Buying half a cow?

JackBurton

Well-known member
Jan 5, 2012
2,035
897
113
Hwy guys and girls:

My family wants to all go in on a half a cow this fall. The farm grass feeds them and their cows aren't on any growth hormones. Good right?

Anyone ever have experience with this? They will provide us with a cut sheet so we can choose how we want it done. Their prices are very competitive and we like the idea of supporting family farmers.

Any pitfalls or hidden costs that I should be aware of?

Thanks!
 
I've done it a few times.
The only problem I found was we used up the best cuts first and then felt like we had to get through the rest before buying better cuts again.
We ended up with some stuff left over that we never used.
I think it was still an economical decision but seemed like a shame to have some go to waste.
 
As long as you have a chest freezer I think you are good.

As newguy pointed out you have to be open to using all cuts of meat otherwise you feel like you are stuck with some.

Once in a blue moon I order meat through kids fundraisers not as cheap but at least I get to pick exactly what I want.

I say go for it. Aside from saving money it will also force you to be creative with your cooking.

As an aside I thought this thread was about "why buy the cow when you can get it for free" and if you had to buy just half a "cow" which half would you buy..... lol
 
It is very common. You'll need to decide how much of various lesser roasts and steaks you will want, versus having them grind it into hamburger.
 
I've done it numerous times. Get the cuts of meat you know you will eat, i.e. the better cuts, and have the rest turned into hamburger. I never have stuff left over as hamburger can be used to make alot of things. i.e. stews, shepherds pie, hamburgers, meatloaf, hamburger helper meals etc.
 
I have done it. Be aware of the amount of work to cut the quarters into dinners.
 
I do it every year and have it butchered to my liking, and the price is fantastic. So is the meat.
 
I have never done it, I can only suggest that anyone looking into doing it should be aware of what is involved.
You need the right equipment, and you should watch someone do it at least once before you jump into it. I watched a guy do it once in a small grocery store. They order a whole cow, a side of a cow or a quarter cow. They start to chop it up into steaks and cubes. A lot of the meat is marbled up with fat, this is chucked into the grinder to make hamburger. From what I saw at least 40% of the meat was marbled with fat. This is not something I would do to get better cuts of meat or save money. I prefer to get my meat fresh.
 
Hwy guys and girls:

My family wants to all go in on a half a cow this fall. The farm grass feeds them and their cows aren't on any growth hormones. Good right?

Anyone ever have experience with this? They will provide us with a cut sheet so we can choose how we want it done. Their prices are very competitive and we like the idea of supporting family farmers.

Any pitfalls or hidden costs that I should be aware of?

Thanks!
Don't buy a cow. You want half a steer. Steers are raised for eating. Cows are used for milk and breeding- by the time they are slaughtered used for low quality meat (soups, dogfood etc)
 
Have done it many times successfully but I have more that average knowledge having worked in a meat department years ago, and knowing more than the average about cooking.

1. The hind quarter is more expensive than the front quarter because there is a greater percentage of expensive cuts in the hind quarter.
2. I always took a front quarter because its better value: Specifically prime rib steaks and roasts (the very best) and flank steaks.
3. You need to know a little about butchering to make the right choices.
4. I believe the savings are in being able to use stew beef and most people aren't into making stews anymore.
5. Make sure it is professionally butchered. I bought a whole lamb once and the butchering was strictly amateur. I could have done it better myself. Butchering is a craft and the ability of the butcher makes a huge difference.
6. Make sure you can trust the farmer and the butcher. A lot can happen between the kill floor and the wrapping of meat and most of us would never know if some of the prime cuts were "short".
7. The grocery store today is set up so we pay for parts of the animal we never receive. The entire animal is used but only a fraction goes on the supermarket shelf. Take the simple example of a chicken. If you buy a boneless, skinless piece of chicken, you paid more than if you bought the same piece of meat with skin and bone. If you had bought say a leg quarter, cut off the backbone portion for stock and chicken salad, separated the drumstick from the thigh and skinned the thigh after cooking, you would have paid less money and have one or two more meals. Over the years I see very few roasts in the store and very little stew meat. These were the cuts that could go a long way. In our affluent society we all eat steaks and chops. Don't worry. The stores have figured us out and they still make money.

One of the best things I ever did in my life was to get part time work in the meat department of the IGA. The butchers really taught me how to use all the cuts, especially the less expensive ones and for the rest of my life I could eat economically. It was amazing how far I could stretch the grocery budget years ago and still eat well.

My 2 cents
Havin
 
red is correct. Steers are young. I prefer the ones born on the pasture, raised by their grass grazing mother then wintered with a high protein feed. Wiened at 600 lbs then castrated. Back on the grass pasture then rationed on a beef finisher feed.
Oh my, my mouth waters while typing this....don't forget the horseradish !!!
 
Check out fresh from the farm they bring the beef from the mennonites their prices are listed on the site. You can buy grass fed or grain fed or organic...lots of choice.
 
I bought half a cow many years ago when my dad was still alive. We went to the place and my dad asked to inspect the beef prior to me buying it which kind of through the guy for a loop. My dad was a District Meat Manager for Dominion Stores and therefore knew his stuff. We got choice cuts once they knew my dads occupation. They were'nt going to fool him.

I've heard of people buying half a cow by weight and getting stuck with a lot of bone and hamburger as well.
 
Last edited:
@jgd you know of what you speak. I have purchased two steer halfs and also a half Water Buffalo (really). I would not really recommend going that route. Too much "burger" not enough prime cuts albeit I agree with the OP that knowing how to properly cook less prime cuts is a bonus. As for prime cuts, for example, whole AAA beef tenderloins regularly come on sale at about 10 bucks/lb or about 75 bucks for the whole loin. That is versus 20+ bucks/lb. for butcher cut AAA filets. Learn how to properly pick out a whole tenderloin (shortest tail in the bin) and trim it, cut it. You will get about 8-10+ awesome filet steaks, two excellent roasts, and a few meals of stir fry "cubes." Freeze it up! I would also note that whole AAA prime rib roasts regularly come on sale @ half price, grab three, freeze 'em up! On another note whole pork loins come up regularly also. An absolute fabulous deal. Have fun!
 
Learn how to properly pick out a whole tenderloin (shortest tail in the bin) and trim it, cut it. You will get about 8-10+ awesome filet steaks, two excellent roasts, and a few meals of stir fry "cubes." Freeze it up!


This! :)

I am a carnivore and believe if an animal is going to die, you should use the whole animal. Don't waste it. You can make yummy stocks with the bones. https://thebigcarrot.ca/nc/departme...ood-single/bc/d/c/the-benefits-of-bone-broth/

Never had tongue before but this looks like an interesting recipe: http://www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/tongue-with-mustard-horseradish-sauce-103380
 
Really great points. Thanks!

I'm a pretty good cook and get better with each passing year. I feel like having the challenge to use up all the animal that I get is half the fun.

Ps: tounge is awesome. I'll make sure to ask for it
 
I used to raise Scottish highland cattle. when planning for summer bbq season with lots of visitors , I would take the occasional critter and have it entirely turned into ground beef , well mixed. Sinful you say? Not at all. Visitors never ceased to be amazed by the taste and quality of the Highland burgers. Completely gourmet quality. years later folks still rave about them when we get together
 
I have never done it, I can only suggest that anyone looking into doing it should be aware of what is involved.
You need the right equipment, and you should watch someone do it at least once before you jump into it. I watched a guy do it once in a small grocery store. They order a whole cow, a side of a cow or a quarter cow. They start to chop it up into steaks and cubes. A lot of the meat is marbled up with fat, this is chucked into the grinder to make hamburger. From what I saw at least 40% of the meat was marbled with fat. This is not something I would do to get better cuts of meat or save money. I prefer to get my meat fresh.


If you lack the intelligence or wisdom to first read what someone is asking, at least have the courtesy to read it out of respect for the poster. You seem to just love to read 3 or 4 words of a headline then use it as a jumping off point to yammer on about what YOU know ...completely irrelevant to the OP's question. Typical narcissist. Besides, who fucking butchers their own cow for themselves?

Just a quick recap.... he is NOT going to have a half of a cow delivered to his door then start butchering it himself. He said the farmer provides a "cut sheet" so the family can choose how they want it butchered.

And as for "fresh meat". Again, you have no idea about beef. You probably buy the brightest red steak in the Price Chopper meat section. Proper aging is what makes good beef great.