Canadian Banks

dcbogey

New member
Sep 29, 2004
3,169
0
0
Which, if any, of the Canadian banks will be the first to decrease their dividend? With BMO's latest common share offering the yield, assuming you can get in @ $30, is 9.3% :eek:
Even RBC is yielding 5.8%. Looks VERY interesting when a 10 yr BoC bond is paying around 3%.
Is this a value trap or the opportunity of a generation?
 
You have me thinking there. The little research I have done shows that BMO is still in a healthy position up and including the last quarter. In fact the third quarter of 2008 was better than the third quarter of 2007. It seems to me that they have been caught up in the general negative sentiment surrounding the financial industry. It is a stated policy of BMO that 45 to 55% of earnings are distributed as dividends so if the earnings hold up I see no reason for them to lower their dividend.

I hope others chime in here. I'll be watching this thread with interest (no pun intended).

Edit: It looks like their earnings were actually down somewhat from 3rd 1/4 2007 to 3rd 1/4 2008. My other comments still stand though. The reduction in share price is out of proportion to the reduction in earnings. They can afford to pay the dividend although it looks like the distribution would be more like 60% of earnings rather than the stated 45 - 55% (assuming I understand the figures - not sure of the effect of preferred shares on my calculations). It would be a very negative thing for them to reduce the dividend payout. Have they done this before?
 
Dropping a dividend is a kiss of death. I cannot foresee that they will do that (now watch them drop them this week...)

Timbit
 
I agree that decreasing the dividend for any of the big 5 would be a very bad thing for the share price. The question I have - Why are they raising their capital ratios so far above the required level? One possibility - raising cash to go shopping south of the border OR here at home? Are bank mergers a possibility in Canada in the semi-near future?
 
CIBC is typically the one that opens itself up to bad investments , and this tiome is no different I would look long and hard at it
 
As interest rates decline buy stock that pays a good dividend. Old adage and works too.
 
dcbogey said:
Why are they raising their capital ratios so far above the required level?

10% Tier 1 Capital is basically what the global market is now demanding. With all the banks that have been in trouble globally, not meeting this causes other banks to wonder and less likely to do interbank lending.

What (IMHO) really demonstrates the strength of Canada's banks is that while other countries banks have basically had to run to their governments and have them take a direct stake in their banks to raise their capital levels, banks here are still able to go out to the market (RBC, TD, BMO) to raise additional capital! This shows the strength of our FI's, which is inherently a good thing for us all (except the chronic bank bashers, who seem to want to see one of our bank's fail!?)
 
But if the stock prices keep falling, you really believe they pay 15-20% returns. Even 10% is very high.

BMO is issuing more shares to raise cash, that pushed the stock price down more today. Now there is new talk of more banks losing to the 50 billion fraud in NY.

Then there is the weak Canada dollar, you factor in that compare to the US dollar the Canada bank stocks aren't doing well in terms of stock prices. (not that the US banks are any better)


I said in the start of 2008 to buy CD's...but not from which country...anybody who brought cd's in US dollars from a US bank is doing pretty darn well even thou on paper its paying 2% (if you were to cash them in to Canadian dollars today.
 
S.C. Joe said:
But if the stock prices keep falling, you really believe they pay 15-20% returns. Even 10% is very high.

BMO is issuing more shares to raise cash, that pushed the stock price down more today. Now there is new talk of more banks losing to the 50 billion fraud in NY.

Then there is the weak Canada dollar, you factor in that compare to the US dollar the Canada bank stocks aren't doing well in terms of stock prices. (not that the US banks are any better)


I said in the start of 2008 to buy CD's...but not from which country...anybody who brought cd's in US dollars from a US bank is doing pretty darn well even thou on paper its paying 2% (if you were to cash them in to Canadian dollars today.

See I strongly disagree. Buying CD's is such a waste of money. Ipods are the wave of the future...and since when do you buy CD's from a bank? I used to get mine from HMV back in the day.

Weird shit
 
A cd is worth as much today as it was in the start of 2008.....name 5 stocks (wait make that one ha ha that is worth as much today or more that 12 months ago.:cool: ...there has to be a few but very few.
 
What CD's are worth as much though? I mean if you look at the Fall Out Boy cd, it wasn't even out at the start of 2008 so obvioulsy it is worth MORE today than it was at the start of 2008.

I'm not following here...
 
Surfbum84 said:
See I strongly disagree. Buying CD's is such a waste of money. Ipods are the wave of the future...and since when do you buy CD's from a bank? I used to get mine from HMV back in the day.

Weird shit

LOL!! :D

Surfkid -- GICs are called CDs in the US.
 
Serpent said:
LOL!! :D

Surfkid -- GICs are called CDs in the US.



Don't feel bad, I am likely twice your age and didn't know Canada had a different name for GIC's-CD's...


I gets that way sometimes, somethings are the same between the USA and Canada and other stuff is not even close.
 
S.C. Joe said:
Then there is the weak Canada dollar, you factor in that compare to the US dollar the Canada bank stocks aren't doing well in terms of stock prices. (not that the US banks are any better)

Actually, a weaker CDN dollar significantly helps us in this environment! It makes our exports much cheaper and drives our overall productivity higher. It's true that the rules of the game may have changed for our manufacturing sector, with protectionism raising its head in the US with all of the bailouts, but the fact remains it is significantly cheaper for companies to manufacture in Canada than in the US, simply because of our dollar! And for the few CDN companies earning US dollars (mostly banks), it gives us a significant increase in ROE.

Truthfully, I think a weaker CDN dollar vs. US dollar is inherently good for Canada! Not necessarily true for many individuals, but it is true for the country as a whole.
 
Historically, the Canadian banks always surpass their previous highs after every downturn. Will this be the exception in the 200 year history of BMO? Time will tell. You pay your money and take your chances. YMMV.
 
I tend to think of RBC and TD as the best run banks in the country but I've not done any analysis of the financials in a few years.....

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I tend to think of RBC and TD as the best run banks

I recently applied for a $10,000 line of credit (to finance my SC addiction) at one of these banks and it is amazing the vast amount of due diligence the bank did on me (including a DNA sample) so how is it possible that they lose billions in crappy loans like the ABCP's?