1 with the windows open. The vehicle speed was set at 60 mph, with cruise and were checked with radar (I believe). Now I realize that a lot depends on accuracy, age of engine, mileage, viscosity of oil, tread on the tires etc but the vehicle with the windows open drove approximately 20% or 30 mins. longer than the vehicle with the ac on. This was done on an oval track in socal.......

20% doesn't sound right at all. That is a massive difference. Did they reverse the study and run each truck both ways to eliminate the effects of other differences which can affect mileage? Did they run the air conditioners in high, or in the economy position so that the compressor cyles on and off? Did they determine common compression levels and states of wear between engines? As you say did they use the same oil?

I know that when my car's air conditioner is on I don't even notice the difference in range of the car at highway speeds. I would notice a 20% reduction in range. That would be over 100 km.
 
Why Not? said:
20% doesn't sound right at all. That is a massive difference.
I did a quick web search and was surprised to find that fuel mileage can be negatively affected by up to 21% according to various government websites. But, there is that wonderful “up to “ phrase.

I also however, found two websites which support my conclusion.

http://www.mema.org/news/releasedetail.php?id=60

The Motor and Equipment Manufacturers Association said this.

“As the summer temperatures remain hot and gas prices remain high, motorists should remember that vehicles can get better fuel efficiency with their windows closed and air conditioning on when at highway speeds.”

http://www.straightdope.com/classics/a2_393.html

The straight dope ran a test and found this.

Windows up, AC off: 35 MPG
Windows up, AC on: 34.4 MPG
Windows down (all four), AC off: 33.8 MPG

I also found some evidence supporting the other side including a follow up post on the above site. As I said in my post not all vehicles will experience this but it is very possible.