Canceling home phone and using cell question.

stinkynuts

Super
Jan 4, 2005
8,939
3,220
113
Right now I have dsl, a land line, and a cell. I must have Internet, but the cell and land line seem redundant. I know many people who have just a cell.

Problem is that I have dsl, and I can't have dsl Interne without a land line. So I'm stuck with paying all three bills.

I just overheard some people talking about this, and they were talking about getting cable Internet access. This way I can cancel my dsl and land line, and use my cell. This would save me about $500 per year (maybe less since I would have to upgrade my cell phone service to have more free time).

Are there any disadvantages to doing this? I want to make sure there are no drawbacks before I cancel my services and get a new one.

Thanks in advance.
 
I have had only a cell for a couple years & use cable.. but I am anxiously waiting for wireless broadband.. it will cost ($24.99/month) just a little more than 1/2 of internet over cable
 
Last edited:
The only drawback I've heard -- and I don't know if they've fixed it yet or not -- is with 9-1-1 service. If you call 911 from your landline, they know the address you're calling from immediately. This could be important if you are choking, or losing consciouness, and can't talk. If you're calling from a cell, how do they know where you are? Newer phones with GPS?
 
Cels are still too unreliable like 90 - 95% reliable while land lines are 99.9 percent reliable.
 
Viewer said:
The only drawback I've heard -- and I don't know if they've fixed it yet or not -- is with 9-1-1 service. If you call 911 from your landline, they know the address you're calling from immediately. This could be important if you are choking, or losing consciouness, and can't talk. If you're calling from a cell, how do they know where you are? Newer phones with GPS?


That is a very serious drawback. It's not impossible that I will need to dial 911 and yet not be able to talk. I don't think my life is worth saving a few hundred per year. However, the odds of something like that happening are pretty slim. If I were a senior, then yes, having a cell without a landline makes no sense, since the odds of needing 911 goes up dramatically.

As for the reliabilty issue, that is also a concern. In the future I will be using the phone for finding jobs. If I lose a call because of a bad connection, that could cost me a job.

It's a hard choice....
 
I provide a variety of technical services to a major wireless carrier and let me tell you, these devices are far more convenient when they work but still flakier than their predecessors. And what do the clients rely on to obtain the support they need? Land lines and pay phones.
 
You might want to check, but at least in the States, most phone companies are required to accommodate 911 service even if you have no phone services. Meaning, if you plug a phone into a household jack, the *only* thing you will be able to dial is 911.
 
stinkynuts said:
... It's not impossible that I will need to dial 911 and yet not be able to talk. ..


Just about any cellphone made in the past couple of years can do something called "e-911". The cell companies use special software (in the phones) and GPS (in the cell towers) and can locate a cellphone to about 200 meters.

http://www.bell.ca/support/PrsCSrvWls_E911_safety.page

On Bell cell phones, there's an options to turn off sending of location; send only on 911; or always send location.

Bell used to have a paid service where you can track the location a cell phone on the internet for business applications like delivery trucks, taxis, etc

http://www.bell.ca/shopping/WLS05.details?ADV5=OFF_CDN_FINDERSERVICES

I would think Rogers and Telus can do the same...
 
I tried the cell only thing and my bill skyrocketed.

And I really am not one to talk a lot on the phone.

I kept my cell and had the most basic phone package for a land line and it was actually cheaper that way.

My cell plan does suck though.
 
This...

MuffinMuncher said:
You might want to check, but at least in the States, most phone companies are required to accommodate 911 service even if you have no phone services. Meaning, if you plug a phone into a household jack, the *only* thing you will be able to dial is 911.


...is not true. If there is no dial tone NO call will go through.

You might be thinking of wireless services / providers....who are required to route your emergency (911) call whether your service is terminated or not...
 
Do you use long distance much? That might be a consideration. I know there has been a little bit of complaints on here about Rogers, but...

I have high speed Internet, digital TV (over 200 channels) and Rogers home phone. And I have no complaints. For cell I use TELUS pay as you go plan. For last couple of years I only had my cell and again Rogers’s cable/internet. Now I got Rogers home phone because they have a package with unlimited long distance (Can/USA unlimited) and they gave us a special package deal. I can't remember how much it is right now cause it's all in my landlady's name and I just pay my share every month. But I know it's a good deal. Just call Rogers and ask about a bundle for everything you want.
 
As I understand it, DSL services are now unbundled from the phone service, meaning you should be able to have DSL with having to also pay for the phone service.

The last time a sympatico sales person came to my door trying to switch me from cable I said I don't have a phone service, just a non functioning phone jack.

He said that's ok, you don't need an active phone anymore.

He may have been lying, but I believe this is true now.
 
stinkynuts said:
That is a very serious drawback. It's not impossible that I will need to dial 911 and yet not be able to talk. I don't think my life is worth saving a few hundred per year. However, the odds of something like that happening are pretty slim. If I were a senior, then yes, having a cell without a landline makes no sense, since the odds of needing 911 goes up dramatically.

As for the reliabilty issue, that is also a concern. In the future I will be using the phone for finding jobs. If I lose a call because of a bad connection, that could cost me a job.

It's a hard choice....

911 over the cell works well

you have a GPS locator chip in most new cells and you will have little lag time
 
I've been using only a cell phone for the past 3 & a 1/2 years and i don't miss the landline at all. I have cable internet connection, so during the day i use Skpye to make calls and check voicemail ( even from my laptop ) and worst case if i miss a phone call the person leaves a message on the cell.

my 2 cents

View
 
I have cable internet and a cell.

Cable internet is not that expensive anymore. and if you good reception with your cell at your home then go with a cell there is soo many rate plans out there that offer free incoming calls and unilimited nights and weekends after 6pm.

Telus has a great plan I use thier plan for work. free income locall and unilmited nights and weekends for about 30 a month then 15 a month for thier bundle package for caller id and voice mail.

then of cours fido has thier urban plan, but thier reception is not the greatest then bell mobility just added in thier free incoming planning as well.

so now you have options to have one phone again.
 
For $10 you can get dummy land line service from Bell. You don't get a phone # and if you plug a phone into it, you can't make calls, but you can use it for internet access, and you don't have to use Bell Sympatico as your ISP either. I'm not sure whether it works for alarms, but probably. Call Bell and they'll give you the options.