Canada banning foreign buyers

One acquaintance told me he has seen a whole floor of 1 or 2 bedroom condos bought up by one chinese foriegn national. Not a resident. Then the floor turns into student housing for chinese students. With LV bags and other finery.
It seems that a generation or two of buying goods made off shore, by a labour force earning 5% of what would be earned here generates significant buying power that ends up warping our housing market and partially biting us in the behind.
I'm sure there are other factors, but this one does not help our situation.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: stinkynuts
If you believe the stats, only about 5% of deals are done by foreign buyers. I think they should look at banning companies that buy a lot of these properties to rent out. That's constricting the supply significantly and inflating the price for both rental and sales.

TBH, there are several issues at work in the housing market, and I don't really know how we can make them more affordable. There are few solutions that won't fuck up the entire market. I remember Jim Flaherty as finance minister made it harder to get a mortgage back around 2007/08, but it really didn't do a hell of a lot. I know some friends who've seen the value of their homes jump by $1M in under a decade. That's fucked up and unsustainable!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
My buddy is a property manager for well well funded Guys from India. They set up corporations in Canada for their buying, and if some new laws make things challenging, they will list my buddy as head of the corp. Canadian born citizen.

This is just smoke and mirrors.
 
My buddy is a property manager for well well funded Guys from India. They set up corporations in Canada for their buying, and if some new laws make things challenging, they will list my buddy as head of the corp. Canadian born citizen.

This is just smoke and mirrors.

Exactly there is many ways to go around the ban.

What I would do is heavily tax empty houses and empty condo. Housing should become a right and not just a speculative item to make money on. You buy a house or a condo but leave it empty? You give 25k per year in tax... This would neglect the gain buyers expect to make.

As things go right now my retirement home will be in a small remote village in mexico. Hopefully near the sea. Because once I sell my house I won't be able to buy anything else anyhow...
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
My buddy is a property manager for well well funded Guys from India. They set up corporations in Canada for their buying, and if some new laws make things challenging, they will list my buddy as head of the corp. Canadian born citizen.

This is just smoke and mirrors.
that wont be easy
 
that wont be easy

Not sure what you mean. They already did it with one of their companies to get around the 15% foreign buyers tax.
 
There ways around it as someone mentioned like setting up a company to buy property or getting a resident or citizen to buy on one's behalf.

Students are also exempted and many rich students (chinese , Persian) buy houses and condos.

This won't do much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Exactly there is many ways to go around the ban.

What I would do is heavily tax empty houses and empty condo. Housing should become a right and not just a speculative item to make money on. You buy a house or a condo but leave it empty? You give 25k per year in tax... This would neglect the gain buyers expect to make.

As things go right now my retirement home will be in a small remote village in mexico. Hopefully near the sea. Because once I sell my house I won't be able to buy anything else anyhow...

That is the underlying issue ..it's that housing is financialized ...no govt is going to change the system ..making more supply won't fix the issue because the investors will just scoop it up ...

So the focus needs to be to discourage the demand for housing for financial gain and building supply specifically for housing (apartments), which requires convincing people that renting is acceptable
 
If you believe the stats, only about 5% of deals are done by foreign buyers. I think they should look at banning companies that buy a lot of these properties to rent out. That's constricting the supply significantly and inflating the price for both rental and sales.

TBH, there are several issues at work in the housing market, and I don't really know how we can make them more affordable. There are few solutions that won't fuck up the entire market. I remember Jim Flaherty as finance minister made it harder to get a mortgage back around 2007/08, but it really didn't do a hell of a lot. I know some friends who've seen the value of their homes jump by $1M in under a decade. That's fucked up and unsustainable!!!

Part of the issue is that the beneficial owners are not identified ... Beleeive the fed govt is working on it so that it's nation wide ...that said, BC already has it and it hasn't helped with prices even though it was implemented late 2020


 
  • Like
Reactions: poker

In many American popular states like Florida, Arizona, etc... Capital firm are buying 1/3 of all houses on the market. They go 30% over asking price and do not visit the house. They put up everything for renting. This will soon happen in Canada. Making the divide between the riches and middle/poor classes even higher.

If nothing is done we are heading for future generation of slave renters ... :sick:
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: silentkisser
I am not an expert in this area. This is the kind of shit I think of, but I certainly don’t claim to have the answers here.

Start with taxation. If you are using housing as a vehicle to increase your wealth, it needs to be taxed.

Start confiscating the illegal stuff. Unregistered Air b&b…. Drug houses…. (This one should be popular) and the rentals escorts use.

Stricter rules for use of residential property. It’s zoned “residential” for a reason. We already have hotels and motels.

Cease and desist all new immigration until we have a 10% vacancy rate in the 3 major cities… and for god sakes put a committee together with reps from all 3 levels of gov’t to start actually managing supply and demand once immigration opens back up, as we need immigration.

The Provinces need to put a task force together to start investigating the misdeeds of realtors. Licences need to be taken away, and fines levied. They are the most corrupt cock suckers I have ever seen, and I’m willing to bet the fines alone would pay for the dept, and the staff Xmas party. (Truth be told…. The entire industry needs to be upended with a new way to buy and sell)

Stop allowing realtors to say… “we have another offer, but we can’t disclose the amount”.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SQUAD51
Exactly there is many ways to go around the ban.

What I would do is heavily tax empty houses and empty condo. Housing should become a right and not just a speculative item to make money on. You buy a house or a condo but leave it empty? You give 25k per year in tax... This would neglect the gain buyers expect to make.

As things go right now my retirement home will be in a small remote village in mexico. Hopefully near the sea. Because once I sell my house I won't be able to buy anything else anyhow...
That's how BC does it.
 
Or just impose sale price controls the way we cap rent increases.
 
ainnt going to do squat.

low inventory atm, with a population wanting to buy homes. higher mortgage rates will slow the multiple offers and price extremes. perhaps a slow growth compared to the outrageous growth that happened.

without more new housing being built on a much more massive scale then at current rates growth will continue. new housing would take years of political maneuvering to achieve this to a point where housing could be affordable and or see a price correction.

unless interest rate go up significantly towards double digits I dont see any significant correction.
 
I concur that little will happen.
Som of suggestions will never get traction.
Even the federal ban on foreign purchases is only temporary and then in three years its back. Isn't that special?
The real estate agents are always sought for their input when things get scary, which is the most moronic thing the media can do. The agents are little more than snake oil salesmen who have a financial vested interest in low supply, high demand and high prices. They will never have anything constructive suggestions for change.
Lets agree to stop asking them WTF, and just accept they need to make real estate sales an unattratcive career because ou will work harder for your money.

The most likely items that could get legislated in are
-Eliminate the loop holes for students of rich parents. If they are a student and dad can afford to buy a place, pay a tax equal to 100% of the profit from selling.
Sending your kids to university overseas should not be a money making enterprise.
-Empty house, pay a tax. The bigger the better.
-If you own a home that serves as a rental in the student slums of a university town, you pay 50% of the differencee between what you bought it for and sold it for.
-if you own a second residence thats a cottage, pay a vacant house tax.
-if you own several properties, either rent them out or let family live there for free, pay 50% tax when you sell.
-if you dont live here, you don't own here. Its time we insisted that home owners are invested in the community and not just their MP at election time. They need a place sporadically, they can get a long term lease.

I say this as someone who has watched and particpated in real estate speculation. In the 90"s i saw a lot of real estate agents walk away from $60K deposits on new homes they could not afford to close on or flip. A lot of builders took them to court and got damages.

There are good times and bad times for real estate, but we are in a time of unbridled greed and when the bubble pops, it will be a mess.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jalimon