Building Walls

this ruling puts an interesting dilemma for Israel, the Palestinians living in the West Bank arent Israeli citizens so they arent subject to Israeli law and protection but are under actual military rule, do they start treating them all in the same manner,because if thats the case then say good bye to the Jewish homeland and say hello to a pluralistic state with an Arab majority in the future and a sizeable Jewish minority, much like South Africa worked out to be, and that turned out really well for the most part
 
scouser1 said:
this ruling puts an interesting dilemma for Israel, the Palestinians living in the West Bank arent Israeli citizens so they arent subject to Israeli law and protection but are under actual military rule, do they start treating them all in the same manner,because if thats the case then say good bye to the Jewish homeland and say hello to a pluralistic state with an Arab majority in the future and a sizeable Jewish minority, much like South Africa worked out to be, and that turned out really well for the most part

Excellent point .

I think the only solution is the eventual 2 states , some solution for Jerusalem where there can be space for all to pray,and a limited right of return and Israel paying to the Palestinians to live in the new Palestine ( the ones who do not come to Israel). Problem of course will be Jordan, and Syria et al then infiltrating Palestine and launching missles etc , and then forcing Israel to retaliate blah blah blah.
 
DonQuixote said:
That's why they have to come to an agreement
and follow the Quartet's recommendation of a
two state solution. Even then the Jews in Israel
might be outnumbered by Arab-Israelis by the
year 2020 per Jewish demographers estimates.
Arabs of Israeli citizenship are having larger
families than Jews. If the trend continues the
Arabs will outnumber the Jews in Israel.

Israel has pressure from within as from outside
to resolve the Palestinians right to return under
the UN Charter.

As to Anderson's opinion, the Israelis are in no
better moral and legal position and violations than
are the Palestinians. Neither side is all right or
all wrong.

As an American, its in my country's best interest
to settle this matter.

Bush has met with the Israeli 5 times. He has yet
to meet with the Palestinian leader. His hands-off
approach to the Palestinians is typical and wrong.
When we negotiated with N Korea we were successful
in settling their nuclear program. We also worked
behind the scene with Tony Blair to settle the Irish
issue. Negotiations and compromise are far better
than military operations.

No my friend, as per Pollard it is the US' best interest to continue to keep a level playing field to sell weapons to all sides to keep the US military economy moving strong. Surely intel is aware of this most basic concept.

I also assure you that Israeli scaremongers produce whatever numbers they want to scare the public.The Israeli military and the Mossad though will never ever allow Arabs in Israel to vote out Hatikvah, and the star on the flag.Does not matter how left Israel gets -this will not happen.
 
I think the one-state solution for Palestine has as good a chance of looking like Mugabe's Zimbabwe as Mandela's South Africa.

Jewish Israelis aren't going to let it happen anytime soon.

Doesn't look like anything is going to happen soon on the peace front, but there seem to be some positive signs in Salaam Fayyad's PA. We'll see if there's any real movement before the next Israeli and US elections, although I have doubts that the supposed talks and summit have any purpose other than to create a front against Hamas, Hezbollah, and Iran.

I don't see how anyone can dispute that the Supreme Court's decision was anything but positive, it shows the strength of Israeli democracy. So the fence has to be moved; MOVE IT!
 
sick sick sick..

DonQuixote said:
There'll be two separate nations so Palestinian citizens
won't be voting in Israeli elections...
DQ,

That's an eloquent, perfectly reasonable diagnosis and solution. Too bad it has no chance of adoption because our government policy in the area is more influenced by the Book of Revelation than good sense like this..

MW
 
maxweber said:
DQ,

That's an eloquent, perfectly reasonable diagnosis and solution. Too bad it has no chance of adoption because our government policy in the area is more influenced by the Book of Revelation than good sense like this..

MW

You have 473 members on ignore yet you understand how peace should be made -got cha !
 
it will have to be a two state solution but will eventually form into a single state when the Arabs inside Israel outnumber Jews and vote for unification, now the Jews will have to decide either we will follow the whites in South Africa and the Protestants in Northern Ireland and live together or they will launch a suicidal war, I really hope its the former rather than the latter.

As for Syria and the rest of the gang launching missiles the minute Israel is serious about giving back the Golan Heights which it has indicated it is willing to do, the Syrians will kick out Hezboallah and Hamas out of Damascus immediately, they were only used as leverage against Israel, once their usefulness is up they will have to find a new franchise office. But this will only happen with an administration in Washington that doesnt include blatantly pro Israel evangelical looney tunes.
 
The Arabs inside will never ever have greater numbers than the Jews-sorry, it sounds cute but cannot be.That though cannot stop you from hoping.Now, I do agree that some people are very stupid inside the Jewish administration in Israel, but not that stupid to vote to die.
 
the birth rate is 7 kids per family for Arabs and 4 for Jews inside Israel, in 1948 there were 60 thousand Arabs inside Israel, today there are close to 1.2 million, you can sing and dance to Nagila Hava and wave the Star of David all you want but you cannot change demographic facts, well unless you launch genocidal extermination a la Stalin, Hitler or Pol Pot.

http://www.jcpa.org/brief/brief004-19.htm
 
Instead of using birth rate, I would use the cumulative growth rate to take into account deaths, immigration and emigration (that and your disapproval of a two state solution has you sourcing data including the whole of British mandate Palestine instead of the just state that you refuse to accept but exists anyways). Recent growth rates in Israel have Jewish population growing at about 1.4% and the Arab Israeli population at just under 2.5% based on 2006 numbers. The Arab Israelis currently make up about 20% of the population as of the 2005 census ( 5,313,800.00 vs 1,377,100.00).

Using these numbers, the Arab population will exceed the Jewish population in the year 2131. I don't think this demographic fear is as serious (or as hopeful if you prefer) as some claim. If 100,000 refugees were accepted into Israel this year, the date would be the year 2129. Even a million Palestinians refugees would make the break even date of 2087.

Sorry scouser, the only way that even in our children's lifetimes that you can end up with Arabs controlling Israel through democracy is if you refuse to let both an Israel and a Palestine to exist in the first place.



Based on data from:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Israel and using the compound formula of A=P(1+%)^n.
Of course, there could be something seriously wrong with my math.
 
The only people who see demographics as an urgent issue (besides politicians of course) are the Jewish Israelis who believe Israel should be from the Jordan to the Mediterranian and the Arabs who think the same for their Palestine.
 
basketcase said:
Instead of using birth rate, I would use the cumulative growth rate to take into account deaths, immigration and emigration (that and your disapproval of a two state solution has you sourcing data including the whole of British mandate Palestine instead of the just state that you refuse to accept but exists anyways). Recent growth rates in Israel have Jewish population growing at about 1.4% and the Arab Israeli population at just under 2.5% based on 2006 numbers. The Arab Israelis currently make up about 20% of the population as of the 2005 census ( 5,313,800.00 vs 1,377,100.00).

Using these numbers, the Arab population will exceed the Jewish population in the year 2131. I don't think this demographic fear is as serious (or as hopeful if you prefer) as some claim. If 100,000 refugees were accepted into Israel this year, the date would be the year 2129. Even a million Palestinians refugees would make the break even date of 2087.

Sorry scouser, the only way that even in our children's lifetimes that you can end up with Arabs controlling Israel through democracy is if you refuse to let both an Israel and a Palestine to exist in the first place.



Based on data from:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Israel and using the compound formula of A=P(1+%)^n.
Of course, there could be something seriously wrong with my math.

whether it happens in 20, 200 or 2000 years, the Zionist fantasy of a pure Jewish homeland will eventually cease to exist not through missiles or suicide bombers but simple numbers, Jewish Israelis mostly of European descent have different beliefs than their Arab fellow citizens, and one of them is the idea of having a large family, with the exception of ultra Orthodox welfare cases in the occupied territories.
 
three points against scouser here:

1. The orthodox are having kids at a very high rate and will make up a much larger proportion of the population in 30 years than they do now (and PS they don't all live in the territories; most don't actually -- when ever you make these sweeping, ignorant statements you remind me of how little you know and how ideological you are, you're a schizo, because sometimes you're quite informed...). Negotiating a two state solution is much more liklely now than when the religious have twice the representation in the Knesset; how do you know that the solution to the "demographic problem" in 50 years, coming from a huge religious right wing, won't be to kick out or kill all the Arabs? This wouldn't be much more radical than the mainstream on the Palestinian side.

2. The Arab Israeli birth rate will go down significantly if there is peace, if the Israelis are smart enough to pair that with real gains for their Arab citizens.

3. "Jewish Israelis mostly of European descent" - not true, the majority have origins in muslim countries, but they don't have 10 kids because they aren't very religious.
 
But in ISRAEL, (which is what we're talking about, right?) the population of Mizrachi and Sephardic Jews is about 2.5 to 3 million, or more than half of Israeli Jews, "It's a fact!" ~~ to coin a phrase:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mizrahi_Jews
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sephardi_Jews

So go bite me before you (a) twist facts (b) call me a liar (c) call me a rah rah Israel member when all I argue for is Israel's existence. That's not based on stories any more than the made-up stories of the Palestinian/Arab propaganda machine (which you keenly support).

Ask a Palestinian this:
1. OK let's assume that there was a Naqba and that it was on the scale that you believe -- hundreds of thousands of Palestinian Arabs pushed out of their villages by the Jews and forced into exile from their ancestral homeland, lets' say all that is true.

2.Let's say you don't get your homeland back for 2000 years, will your claim to it be any less strong, no matter who happens to be living here then?

3. If your answer to 2 is "Yes", how can you deny the Jews' claim? And If you don't deny the claim, why won't you share the land in some way?

Well this simple argument can ONLY be countered by the argument put forward that the Jews are NOT the descendants of the Hebrew/Israelite inhabitants of the land who are described in the Jewish Bible and related texts. Significant time and energy has been put into this spurious argument (which scouser hints at when he writes "the state they support is based on guys splitting seas and drops of oil lasting 8 days" and manyo f the other phrases he likes to substitute for reasoned argument or understanding of the "Other"). YOUR SHIT IS BOGUS AND BACKWARD DUDE.
 
Anyway, I hate these debates because they go nowhere. We're armchair players in this game. I'm switching back to the Playboy Channel.
 
DATYdude said:
But in ISRAEL, (which is what we're talking about, right?) the population of Mizrachi and Sephardic Jews is about 2.5 to 3 million, or more than half of Israeli Jews, "It's a fact!" ~~ to coin a phrase:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mizrahi_Jews
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sephardi_Jews

So go bite me before you (a) twist facts (b) call me a liar (c) call me a rah rah Israel member when all I argue for is Israel's existence. That's not based on stories any more than the made-up stories of the Palestinian/Arab propaganda machine (which you keenly support).

Ask a Palestinian this:
1. OK let's assume that there was a Naqba and that it was on the scale that you believe -- hundreds of thousands of Palestinian Arabs pushed out of their villages by the Jews and forced into exile from their ancestral homeland, lets' say all that is true.

2.Let's say you don't get your homeland back for 2000 years, will your claim to it be any less strong, no matter who happens to be living here then?

3. If your answer to 2 is "Yes", how can you deny the Jews' claim? And If you don't deny the claim, why won't you share the land in some way?

Well this simple argument can ONLY be countered by the argument put forward that the Jews are NOT the descendants of the Hebrew/Israelite inhabitants of the land who are described in the Jewish Bible and related texts. Significant time and energy has been put into this spurious argument (which scouser hints at when he writes "the state they support is based on guys splitting seas and drops of oil lasting 8 days" and manyo f the other phrases he likes to substitute for reasoned argument or understanding of the "Other"). YOUR SHIT IS BOGUS AND BACKWARD DUDE.


the Ashkenazi Jews arent the descendants of the Israelites of that book of magical stories of drops of oil lasting 8 days, they are descendants of a mix of the Khazars who were driven into Eastern Europe by the Mongols and Slavs who they intermarried with or converted to Judaism, they have about as much right to Palestine as I do to your house. The Sephardic Jews of Yemen, Palestine,Iraq etc are those descendants but their numbers are far and few, and before the gang of bigots and wack nationalists who have never seen the inside of a synagouge showed up in the 19th century, they got along fairly well with their Arab neighbours, sure there was discrimination and hardship for them, but alot better place to be than a Jew in the Russian Empire.
 
scouser1 said:
the Ashkenazi Jews arent the descendants of the Israelites of that book of magical stories of drops of oil lasting 8 days, they are descendants of a mix of the Khazars who were driven into Eastern Europe by the Mongols and Slavs who they intermarried with or converted to Judaism, they have about as much right to Palestine as I do to your house. The Sephardic Jews of Yemen, Palestine,Iraq etc are those descendants but their numbers are far and few, and before the gang of bigots and wack nationalists who have never seen the inside of a synagouge showed up in the 19th century, they got along fairly well with their Arab neighbours, sure there was discrimination and hardship for them, but alot better place to be than a Jew in the Russian Empire.

RIGHT, THAT'S EXACTLY THE MYTH I WAS TALKING ABOUT!
Thanks for giving me the party line, Yasser. Without that myth what would all your arguments be? Flimsy stuff. There is genetic evidence that shows your myth to be just that.
 
"the gang of bigots and wack nationalists who have never seen the inside of a synagouge showed up in the 19th century"

~~ don't you think your falsehoods would be better-propogated by less vitriolic statements? I thought cyrus was gone, are you sharing your handle now?