Cain's 9-9-9 plan

As my experience has been that hardly anybody here reads more than 2 lines of any article or
commentary (and Papa less than that), I have taken the liberty to copy the conclusion of Bruce Bartlett's analysis:

Even allowing for the poorly thought through promises routinely made on the campaign trail, Mr. Cain’s tax plan stands out as exceptionally ill conceived.

You also should have included the paragraph above that.

"At minimum the Cain plan is a distributional monstrosity. The poor would pay more while the rich would have their taxes cut, with no guarantee that economic growth would increase and good reason to believe that the budget deficit will increase."

My only hope is that the US citizens aren't so gullible as to swallow an advertising slogan dreamed up by a former pizza baron and an accountant from Cleveland. But then, based on the responses to this thread so far, there are at least 3 posters here who are that easily fooled. Or greedy. Take your pick.
 
Last edited:
What is the funding source of Government jobs??

How much do you contribute to this??

BTW I disagree with using public money to create jobs

The funding source of government jobs is taxation. It is the premise of the existence of the state throughout history that the state has the power to tax. People are crying out for government to fix the unemployment problem which evolved in a low tax environment, again proving that lowering taxes does not fix the unemployment problem.

The exact amount I contribute to this is between my accountant, me and the CRA. However you can rest assured that I have paid the highest marginal rate for about 15 years straight now. And I don't whine about it. If you feel the need to post your tax returns feel free.

You may disagree with using public money to create jobs, but most of the public sees one of the roles of government as regulating the economy. I am one of them. I don't believe the mythical free market results in a just or safe society and I believe there is a need and moral imperative to regulate businesses. Mine included.
 
His plan calls for a 9% national sales tax, a 9% personal income tax rate and a 9% corporate tax rate.

What do you guys think?
i wonder what the religious nuts think about a guy named "Cain" and his proposal of a "999" solution? (turn it upside down, you get "666")?...
 
Papa, Warren Buffet also stated that having low corporate taxes doesn't necessarily create jobs. It just lowers the risk of them leaving the country.
 
Papa, Warren Buffet also stated that having low corporate taxes doesn't necessarily create jobs. It just lowers the risk of them leaving the country.

Have you asked him why he has not created jobs??

Or do you just swallow what he says because his is bigger???
 
i wonder what the religious nuts think about a guy named "Cain" and his proposal of a "999" solution? (turn it upside down, you get "666")?...
Perry will be working on that angle, once he's done with running his Mormon angle against Mitt the twit...:D
 
the more a liberal complains the better the plan must be
 
It could be, but there is 0% chance that his plan will become law.


You see the light.

Elect or do not elect Cain based on his abilities and not 999.

Of course Obama held his breath and had tantrums until his Social Medicine was passed.

HE is trying to do the same with his we need more government jobs bill.
 
You see the light.

Elect or do not elect Cain based on his abilities and not 999.

pay no attention to what he says, another brilliant papaism.
 
pay no attention to what he says, another brilliant papaism.

As a non American I can not expect you would know about how the Executive Branch works.

I would be happy to educate you on this; just as soon as I learn how to teach a brick to swim.
 
pay no attention to what he says, another brilliant papaism.
That's why we enjoy his steam on unconsciousness logic soooo....:D
 
pay no attention to what he says, another brilliant papaism.

Pappy. 999 is all he's got. Have you watched any of the debates? When asked a question, he either responds that what others think isn't true without offering any explanation, or "as my Grandpa said, I don'ts care", or he'll just repeat 999 regardless of what the question was. He is a master at saying nothing at all. No wonder you like him.
 
As a non American I can not expect you would know about how the Executive Branch works.

I'd be willing to bet he knows at least as much as you, not that that is anything to brag about.

.... just as soon as I learn how to teach a brick to swim.

Well, at least you have a hobby.
 
I'd be willing to bet he knows at least as much as you, not that is anything to brag about



Well, at least you have a hobby.

from woody's mouth to your computer.
 
from woody's mouth to your computer.

Nope, just responding to your ascertion that as an ignorant foriegner, danmand might need his self some teachin', and that you is the man for the job. After you were done playing with your brick that is. Maybe after that you can teach him how to speak good english. We're all aware of your talents there.