The key to the ministry's success, according to Dwyer and many other experts involved, lies in the development of what are known as high-value, high-volume orchard crops. What makes products like pomegranates, almonds and especially grapes so exciting, experts say, is that a plot of these legal gems can be five times more profitable than an equivalent-size plot of poppies. The drawback, however, is start-up time. "How long does it take to do each one? Therein lies the dilemma," says Dwyer, who helps run the Accelerating Sustainable Agriculture Program at a demonstration and training farm on the outskirts of Kabul.
To the impoverished farmer, it's no contest. Poppies, which are cultivated to produce opium, are an annually harvested crop. The establishment of a grape vineyard could take three to five years, says Dwyer. Compound that with the fact that poppy growers face a strong market and get monetary guarantees from their buyers up front, and there's little incentive to switch to the legal stuff. "Until now, I don't believe there has been an adequate focus on how long it takes to break that annual cycle of production," Dwyer says.
But the production cycle is only part of the problem. Even with a recent poppy blight that has wiped out 70% of this year's illicit crop, most say physical security continues to factor most prominently in any rehabilitation of the legal agricultural sector. In southern Afghanistan, which includes the country's historic breadbasket province of Helmand, a deteriorating security situation over the past year because of heavy fighting between NATO forces and Taliban insurgents has made development in many areas difficult, if not impossible. "To be honest, very little efforts have happened there," says Khalid Pashtoon, a member of parliament from the Taliban's southern stronghold of Kandahar.
Basic infrastructure including roads, electricity and packaging centers is also essential if high-value crops are going to reap any real profits — another step that has been typically overlooked in the hype over expanding production, according to Mohamed Hasham Aslami, an expert in saffron-farming with the Danish aid organization DACAAR in the western city of Herat.
Saffron is also a high-value crop: one kilogram can fetch $2,000 to $3,000 in the local market, says Aslami. That compares to just over $90 a kilogram for poppies. But, he adds, "The Agriculture Ministry focuses on production only. The farmer's problem is processing, development, getting a brand and entering the international market ... There is no clear international marketing system in Afghanistan for saffron."