Buying A Life Annuity?

lamgos

New member
Dec 14, 2010
415
0
0
Looking to buy a life annuity, the type you put in a certain amount each month. Heard only life insurance companies are allowed to sell those? Any recommendations?
 
Not to be insulting, but if you don't where to buy this product, how do you know it's right for you. Annuities are a complex financial product; it can be like buying a personal pension plan with huge variables on investments and payouts.
 
Aardvark is right on! I don't think you understand really what you are looking for. This is not the time to be buying annuities with interest rates so low. Easy subject to look up,so do that first to get a handle on what you really want. Whatever you do stay away from segregated funds no matter the story the agent or planner gives you!
 
How old are you? You should not buy an annuity unless you are retired. Prior to that you are better saving up in more conventional ways, investing your money yourself, either conservatively in bonds, or in a mix of bonds and stocks. Then when you are getting to retirement age sell your investments and convert to an annuity. If THAT is your situation it might be worth doing. If you still have >10 years to go before retirement it's probably a bad idea.
 
That makes sense. However, what I am trying to find is a product that would work like a defined benefit pension plan, since I have more than 10 years to retirement, I am looking to make monthly contributions now instead of a lump sum purchase in the future.

How old are you? You should not buy an annuity unless you are retired. Prior to that you are better saving up in more conventional ways, investing your money yourself, either conservatively in bonds, or in a mix of bonds and stocks. Then when you are getting to retirement age sell your investments and convert to an annuity. If THAT is your situation it might be worth doing. If you still have >10 years to go before retirement it's probably a bad idea.
 
The problem is that the annuity vendors will charge you very high fees for this service, and you will end up with an inadequate return. Moreover, you can't be sure what your'e even buying, as you won't be very well protected against inflation, unless you buy a product that is indexed against inflation--which will come with even higher fees.

Your best strategy would be pumping your money into "real return bonds" directly. These are bonds that are indexed to inflation, so they come with a real income guarantee. Returns aren't great, but they will be better than what you'll get from the annuity vendors after they're done with all the fees they charge. Buy bonds that have a maturity around the date of your retirement, and when the bonds mature pump the money into an annuity product. If you want to make it a regular payment, have the money automatically transferred to a high interest savings account every pay period. Then once a year take that pool of money and buy the real return bonds in one big purchase.

I would also recommend that you mix in at least a little bit of equity in with your bonds. Even if you are a very conservative investor with 90% of your assets in government real return bonds, you would still want 10% of your money in equities, perhaps even 20%. If you're a little more willing to take risk (and if you are looking at annuities, you are probably NOT) you could consider even up to 50% equities.

There's nothing wrong with your wants or your strategy, but what you are going to run headlong into is the harsh reality that these products are simply too expensive to be worth buying.

What happens to annuities is that as you age in retirement the odds that you will die before getting all your money back increases, meaning that the insurance company can offer you a higher and higher payout, and still make a buck--because enough people die before collecting it all. Thus it's worth your while to put off buying the annuity as long as possible, to get the highest payout. The downside to an annuity of course is that when you die there is nothing for your kids, however, you may have covered that by, say, owning your own home--the kids get that, for example.
 
For the OP, do you contribute to the maximum limit for your RRSP over the years? There really isn't a DB plan for individual's unless you are incorporated and even then you would have to get an actuary involved to design it for you. Expensive but it can be done.
An annuity is for the person who is concerned about living too long and running out of income. Buying an annuity provides you with that certainty and there are minimum guarantees depending on the annuity you purchase that would flow through to your estate. Buying an annuity really isn't about fees as they not shown to you explicitly. The key really has to do with the state of interest rates and in the case of some insurers who at that point in time need cash. The insurer is assuming the mortality risk and investment income risk although frankly they seem to have quite a handle on these matters and indeed make a good income from annuities. What is important is having in place a sufficient amount of income to support your lifestyle and cover your fixed and future obligations. At the same time do not put your money into something that you do not fundamentally understand and by that I mean the nature of the product and the risk of it not doing the job you want. If you are looking for a fixed income stream with ten years to go to retirement you cannot afford a high risk level no matter the direction you go. If this is a play money thing for you then by all means Fuji is proposing an interesting approach.
 
I think that real return bonds have had their run, they are now overvalued IMO. They can fluctuate a LOT in price - i.e I could see them falling 10 - 15%.

As others have said, interest rates are so low now that annuities are IMO a rip-off (as is almost all secure fixed-income. In fact, low interest rates are a rip-off of savers to the benefit of debtors.

I think ther are not so many options nowadays, and unfortunately I think you are going to be forced to take soem risk unless you are satisfied with extremely low returns.

If you still want an annuity, my advice is delay delay delay. Every year that goes by all else being equal your returns will increase because you will have shorter life expectancy.
 
Something interesting to consider and the closest thing I've seen to a private pension (although they are fee-laden) are the Guaranteed Minimum Withdrawal Benefit products offered by Manulife and Sunlife - they will guarantee an income stream for life. They are ideal for investors with 10 - 15 years of time before withdrawals because they will grow with the market and they protect your downside by offering a notional 5% return each year. As previous posters have said though, talk to a financial advisor - these products are complicated.

Timbit
 
One other thing - fuji - while RR Bonds are interesting, something more viable to consider would be floating rate bonds - these are typically corporate high yield bonds with a floor on the interest rate but also are tied to rising rates, therefore, if interest rates go up, the issuer is compelled to pay out higher interest to the bond holders. Yes, there is more risk involved because they are corporate debt (typically, in Canada RR Bonds are 99% issued by government or quasi-government agencies). If you don't want to source your own bonds, Manulife has a pretty decent Floating Rate Bond fund - mostly US domiciled issuers, but hedged 100% to the Canadian dollar.

Timbit
 
Something interesting to consider and the closest thing I've seen to a private pension (although they are fee-laden) are the Guaranteed Minimum Withdrawal Benefit products offered by Manulife and Sunlife - they will guarantee an income stream for life. They are ideal for investors with 10 - 15 years of time before withdrawals because they will grow with the market and they protect your downside by offering a notional 5% return each year. As previous posters have said though, talk to a financial advisor - these products are complicated.

Timbit

I hate these things, EXTREMELY complicated, i don't believe ANYONE who buys them truly knows what they are getting, and and I don't see any value - infact they are a subtraction of value, they are basically an annuity plus a fund with big fees. Advisors probably earn a 5% commission. Keep that in mind when considering the motives of anyone pushing them.

From teh web:

http://www.canadiancapitalist.com/manulife-income-plus-the-high-cost-of-peace-of-mind/

http://blog.taxresource.ca/gmwb-case-study-and-a-suitability-nightmare/
 
The product as sold by life insurance companies is a combination of a contribution to a fund, life insurance, with the fund converted at some age to an annuity that pays you back some of what you have contributed. It will be very costly compared to doing these elements seperately. An RRSP converted to a RIF at age 70 is really the same thing, minus the life insurance. For life insurance you can buy the cheapest term insurance you can find, maximize your RRSP and TFSA each year, and voila...you will end up with a much larger (assuming reasonable investing) annuity than you ever will with a life company. Why? Because they make a fortune on you if you go with them...a way more than you will make, and that means you will get much much less.
 
I hate these things, EXTREMELY complicated, i don't believe ANYONE who buys them truly knows what they are getting, and and I don't see any value - infact they are a subtraction of value, they are basically an annuity plus a fund with big fees. Advisors probably earn a 5% commission. Keep that in mind when considering the motives of anyone pushing them.

From teh web:

http://www.canadiancapitalist.com/manulife-income-plus-the-high-cost-of-peace-of-mind/

http://blog.taxresource.ca/gmwb-case-study-and-a-suitability-nightmare/


I agree with you. One of your links ends up with this quote:

"IncomePlus has become very popular, attracting more than $5 billion in deposits since its launch about two years back. The downside protection offered by minimum withdrawal guarantees and the upside potential offered by market growth (and, it must be mentioned, hard sell by financial advisors) could explain its popularity. Other providers such as SunLife and Desjardins have launched similar products.

It is hard to see how these products are better than low-cost, diversified portfolios that have a large fixed-income component suitable for someone at or near retirement considering that the income stream is not indexed to inflation. The fees for these products are extra-ordinarily high: a 0.25% to 0.75% fee for IncomePlus in addition to a MER in the range of 2.75% for the mutual funds on offer. Does anyone believe that the upside potential of market growth will amount to much when paying 3.5% in fees every year? Why then are advisors pushing their clients to buy these products?
"

Just build a diversified portfolio with stocks and bonds and move to more bonds as you get closer to needing your money back. Educate yourself or find an advisor you can trust [look for referrals from someone you know]. It's a terrible time to be buying an annuity with interest rates so low and if you have more than ten years to retirement you have lots of time to carefully invest for some growth.

Good luck. D.
 
My understanding about annuities is, although you get an income stream for life, once you kick the bucket, all the money is gone !!! Forever !!! You cannot leave an annuity to a spouse, relative or loved ones.
 
There are some where you can get a minimum number of years payout regardless. But of course you pay a price for that.
 
I agree that rrb's are not as good a value as a few years ago but it sounds to me like the o.p. Is a very conservative investor trying to simplify his retirement plan. They are still better than the annuity products and would accomplish what he wants.

He does not strike me as the sort to chase yields by doing tons of research and getting into complicated stuff.

The rrb will accomplish that. I do agree he should hold at least a small quantity of equities.
 
If he is very conservative he might not appreciate being down 10 - 20% on his RRB positions.
 
If he is very conservative he might not appreciate being down 10 - 20% on his RRB positions.

If he purchases an RRB with a maturity date equal to his retirement date it's not an issue. Those ups and downs are only a concern to people who trade in and out of RRB's other than at maturity.
 
RRBs are long-dated, so unless he is under 45 he will have to start withdrawing before they mature, potentially locking in a loss.