Building Walls

And in case you're looking for scholarly citations to disprove your BIG LIE:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashkenazi_Jews#Population_genetics

DNA clues
Efforts to identify the origins of Ashkenazi Jews through DNA analysis began in the 1990s. Like most DNA studies of human migration patterns, these studies have focused on two segments of the human genome, the Y chromosome (inherited only by males), and the mitochondrial genome (DNA which passes from mother to child). Both segments are unaffected by recombination. Thus, they provide an indicator of paternal and maternal origins, respectively.

A study of haplotypes of the Y chromosome, published in 2000, addressed the paternal origins of Ashkenazi Jews. Hammer et al[12] found that the Y chromosome of some Ashkenazi and Sephardic Jews contained mutations that are also common among Middle Eastern peoples, but uncommon in the general European population. This suggested that the male ancestors of the Ashkenazi Jews could be traced mostly to the Middle East.

The first research on Ashkenazi maternal ancestry was less conclusive. A 2002 study by Goldstein et al[13] found that "the women's origins cannot be genetically determined", but that "his own speculation" was that "most Jewish communities were formed by unions between Jewish men and local women."

More recent research indicates that a significant portion of Ashkenazi maternal ancestry is also of Middle Eastern origin. A 2006 study by Behar et al[1], based on haplotype analysis of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), suggested that about 40% of the current Ashkenazi population is descended matrilineally from just four women. These four "founder lineages" were "likely from a Hebrew/Levantine mtDNA pool" originating in the Near East in the first and second centuries CE. According to the authors, "The observed global pattern of distribution renders very unlikely the possibility that the four aforementioned founder lineages entered the Ashkenazi mtDNA pool via gene flow from a European host population."

Both the extent and location of the maternal ancestral deme from which the Ashkenazi Jewry arose remain obscure. Here, using complete sequences of the maternally inherited mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), we show that close to one-half of Ashkenazi Jews, estimated at 8,000,000 people, can be traced back to only four women carrying distinct mtDNAs that are virtually absent in other populations, with the important exception of low frequencies among non-Ashkenazi Jews. We conclude that four founding mtDNAs, likely of Near Eastern ancestry, underwent major expansion(s) in Europe within the past millennium.[1][14][15]
 
Of course, facts are not a convenient partner in the cause to exclude Jews from the nations who have the right to sovereignty. Just keep repeating the lie over and over again, eventually people will believe it...
 
...now I can go home, have a good weekend fellow earthlings...
 
I fully agree with scouser that what happened 200 years ago has no significance in justifying the state of Israel. What is is that the UN determined that there was supposed to be a state and that state has existed for the past 60 years.

Unfortunately, scouser is stuck in his own Arab mythology about all the evils the Jews have committed on the Palestinian people. It is very clear from his posts that he is adamantly opposed to the idea of a two state solution, just as his grandparents were when the UN voted for partition. It is clear in his manipulation of information on the make-up of Israeli society, his complete ignorance on the 800,000+ Jews that entered Israel as refugees from Arab lands (which is actually more than the number of Palestinians refugees in '48). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_exodus_from_Arab_lands You can see it is his characterizations of Lenny and Sergui representing all Jews, and you can see it in his merging of Jews history with that of the Mongols, another of historic Islams succesful enemies. You can see it in his refusal to admit that Jews had any connection to Israel similar to the traditional Islamic view on the temple mount and his characterizations of settlers (from the 1850-1949 period) looking for a safe place to live as a "gang of bigots and wack nationalists" and criticising them for their lack of religious feeling while in the same thread criticizing Israel for being too religious.

Quite simply, scouser is caugth of in the myth of victimization that many palestinians, especially the children of refugees, are indoctrinated with and therefore see progress is impossible unless it gives the result wanted by the Arab leadership in 1948 and stil remains.
 
DATYdude said:
...
2. The Arab Israeli birth rate will go down significantly if there is peace, if the Israelis are smart enough to pair that with real gains for their Arab citizens.
...
This is the biggest reason there will not be an Arab majority in Israel. Quite simply, with Israel safe, there will be no reason for Israeli Jews to fear Israeli Arabs (as anderson does) as a fifth column. The lack of fear will result into continued improvement in relations between the two groups and the birth rates coming into sync. It has been seen repeatedly that greater opportunity results in a lower birth rate.
 
I wonder how things would of progressed if Sharon hadn't gone into a coma. He was elected with a significant mandate to pursue a two state peace in some form or other. I think his idea was to force the Palestinians to the table by continuing his one sided withdrawls. Without negotiation, the Israelis would have withdrawn from all the land they wanted to withdraw from, thus showing a willingness to give up something in the name of peace. The Palestinians would simply have to come and negotiate for peace before the Israelis consolidated on the land they wanted. It probably wouldn't work but a continuation of attacks from the Palestinian territories despite the price would cause Israeli opinion to harden against giving up any more.
 
Don't know if I like the idea but it makes an interesting observation on human rights and equality in the region.

Over the past 20 years we have started to realize that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict will be resolved by the establishment of a Palestinian Arab state alongside Israel, to its east. The familiar slogan, "Two States for Two Nations," seems like a good idea, but it involves an inaccurate description of the situation.

If this formula is to be accepted, we are talking about establishment of a Palestinian state that will include no Jewish communities, and opposite it the State of Israel, where two nations will live - about 80 percent Jews and about 20 percent Palestinian Arabs. There is no national equality in this formula, and therefore in the past there have been proposals to set the boundary line between the Palestinian state and Israel in such a way that most of the Jewish communities located beyond the Green Line will remain part of Israel.
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/901850.html

Also, it seems a similar offer from 2000 is on the table.

According to the report's account of Ramon's offer, the border between Israel and the future Palestinian state will roughly follow the route of Israel's West Bank security barrier, leaving major Israeli settlement blocs and between 3 and 8 percent of the West Bank in Israel's hands.

In return, Israel will cede to the same amount of land inside Israel to the Palestinians to make up for the annexed territory, the report said - possibly including a land corridor between the West Bank and Gaza, a central ongoing Palestinian demand.

Palestinians who became refugees when Israel was founded in 1948 will not be allowed into Israel, but only into the Palestinian state, and an international fund will be set up to pay for their rehabilitation. Holy sites in Jerusalem's Old City will be under the control of the various religions and no national flags will be flown, the report said.
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/902018.html
 
basketcase said:
Don't know if I like the idea but it makes an interesting observation on human rights and equality in the region.

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/901850.html

Also, it seems a similar offer from 2000 is on the table.

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/902018.html


so the same deal the Israelis and the Clinton administration tried to sucker the Palestinians into is going to be offered again hmmm well who knows Abbas is already being paid by Israel and having thugs given weapons by them so why shouldnt he accept it. The West Bank gets chopped up into 4 pieces that arent linked but separated by Israeli military posts, uhuh real fair deal

http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Peace/rossmap2.html

As for ceding Israeli territory in the north where Arabs make a large number to the Palestinians in exchange for keeping the settlements, wow this is equal to the US ceding parts of Arizona, Texas and California to Mexico where large numbers of Hispanics live, Eretz Israel can get away with this kind of talk, but imagine an American politician said this, how long would their career last hmmm?
 
Obviously your deeply ingrained mythology is preventing you from even reading a map, let alone understanding anything related to the two state peace you despise.

The map CLEARLY shows a gontigous West Bank. The other big demand in this regard from the Palestinians is to have a land corridor to Gaza which would be built on Israelii land and be under control of the Palestinians. As for ceding land, most of the recent talk has involved land that would be added to Gaza.

Why can some of the hard core politicians get away with the idea of population transfers? It might have something to do with the idea from the first article I posted and you choose to ignore because any comment wouldn't fit your view on how the region should be.
establishment of a Palestinian state that will include no Jewish communities, and opposite it the State of Israel, where two nations will live
 
basketcase said:
Obviously your deeply ingrained mythology is preventing you from even reading a map, let alone understanding anything related to the two state peace you despise.

The map CLEARLY shows a gontigous West Bank. The other big demand in this regard from the Palestinians is to have a land corridor to Gaza which would be built on Israelii land and be under control of the Palestinians. As for ceding land, most of the recent talk has involved land that would be added to Gaza.

Why can some of the hard core politicians get away with the idea of population transfers? It might have something to do with the idea from the first article I posted and you choose to ignore because any comment wouldn't fit your view on how the region should be.

if the Israelis are so interested in living side by side, why dont they annex the West Bank and Gaza, give the Palestinians equal rights and citizenship and problem solved. The vast majority of Palestinians would gladly accept this single bi national state, but find an Israeli that would, it would be end of the Zionist wet dream of a mythical Jewish homeland.
 
If we ever hope to rid the world of the political AIDS of our time, terrorism, the rule must be clear: One does not deal with terrorists; one does not bargain with terrorists; one kills terrorists.


How I miss the wisdom and strength of Meir Kahane.Too bad and how sick that the Israelis choose Arafat over him.
 
scouser1 said:
if the Israelis are so interested in living side by side, why dont they annex the West Bank and Gaza, give the Palestinians equal rights and citizenship and problem solved. The vast majority of Palestinians would gladly accept this single bi national state, but find an Israeli that would, it would be end of the Zionist wet dream of a mythical Jewish homeland.
Is this a joke?

Pretty much every major international body recognizes that the West Bank and Gaza are not a part of Israel and were never intended to be. Jordan annexed them but that got undone when they made peace with Israel for the exact same reason that Israel will eventually cede the land to the Palestinians Authority. Simply put, the Palestinian people want the right of self determination no matter how much smoke you blow.

Besides, bi-national states don't seem to work very well in the region. Just look a few miles north of Israel and see what kind of mess it can cause.
 
basketcase said:
Is this a joke?

Pretty much every major international body recognizes that the West Bank and Gaza are not a part of Israel and were never intended to be. Jordan annexed them but that got undone when they made peace with Israel for the exact same reason that Israel will eventually cede the land to the Palestinians Authority. Simply put, the Palestinian people want the right of self determination no matter how much smoke you blow.

Besides, bi-national states don't seem to work very well in the region. Just look a few miles north of Israel and see what kind of mess it can cause.


If you are refering to Lebanon, that isnt a bi or multi national state, its a multi confessional one but all the Lebanese speak the same language, same traditions, eat the same foods
 
scouser1 said:
If you are refering to Lebanon, that isnt a bi or multi national state, its a multi confessional one but all the Lebanese speak the same language, same traditions, eat the same foods

Yes , but while the Christians in Lebanon are murdered by fellow Lebanese they really do not care about language, traditions and food.

They are forced to go across the good fence to work in Israel and shake hands with the Israelis as they cross that fence, looking overhead while their brothers shoot rockets overhead.
 
Anderson said:
Yes , but while the Christians in Lebanon are murdered by fellow Lebanese they really do not care about language, traditions and food.

They are forced to go across the good fence to work in Israel and shake hands with the Israelis as they cross that fence, looking overhead while their brothers shoot rockets overhead.

its alot more complicated than Christians against Muslims in Lebanon, there are factions within factions, the problem with Lebanon is there never a shortage of politicians who are willing to sell their country to foreigners, be it Israel, Syria or Iran, yes there were Maronites who sided with Israel, but some sided with Syria, as a whole mess of dealing and double dealing was made by all sides.
 
scouser1 said:
its alot more complicated than Christians against Muslims in Lebanon, there are factions within factions, the problem with Lebanon is there never a shortage of politicians who are willing to sell their country to foreigners, be it Israel, Syria or Iran, yes there were Maronites who sided with Israel, but some sided with Syria, as a whole mess of dealing and double dealing was made by all sides.

I agree ,