Canada Leaving Afghanistan

SkyRider

Banned
Mar 31, 2009
17,546
2
0
Afghanistan is a much better place than it was 12 years ago when Canadians first arrived. Many more girls/women attending school, much more human and women's rights, much better health care, etc. But, we can't stay forever.

To our Afghan friends, good bye and good luck.
 
Afghanistan is a much better place than it was 12 years ago when Canadians first arrived. Many more girls/women attending school, much more human and women's rights, much better health care, etc. But, we can't stay forever.

To our Afghan friends, good bye and good luck.

Can I have some of what your smoking ? Other than heroin production increasing by 98%. How are things improved ?

BS
 
The war cost the lives of 158 soldiers, one diplomat, one journalist and two civilian contractors.
 
Mission scope creep. We went in legitimately to end the use of Afghan territory by Al Qaeda. That was achieved pretty early on.

We then tried to fix everything wrong with the country, make it a democracy, and eradicate the Taliban. All laudable but the mission never had the resources to succeed and the money likely could have been put to better use elsewhere.

Afghanistan is not the only country with issues and not the only one harboring Al Qaeda. There were better ways to make the world a better place and better ways to fight terror.
 
Can I have some of what your smoking ? Other than heroin production increasing by 98%. How are things improved ?

BS
SkyRider already named some.

The problem is crops for which there is a ready cash market - it isn't that Afghan farmers love Opium it is rather that it is the crop from which they can make the greatest profit to support their families.
 
Should have been out of there 10 years ago.
 
SkyRider already named some.

The problem is crops for which there is a ready cash market - it isn't that Afghan farmers love Opium it is rather that it is the crop from which they can make the greatest profit to support their families.

If I could grow opium I could make a tidy profit to support my family as well, even if I had to grow it hydroponically in winterized greenhouses and such, it would be quite profitable but for the years I would serve in prison.
 
If I could grow opium I could make a tidy profit to support my family as well, even if I had to grow it hydroponically in winterized greenhouses and such, it would be quite profitable but for the years I would serve in prison.
You have plenty of other options, a farmer in Afghanistan on the other hand.

Right there is summarized the problem of telling Afghan farmers that they shouldn't grow opium poppies without providing them an equally profitable market for alternative crops.
 
You have plenty of other options, a farmer in Afghanistan on the other hand.

Right there is summarized the problem of telling Afghan farmers that they shouldn't grow opium poppies without providing them an equally profitable market for alternative crops.

They've been trying, and apparently there have been some successes although infrastructure etc. are a major issue.

The key to the ministry's success, according to Dwyer and many other experts involved, lies in the development of what are known as high-value, high-volume orchard crops. What makes products like pomegranates, almonds and especially grapes so exciting, experts say, is that a plot of these legal gems can be five times more profitable than an equivalent-size plot of poppies. The drawback, however, is start-up time. "How long does it take to do each one? Therein lies the dilemma," says Dwyer, who helps run the Accelerating Sustainable Agriculture Program at a demonstration and training farm on the outskirts of Kabul.
To the impoverished farmer, it's no contest. Poppies, which are cultivated to produce opium, are an annually harvested crop. The establishment of a grape vineyard could take three to five years, says Dwyer. Compound that with the fact that poppy growers face a strong market and get monetary guarantees from their buyers up front, and there's little incentive to switch to the legal stuff. "Until now, I don't believe there has been an adequate focus on how long it takes to break that annual cycle of production," Dwyer says.
But the production cycle is only part of the problem. Even with a recent poppy blight that has wiped out 70% of this year's illicit crop, most say physical security continues to factor most prominently in any rehabilitation of the legal agricultural sector. In southern Afghanistan, which includes the country's historic breadbasket province of Helmand, a deteriorating security situation over the past year because of heavy fighting between NATO forces and Taliban insurgents has made development in many areas difficult, if not impossible. "To be honest, very little efforts have happened there," says Khalid Pashtoon, a member of parliament from the Taliban's southern stronghold of Kandahar.
Basic infrastructure including roads, electricity and packaging centers is also essential if high-value crops are going to reap any real profits — another step that has been typically overlooked in the hype over expanding production, according to Mohamed Hasham Aslami, an expert in saffron-farming with the Danish aid organization DACAAR in the western city of Herat.
Saffron is also a high-value crop: one kilogram can fetch $2,000 to $3,000 in the local market, says Aslami. That compares to just over $90 a kilogram for poppies. But, he adds, "The Agriculture Ministry focuses on production only. The farmer's problem is processing, development, getting a brand and entering the international market ... There is no clear international marketing system in Afghanistan for saffron."


Read more: Afghan Poppy Farms: Little Take-Up for Alternative Crops - TIME http://content.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1991283,00.html#ixzz2vnZ1Ei82
 
legalize poppy cultivation.

there's a shortage of opioid anesthetics in the world, farmers can benefit.

it's a win-win.
 
Talk to a Canadian who fought there... And don't give me that "brain washed" crap. Al Qaeda was never eradicated as it was essentially a guerrilla war with uneducated peasants caught in the middle with corrupt chieftains.

However, EVERY SINGLE Canadian soldier, sailor (yes they were there too), Air Force personnel, private contractor and civilian that was there that I have had the distinct privilege to talk candidly to says, "We made a big difference to the lives of the Afghan people in many, many, many ways." Ways that were not possible by diplomacy, UN observers, aid missions, etc. And, "by taking the fight to the terrorists we did not have to fight them on our soil!"

I'm pretty sure that this was the same sentiment of my father, uncles, aunts and they're comrades who returned from a burned up and busted up Europe after WWII as part of Canada's military.

In every war or "police action" our military pays an awful price in lost and damaged lives both physically and psychologically but we can be proud of the honourable men and women who put on helmets, fatigues and the Canadian flag proudly on their shoulder and for them, I am eternally grateful!
Amen!
What a shame.
All that effort,money,lost lives and goodwill and for what? Really.
I will bet anyone, once the US leaves as well , Afghanistan will revert back to the shithole it was and is destined to be.
It is always so easy to destroy , but hard as hell to create and build a lasting democracy with values and human rights.
It may take 2,5,10 years, but the thugs and religious fanatics will come back to take over again.
The UN can huff + puff until they turn blue and die, but they can not fix this.
 
You have plenty of other options, a farmer in Afghanistan on the other hand.

Right there is summarized the problem of telling Afghan farmers that they shouldn't grow opium poppies without providing them an equally profitable market for alternative crops.

Are you saying a soybean grower in Ontario makes as much profit as they could growing opium?
 
Talk to a Canadian who fought there... And don't give me that "brain washed" crap. Al Qaeda was never eradicated as it was essentially a guerrilla war with uneducated peasants caught in the middle with corrupt chieftains.

You are confusing Al Qaeda, the largely non Afgan jihadist network that planned the 9/11 attacks, with the Taliban, an Afghan guerrilla organization that sponsored Al Qaeda when it was the government.

Al Qaeda ceased operating in Afghanistan quite early in the war. The Taliban were never eradicated and are now gaining ground.

Had we limited the mission to kicking Al Qaeda out of Astan, we could have scaled back years ago.

Yes I am sure that Afghan civilians benefited, but there are people in many countries that need help. As a charitable outreach we could have provided more help to more people for less money and without losing Canadian lives somewhere else.
 
What a shame.
All that effort,money,lost lives and goodwill and for what? Really.
I will bet anyone, once the US leaves as well , Afghanistan will revert back to the shithole it was and is destined to be.
It is always so easy to destroy , but hard as hell to create and build a lasting democracy with values and human rights.
It may take 2,5,10 years, but the thugs and religious fanatics will come back to take over again.
The UN can huff + puff until they turn blue and die, but they can not fix this.


If you are right, then its all the more reason for us and other developed democratic nations to help the Afghans get a solid foothold on democracy. We should stay until the job is done.
 
No, talk to the military intel officers. Al Q was still there and in fact they have cells around the world, including Russia.
They didn't just pack up and leave Afghanistan they went underground like any terror cell just like vermin.

The mission in Afghanistan is not a failure, it is to show the people of that country that they can self govern and choose their own destiny without the outside interference of wealthier Arab countries and organizations. There will always be sympathizers and wannabe Al-Qaeda, there will even be deluded home grown individuals like the Boston Marathon bomber kids that moved to the USA and because they were no delivered the American dream they committed horrendous acts of inhumanity to get their promised allotment of virgins.

 
The war cost the lives of 158 soldiers, one diplomat, one journalist and two civilian contractors.

What a tragic waste. After the western powers leave, the country will be back to its usual state again.
 
The war cost the lives of 158 soldiers, one diplomat, one journalist and two civilian contractors.

What a tragic waste. After the western powers leave, the country will be back to its usual state again.

It's only a waste if no change was achieved. If you think no change was achieved, are you saying that none was needed, none is possible or that we should have remained in country longer?
 
Does thay have a permission of USA? Because, as all we know, Canada doing nothing is USA is not agree :P
 
I would hope that with a decade of easier access to education, the Afghan people might be more interested in changing for themselves. It will be a long haul though.