Can a company do this?

21pro

Crotch Sniffer
Oct 22, 2003
7,829
1
0
Caledon East
My cousin got a termination package from 1 high tech company. So she is left now without a job. In part of the firing package, it states that she cannot go and work for any of a list of competitors, including RIM- which she would like to go work for as it is her hometown and they are currently hiring her position with a higher pay than the last company.

Can a company really fire or layoff it's employees and still dictate where you can and can not look for income to put food on your family's table?

sounds f'ed up to me.
 
Can a company do this? In a word, yes.

It all depends on the initial contract/paperwork signed at the time of hiring or promotion. Non-compete clauses are often parts of standard contracts in a lot of industries. Sadly, they can try to enforce this (usually for a set period of time) and legal action may be the only recourse...

Do a search on non-compete clause or covenant not to compete for more information.

As far as the position with RIM, she should consult an attorney before applying. But if she's interested, she should get on the legal process quickly. Even a temporary injunction could free her up to at least throw her hat in the ring.
 
I have broken every non-compete clause I have ever signed. I do however have enough integrity to not disclose anything I know about my previous employers.
 
Cosigning...

Strongbeau said:
It won`t stand up in court. She can go ahead to RIM if she wants to. She should talk to a labour lawyer, but I`m pretty sure he`ll say the same thing.


...on this.

This is fairly common place amongst high tech companies, but unless your cousin was a senior officer for her previous employer, or a true one of a kind rocket scientist in her industry, she can ignore it, as it will not stand up in court.

Now, what she CANNOT do is start providing insider proprietary information regarding her previous employer. Usually the sort of stuff junior and mid level employees know isn't worth the legal fight for either company (the new or previous employer) so no one is particularly diligent about this, but I HAVE seen people who possessed fairly unique and specific technical or business strategy knowledge get in trouble.
 
It has to do with so called "intellectual property" rights. The former company is concerned that the employee will take his or her knowledge of the former employer to another company and use it against them. As some have said already, that former company CANNOT deny a person a right to make a living. Whether it is in a contract or not, it won't hold up in court. If the person was THAT valuable, they shouldn't have let them go to begin with, or at the very least pay them for a significant period of time once they were let go...
 
Actually CG is correct. I wasn't involved in the actual Non-competition Clause review by an attorney but yeah, it is against the law to deny a person's right to work in their field.

A company could argue that since you signed the employment agreement you agreed to the conditiions but (from what I was told) an item that is illegal cannot be enforced simply because you signed the agreement.

I remember signing one that said I couldn't use any experience I gained by working at said company if I worked at another. Like if I learned how to create complex spreadsheets I couldn't create complex spreadsheets at my next job...lol....
 
Most of the advice given by other posters is correct. The only protection the former employer can get is what the courts refer to as "reasonable protection of its legitamate interests". This level of protection may prevent her from using such proprietory information as customer lists and the companies trade secrets.
A non-comp clause in the initial employment conract will not prevent her from from taking a job with a similar company unless she is using confidential information from her previous employer. HR people at her new company would be sensitive to the issue.
 
Non-compete agreements are always by the courts balanced by the
legitimate need for the employee to be able to make a living.
 
Captain Fantastic said:
Can a company do this? In a word, yes.

It all depends on the initial contract/paperwork signed at the time of hiring or promotion. Non-compete clauses are often parts of standard contracts in a lot of industries. Sadly, they can try to enforce this (usually for a set period of time) and legal action may be the only recourse...

Do a search on non-compete clause or covenant not to compete for more information.

As far as the position with RIM, she should consult an attorney before applying. But if she's interested, she should get on the legal process quickly. Even a temporary injunction could free her up to at least throw her hat in the ring.

NO

Non compete clauses (which are easily circumvented) can only stipulate that you can not start your own competing business and lure clients away from your previous employer, or use technical secrets, etc. (Virtually impossible to prove).

They typically apply to share holders / owners, not employees. For example, if you are a minority shareholder in a company, that company will often times have you sign a noncompete clause which says that if you leave, you can't start your own company in the same field (and it will specify exactly what qualifies as competition) for a certain period of time - usually 3 years. It will also set out reasonable penalties if you. It can not, however, prevent you from quitting your position and working as an employee of another company.

You can not restrain someone from making a living. It's not legal.

At most, they would have given her a severance package with strings attached. However, no severance package, no strings. Furthermore, the victim who would be receiving the severance package would simply weigh the bennefits of signing the severance package vs. just going out and finding another job and telling the original employer to go pound salt with their severance package. For example, if she had a line on a good job with RIM, then tell the original employer to fuck righ off, don't sign anything and walk away.
 
james t kirk said:
You can not restrain someone from making a living. It's not legal.

At most, they would have given her a severance package with strings attached. However, no severance package, no strings.

The first part may be true, or it may not. A company get try to get a new employee to sign something that will restrict employment in the event of termination. However, the courts view this is a negative light and will not uphold any agreement that prevents someone from earning a living. It's all in the wording though. An employer might be able to restrict you from working for a competitor for a very limited period of time (say 3-6 months). Anything beyond that and good luck making it enforceable in court.

Also, such a limitation must be geographically specific. Saying across Canada or the province won't fly.

Non-disclosure agreements are much more common and easier to enforce.

So yes, an employer can attempt to get you to agree to a non-compete agreement. The employer must, however, be very reasonable in how extensive that is because when/if it gets challenged the courts will be looking for a reason to shelve it.

As for the severance, severance pay is a statutory requirement under the Employment Standards Act. If the employer meets the criteria (IIRC, $2.5 million payroll and/or 50+ employees) then the employee is entitled. Usually it's around 1 week per year of service.

The employer may be offering a "package" to buy out an employee but it's important to be clear on exactly what that package is for. The employer will usually specify that it accounts for everything they owe (which would include termination pay-in-lieu-of-notice and severance if it's applicable). But you may get those already so don't be signing a non-compete clause for something you're already entitled to.

You need to know how long she worked for the company and her approximate salary to determine if she should hire an employment lawyer. If it's just termination/pay-in-lieu-of-notice and/or severance pay that's at issue (both covered under the ESA), then she should contact the Office of the Worker Advisor at the Ministry of Labour and they can provide free guidance and/or help her get her money.
 
I agree with what eveyone is saying about this. The one thing you have to remember is that the former employer has to find out whether or not the former employee has actually gone to the competitor. Generally speaking, former employers do a lousy job at keeping track of former employees and the information that comes back to the powers to be is usually word of mouth. In that case, it is recommended that unless you can trust your former co-workers it is best not to tell where you are potentially going. This also helps if you are in a lump sum or salary continuation situation.

Also, unless you are in an executive position it is difficult to enforce the non compete clause (for all of the previous statements). In the executive positions you are usually setting company strategy and could have an adverse affect on the former employer's competitive position. It is common for executives to go to the competitor but goes to a non competing division of the new company. Then waits out the non compete clause. There is usually releases and other fancy paperwork that must accompany.

My 2 cents on this!
 
ensue that your cousin understands that while the non compete clause may be basically unenforcable any disclosure of company information will probably get her sued. Make sure that her new employer understands that she will not disclose anything relating to her previous employment. Senior mangment usually understand this but middle level people trying to make their bones may note and might see an oportunity
 
landscaper said:
Make sure that her new employer understands that she will not disclose anything relating to her previous employment. Senior mangment usually understand this but middle level people trying to make their bones may note and might see an oportunity

That's a good point. Even if you signed nothing, most companies own the proprietary rights to everything you were working on when you were with them. So if you invented the wheel at Company A, were terminated, went to Company B, and then reinvented the wheel, you're likely going to have a big problem (or at a minimum your new company will have a big problem and they'll probably end up turfing you as part of the solution).
 
If I quit and walk across the street to the competitor that is fine. If I get turfed and told that my package is X beyond the statutory period then it seems there is a choice. Take the full package or just the statutory amount payable. I think the intent here is that if I take the full package and then immediately get any job not just the one with the competitior then I should not get the amount over the statutory period. I would not have lost anything with the new job.
Lots of folks are going to be getting packages come January and February (I sure would like one myself to be sure)but a new job if you can get it then go for it for the long term protection and career advancement.
 
My experience is that most companies like to have a non-compete just in case, but if they lay someone off, they are just as happy that you got a good job somewhere else. Realistically, who in Canada is in deadly competion with RIM anyway? My guess would be that unless she came in with a hard-drive full of secrets, they are happy enough for her to work there. But if she sued for wrongful dismissal or something, they would have the non-compete violation as one thing for their counter-suit.
 
In addition to what has been mentioned, this varies from Province to Province and State to State.

Another factor to take into account is, how specialized is her knowledge? If you are one of five people in the country who knows how to make widgets and your learned how to do that in the course of your former employment, your former employer may well be able to enforce an Covenant not to Compete.

On the other hand if you are a barber, the enforcement of a covenant not to compete will generally be quite limited if it is even enforceable.
 
Non-competes are generally enforceable if they are reasonable in scope which includes such factors as geographical location, duration, list of competitors. On this last point if she has specialized knowledge/skills that only a few companies can use, and all of these companies are banned in the non-compete clause, then the scope of the clause can be interpretted as too narrow and would prevent her from making a living which a company cannot do. There are many variables at play though including her original contract. It sounds like there may be enough money on the table and she should seek proper legal counsel to review the termination agreement within the context of her particular employment situation.