Busted in States?

Hey contact, are you sure border has arrest records for municipal level crimes? From what I know, the database they have access to is NCIC, which is a National/Federal database. Hobbying charges are at the Municipal level, sometimes at the County level, and not all Municipalities or Counties report this to FBI/NCIC.

I don't know any state that considers Hobbying at even State level, unless it involves underage.
No I'm not 100% not the type of information they release
 
US Customs has a term called Moral Turpitude which can get you barred for entry. The list in the link doesn't specifically reference solicitation or getting busted with an escort but I suspect it would fall on their list, particularly if they think you're a "sex tourist" with no other reason for entry.

 
As was my right, I applied in writing to the police department to have the record of my arrest, my fingerprints, and mug shot expunged from the their records, and about a year later, I got a letter from the RCMP, confirming that this had been done. I don't think border guards would have a record of this arrest.

If I had accepted the Crown's offer to have charges dropped, I could not have applied to have the arrest records removed. If I had not made the written request to the police, they could have kept the arrest record, fingerprints, and mug shot on file, despite my acquittal.

It sounds to me like you are describing what is called a file closure which the RCMP grants on a case by case basis. From my understanding file closures are allowed if you have been granted a pardon or if you went to trial for a criminal offense but had the sentence reduced to a non criminal offense. If the Crown offered to drop the charges I don't see how you would not qualify to have a file closure. Usually you submit a request with the police department of the jurisdiction you were arrested and they forward that request to the RCMP. I seriously doubt your finger prints and mugshots are permanently removed from the database, they probably just have an inactive status set.

Anyhow, I have read that if you have a file closure you are more likely to be barred entry into the United States then if you had a criminal record. The thinking goes that they would rather see what you were arrested and charged for and with a file closure they have no way of knowing. So someone with DUI charge is more likely to get in the USA then someone who was pardoned and had a file closure.

Does anyone have any experience with this? Do the border guards make a distinction between a file closure that resulted from a reduced sentence versus one that was a result of a pardon? Or are they treated the same? Why spend so much money on lawyers in order not to have a criminal record if you are going to be treated like a criminal anyway?




To avoid hassles I ended up getting a nexus card so I'm pre-cleared. There is also a way allegedly to get the US to expunge your police record but I never looked into it.

How do you apply for a nexus card and how much does it cost?
 
It sounds to me like you are describing what is called a file closure which the RCMP grants on a case by case basis. From my understanding file closures are allowed if you have been granted a pardon or if you went to trial for a criminal offense but had the sentence reduced to a non criminal offense. If the Crown offered to drop the charges I don't see how you would not qualify to have a file closure. Usually you submit a request with the police department of the jurisdiction you were arrested and they forward that request to the RCMP. I seriously doubt your finger prints and mugshots are permanently removed from the database, they probably just have an inactive status set.

Anyhow, I have read that if you have a file closure you are more likely to be barred entry into the United States then if you had a criminal record. The thinking goes that they would rather see what you were arrested and charged for and with a file closure they have no way of knowing. So someone with DUI charge is more likely to get in the USA then someone who was pardoned and had a file closure.

Does anyone have any experience with this? Do the border guards make a distinction between a file closure that resulted from a reduced sentence versus one that was a result of a pardon? Or are they treated the same? Why spend so much money on lawyers in order not to have a criminal record if you are going to be treated like a criminal anyway?






How do you apply for a nexus card and how much does it cost?
google it
 
The moment you go to the states you either A make sure shes known for it as in porn stars who you can book through their twitter or w.e

Or B just break out tinder and pof and go that route
 
I mentioned this before, but a buddy of mine got busted in Florida for solicitation in a bar- a hot lady asked him for a drink and she offered...at a price. Being half drunk and stupid... well, he got arrested. That was some 25 years ago. To this day, when you google him, you can find his mugshot.
 
My info is about 10 years old so it may be out of date...

If you're charged with a criminal offense there's a record of it and the police service has your fingerprints. If the charge is dismissed, you need to have your lawyer write a letter to the police service instructing them and the OPP (who run the CPIC database) to delete your file & fingerprints from the database. My understanding is that they really do delete them because you can sue them if you've properly notified them and they fail to do so. I dunno how long it takes but after a few months make sure you run a criminal record check on yourself to make sure it's gone.

The key is to NOT travel to the US before your file is deleted. US Customs has access and can check to see if you have a police file/fingerprints. Once the US checks, the data is now in THEIR system and they'll never remove it. Doesn't matter if the charges are dismissed, you get a pardon, etc., they have that data and they'll keep it. I don't believe they can check the database unless you're actually traveling to the US, which gives them a legal reason to do so. You can really get fucked if they ask you if you've ever been charged, you say No (thinking your file has been deleted), and they see on their system that you had a charge at one time. For security purposes the cooperation between Canada and the US keeps changing so I dunno if it's reached a point where the US has your charges on file as soon as they appear in the Canadian system; if they do then even that will keep you on their system forever.

I'm a bit fuzzy on this but I believe the police service that arrested you may still have a file on you. It doesn't show up in a normal criminal background check but if a particular service wanted to dig you up I think they can (e.g., the police officer's report of what happened on that particular shift). They've REALLY gotta want to look you up though and it would only be the police service that arrested you that would have that ability. Again, I'm not 100% on this and it may be that even that file gets deleted when your lawyer requests it.
 
People still want to travel in the USA?

Wow.

I have 0 interest in ever going there again. Basically a gun crazed shit hole filled with millions of crazy people (who voted for Trump.)

Give me Europe for the history and beautiful cities, culture and food. Give me the Caribbean and Mexico for warmth in the middle of winter and Australia and New Zealand for something to see.

But the USA?

it has nothing that draws me. Absolutely nothing.
 
In 2007, I was falsely accused of minor assault by a former neighbour, who had actually assaulted me, but told the cops he was the victim. Since the police didn't ask for jail time in the event of conviction, (they only asked for a DNA sample), I didn't qualify for court-appointed counsel at the trial date, but I successfully defended myself, and won acquittal, without having to present my defense case, through the cross examination of the two prosecution witnesses. I had refused the Crown's offer to have charges dropped after the first cross.

As was my right, I applied in writing to the police department to have the record of my arrest, my fingerprints, and mug shot expunged from the their records, and about a year later, I got a letter from the RCMP, confirming that this had been done. I don't think border guards would have a record of this arrest.

If I had accepted the Crown's offer to have charges dropped, I could not have applied to have the arrest records removed. If I had not made the written request to the police, they could have kept the arrest record, fingerprints, and mug shot on file, despite my acquittal.
From what I understand, the data sharing between Canadian and US is a regular thing and the US will not expunge records unless you specifically apply to them. The person I knew who was embarrassed had their Canadian record wiped long before that trip but was still called on it by US Customs.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: onomatopoeia
A pardon and an acquittal are two very different things. If I was denied entry to the US based only on the the arrest, I could possibly have grounds for civil damages against the Toronto police, based on the specific facts and evidence of my case. Some cops will arrest anyone, if someone calls 911, and wants to 'press charges', as if the complainant should decide whether or not an arrest is made, regardless of whether or not there is any or sufficient evidence for an arrest.
...
Sounds good but I doubt that would hold in any way.

An arrest without a conviction doesn't disqualify you from entry to the US but it's their country and the border cop's job to determine. As I said, if you're not sure, get pre-cleared.
 
"I was once falsely accused of assault, I defended myself, and won acquittal, without having to present a defense case. The trial Judge deemed the complainant's testimony to be unreliable, and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police gave me written confirmation that all police records of the incident had been destroyed".
That will likely be okay - assuming the customs agent isn't having a bad day. They might want confirmation of the RCMP thing too.

My dismissed charges didn't stop me from getting a nexus card. Coming to think of it, they didn't even come up in the interview. I'm guessing the guy at the border who questioned me was just using the question as a test to see if I'd lie.
 
From what I understand, the data sharing between Canadian and US is a regular thing and the US will not expunge records unless you specifically apply to them. The person I knew who was embarrassed had their Canadian record wiped long before that trip but was still called on it by US Customs.

The question is, is there a difference between Canada sharing charges vs sharing convictions. Absolutely they do the latter, whether they do the former would depend on what the data sharing agreement actually was/is.
 
From what I understand, the data sharing between Canadian and US is a regular thing and the US will not expunge records unless you specifically apply to them. The person I knew who was embarrassed had their Canadian record wiped long before that trip but was still called on it by US Customs.
In 2007, I was falsely accused of minor assault by a former neighbour, who had actually assaulted me, but told the cops he was the victim. Since the police didn't ask for jail time in the event of conviction, (they only asked for a DNA sample), I didn't qualify for court-appointed counsel at the trial date, but I successfully defended myself, and won acquittal, without having to present my defense case, through the cross examination of the two prosecution witnesses. I had refused the Crown's offer to have charges dropped after the first cross.

As was my right, I applied in writing to the police department to have the record of my arrest, my fingerprints, and mug shot expunged from the their records, and about a year later, I got a letter from the RCMP, confirming that this had been done. I don't think border guards would have a record of this arrest.

If I had accepted the Crown's offer to have charges dropped, I could not have applied to have the arrest records removed. If I had not made the written request to the police, they could have kept the arrest record, fingerprints, and mug shot on file, despite my acquittal.

I had a similar experience as you in the mid-1990s. Long story short, a guy challenged me to a fight, I declined and attempted to diffuse the situation by walking away, but he came back around and shoved me, at which point I hit him in defence. A week later the police turned up at my door and arrested me and charged me with assault. It never went to court. The other guy manned up and admitted he'd pushed me and the Crown saw my actions, since they weren't excessive, as being justified self-defence and dropped the charge.

Years later I went to apply for a job that required me to be fingerprinted as part of a background check. When I received the results of the check from the RCMP National Repository, I was surprised that my lone arrest record was on there. (it also mentioned the charge had been withdrawn)

This was frustrating, as I really wanted to put this episode forever behind me, so I called the police and they advised me to submit a petition to have the record expunged, which I successfully did.

The letter I received back from the police nine months later said that although the record would remain on file by the local police, my record in the RCMP National Repository had been "purged, as requested", and was "not searchable by any other agency, including the RCMP and U.S. Customs." (direct quotes from the letter)

My understanding, and I heard this years later from a lawyer, is that the RCMP chooses which files to share with US Customs, and since being arrested is less serious than being convicted, my record was likely never shared with US Customs, given it was so long ago and such a minor charge.
 
  • Like
Reactions: onomatopoeia
I had a similar experience as you in the mid-1990s.... charge.

I was arrested in November, 2007. My trial date was early August, 2008, (I had waived pretrial, and had requested the earliest possible trial date. My trial was in two parts, with the acquittal three months later. It was because of experiences like yours that I declined the option of having charges dropped, which would have wrapped up the case in August.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JeanGary Diablo
My understanding, and I heard this years later from a lawyer, is that the RCMP chooses which files to share with US Customs, and since being arrested is less serious than being convicted, my record was likely never shared with US Customs, given it was so long ago and such a minor charge.

I'm not an expert but I suspect this is how it works. I highly doubt RCMP choose case by case which gets shared but they probably have a standard (child molesting/terrorism charge = Yes, minor assault charge = No) for sharing. If you are convicted, it gets shared regardless. They're balancing the privacy rights of individuals vs security interests of the US and somewhere in the middle is an acceptable level of disclosure.

Buried in the vaults somewhere there's probably an explicit agreement between the US and Canada as to what gets shared but that will never see the light of day (and probably changes over time).
 
  • Like
Reactions: JeanGary Diablo
I was arrested in November, 2007. My trial date was early August, 2008, (I had waived pretrial, and had requested the earliest possible trial date. My trial was in two parts, with the acquittal three months later. It was because of experiences like yours that I declined the option of having charges dropped, which would have wrapped up the case in August.

Yes, it was a major pain in the arse to go through. I bet a lot of people are unaware that the arrest record stays in tact even if there's no conviction. And you're correct in your initial post, the RCMP is not obligated to remove the record, even if you petition them to do so. My guess is that my arrest record was erased because the arrest was 15 years earlier, the charge was relatively minor and it was literally the only thing on my record.

Lesson I learned, though, is that anytime there's even a remote chance of a physical altercation with someone, walk the fuck away from it, not out of fear of losing a fight, but out of fear of them calling the police on you if you win.
 
The question is, is there a difference between Canada sharing charges vs sharing convictions. Absolutely they do the latter, whether they do the former would depend on what the data sharing agreement actually was/is.
From personal experience, yes, they share charges and from people I know, those charges stay in the US system even after the Canadian government wipes records (and my charges weren't anywhere near serious).

There was even a story a while back about Canadian police sharing information on mental health calls.
 
Last edited: