California's electrical grid has an EV problem

oil&gas

Well-known member
Apr 16, 2002
17,167
3,458
113
Ghawar
May 19, 2022

California energy officials issued a sobering warning this month, telling residents to brace for potential blackouts as the state’s energy grid faces capacity constraints heading into the summer months.

In Sacramento, officials said California’s grid could face a potential shortfall of roughly 1,700 megawatts, which would affect the power supply of between 1 million and 4 million people this summer. That number would likely be exacerbated by an additional shortfall of 5,000 megawatts in the case of extreme heat and further fire damage to existing power lines.

And since the state has committed to phase out all new gas-powered vehicles by 2035 — well ahead of federal targets — the additional load from electric vehicle (EV) charging could add more strain to the electric grid.

“Let’s say we were to have a substantial number of [electric] vehicles charging at home as everybody dreams,” Ram Rajagopal, an associate professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering at Stanford University, who authored a recent study looking at the strain electric vehicle adoption is expected to place on the power grid, told Yahoo Finance. “Today’s grid may not be able to support it. It all boils down to: Are you charging during the time solar power is on?”

The alert in the nation’s most populous state highlighted the delicate dance utility companies face in managing warming temperatures with tightening energy supply as the country moves rapidly away from fossil fuel generation to meet ambitious targets aimed at drastically reducing emissions.

California has set out to become a leader in the green transition, aiming to rid its electrical grid of all carbon sources by 2045. The state is already the nation’s top producer of solar, geothermal, and biomass energy, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, with renewables accounting for more than 30% of the energy generated in the state.

But as California creates a template for other states to follow, Rajagopal says it is also exposing some critical gaps that are likely to strain the power grid in the race to net-zero, especially in the transportation sector, where the acceleration of electric vehicle adoption is already underway.

“Business as usual will no longer be the case,” he said. “I really believe we need to balance our need for reliability and our desire for a clean grid.”

Globally, the number of electric vehicles is expected to swell from 7 million to 400 million by 2040. The transition to zero-emission cars is estimated to add 2,000 TWh to annual energy demand by 2050 — a 40% increase — according to a study by global advisory group ICF.

Rajagopal’s team of researchers at Stanford developed a model framework to help utility companies around the world calculate charging patterns to better manage electricity demand. In California, it found that peak charging demand would more than double by 2030 if EV owners opted to charge in the evening at home.

“The use of an electric vehicle is like adding one or two air conditioners to your residence in terms of its energy increase,” Mike Jacobs, Senior Energy Analyst at Union of Concerned Scientists, told Yahoo Finance. “So when the local utility engineer looks at this, he thinks of that air conditioning in the afternoon and the electric vehicle coming home at the same time.”

Jacobs said the transition will mark a dramatic adjustment in behavior. Utility companies and service operators, who have long grown accustomed to “a predictable shape” and schedule in energy usage, will be forced to more actively manage the grid to avoid surges. Likewise, drivers will be forced to adapt to new charging times, with some being asked to plug in at work during the day, while others commit to set hours at night to ensure even distribution of energy capacity.

In Concord, Massachusetts, where Jacobs lives, his local utility has already asked that he set a timer on his electric vehicle so he is not charging until after 10 pm at night in exchange for a discounted rate. Technology that allows the grid and cars to communicate directly is likely to follow, he said.

A study from Boston Consulting Group estimated utility companies with two to three million customers will need to invest between $1,700 and $5,800 in grid upgrades per EV through 2030 in order to reliably meet the surge in energy demand.

“If you can charge the vehicles in the middle of the day or in the middle of night, it is almost not a worry because our system is built to meet that evening demand, that peak,” he said. “So spreading it out a little bit more, especially shifting it to sunshine hours when the solar is strong, makes it less of a concern.

The transition to reduce emissions is complicated by the existing energy mix: More than 60% of U.S. power generation still comes from fossil fuels. Without a clean electricity source for EVs to plug into, greenhouse gas reduction would be limited to 67% for vehicles, compared to 2020 levels, according to ICF.

Battery energy storage is expected to play a critical role in bridging the divide and would allow the grid to tap into full capacity in the hours when the sun isn’t shining or the wind isn’t blowing.

Tom Jensen, CEO of Norway-based Freyr Battery (FREY), which designs and manufactures lithium-ion batteries, said each battery it manufactures has the capacity to store four hours' worth of energy for 20 years.

“You can deploy large amounts of 4-hour storage using lithium-ion batteries coupled with solar and wind, and you can upgrade or overhaul the entire U.S. energy system either in three large regional grids or in nine smaller but still very large grids,” Jensen said. “That is technically feasible to do within the next couple of decades, but of course, it's an unprecedented level of investment into overhauling the energy system.”

Jensen cautioned that meaningful decarbonization is unlikely until roughly 80% of the battery supply chain is developed using renewable energy — a goal Freyr plans to reach by 2025.

“It's like a 4-D puzzle because you have policy, you have economics, and you have the engineering and you have people's acceptance,” Rajagopal said. “Engineering-wise, you can have 20 viable solutions, but maybe they don't satisfy the other three and then those are useless. Once you crack the code you will be able to help so many regions around the U.S. and across the world to transition, [but] you’re going to have to suffer through it to learn.”

 
California is a cess pool run by brain dead morons.
 
May 19, 2022

California energy officials issued a sobering warning this month, telling residents to brace for potential blackouts as the state’s energy grid faces capacity constraints heading into the summer months.

In Sacramento, officials said California’s grid could face a potential shortfall of roughly 1,700 megawatts, which would affect the power supply of between 1 million and 4 million people this summer. That number would likely be exacerbated by an additional shortfall of 5,000 megawatts in the case of extreme heat and further fire damage to existing power lines.

And since the state has committed to phase out all new gas-powered vehicles by 2035 — well ahead of federal targets — the additional load from electric vehicle (EV) charging could add more strain to the electric grid.

“Let’s say we were to have a substantial number of [electric] vehicles charging at home as everybody dreams,” Ram Rajagopal, an associate professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering at Stanford University, who authored a recent study looking at the strain electric vehicle adoption is expected to place on the power grid, told Yahoo Finance. “Today’s grid may not be able to support it. It all boils down to: Are you charging during the time solar power is on?”

The alert in the nation’s most populous state highlighted the delicate dance utility companies face in managing warming temperatures with tightening energy supply as the country moves rapidly away from fossil fuel generation to meet ambitious targets aimed at drastically reducing emissions.

California has set out to become a leader in the green transition, aiming to rid its electrical grid of all carbon sources by 2045. The state is already the nation’s top producer of solar, geothermal, and biomass energy, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, with renewables accounting for more than 30% of the energy generated in the state.

But as California creates a template for other states to follow, Rajagopal says it is also exposing some critical gaps that are likely to strain the power grid in the race to net-zero, especially in the transportation sector, where the acceleration of electric vehicle adoption is already underway.

“Business as usual will no longer be the case,” he said. “I really believe we need to balance our need for reliability and our desire for a clean grid.”

Globally, the number of electric vehicles is expected to swell from 7 million to 400 million by 2040. The transition to zero-emission cars is estimated to add 2,000 TWh to annual energy demand by 2050 — a 40% increase — according to a study by global advisory group ICF.

Rajagopal’s team of researchers at Stanford developed a model framework to help utility companies around the world calculate charging patterns to better manage electricity demand. In California, it found that peak charging demand would more than double by 2030 if EV owners opted to charge in the evening at home.

“The use of an electric vehicle is like adding one or two air conditioners to your residence in terms of its energy increase,” Mike Jacobs, Senior Energy Analyst at Union of Concerned Scientists, told Yahoo Finance. “So when the local utility engineer looks at this, he thinks of that air conditioning in the afternoon and the electric vehicle coming home at the same time.”

Jacobs said the transition will mark a dramatic adjustment in behavior. Utility companies and service operators, who have long grown accustomed to “a predictable shape” and schedule in energy usage, will be forced to more actively manage the grid to avoid surges. Likewise, drivers will be forced to adapt to new charging times, with some being asked to plug in at work during the day, while others commit to set hours at night to ensure even distribution of energy capacity.

In Concord, Massachusetts, where Jacobs lives, his local utility has already asked that he set a timer on his electric vehicle so he is not charging until after 10 pm at night in exchange for a discounted rate. Technology that allows the grid and cars to communicate directly is likely to follow, he said.

A study from Boston Consulting Group estimated utility companies with two to three million customers will need to invest between $1,700 and $5,800 in grid upgrades per EV through 2030 in order to reliably meet the surge in energy demand.

“If you can charge the vehicles in the middle of the day or in the middle of night, it is almost not a worry because our system is built to meet that evening demand, that peak,” he said. “So spreading it out a little bit more, especially shifting it to sunshine hours when the solar is strong, makes it less of a concern.

The transition to reduce emissions is complicated by the existing energy mix: More than 60% of U.S. power generation still comes from fossil fuels. Without a clean electricity source for EVs to plug into, greenhouse gas reduction would be limited to 67% for vehicles, compared to 2020 levels, according to ICF.

Battery energy storage is expected to play a critical role in bridging the divide and would allow the grid to tap into full capacity in the hours when the sun isn’t shining or the wind isn’t blowing.

Tom Jensen, CEO of Norway-based Freyr Battery (FREY), which designs and manufactures lithium-ion batteries, said each battery it manufactures has the capacity to store four hours' worth of energy for 20 years.

“You can deploy large amounts of 4-hour storage using lithium-ion batteries coupled with solar and wind, and you can upgrade or overhaul the entire U.S. energy system either in three large regional grids or in nine smaller but still very large grids,” Jensen said. “That is technically feasible to do within the next couple of decades, but of course, it's an unprecedented level of investment into overhauling the energy system.”

Jensen cautioned that meaningful decarbonization is unlikely until roughly 80% of the battery supply chain is developed using renewable energy — a goal Freyr plans to reach by 2025.

“It's like a 4-D puzzle because you have policy, you have economics, and you have the engineering and you have people's acceptance,” Rajagopal said. “Engineering-wise, you can have 20 viable solutions, but maybe they don't satisfy the other three and then those are useless. Once you crack the code you will be able to help so many regions around the U.S. and across the world to transition, [but] you’re going to have to suffer through it to learn.”


Gee I guess no has thought about increasing generation capacity before 2050. Why do you and your friends ignore the cost of climate change. that of cousre was a rhetorical question.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Gee I guess no has thought about increasing generation capacity before 2050.

Like many other issues we are facing the solutions are almost
always too obvious to be overlooked.

We have a problem with escalating cost of housing. In California even
people with a decent job could be driven homeless because of skyrocketing
rental cost. The problem could be easily solved if only the government and builders
can increase supply of affordable housing. Likewise the problem with rising
cost of EVs should be only a temporary issue as supply of copper, nickel, cobalt
and lithium would increase to bring down their prices eventually. To the cornucopians
earth's resources are practically infinite.

Before renewable power generation capacity is increased to a sufficiently
high volume for conversion of ICE vehicles to EVs is complete the entire
power grid in North America will have to be modernized. How do you
think the capital needed is to be raised? But I guess the grid is not to
be worried about. Well before more than a fraction of ICE vehicles are
replaced by EVs people will wonder where all the affordable electric
power and metals needed for further expansion of renewable power
capacity are to be produced.


Why do you and your friends ignore the cost of climate change. that of cousre was a rhetorical question.
 
California’s power grid was a victim of deregulation, and for profit private companies not investing in the grid for short term profits. Thanks GOP! Deregulation has been awesome!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Gee I guess no has thought about increasing generation capacity before 2050. Why do you and your friends ignore the cost of climate change. that of cousre was a rhetorical question.

The cost of climate change?

Our complex, chaotic and dynamic climate will do what it will do
Thinking mankind can control climate is delusional
 
California’s power grid was a victim of deregulation, and for profit private companies not investing in the grid for short term profits. Thanks GOP! Deregulation has been awesome!

do not be ridiculous
they turned off nuclear & Fossil Fuel power plants , after deluding themselves W& S could replace the generation
 
  • Like
Reactions: bluecolt
The cost of climate change?

Our complex, chaotic and dynamic climate will do what it will do
Thinking mankind can control climate is delusional

Humans can't control it but they are definitely affecting the climate.
Larue's statement is an idiotic straw man argument.
 
Like many other issues we are facing the solutions are almost
always too obvious to be overlooked.

We have a problem with escalating cost of housing. In California even
people with a decent job could be driven homeless because of skyrocketing
rental cost. The problem could be easily solved if only the government and builders
can increase supply of affordable housing. Likewise the problem with rising
cost of EVs should be only a temporary issue as supply of copper, nickel, cobalt
and lithium would increase to bring down their prices eventually. To the cornucopians
earth's resources are practically infinite.

Before renewable power generation capacity is increased to a sufficiently
high volume for conversion of ICE vehicles to EVs is complete the entire
power grid in North America will have to be modernized. How do you
think the capital needed is to be raised? But I guess the grid is not to
be worried about. Well before more than a fraction of ICE vehicles are
replaced by EVs people will wonder where all the affordable electric
power and metals needed for further expansion of renewable power
capacity are to be produced.

In order to move forward into the future it will take a lot of PPP projects and this is whether or not climate change deniers like it. It will take political will and ultimately this is not just a climate issue but one for the economy and national security. If the US does not move to own the related industries the Chinese will along with the jobs it will create.

The move to EV has started and will increase at a faster pace. Private industry is taking up the challenge and opportunities but it will not be enough without PPP.

A world leader in convenience and mobility, the company plans to bring EV charging units to 200 Circle K and Couche-Tard stores across North America over the next two years. Today, Couche-Tard activated its first U.S. site with high power DC fast charging under the Circle K banner at a new prototype Circle K store in Rock Hill, South Carolina.
 
In order to move forward into the future it will take a lot of PPP projects and this is whether or not climate change deniers like it. It will take political will and ultimately this is not just a climate issue but one for the economy and national security. If the US does not move to own the related industries the Chinese will along with the jobs it will create.

No political will can increase earth's reserve of aluminium, copper, nickel, cobalt and
lithium. Climate change denial is not the factor that makes EV costly. China will have
access to less costly energy, base metals and rare earth metals. Most likely they will
be world's manufacturer of (relatively) affordable EVs and solar panels. Climate change
denial has nothing to do with the cost of EVs. EV will remain a luxury for the minority.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue
America in general has an electrical grid problem, and what's the republican answer to this....deregulate, let power companies regulate themselves and do not invest in infrastructure. Then when the power goes out or fails like what happened in Texas, the rich can simply fly to Cancun, like Ted Cruz!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Do you have any idea how long it takes and how much money it takes to open a new mine in Canada? Especially an underground mine.

I know that finding all the materials to go electric will be incredibly hard, but its still better than the alternatives.
Did you enjoy Ontario's first Derecho?
More damage than the biggest ice storm in one day.
 
I know that finding all the materials to go electric will be incredibly hard, but its still better than the alternatives.
Did you enjoy Ontario's first Derecho?
More damage than the biggest ice storm in one day.

Where I live the storm never effected me.
Do you think these storms are something new? I hate to disappoint you but storms like that have been happening since the dawn of time. They also won't stop or be less severe if we stop or reduce the use of fossil fuels.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jcpro and JohnLarue
Where I live the storm never effected me.
Do you think these storms are something new? I hate to disappoint you but storms like that have been happening since the dawn of time. They also won't stop or be less severe if we stop or reduce the use of fossil fuels.

Ontario didn't have a history of Derechos. So many new terms like polar vortex.
Sure, storms have happened before but not with these extremes.
Birds dropping from heat in India/Pakistan
Record heat in Spain
Record cold in the EU
Amazon forest fires
Siberian forest fires
Drought in the US

Its true they won't stop if we do stop using oil immediately, there is a massive lag in the system.
Oil prices won't hurt as much as food price increases in the next while.
 
Ontario didn't have a history of Derechos. So many new terms like polar vortex.
Sure, storms have happened before but not with these extremes.
Birds dropping from heat in India/Pakistan
Record heat in Spain
Record cold in the EU
Amazon forest fires
Siberian forest fires
Drought in the US

Its true they won't stop if we do stop using oil immediately, there is a massive lag in the system.
Oil prices won't hurt as much as food price increases in the next while.
Yes, new names...yawn. Polar vortex- a cold spell. Derecho- thunderstorm. Fire in Siberia- we now have satellites to see them because nobody fucking lives there.
 
Ontario didn't have a history of Derechos. So many new terms like polar vortex.
Sure, storms have happened before but not with these extremes.
Birds dropping from heat in India/Pakistan
Record heat in Spain
Record cold in the EU
Amazon forest fires
Siberian forest fires
Drought in the US

Its true they won't stop if we do stop using oil immediately, there is a massive lag in the system.
Oil prices won't hurt as much as food price increases in the next while.

The best new scare tactic is calling rain storms "atmospheric rivers". It's fucking rain!
So I guess in the 4 billion years of earth those atmospheric conditions you mentioned never, ever happened before. Hmmm, interesting theory, but it's wrong.
 
The best new scare tactic is calling rain storms "atmospheric rivers". It's fucking rain!
So I guess in the 4 billion years of earth those atmospheric conditions you mentioned never, ever happened before. Hmmm, interesting theory, but it's wrong.

Ice ages and thermal maximums happened before too.
Does that mean you want them to make them happen again?