Cain's 9-9-9 plan

Brotherman

Active member
Jan 17, 2004
1,158
5
38
His plan calls for a 9% national sales tax, a 9% personal income tax rate and a 9% corporate tax rate.

What do you guys think?
 
999 just another GOPer gimmick

Real economists, not the ones using fuzzy math, have already dismissed it as hopelessly inadequate....:wink:
 
Country is going bancrupt, Brilliant soution: reduce taxation.
 
This is the GOP theme this election cycle namely....
Ask NOT what I can do for my country, ask what the country can do for ME!...:rolleyes:
 
Country is going bancrupt, Brilliant soution: reduce taxation.


9% taxation may sound crazy, but when you realize how many people don't pay taxes and this 9% will include everyone with very very few deductions it may add up.


I'm not familiar with the sales tax rates throughout the US so can't comment on the sales tax rate one way or the other.
 
eliminating deductions and closing loop holes will do more than one can ever realize.

He is also eliminating the returns, I believe and the sales tax will equalize the playing field.
 
Tax experts showed how the poor would be hurt most while the 999 would be a boon to the rich! That's why a GOPer proposed it!....;)
 
It wouldn't work and would give an enormous tax break to the rich. The poorest Americans don't currently make enough to be required to pay federal tax. This plan would require that they would have to pay 9% regardless of how low their income, in addition to a 9% sales tax. Corporations currently pay an average of around 26% after deductions and loopholes That would drop to 9%. Richer Americans would see the top rate drop from 35%, to 9%. There is a reason why we have always had a progressive tax code. It's based on abilty to pay. The rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer as ot is. This would put it on steroids.
 
It wouldn't work and would give an enormous tax break to the rich. The poorest Americans don't currently make enough to be required to pay federal tax. This plan would require that they would have to pay 9% regardless of how low their income, in addition to a 9% sales tax. Corporations currently pay an average of around 26% after deductions and loopholes That would drop to 9%. Richer Americans would see the top rate drop from 35%, to 9%. There is a reason why we have always had a progressive tax code. It's based on abilty to pay. The rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer as ot is. This would put it on steroids.

It is plainly insane. He is a loon.
 
It is plainly insane. He is a loon.
After watching Dubya & his DICK, Palin, Bachmann, Perry and now Cain it appears GOPers prefer loons!....:Eek:
 
It is plainly insane. He is a loon.

And currently leading the pack. The problem is that he is looking at this from the same perspective of a pizza magnate. Come up with a catchy ad campaign to sell your product and repeat it over and over, without be overly concerned about the quality of that product. The product in this case, is him.
 
Tax experts showed how the poor would be hurt most while the 999 would be a boon to the rich! That's why a GOPer proposed it!....;)

aside from having to pay sales tax, how would they be hurt??
 
aside from having to pay sales tax, how would they be hurt??

Watch CBS NEWS in < half hour and they will explain it to you ....;)
 
And currently leading the pack. The problem is that he is looking at this from the same perspective of a pizza magnate. Come up with a catchy ad campaign to sell your product and repeat it over and over, without be overly concerned about the quality of that product. The product in this case, is him.

How well did drill baby drill do for Bachmann?
 
aside from having to pay sales tax, how would they be hurt??

The poorest americans would pay 18% tax on any income they would have.