Canada's contribution to N.O.

kooley

meh
Oct 7, 2002
1,229
0
36
toronto
Ok so we are sending 4 ships 1000 personnel and 3 sea king choppers. Now no joke here but what if one of these things falls out of the air full of refugees, as we all know they are more than prone to doing?
 
I heard that they sent the 4 ships, and I guess Canada's total coastline is now defenseless since thats all of Canada's navy. It's great they helped out, but Canada's navy is pathetic.

Ciao,

VT
 
better than nothing...they need anything and everything they can get
 
Canada Quickly Responds to U.S. Disaster

Since I am in Victoria B.C. I am seeing the massive coverage in the Canadian media and their views.

Most Canadians (as well as many Americans) despise the Bush Administration, not only for its lies for going to Iraq and creating increased hatred of West resulting in more terrorists, but closer to home what they consider totally unfair softwood import duties/restrictions which is a very serious issue for Canadians. Despite this they show overwhelming not only desire but action to help in the Katrina disaster.

The Canadian Red Cross is sending many workers on Canadian Air Force Transports. Donations from Canadians are pouring in. Air Canada is sent among other assets an A321 Airbus from Toronto capable of carrying 166 passengers plus 5600 kg of relief supplies. After unloading relief supplies in New Orleans, it is shuttling back and forth airlifting evacuees to Lackland Airforce Base in San Antonio Texas.

Many other civilian and military assets are ready to go to the Gulf, but as Zuwenda Rodibas of Emergency Preparedness Canada says, "But we need them to ask for it first." One Canadian official said, "the U.S. has been unable to co-ordinate its own resources, let alone accept an influx of foreign assistance...They can't even get their own people in there,." noting it took at least five days before food, water and other relief supplies started to get to those that needed it. It seems the U.S. military had such supplies to the Asian Tsamani victims in 12 hours but took 5 days for a homeland disaster.

Skylink Aviation is also ready and willing to send in air lift assistance but as its President said, "It seems that the U.S. government is not yet in the position to even ask for help because I think they don't know what they are doing," he said. Skylink was responsible for bringing about 2000 refugees from Kosovo to Canada to stay temporarily in a Canadian Forces base.

Skylink has also been contacted by the Italian government to help getting aid in from Italy, but has been told by U.S. Admin while they appreciate the offer but are not in a position to receive it. "I don't think they know where to begin", said the Skylink President.

B'nai Birth Canada is organizing a clothing drive in all major Canadian cities saying after the emergency needs are met, "the need for clothing will become acute for families that have lost everything," said Gerry Weinstein, the national president of the Jewish group.

Vancouver's urban rescue team was on the ground in New Orleans, prior to substantive National guard forces. Granted, they are not able to do much because they cannot travel anywhere without military or police protection. They are held up because it is like a war like zone of snipper gun fire and anarchy in New Orleans.

But there is no one to provide protection since police were long ago overwhelmed and unable to even protect themselves, and regular U.S. military can not actively act to assist local police due to the Posse Comitatus Act of 1878. The Coast Guard is not under the Posse Comitatus restrictions and most of the initial rescue work was a U.S. Coast Guard operation.

Knowing the U.S. has so many resources in Iraq, ironically the CANADIAN armed forces tracked Hurricane Katrina and started preparing plans to deal with a potential devastation. "We're not going to sit around and have a request come in and say, "Oh, we'll need four or five more days to get ready", said General Hillier, Chief of Canadian Defence.

With what many Canadians say is a dismally small military - Three Canadian warships and a coast guard vessel with relief supplies are ready to go to the U.S. Gulf Coast if requested by the Bush Admin. The Coast Guard vessel will support the Canadian Navy in the amphibious rescue operations with equipment such as pumps, generators and medical supplies. In addition, the vessel carries 2 fast response craft, a helicopter and other vessels.

The Canadian mission, dubbed Operation Union, is expected to provide humanitarian aid, along with divers, and engineering expertise for reconstruction.Three Sea King helicopters will be on the ships to ferry personnel into the devastated areas.

All this is preparing to leave Canada to the Gulf BEFORE the U.S. agrees to accept the help, so if they are allowed to help they will be there! Yes this is a tiny addition to the huge amount of assets the U.S. SHOULD have (if its not all in Iraq).

Continued
 
Continuation:

For Canada it might be a good training exercise and they would love to show up the U.S. on how something should be done. As discussed on a Canadian board, Vancouver could be subject to the same type of natural disaster from an earthquake. The city of Richmond is below sea level and could be wiped out by an earthquake created flood. Canada would need massive U.S. assistance to deal with such a large natural disaster. It makes sense to have a good relationship of mutual aid between neighbors if Bush isn't to proudful and arrogant to accept the help offered.

As a Canadian said "National Guard were the wrong troops to deploy to patrol the flooded streets of NO. The Marines with their Canadian built LAV-25's (yah that's a shameless plug) and AAV7A1's would have been my choice. And quite frankly martial law should have been declared."
 
VincenzoTurismo said:
I heard that they sent the 4 ships, and I guess Canada's total coastline is now defenseless since thats all of Canada's navy. It's great they helped out, but Canada's navy is pathetic.

Ciao,

VT

Canadian Navy has over 30 warships, believe it or not. If you think our Navy is pathetic, then write your member of parliament and complain that the military is underfunded, instead of just insulting the sailors who, while we sit here chatting about which escort gives the best bbbj, have left their homes and families with about a days' notice, and are sailing towards New Orleans to help out our neighbours.
 
bayisle66 said:
Canadian Navy has over 30 warships, believe it or not. If you think our Navy is pathetic, then write your member of parliament and complain that the military is underfunded, instead of just insulting the sailors who, while we sit here chatting about which escort gives the best bbbj, have left their homes and families with about a days' notice, and are sailing towards New Orleans to help out our neighbours.

Well said. The men and women of the millitary deserve your support.


We here in the US are thankfull for the support.
 
Dave in Phoenix said:
Continuation:

As a Canadian said "National Guard were the wrong troops to deploy to patrol the flooded streets of NO. The Marines with their Canadian built LAV-25's (yah that's a shameless plug) and AAV7A1's would have been my choice. And quite frankly martial law should have been declared."

Dave

From what I know of the CONUS military structure, the "Guard" are the only troops that the Governor can "order" to sevice. And if those "Guard" units are not of a Marine or SAR nature; well as you can see they can't do the job as well as need, but dear god they are trying.

The people had to wait for Mr Bush to get his PR people working for "photo ops"! It took him far less time to go to war. I think everyone would like to know why he took so long to react. The local Governors acted as quickly as possible, with what they had.

I don't know if any DART personel are heading down the Disaster zone. This is just the type of job they are suited for. I for one wouldn't want to ride a "SEA KING" into any disaster zone. I've have a few firends who have crashed in them and they don't recommand the experience.

Doesn't the US have a large Marine presents in CUBA and some other southeren state? They should have sent in their assest in within 24 hours.
At least a Hospital ship!

I do hope FEMA cleans it's own house and puts people in charge that can do the job and not let this happen again. If they new things could have been improved and they didn't do a thing, well I think some heads should roll :D

Regards

Mack
 
no title

papasmerf said:
Well said. The men and women of the millitary deserve your support.


As I read the recent posts regarding the Canadian Navy, I truly am sadden about some of your views. When someone says that our Navy is pathetic, or "What Navy, we have a Navy?" It really shows the ignorance of some of the people who call themselves Canadian.
I've been in the Navy for over 23 years and still at it. It's been very good to me and I am very proud of what I do. I've spent time away from home, a couple of times being overseas during the Gulf War, spending Christmas at sea under a Canadian Flag and receiving cards and greeting from school kids.
Believe me it very heartwarming to know we're thought of when away from home. It's not our choice to be where we're sent but we go. Many of us volenteer for deployments.
I do....
I'm one of the members going to the Gulf region on Tuesday. I will be on HMCS Toronto
No details have been released of our mission, nor would I speculate it on here or anywhere.
Life is not easy but we all try to be the best we can. The Navy is more and more supportive of the need of its members.
I was one of the ones picking body pieces out of St. Margaret's Bay when Swiss Air 111 fell from the sky.
I was a little fucked up after that. Imagine gathering clothes and toys and shoes........shoes attached to severed limbs. Imagine that, countless unidentifyable pieces. We, the ones assigned with the more unpleasant tasks
spents weeks and sometimes months in counseling, trying to cope and deal with the experiences we encountered.
Thanks for letting me vent......it brought back memories.
 
Be Proud of the Canadian Military

As a Canadian, I want to say that I am proud of the accomplishments of the Canadian military. We should be supportive of the me and women in the Canadian military and try to understand the difficult situation that confronts the decision makers. The role of the military has changed and evolved dramatically over the last four decades. Unfortunately, the decisions about equipping the military have not taken into account rapid changes to the roles that are asked of the military. Canadians have been unwilling to spend the required portio of the federal budget to adequately equip the military for all circumstances. Nevertheless, the capabilities of the military are to be respected.

The difficult question for the Canadian public is where to cut spendig to make more fuds available to the military. I favour cutting social spending by 5% to make more money available to the military.
 
I don't think we should get help from other countries. We should just send a bill to Bill Gates, Donald Trump, Ted Turner, Jessica Simpson, Paris Hilton, Jennifer Aniston, Brad Pitt, Alex Rodriguez, Tiger Woods, Kobe Bryant, etc. They can afford it. Angelina Jolie can adopt some New Orleans kids to round out her collection. And Hollywood needs to come up with someone else who cares, besides Sean Penn, who's the only celebrity gracing the Gulf Coast with his presence.
 
Last edited:
You should scratch Jose Canseco off your list and maybe replace him with Alex Rodriguez. Jose was pretty much bankrupt or near bankruptcy, and the only reason he has alittle bit of cash right now is from his book as well as doing the 5th season of The Surreal Life.

Ciao,

VT
 
Winston said:
He can easily add a 500 million one time expendature to help bring housing and other issues up to date, add 1 Billion a year to spending.

No can do....all that surplus is earmarked for the gun registry boondoggle. :p