Car brakes/rotors

Cobster

New member
Apr 29, 2002
10,420
0
0
What are some good car brakes?
Going in to put some new all season tires on, off with winters.
Have a feeling will need to get some new ones, recommendations?
No cheapy stuff, but no high end rembo either. ;-)
Something that'll last me another two or three years.
 
Cobster said:
....What are some good car brakes?...

I try to use factory OEM, depending on their price and quality.

I was using the cheapest Can Tire rotors with decent pads, but I found I was going through them every year.

I've never warped a rotor, but I have had to change alot due to corrosion or pitting. The rotors either develop pits that can't be turned out or the corrosion gets under the friction surface.

A lot of OEM GM rotors and pads now have a special anti corrosion coating (that looks like primer). The coating prevents the non-contact areas from rusting away on the rotor.

On the pads, the coating on the sides helps stop the material from wicking in too much water. On rear disc brakes, the parking brake forces the pad up against the rotor. If the pad is wet or wicks in moisture, it's held up against the rotor causing it to pit. Eventually, the pits get deeper giving the rotor a "warped" feel. The pits can't be machined out, so a new rotor will be required.

That being said, an OEM GM rotor can go for $150 while a premium Can Tire rotor goes for $70. A cheap Can tire rotor is $25
 
Bendix from Western auto have always been superb..Much better than the OEM stuff.
My Last two Brake jobs ( Mine and My wife's car) replaced the OEM stuff with the most expensive (But still reasonable) NAPA house brand.
I got 90,000 KM on the OEM and dammed near 150,000 on the NAPA.
 
The parts themselves will last years, but you still need to have them maintained at least on an annual basis. At least.
 
be sure to have your local Lordco Auto Parts store deliver your parts.. they have the hottest delivery chicks!
 
l69norm said:
I try to use factory OEM, depending on their price and quality.

I was using the cheapest Can Tire rotors with decent pads, but I found I was going through them every year.

I've never warped a rotor, but I have had to change alot due to corrosion or pitting. The rotors either develop pits that can't be turned out or the corrosion gets under the friction surface.

A lot of OEM GM rotors and pads now have a special anti corrosion coating (that looks like primer). The coating prevents the non-contact areas from rusting away on the rotor.

On the pads, the coating on the sides helps stop the material from wicking in too much water. On rear disc brakes, the parking brake forces the pad up against the rotor. If the pad is wet or wicks in moisture, it's held up against the rotor causing it to pit. Eventually, the pits get deeper giving the rotor a "warped" feel. The pits can't be machined out, so a new rotor will be required.

That being said, an OEM GM rotor can go for $150 while a premium Can Tire rotor goes for $70. A cheap Can tire rotor is $25

Did they try to sell you new rotors because of rust in the cooling vents? That is the oldest ripoff trick in the book.

The steel alloy used in the rotors rusts naturally, and the rotors themselves are designed to withstand the corrosion, from the strength point of view. As for corrosion on the braking surfaces, I have run all my cars with this, with no loss of braking power. Heck, after every rainfall, the surfaces corrode! The first time you use the brakes, the rust rubs off.

Be very careful, there are a lot of ripoff artists out there when it comes to brakes. Find a trustworthy mechanic, or go to a good dealership. Lose muffler places, tire shops and the like. They all either ripped me off or tried to. One had to pay me back for all the unnnecessary work. As for parts quality, there are a lot of good parts and a lot of substandard crap, sold by every service shop. Unless you know which is which, you need to trust your mechanic.
 
If you are doing them yourself use the mid-ranged priced equiptment.
 
shakenbake said:
Did they try to sell you new rotors because of rust in the cooling vents? That is the oldest ripoff trick in the book. ...The steel alloy used in the rotors rusts naturally, and the rotors themselves are designed to withstand the corrosion, from the strength point of view. As for corrosion on the braking surfaces, I have run all my cars with this, with no loss of braking power. Heck, after every rainfall, the surfaces corrode! The first time you use the brakes, the rust rubs off....

I do my own brakes and I change out rotors when they pulse (pitted) or are severely corroded.

I think it depends on what car you have (FWD vs. RWD).

When I say badly corroded, I mean that the friction surfaces (shiny part the pads travel over) of the rotor are starting to disentegrate and pieces the size of your little pinky nail are coming off in your hand. At that point, the rotor is not safe to use.

Pitting from the pads can also be bad too. I once parked a car for 3 weeks at the airport and by the time I got back, the rotors were ruined from pitting. The pitting occurs on the part of the rotor that is left sitting underneath the pads. The remainder of the rotor friction surface that is exposed to air is fine with just a little surface rust. Water wicks in and is trapped between the pad and the rotor. It gives you the same feeling as if the rotor is warped because the friction changes. You can fix it temporarily by grinding/sanding it smooth, but the pulsation will return eventually. The only fix is to change out the rotor (most shops will refuse to turn rotors that are pitted)

A coated rotor = $150 each = 3-4 years life. A non-coated (cheap) rotor = $25 each = 1-2 years life.

The cheapie rotors are less expensive for me in total because my labor is free, but it's a pain swapping them out when they go bad in the middle of winter. If you are paying for labor, it's a different story.

BTW, I'm now using "Monore" brand premium rotors ($70 each) and pads ($70 set) from Can Tire. It's was a Sunday afternoon, they had these in stock and I didn't want to wait till Monday.
 
All rotors are made poorly today compared to 20-30 years ago. They rust early now because the nickel content is lower than in the past, think planned obsolescence and poorly designed on purpose. Years ago I usually got 100,000 miles out of most and you could have them turned a couple times. Not anymore!
Plus most of the junk rotors now come from China.
I always do my own brake jobs because it is so easy to get ripped off today.
I can do it myself for $50-70 while the same work would cost $200-350 at many shops. Brake jobs scams are the easiest to pull off today because people know so little about them.
 
pjoe43 said:
Plus most of the junk rotors now come from China.
I always do my own brake jobs because it is so easy to get ripped off today.
.

Lot's of Do-it-Yourselfer's on US car forums love the Chinese EverWear rotors @ $10 each - they're so cheap they just replace them every year since the labour is free - they figure it's better to have cheapie brakes brand new every year instead of leaving slightly better brakes to dimish over 2-3 years for the same money. It makes some sense if the car is not high-perfomance and if it's an older car whith an uncertain future.

All rotors are made poorly today compared to 20-30 years ago. They rust early now because the nickel content is lower than in the past, think planned obsolescence and poorly designed on purpose. Years ago I usually got 100,000 miles out of most and you could have them turned a couple times. Not anymore!

There probably is some deliberate, built-in wear propensity with many factory rotors. With most brands having the goal to cycle customers into a new model every 3-4 years, the discs have to wear faster in order to provide the service departments the chance to score at least one replacement and a couple of resurfacing jobs in that short period of time.

Also contributing is the trend of offering increasingly open sports rims as standard features, leaving nearly the whole disc and brake mechanism exposed to road dirt, water and salt, which can only increase the need for service. All things being equal, brake systems will last longer on cars with steel rims & wheel covers.

Faster brake wear is also a side effect from reduced engine braking that I've noticed in automatic transmissions on many newer models. Todays automatics tend to glide more when you let off the throttle - probably for fuel economy purposes - this is subtle enough that most people are totally unaware of the change in their driving technique.